← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24947/2018allowed

Vinod Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2026-01-21Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

         

 !

"""""   ## #    #

"""""##     

       

 

 

   

    

 

  ! 

  

         !

   

 "

   #! ! 

 !!

   ! $  % !$ %& !"

#  # ! & & '

()*+ #,    (( *+ #,  !    -. (/*0 #, ,1#2   (3/4#/,1#2   # ! &'

 (&) This Civil Writ Petition Under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India has been filed for the issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the impugned order dated 12.03.2004 (Annexure P-3) and also quashing the Impugned order dated 06.03.2017 (P-9) whereby claim of the petitioner has

 been rejected without considering the Judgment of the high court and the judgment of the Supreme Court and also without considering the judgment dated 19.08.2004 passed by the High Court in CWP No. 1998 of 2003 because the petitioner was similar situated person passed by the Superintending Engineer P.W.D Hisar i.e. respondent no. 3, whereby the services of the petitioner has been regularized w.e.f. 01.10.2003 instead of 01.02.1996 and also quashing the order dated 06.03.2017 (P-9) passed by the respondent no.2 i.e Engineer in Chief Haryana, Public Health Department, Panchkula.

 

     

 



  

   

  

       



   

 

   

    

! "   #



 

$     % &

'



  

       

    

   &(  )          



     

    

 *      



   + &(   *  

    





  & , -           

   (         



$   '

      .   .& !

   /012+. (  

  /  +.,34 5 1',6(   

$      .&     *       

! #

! / 

!71,.&'. (

/ 4 28 %.'.%

 

 +.34 5 1'

69  

 (   '

  

$    

.&  

  & 4   

      ! :

 (      

     .%.&34 5 1'%6    

 % #   (    

)             

$    &&.,(   :



   & + 4  

      

(   



 /     

$    .&   *             7

    

     

   

  

    

* *   

  

$    % &

 + &(  

   .,  



     &  9

     



$   .&(   '

 







$  . (       

   7

          

      

  

$     .&  

       )    

 +.,

 /012+. (  

    ! /  

) 

 5 



  

(  ;

) <

;

!

 

  )     . 9       )    :

       &&., 

 (

   :



  &      .,    

 7

       !           

  

$   

      

    

 

  *      

  

  '

   

$    . , 9           

         

    

$          .&( 

      

    *   *                    

    7

   

    

      

   

  /  

)  

    & 9           

 /        

$         (         

/!



(   

$    

        

 



     

 

 

(





   

   6 2

 !%    !*+,-.

/0 *11+23-*4-/.

*.5 65-3-*7 +284+*-.4 7    

    !    !             4       

  

9  

9 # :   ;%

 <     !%   %  !  ;* 4 :          %       %   # 

 %<    !9    =    

       !"#$%&  "  '  ()%*# %     %      

!  #  4       

  #

  <      %     ! ; 

# !

 ; !  !!     # !9     !     !

    # :   <  ! !

         !  

 ! 8 





 

   (     

   

  

       

  

 

      



$    % &(

 + &(  

  

*    

    .,  



649 /0 4:2 #4*42

   !      %    ! # # 

> %    9    4  !

!     %       !





 

%     !    ,            ! 4  

 %       * !          

% 

 4     *     !     

 #       

 %   

         %       

 !  %    

* :

=) *#  

0   !%*     %   %   !  #  # 

       

! &  #    

  #    

      %9

%  

  

%  %  *     ! :     !   

      <        #  

      

  % %    4       

*   #% #            !%

   ?

    @  % 

   # 

   % !  

  

>    

 

       ! * !     #

      %    % ! !

!   4      !  

       

 %  !   !   <    %     %     @ 

 3

&  !  !%  

; %   ! 

 

?

   !

!



    !        #  % !     % %   

 %    ! %  %9               9 !     !! !   #   % !

   

      4  #   #

%

  ! #  % #          

%   2      @ %   

>  %  #   

    9  % !  !

 ,   

  !9  

    > !

    #

 # 

%   + ,- .      !

! !    ; 

 

9     9  % 

     !  %   

     !   #



  %*      !   

!

  #   

 !  #  

    6 

  !

  ! ;         4  

 ! ! 

     =   

/ '-!(00%&%'1)%# 4 :  %   

 !! % ! # !  %

    

 #

     ! 3  <  !

'

      

 

            

      !

    



  

 !" # 



 



    $  

  

           %      

      



      7  %9 

!    

        %             ,    !     



  %         #   

           %

   :      %    9    = 

#   % ; 

   %   !

  !    ;<         

            ! A234

5/  6,   !(0")&$ '"#0*#  4 :     # A&     

  

 %       

     

  %'

    (

 )*   

      +

 

  

    , +

 





% 

     

' 



 

  -.  

    (

  

   ' 



      -.  

     

    

   /

 !#, ; 

  

   

    %   !!   <         

>    % % =            

    !

        4           %      

,   



  

!    4  @!

 

 ! 

!       =   # ;    

<        !

!   !

! # ;%  # 9  =    

 

   !

 #    ! #    4  #   #             /.82;62.32 /0 86<82;62.4 =

-4:5+*=*7 /0 1/7-39

 ,      !                  %      %   !        

%  4  !2     ! :        *  !



   #          !          !  ;  

#         : 9

#     !           %        !         

 

 =     #      % *    #    #% !     * < #  ;4  %   !!    

!4  #     

 

! %  

!        !      

 #

   B! ! !

# 

 %  !!           *!  

! *+-49 =-4:

#->-7*+79 #-46*425 >17/9228

=               

            *     1 ;/            #  !               %        ! *#    %       % !  !   ;   

    #            

#  *              %!! !     %9   !

  2 #%  

#   #     

 

C9  %! 9          %    *, 4     !!!%    !

,   ! : 4 :   A5 , 

'



/3 7!"#$)&)'8*#   %       !

9    %   ! !  %! #       %!  #     

% %#          % %  

  

   %     %            % 

>  

 =    !           !    #   ;  

   !  %      ! 

  

  !  #            #   !    !9    %   

 !#         %       7 -,

< &;.% 9       ; 

!   % %

    !#  

 9  % ! 

6    ;                   % ! ! ; 

    !  

 9  % !  !      !B

!  !  

  ! @         !  ! ! ! ! 

7 &     

  %%  

 &     -.#!   ! (# ! &)

 "

" 



  $  %)

 0 1 )2 $  

 1 )2