M/S R.R Coals v. Union Of India
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 05.05.2015 M/s R.R.Coals (.. Appellant versus Union of India ((Respondent
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh
!"
!
Kuldip Singh, J.
#"
!
$!"
%&'%(%
)* + * , "
- )!
, .
, / - )!
/
!
0 1 + *, "
- )!
2&3 / /
"
+ %4453%&67 !
*
"
"
.
) !
6 . , 8 9! : 4( .,
" + * ;
+ * 8 + *8
<! %(.,
"
., !
% <:
- 2.,
: 4122& 6 . ,8 : '&.,
"+ * 8 !
1 "
. :
%%122& %'122& 2.,
1.,
* "
#
) :
!
= . + * %122& %%122&
*)* > 0
.!
8
8! 9 0!
"
*
*
-
?!
+ * 7 "
"
.!
"
- , 9 0!
8 ?!
0 8 ,"" ; @ !
7 "
!
): * :
)*
-
*
+ 5(2&367
%4122& -
8 ,"" ; @ ! 7 "
%5122&-
)* + * *
-
?!
,
6 . , 9! : ) 6 . ,
9! ,! "
) :
- ,!
'
(322& + * 7 *
<! + *0
"
) + * A
) ) )*
+ *
) 8
.
9! ,!
$!"
0 .
- " "
3&22& "
7 "
!) " )
<:
!
)* "
: = . #
8 "
?! ) !
)
7
+ *
)* 8 .
0 <
/) 0!
" ,! # "
%22& - , 9 0!
8
"
2%22& "
9! ,! 7 "
"
! "<:
7 "
) ) )*
!
)
+ *+! *
+ %'52%&67
2%22& , 9 0!
8
'2'55' - ,
*
0 0!
%(%22& ?!
:
)
9! ,! ) !
:
7 "
:
+ *!
A ) )
":
<:
)
%2%22& '(%22&)!
! ) " - + *
$
* $!
+ * !
"
) - 0 0!
'(%22&
"
:
! ) 7
) ! ) "
- , 9 0!
8
!
"
4222 + * ) ) !
7 "
:
!) . #
" !
) -
! 7 "
) 6
; @ < "
8")* *!
+ *!
)! :
"<:
;< 8" 7 "
%(222 %222
0 + *
! , > #
.!
8 7
!
+ (55((- ) :
) <:
A
* + 53%((&67 )
" )* + * -
:
!
+ %%1&%567. :
!
8
%'222 *
)* + *
)*
# !
"
A "
A
) "
+ '5(67 - <
-
+ 42432567
"
4'B3((-, -
8 %3222
+ 5(2&367 %4122&
+ * + 44(3567 %&5%(( !"
3(%'167 ! + %14567 !
"! %5.,
- ! ) "!
4'&%67 !
* "
- "!
?! ) #
44(3567 "%4&22& %35%((
) 4'&%67 "%4122&
"* )
;! !"
+ %'52%&67 + * 2%22& 7
!
?!
9 + * 8 !
%3222
"!
- " ) -
" "* )
"2%22&
*"
# !
A
+ '%1( " ): "
*
+ '4%25267C&D
!"
-
!* *! "
5( - 522- *! "
+ 24((67 -
"
!
A
2((((67
)
9! ,! 0!
" ,! -
"
* " !"
!
*-
! "
%4453%&67 !
) "
"
* " !" - + *
"
: )$
"
) 0 12 #
-
"
!
@ !
0
3& + *
# + *
,"" ! ++
!
!
) * - - )!
$!
#
"
+ %4453%&67 !
"
* " !" " #
* "
) +! - )
* " 7 "
;"
"
"
# $ %&
' #
( #
)
& * .
+ *- )!
+:
8 =":
) "
<9!
" 9 , : + *
<:
+=
+" 9 , :: +=% #
!
!
0 (1 !
#
! % ' :
!
#
! 4 5 :
!
!
*
"
# !
!* ! # "
'5:
"
")*6 . , 9! -
%%122& %'122&# " :
!
<:
) * %122& %%122&
*)* > 0
.!
8
!
,
?!
*
5(2&367
& "
%4122& )*
!
" 7
- 7 "
)* 0 8 ,"" ; @ ! %5122& ,
?!
*
,! 0 .
9! ,! (322& * 7
* <! + *0
"
) *
) ) )*
+ *!
8 .
,! "
" 7 "
!)
" )
!
)* "
: ) #
"
!
?! ) !
)
7 "
0
*
0!
" ,! )* * 0 <
"
%22&# * * 7 "
:
!
,! * ?! 7 :
0 * " ) !" %'52%&67 "
2%22&
! "<:
# * ) 7 "
!
)
?!
*
422&
7 "
) .
6 ; @ < "
8" + 7
* ;<8" %(222 %222 !
(55((- !
?!
!
) )"
"
"
* ) )" "
) * "
# ) ) * "
"
=
7 "
) 7 "
* 7 "
F 0 .
9! ,! 7 "
*
8 .
0!
" ,! # *
!
0!
"
,! * 7 "
= 7 "
! ) ) *
!
) 7 "
! ) !
G " * 7 "
;<8"
%(222 %222 !
(55((- !
# %4&22&
5(2&367 *
" ) ) !
"!
!"
+ 44(3567 * %&5%(( "
"!
) - * ) )"
"
<:
* 7
(
;<8"
?!
* %'222 # !
)
44(3567 "%4122& %35%(( - ,!
C35D
!" "
$!
; ) "!
!
+ 5(2&367 + 3(%'167 "!
) )
C 35D
!" " %4122& *"
,"
! %'52%&67 2%22&#" *
<:
): -
* 7
!
7 "
<:
) *!
) )" !
7 "
- "!
)
C35D "2%22& *"
(55((- !
*
) * *
)
!
F
"
): ":
0= /
*
/)!
"
7 "
!
7
!
- )
0= !
) ) )* *-
)
(55((-
"
+ %%1&%567
" "
!
" "
!
*
A
'%1(
" ): "
" !" '4%25267C&D
!"
"
! " "
522- ! 24((67 " + 2((((67
)
9! ,! 0!
" ,! " "
+ %4453%&67 !
"
* " !"
#" * "!"
) ! ! * " "
) ;): " *
) -
"
)
-
!* "
!
! ) 0!:
* )!
- "
"
* "
!"
) # "" )!
"
"
!
* :
)!
" !"
-
" "
!
2((((67
)
% 9! ,! 0!
" ,! # A
"
"
!
) 9! ,! )*6 . ,8 9!
-
0 .
"
:
8 .
0!
" ,! - )** !
:
"
+
# :
)* + *, "
- )!
" *
! + * )"
"
=
7 "
) !
7 "
7 "
-
7 "
! ?! :*
* - * )
! + 7
)*
*
9! ,! )
7 "
*
"
!
0!
" ,! -
! !
!
! * !
< !
! !
): * :
%4122& ):
* ! * "
'
" * : 7 "
)
*
" - ! *!) :
*
- )!
! 4 5 ,"
! % ' - )!
!
0 (1 ) 0 (1 !
+'
, ,, - #
,
# ,- .+
/ .+
,
, ,
,
0
.
+'
1
, ,
- .+
- # #
4
,
,
. +'
#
# #
0
#
, # 2 - !
)
! " 7 *
)* * A
!
0 (1 - ) "
" 7 * * * #
) ) )!
* :
7 7
!
*) )* >
*
)
- "
7 "
)* * *
)* ,!
)* *!
0!
" ,! 0!)7
' 0 (1 :
7
)* * )
A"
" *"
* # %'222
5 -
" "
! * :
"
*"
"
%&22& ! # *) :
)*
7
)
$!
* !
7 "
- #" 0 (1
-
"
"
) ;
- )!
% ' ;
! )
,! # !
"
+ 5(2&367 !
!
+ 44(3567 )* *
%&5%(( -
C 35D
!"
+ 44(3567 "%4122& %35%(( ) "!
!
+ 5(2&367 + 3(%'167
"!
3(%'167
C35D
!" "%4122& *"
- "!
! + %'52%&67
1 2%22& )
C35D "2%22&
*"
-
(55((- + %%1&%567
C35D
!"
"%'122& *"
"
!
C35D
!" "%22& *"
*
?!
+ %5(((67 - $!"
%&'%(%
)* + * , "
- )!
05.05.2015 (Kuldip Singh) 3 Judge