High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6384/2015disposed of

Jind Vandana Cooperative Transprot Society Ltd. v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-07-04Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan5 pages

!"#$ %&' (')*+*,- .

#- / 0# 1

1 / 0# 1 11 2'+',&- #211%34,'561',*2 (7)%&'3*&4 #2%89%:+4*;6 (7)%&' 2&4'<'&*&*,'2+ #+#%=&%1*,>?%%?3%26'<:&5 (7)%&'','2%?6 %25%,% %8'+4 *,(%? 4' 2('2 (%&'( 6 <%++'( @5 &4' 2%,+<2& ==*++*,'26%25%,%A):=A'7*+*,%? :&42*&5:,('2%25%,%#&2 B'4*)?'+%C%&*, )&6 !

2+42&6/&4' )&/$*,'C'2)*+' <3'2+ :,('21')&*,.! $ )&64%+@'',*=<:>,'(*,&4'<2'+',& <'&*&*, 0'%2,'( ):,+'? 2 &4' <'&*&*,'2+ +:@=*&&'( &4%& &4' <'&*&*,'2+%2'4?('2+ +&%>')%22*%>'<'2=*&+4%7*,>@'',>2%,&'(@5&4' )=<'&',&%:&42*&54'5):?(,&<'2%&'&4'@:+'+ 234*)4&4'<'2=*&+ 3'2' >2%,&'( 2 (*

'2',& <'2*(+ , %)):,& 7%2*:+ )=<'??*,> )*2):=+&%,)'+6 234*)4'C'=<&*, &%C<%5%@?':,('2&4'

:,8%@#&2B'4*)?'+%C%&*, )&6D

2+42&6/&4'D

)&/$3%+

<2%5'( 24')=<'&',&%:&42*&567*('(*

'2',&2('2+<%++'(6>2%,&'( 'C'=<&*,&&4'<'&*&*,'2+ &%C:,('2&4'D

)& 2 (*

'2',& <'2*(+ *&4:& &4'2' @'*,> %,5 >( 2'%+,6 &4' 2%,+<2& ==*++*,'26%25%,%634*?''C'2)*+*,><3'2+:,('21')&*,.! $

)&6+'&%+*('&4'2('2>2%,&*,>'C'=<&*,&&4'<'&*&*,'2+&3%+ +:@=*&&'(&4%&&4'2('2+<%++'(@5&4')=<'&',&%:&42*&5*,'C'2)*+'

<3'2+), '22'(:,('2&4'D

)&3'2'+%7'(*,&4'+%7*,>)?%:+'

)&6<2&')&*,>%??%)&*,+&%;',64',)'6&4'2('2):?(,&@'+'& %+*('' :2&4'2+:@=*&&'(&4%&&4'<27*+*,+ )&%2',& <'2%&*7'6%+,2:?'+%++:)44%7'@'', 2%='(&4'2':,('2, %)&6,&%C 4%+@'',?'7*'(:,('2&4%& )&&3%+ :2&4'2+:@=*&&'(&4%&<<2&:,*&5

4'%2*,>3%+>2%,&'(@5(*

'2',&

*)'26&4%,&4'

*)'234<%++'(&4'

2('2 ,&4'&4'24%,(6?'%2,'():,+'? 2&4'1&%&'+:@=*&&'(&4%& &4'2'*+,*??'>%?*&5*,&4'2('2*=<:>,'(4'D

)&+&(2'<'%?'( 3*&4&4'',%)&=',& )&6%+,&* 4'2('2+ 3'2'<%++'(@5&4'1')2'&%256'>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&56*, %7:2 <'&*&*,'2+,(*

'2',&(%&'+ 2= &D +<'21')&*,

)&6&4'D

)&+&(2'<'%?'(64',)'6,'C'=<&*,):?( <++*@?5@' >2%,&'( @5 &4' 1')2'&%256 '>*,%? 2%,+<2& :&42*&5 *, 'C'2)*+' &4'<3'2+), '22'(:,('2&4'2'<'%?'( )&&3%+ :2&4'2 +:@=*&&'(&4%&%+<'2&4' )&6*&*+,?5&4'1&%&'7'2,=',&34*)4 ):?(>2%,&'C'=<&*,6&4%&&@5%,&* *)%&*,4'<3'2*+,&7'+&'( 3*&4&4''>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&564',)'6&4'2('24%7*,>@'',<%++'( :,('2&4'2'<'%?'( )&@5%,*,)=<'&',&%:&42*&563%+2*>4&?52'7*+'(@5 &4')=<'&',&%:&42*&514' :2&4'2+:@=*&&'(&4%&*=='(*%&'?5% &'2&4'

'C'=<&*,3%+>2%,&'(6&4'=%&&'23%+2'

'22'(@5&4'1')2'&%256'>*,%?

2%,+<2& :&42*&5 4*=+'?

2 2'7*+*, 7*(' )==:,*)%&*, (%&'(

7', &4' *,%,)' '<%2&=',& <*,'( &4%& &4' 'C'=<&*, >2%,&'(@5&4'1')2'&%256'>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&53%+&&%??5:,A )%??'( 2&3%+ :2&4'2+:@=*&&'(&4%&&4'2'*+,<2'8:(*)')%:+'(%++:)4 &&4'<'&*&*,'2+%+&4'2'*+,*??'>%?*&5*,&4'2('2%++:)4'7',* =%&&'23%+,&4'%2(@5&4'

*)'234<%++'(&4'2('26%+*&3%+%?'>%?

*++:'34*)43%+(:?5),+*('2'(%,((')*('( '%2(?'%2,'():,+'? 2&4'<%2&*'+%,(<'2:+'(&4'<%<'2 @; 4':,(*+<:&'( %)&+,2')2(%2'&4%&&4'&%C3%+'%2?*'2 ?'7*'(:,('2&4'<27*+*,+ &4'D

)&634*)43%+2'<'%?'(3*&4&4'

',%)&=',& )&6%+,&* 4'<'&*&*,'2+4%( +&%>')%22*%>'<'2=*&+*++:'(*,&4'*2 %7:2&3%+)?%*='(&4%& 27%2*:+ 2'%+,+6 &4'5 ):?( ,& <?5 &4' @:+'+6 4',)'6 +:>4& 'C'=<&*, 2= <%5=',& &%C 2(*

'2',&<'2*(+6%+,&*)'(@'?3E%=' 1)*'&5 '2*( 'C'=<&*, %(%C CCCCCC

4' *,(B%,(%,%<& & &

CCCCCC .4'B*;%+#%?7*<& . D& D

4' +4;%<& & D4'0%?*&94'2% & CCCCCC 4' %*,+?%<& &

CCCCCCF

4' 1')2'&%256 '>*,%? 2%,+<2& :&42*&567*(' (*

'2',& 2('2+<%++'( 2= &D *,&4')%+' &4'<'&*&*,'2+ >2%,&'('C'=<&*, &%C634*?''C'2)*+*,><3'2+:,('2&4'

)&&):?(,&@'(*+<:&'(&4%&&4'D

)&+&(2'<'%?'(3*&4&4'

',%)&=',& )&634*)43%+,&* 1')&*,!

$ &4'2' <27*('+&4%&&4'7'2,=',&=%56@5,&* *)%&*,6'C'=<&%<'2+, 2)?%++ <'2+,+ 2=?*%@*?*&5&<%534?'2<%2& &4'&%C*,2'+<')& %,5=&27'4*)?'2)?%++ =&27'4*)?'+#'%,*,>&4'2'@56&4'<3'2 &>2%,&'C'=<&*, &%C3%+%7%*?%@?'3*&4&4'7'2,=',& %,(,&3*&4%,5&4'2%:&42*&5,&4'(%&'&4'2('23%+<%++'(@5&4' '>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&5,&4')%+'*,4%,(6&4'<3'23%+'C'2)*+'( @5&4'1')2'&%256'>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&5:,('2&4'<27*+*,+ 2'<'%?'( )& D

4',&4'=%&&'23%+@2:>4&&&4',&*)' 1')2'&%256'>*,%?2%,+<2& :&42*&564'4*=+'?

7*(')==:,*)%&*, (%&'( 6 *=='(*%&'?5 % &'2 <%++*,> 7%2*:+ 2('2+ >2%,&*,> 'C'=<&*,62'

'22'(&4'=%&&'2&&4'2%,+<2&==*++*,'26%25%,% 2 &%;*,>:<&4'=%&&'2 2+:A=&:2'7*+*,&3%+&4'2'% &'2&4%&2'7*+*,%?

<2)''(*,>+3'2'*,*&*%&'(@5&4'2%,+<2&==*++*,'2*,'C'2)*+'

<3'2+), '22'(:,('21')&*,.! $ )&&*)'+3'2'*++:'( &&4'%:&42*&*'+

&'2<<2&:,*&5 4'%2*,>6&4'2('2+3'2'2'7*+'(%,( &4''C'=<&*,%?2'%(5>2%,&'(*, %7:2 &4'<'&*&*,'2+%,(&4'2 <%2&*'+,+*=*?%2>2:,(+3'2'3*&4(2%3,4'2'*+,'222*,&4'2('2 <%++'(6* ),+*('2'(*,&4'?*>4& &4'<27*+*,+ )&634*)4 3'2'*, 2)'%&&4'&*=' >2%,& 'C'=<&*,@5&4'*,)=<'&',&%:&42*&5 4'%2>:=',&&4%&&4' )&*+,&<'2%&*7'%+&4':?'+4%(,&@'',

2%='(*+='2'?5&@',&*)'(%,(2'8')&'(%+,&4*,>3%+&@'(,':,('2

&4':?'+%++:2)' <3'2*+<2'+)2*@'(:,('2&4' )&,?54' )& 4%(@'',', 2)'(*+,&&4'=%&&'2*,(*+<:&'

))2(*,>?56&4'32*&<'&*&*,*+(*+=*++'(3'7'26&4'+%=' 3*??,&('@%2&4'<'&*&*,'2+ 2=+'';*,>'C'=<&*, &%C :,('2&4'D

)&2&4' )& 2=)=<'&',&%:&42*&56*,)%+'*&*+ %7%*?%@?'&&4'=:,('2&4'<27*+*,+ )&%<<?*)%@?' !%8'+4 *,(%?$ :(>'

!%2*,('21*,>41*(4:$ :(>'

. =;