Major Singh v. Ram Nath & ORS
!"#$# %&'
('
"# % %) *+, %-.!*-*/ "#"
' #/$ &0$$12(34'"2
'
' "#5 ("
'78 #$ 4"&5 9 :::
;6< "5"#"
'55"6# $'4&" &'3"
4$644("
= 4 44$"(
("#$6'"( '
> $ 4' 6(#?6'9
46&5"'' $ (""4'
"'!"
46"#4'2 @@;
# '2A'
"4'+<=# 6"( "'44("
'6&#?$ 62'6;
# '2A'
?$ 6+<24 #("
4''
$"(=#=1
#(3" &? " (#"#$6' "44("
'2 "#$
""(#5 $9= 4
4556"( &2=("(#$& 2B
C)6
='
'""#'''
"'"
>5"
$&23("=(('"( B
) )
"3"( "#(=(2'
"5"#"
'55"6 #?""
6"(
"
4"&"
' 4&5"
#
"##$"'
'''
"'&" 44("
'2'
$"(=# "(B 9"#2'
""
"2&$6'56" 7# $6(
3"?""
556"( #'"( "#"4 (6&? #3"9 $&"
'# ' 4&" " $"( # ?""
##"##"( # 2
C)5"& = ""#'
6'#"6 #?#"3"('
' "=##166"(6?$" (
#& 69"
44(
''
"& &$&= "## $6( 3"?""
'1"
" "( 4$ #"6 '
" 55"66 ' $'
" $"( '
' '
44("
''1564" # '*"$ ("="
''"'&"
' # ' ( '
"" '"=# # '"( '$ ?2' #5'' "( # ' ?""
4 #(""(?9'
6= 6"=(
4&5"
*" "3 4"# '?"4$#" #5 $92'
$"( #?"4&"?"((("
(=$6( ?" ""(
5"& '''"
' (
C)=("('=(##5"46 ''"
' # &" " &$ ' " 4 '"
("( "
4"&"
'
4&5"
=("( 6## "2#5"46("' ( 5
(#$
"
# "4 46$("( " $&"
'#?9$
'&"(46?66#
C)=""5($4"(?"
"'
6#DEC'DEC7 "#(?66#="" '"&?$#"( '"4
46 $ '/$(#
# $"(2'
"'' "9 6("2=# '?6"'53"'
"#( ?66##5"'
"3("
4"4' #55""( ?"
6 "#5 ("
'78 #$ 4"
&5 9 #5'" #"34" &'
""(
'
"=(2'#55"
''
4'#"
)7)
'(#5$'"( " " $"( #?""
'1"
#B 9"#?9'
?$ 6'#"6 #$4 44$&#' 4"#2#5"'
"("4# "* +?6"
5"D$'
;
< 2'
"&$6'56" 7 #'?"556"( 4#"
B 9"#6(5"# 6""( 5569
"&$6'56"
$
'
" "&569" '
" 55"66 ' ("5#"( ?"
" '
?$ 6='
"
(' #& 69#69?$''
"#(#''"&"
'##$4
=# '44"5'"(?9'
6 "#&" # '?""
4 66"
"( 5"#"
' 55"6 " 69 "3 4"#"( ?9'
" 55"66 ' # '
' '
& &$&= "# #166"(6?$"5"36
''
"'&" "44("
$6(?"'1"
"& &$&= "# #166"(6?$" "?$92
2=#2 C)5"& "#&"=#"3#"( "5'"&?"2
*"
4"2'
"& 69"
$"(''
"'&" "44("
'# $ ("(
(#'1"
#2
C) " (#?6'9 4"' 4'" '
" 55"66 ' =# 5($4"( # DE (53"(?9E ""6 2"
###' ' &'
"
4"
36$ " 2'6E7 6 2= '"'"('
'
($#*#5'62 622("5#"('
"6="5' &'
"41 # 4&56"'"69?"4&"(#?6"(2= 4 #"#$6'"( '
>(#?6'9 $#2 6
'69556"(&$6'56"&"'
('464$6'"4&5"
"#&"#?"
")464$6'"('1
"& 69 4&" "46& #2
C) (?95569
"&$6'56" 72= 4 4&"#'
F F7G 2BB2
C)
)) '5($4"('
"&"(46?66#?"
"'
6 *# $9=##$4 '$6'&'"692 "=#?"((("
'"'"
("
#
(3'DEC2 "=# '?6"'''"
"54""(
# 4##) "D& ' 2 (5=" '' "9=# 3"
' ## /$(#
= =#4##)"D& "( "&"(46?66#5($4"(?9'
'=""
'4 #(""(?9'
6 $ "#&"="" '53"( ?9 # # 44( 4" ='
'
" 3("
4" 4' $
'"4
4669 ""4' "&"(46?66#4
'?" $6'"(2?$'1""5
3"='
4'
"44("
'2(#?6'9 '2#$ "9 # 4'$"(#5 "2
# #5'6H' 3$#44# #" '(#5$'"(2'4 ?"# "69 4 46$("('
"&"(4 "#='
C)=$6( 3"?""
4 #$&"( #$4 6
'"'&"
'0""5
3"='
"#" 4'#2#$&
C)# =("(''
' &"(46?66# "4 '"
' # 6" "(4$ #"6 '
''
' 4&5"
' #5'' #?""
=("( "&$ '#=("(
''"
' (6## ""I$""
4"&"
'("#"3"
44"5' 4"
!
"#
$%
# &!'
(" %
' "
' )
' #
# "
'& # "
* +
& '
'
!
"
)B) $ !
,#
$ "# '
+
& ' ' & # - +
&& '
"" &
#
%* . # "
* /0 " %
' 1
' ,2 ' &
&&' #
" 3"& $ * ,+
& # 4
&
"
& '* ,+
&
"
&&
'& # ', %* * $%"
"#
!
!
%
,* %
"
&$%!
"&"# "
, "" ' , & " #
"#
!' %&
, , '
&& '
"" & #
%& # "
& # 4
&
"
&# '
&
"
&&*
& , "
!
"
& $% " %
'
"
'
"#
,
* !
&
0 " %
'
"#
* .
) ) 5
,
0
!
0""5
3"='
"6="
$ 4'"(?9'
"("4# #"
""( ?3" 4'# #4#"'
$9 #"#$6'"( '
>
$ 4' 6(#?6'92'
"&$ '=("( 6## "#
"6="#(" ' ""("(' #5'' ' 69 &'
"564"
44("
' # ''*#5'6 # ' ' ($# *#5'62 62= 4 #'?"4 #(""($'
"2'#'?"1"5' 3"= '?"((("
5"# 4
''3"6 '"'&"
' #= ='
$'
"( #5"4669
"(' #5'' #$4 44$&#' 4"#2$#'
("I$'?6"4&5"
' #5'' # $6(?"=("( " "# # "
""( ?3" '
4&5"
44$ ' ' #5'' =$6(5569='
"
('''"
'6# 55"66 ' =$6( 3" "I$"( ''"
' ($
'
" 5"( #
#5'6H' ( '
""#' #6 " "5 (#$
"
#("# '
6'"669&" "5 9#465 (#$
"
#?$' 46$("#'
"'$&2 &"
'6 9 ( ##&"
' 4"(?9'
$"( ( # &69 ""
"2 " 4&5"
=("( 5 ( #$
"
# 6# "I$"#
4"&"
' " &$ ' =("( #5"46 ("' 6# "I$"#
4"&"
'2#'
"55"66 '=$6( 3"#5"
'#$
4"
'&$ '
)) #5"46("'2#5"#4?"(?9'
"(4'($
'"'&"
' "" '"6# '
""# #&"
' "(?3"2'
"4&5"
6"(9 =("(?9'
6$ ("3$# "(##"
4"(#5"'
"'?6"
3"
?"6=) *"( =("(?9'
?$ 6 =("( =?9'
#4$'
#?6'9 B2 @2
C) 2BB2
C) ,66# &"(46 '"'&"
B 2
C) B 2
C) 5"46''"
C)
C) 5"46("'
C) B2
C) ## B
C) B2
C) $'$"5#5"4'# B
C) B
C) (#$
"
B
C) B2
C) "(46?66# 6
C) '6 2 @2
C) 2B
C) 3"= "?3"2'
"=(('"( B
#&( "(' ""D'"
''
"4&5"
2 @2
C)=("(?9'
6#
4"(' 2B
C) '# 66?""
''6"(''
""
4"(&$ '6
='
'""#'''
"'" >5"
$& &'
"('" 6
"46& 5"'' '66"6#' "&$ ' "55"6#5'6966="( " "#('"&# !" #
$ %&
(
7'4
8 4/ 9 8 4/