← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5546/2016dismissed

Rashpal Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-05-12Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari12 pages

    

         

 !!"



$

! !!"



   

 !

" !#!

$$%&'()  !* +

,

  (% 

 !

" !#!

$$%&'() !* +

%   &'%  ( (

() *

  &'%  ( * ')  -#+./0  1+2#3+4  2*

 ! !

71(18

13 3#91. !' 41!2  -23+4   "

47 -813+4   !* + !  1+ ::::

(

() *

+     5.

2 2;

*

! 81 

15 <<  8 63 .!

+! 81 

15 << <*#-+ + =# >$2 6 3

2/1 1<1.8

.+5 ++ #-215 << 4 +  ,$-#,.,$/0 

!  

+<

+8/ #-2

  ?

?@@ $ A? A >3 +1 +A A

!!#+./ 2 4 < 6#91.3*1 < 84

=# 3 2*

81+!.51<15B# +36

1  *#.8 5  *# * !3  81

- 

2  = !

  1+  +48 *< 191!1!

  < 

 1    1

18   <3  1+  18!

81

-

2!

-#* 616#8868+-+1 -  <*8=31 4 881- 52 +  ) A 1+ ) A ,3$2!

8<

!1 3 

<

!1  A +<

+8/3 2!1 +

.51< !!#+ 5

  21+5B#

5 3>@   6 !2

5188+  1!  2  C5 6  >@ D  $2 

  6  15B#

3  1!

418+./=# 31+18!

1!1+<

 *8/6 8+

*

./5  !* + !  1+A3 2#!;1!<1+3 #-2 5 # !

-. -<1+

!31!35

<*81 5

,

 6>@ C !18!

1+<

+.!

+! ! 418+6 <

<*#-+=# >31!1**++

.

2 2;

*

!3 + +5

2#!.51< 81!+

281+ ; !

5 +  4 31 8  

2

2 *

2;

*

 !321+1+<

+8/6 8+ 8



  @

 3.6  ! 31+ 2!1 +;

*

#-21 + + 1; !3 ,

 3.51<+ !* !+ 6;

2 22   = +    

        

  

 !  !

"# $ %&'()) 

 +

 

* 

" *     ,

"

 $*  

 $

  "

   "

"   

-    #

 

 +

"

 

        "  

  . "    $# 

  #  

$#       *   *   " " " #   /  ;4 3 *# !#15

21.

4+ 5

. -<1+

2#.

181- 3<

!1 3 281

 +58 + 8 6

2!1 + * !

2*

 !3 2#! #-22 !<17 - =# >3;2 ./ 2*

 !1 8+

 <

!

#-2 2 ;

*

!  $2 1!

1!< =# >36 + 1;

-31 1;1 +

 6>@ C3 !-

4+3 #<3 > * 5 25

21+.+ +

#-211;1 +<1+  

31+18!

.51<

#<3 2!1 ++ +5

.51< 81!+

<1 !3  .!

+!  * !!!!

6  2  15B# +  81+!  18!

 .51< 1!!#<+$2 6 3 2- 415 1 !+./ 2*

 !3 2/ ; / 

8+

35

.+ +3 2#!

6$2 -2

&1 

1+ $ 1!*1 5/   1+  5B#

3  21.

 1+  !

8<

5

A  6 !2

 6 

1!

AC3.#

.4

#!8/.51< 95 +$2*

!#* 1

AC 1 = +2    

!"#$#%#&

'(& )$$ "

)(  % &

&*

+ $, -- .) ))/) %& , 0) - '$)

)(%

$)$  01 2   + # +"

   " "

   "3   "   

1   ,  "3  " 4 (( 1  

 "  

, 

"3  "

$ * 

  

 

"  +  *

 " *



#5

0$1  



 " 

$ *

 " " "

   



,  "3  "



 "

$   012   + # +"

  $( " 01

 "

   "3   "    ,  "3  " 4   

 

 " 

$ * #

*    " ** "*   "$# "





 

$  . " *



$  

 " $*        6 

*  "

         "    "     "3 

  ""

 "  

  "7

        

  

 $  *    " *

"  * #    

$    ""

 $ "





  $ "

 "      "

 

"3  "  

,  "3 

" $  " *

""

 "   

  "/ (#2344

 5-6., $ .5 -67-4-4

89

$2  2  1.

4  = +  *

!  <17  51+ !*17 -!3 ;2  1;1 +21!.<1+#+ 5

 C5 6>@ C3 2 #*

AC!21881**8/ $2 6 3 281 +5 #!86 2*

 !1 -#!3 !

5

6 15B#

=# .51< !!#+31! 418+

! 1+ -3

, 

 6>@ C

    !#8 8/3  2  1 -#!  2  +

6  >  * 5 #< 

3    614 #  6  2  81+  ; !  5 5 +3  1+  18!

!.# !<

2<3/ + +

 8 4 2 885

5 5 +3

/

 6>@ C3 2#!<1711;1 +  ;4 3!

5221!

<1+11;1 +

 C5 6>@ C$2#!321 -#! 6 + 1;

- 2!1 +1;1 +3

2 ./ 2#!;

21<.

 1

AC3

5+ -!#+  6>@ C1 +<+

214.5 < 81*!+31+3;

216# 2 5 !B#5 5

. +

AC (#2344

 5-6., (-,-$ . , $281 + 5 #!81 -#!3 21.

4<1+ 1 -#< 51

.155* +31!.

2 2*

 !214155* +>

* 5 65

#-2 2!1 +5

. - 81!+

614 #  > $2 6 3  2  !!#  ;2 52  6188!  6  5 + 1

;2 2  21.

4<1+1 -#< .6  ! ./ 281 + #!8  6 2  *

 !3  !  5 4 +3  ./  2  9#+-< 6 

)52 2 C.8*= 3 + + 51!

8+ 1!C+ 48 *< #

/" !#!1 21 8181+

2 !C3

;2 52 8 !@ @ A>

 321!.1!!

-+ 51!  !#* 13  2   C.8  *=   3  16   +8 . 1

-  #*

AC321! *1 1- 1*2    A A  63  2#!  !#<<1 E+  2  * *8!  81

- 

1**8

AC31+ 21!=* #81 +3 *8!3;2 52!*17;2 2  2!1 +81*!

-!

:  

615B#

* 5+ -!#+ C 25 6>@ C31 1**8 51.8

1**8 51.8

2615 #18!51

!5 5 +$2!1 +* *8!31!

*1 1- 1*2 A A 29#+-< !#* 131!<1+./  C.8*= 2#!1 = +2    9)   

 "





  3

:

  

  %" 010 1  "





     *  

         " ** "*     "               " ; *



 $ * 

  

  "  ) "

 



$ 

       #

 " +  "  $#

  *  "

  " "

  %" 010$1   " 

 " 4



$    < =  %" 01$ 



" *



 $ 

<

=

< = *          "3    "

%" 01  "  .  "  

"      #

*    " ** "*  

 " 

   

$  .

" *



$  )  

 

"



 

$  .

" *

$      %*

#  " *

 

 $     

  

  $

.      

 - - *  

 %" 01     "           "       " *

"

"

3 " 

( 

    %" 01 "



$

  " * #      $ "

 0  

1

   "

   "3  %"    " 4

;  

$  " *

""

 "  

  " ) "

 $+

%"   ,  "3  " 4

$    %"  

 ""

$+

2 (  " *

0 "

1 

      "3   " )

"

   

(     "      * #      #

* " *



" 

 $  >  

>

    "

   "3  %"    " 4 ) "

 



$  " *

 %" 01  " 4    * " *  "3  

 

%"  01    

( #*  

(    " *

"

 $+   # " * $#  +  %" 01,  

      """ *

  +

 " + " *

"

" * 

"3   "    %" 01   "  9   %" 01  "   $  

 

   %"  01    

   %"

010$1 *   . +

  " 4



"

*  %" 01 $#

 +   3    !  **

*  ?

"  

  

 $

  . +

 %" 9  "  4   %    + 

%" 01  " 

"



$  .     %" 01 4  

 %" 01  + *    "

 "

$ "

  

  

"   .

  #" *

 #

* $  " 

<   "

*   "  " +   "3 

  +   "

"

  #

      $   "   *



$#"



 $ " " *  #

 %" 01  "   +  

"

  "  3 + # "

" "    "3   %"      " +  +     "*   "   )     *( $

" *      "

" "

   

 3 + # *   . +  

        "  *      " *



#

  "

    "3   @ $

8/3 2 C.8*= 321! 21.

4= + *8!3=* #81 215B#

* 5+ -!+ 1;#+

6>@ C3 1 2 ;

88

81*!#+ 5

 6C 25

AC3.# 65

!+*

2 1!# / 1+   4 3

21!18!

.=* #81 2;

C#!+ 5

. ;* !!!!

1+5

3!2 #8+ . 1+1!C C 1!C1+C1++

21!18!

.<1+1 +

51!15B#

* 5+ -+ 1;#+  >@ C31 

+1+* !!!!

173.# 1;1 +

*1!!+3

2 #* 2  81*! 2

* 5+ -!1!<.1 7+#*

#+  2 C5

AC3.# 5

 .+

+15  ;

2

6  2  C5

AC $2 841

*1 1- 1*26 <17 -1+5

3#* 2- 14

/ 418

/ 1.

41 -#< 31!3< 4+.6  ! !51 *1 1- 1*2    

6  2  4 + !#* 13  *1 1  ;2  6  !

1+!  = +  

=    %"  01      "          

 #  



$ * #

$ " ** "*   " $# "



         

  $   .

" *

 

 $     )      

@ 

     

  

 $   .  

+ "#    %" 01 $ 



$ * ) ""

%" 010 1  

"        " 7$ " *

 $ *  ""

 "  

     "      )  "

    + "#



# . $  

 

 

  

 

   + "#  

%" 01  " 4 $  .

   #+ " *

   

%" 010 1  #* 

$ *

  %" 0 1  " 4   1+ - 21.

4*1 1- 1*23#6 8+! 5



AC3+18!;

2 2!

#1

8/;2 21;1 +

!<1+6 4/1 ! < .6  25 <<5< 25 3.#

!!!!

281+21!

. 17 5

21!. *1 + 21!.6# 2 <1+1 +3 2!1 +*

3+ !

4 !#18 E1!

#1

3;2 * !!!!

21!. 173#+  # -5/*

,  6>@ C3.# 1;1 +21!

.<1+$2 6 3 !#521!

#1

2#!3  <

 1

AC3 2  81*! 2

* 5+ -!

.# 5

.+ 155 +15;

2

AC1! 51! 6# -5/3* !!!!

!#!#188/ 17 .6  21;1 + !*1!!+$2 6 3

21!.!2

;2 1;1 +21!.*1!!+3;2  2# -5/*

   - 16 !5

,  6>@ C3 2#!21!. 7+3

2 ./3 2  81*! 615B#

* 5+ -!+ 1;#+ C5

6>@ C3.# 8/2 -2 5

;

#8+6 ;#+ 5

 1

AC34 6*1/< 21!

.<1+

+ +#+ 5

, A 6>@ C$2 <* 1

4 #+ 8

-!<1+ 21.

4= + 841 *1 1- 1*2 4 + 2 C.8*= 31  #-2;2#+ 

6>@ C3 2

6 15B#

55# ! 2#!

,  6>@ C3 !#8

- * !!!!

4  215B# + 81+!.5 < -1!!#<+.# 1;1 +21!.<1+ 5

 6>@ C$2#!3

 1 5

A3 2  81*! 2

1 8  + 1;15B#

5+ -! 1 2 #+  6>@ C3.# 5

. + +3/

!#* 13

AC  ;4 3  /  6# 2 

 21!  18!

 .  #+ 8 +  3 

2#!

 1

AC ;

#8+.+ +B#1 281+ ; !5 5 +3 !*5

4 *1/<

. -<1+

2< . - + +#+ 5

, A 6>@ C!#8 8/ 2 -2 6#8!

-

21.

43 2#!3 4 61!!#< -8/ 1;1 + !*1!!+#+ 5

 6>@ C3 !B#8

115B#

.5 < - !!#+

,  6>@ C3

#-25

.+

 1

AC3.# ;

21 +  8/ 6*1/< 321!

. <1+ + +#+ 5

, A 6>@ C$2 6 3

8/ 2*

 !; 

+ !.# !+5

34

;1!

  

8/> * 5 #< 21< !3;2 52 2/; 

2 ;

!

8+

31+ 6*1/< ;1!

<1+ + +#+ 5

, A

2 C5 6 >@ C3 ;2 ./ 2 81+! .51<15B# +3 .!

+!

!!!!

4  2<.51<

1!!#<+3 2 #* 318 6 ;1

6<17 - 61;1 +

 6>@ C3 2 ./

2  *

 !  ;

#8+  .5 <  

8+ 

 581 <  +

 1

AC  !B# 8/;2 2 51!3 #-2 1;1 +

!!#21!.<1+

 6>@ C3 .# ;2> * 5 #< 25

21!.+ +3 #+ 311;1 +<1+./ 25 <*  #

/31+ 2!1<;2 18!

 .5 <! 4 + 8/+ !.# !+ 

2<3 .# 1!  418+ ./

<*#-+=# >31!;881!./ 2 *8/6 8+ .2186 !* + !  1+A$2 6 3 21.

45

* 5+ 6

!C -

 1

AC3

1!<#521!3 5

. -*1 +

2<3 *# !#15

1 1;1 +3 2#!+ ! <1 !.# 5 <*8 8/#!1

+   ) 1!

<1/3 21.

4

 * 

2#!;

#8+6188

5 <*8 18 -< ;

2* *8 A31!51 *1 1- 1*2  A A 29#+-< #* 13;2 525

<*81 !3 2 ;

#8+ . 81*!

- 6* 5+ -!1!+ 1;#+  6>@ C3 51!

21!.*1 +3

281+ ; !5 5 +3.!

+!

;2* !!!!

215B# +81+!3 2#!21!18!

.1!!#<+ $2 6 3;2 2;

+C C#!+ !#.!5



AC. ;* !!!!

1+5

2#!.5 <<1+1 +3

. 1+1!C C 1!C1+C3 2 ./;2!#.!5



!  

2  C5 6 

AC3  .8 -1 !  !*5

4  6   1;1 +3  . -

#5+#+ 5

 6>@ C3.# .

2*2/!

!!!!

6  2  15B# +  81+  .5 <!  1!!#<+3  .!

+!

.51<+ !.# !+

281+ ; !5 5 +3 2 ./

281+ ; !5 5 +3.5 < -



8+

2<1+1  6!#.

!5

 1

A A   28!!3 2 <1

-

* 5 65

.

2;

2 81!+

281+ ; !5 5 +3.# 18 -;

2

 !

155# + !3.# 2 841 !

/*

!31!

6>@ C   $21.

4.+ ;

6 # ;7!6 <

+1/$2 < !!

2!1 +1< !.<1+ 2 !*5

4!14 -!.17 281+ ; !5 5 + 4 ,.   16  <1 23 ! 6 +! <

2;

*

!3 1+3  ;

2  2  1.

4  .! 41

!3  2  !1<  1   + !< !!+  $2

<*#-+ + !3=# >31 <1

+1+166 <+   + 1!

5 ! ,  5 2<1 51!!

!8621!.+5 ++3 2#!3188 *+ -1**8

!3 61/318!

!

1+ !+ !* !+ 6  8(

() *

   8* ') 9 ! !!"

   714 !

-2 )6-67,/4 0>,



>

)6-67 -,2. >