High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4945/2012dismissed

Gurnam Singh v. Sudesh Kumar & ORS

2017-05-08Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh7 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.05.24 10:46

!"#$ %%&'' ( )& * * +&*$, !

" +($& * -&*%+&(*

&*&(/ *$0"#' 1+23 (&

($& %%&'' ( 2"+- 4(" 1+23 (&

&*%+&(*( )"+$ +$ "1+23 (&

&*%+&( %%&'' (/

!"#$16&

&+"#2&$"3'&$ *

"'&+($&% &*&( %%& '(3$ ''&#&($& 6 ++ (&+

% **&+78 ( 33"+&(*' "!* '1- % # $& &"

&+( *9($& '912"+&6$"3$1($&3' "!%&("(" "'&+ 78($&3' "! (* +&

&3(":: ($&( )&$"3'&3($ *7&& ''6&+ +3!%&* (" (($&( & 11

;/$ *7&& 6 +&+(3' "! (*(<$& 6& ++

&+"#2&$"3'&6& &$&'+4"('8 +*&2& ''8 '" 7'&(% 83!%&* ("16$& & *1*

3&!% 86 *&=&!%(&+( % 8 83!%&* (" *($&+

&+"#2&$"3'&6 *($'+"# 2 '"++ "2"#'"3&3& (($&("!& 33"+&( > "& '81($& 3(* ($&3 *& &($ (3' "! (*16$ &6"+61 !" 3$"'+ & + ($& +&3& *&+/ " "#$ "'&+ %&("(" +&

&3(":: ($&( )&$"3'&3( # 3!%&* ("78*( ("#

($ (

1 " "#$ '#6"($$"**- 2", !

6& &#"# (6 +*, (3$ 3$$"6 ($&"

+!&*("36 0!( 383'&$& !( 383'&6 *7&"#+ "2&78 " "#$ +- 2", !

6 *%"''"

"+& ?$& " "#$ & 3$&+& > 7 ' $"$60" &2& &'"!"(* 2"'' #&$&

>&(1 7 *7& "# &#"*( (".>/<// < 7&"# + "2&" *$ +&#'"#&(! & 78($&+ 3 !&

!($&*"+&

>&( +$"( # "*(($&!( 383'& " "#$1 * &* '(

6$"3$ " "#$ +$"**- 2", !

&''($& + +* *( "&+ *& " *!

'("%'&"4

"&* " "#$+"&+ (($&*%( +- 2", !

6 * *$"

(&+("2"'@*%"( '1 3$$"6 " "4

&+3+"(" &3& *&+ 6 *8& * #& +$&7&"#&=/*& 2"3&! 6 *+"#47"A "

&> "# +&81.$ *&/1$ '" +6 *& "#

;/%& !($ $& 3' "! %&("(" 6 * 3(&*(&+ 78 6& 1 + + *

3& !% 8 78 "*"# 2 " * # +* + 78 "'"# *&% "((& *( (&!&(* ($& 6 "((& *( (&!&( "'&+ 78 ($& &*%+&(/ *

3&!% 81"(6 *!&("&+($ (($&*

3&!% 86 *( '" 7'&(% 83!%&* (" *&"($& ($&+

&+"#2&$"3'&6 * $'+"#2 '"+ +&

&3("2&+ "2"#'"3&3&

&+"#2&$"3'&6 * $'+"#2 '"+ +&

&3("2& (&%& !"(-&*%+&(/*

3&!% 8 '* "*&+ 74&3("($ ( 33"+&($ +( 0&%' 3&6"($($&

&+"# 2&$"3'& + (($&!*(1"(3 '+7& 3 *& 8&#'"#&3&7 *("''($&3' "!%&("(" "'&+78($&3' "! (* +& &3(":: ($&(

)&$"3'&3(6 * ''6&+ A& ($& %%&'' (3(&+*($ (($& &6 * &2"+&3& &3 +(3&3(($&

&+"#2&$"3'&6"($($& 33"+&( * &8&6"(&**6 *% &*&(A&

($& 3(&+*($ (&#'"#&3&

< 6 *($&% +&3& *&+ +'& &+ '*$ '+$ 2& %%'"&+($& "3"%'&

( $'+ ($ ( +&3& *&+/ " "#$ 6 * &#'"#&(+ &(6$"3$ 33"+&($ +( 0&%' 3& +$&*$ '+$ 2&7&& $&'+'" 7'& 8&#'"#&3&A& *&' '*3(&+*($ ( * %& 3' "! ($& 3' "! (*1 ($& 33"+&( $ + ( 0& %' 3& 6$& ($& +&3& *&+6 *3 **"#($&3$607 ( *%& ($&&= !" ("/"/3$"&

''&#&+&8&6"(&**.?/ 1+&3& *&+$ + '!*(3 **&+($&.' $"$60 ( ($&("!& 33"+&( $& &6 *+"

&3(&2"+&3& 2 "' 7'&6"($($& 3' "! (*(% 2&($ ( 33"+&($ +( 0&%' 3&6$&($&+&3& *&+6 * 8"#(3 **($&3$60("* '*($& !&( '& ($& %%&'' ( ($ ( &2"+&3& 6 * ($& & ( *$6 ($ ( ($& *$&** + &#'"#&3&6 *($&% + 7 *'8$& '$ *6 #'8

&'"&+ %($&*( (&!&( .?/ (% '"#$78* 8"#($ ($&"* ($

($&-16$& & *1($&-6 * &#"*(& &+($&*( (&!&(! +&78&

"+& . '"#$16$6 *(&= !"&+ "+ (% '"#$"* ! +& 6"(&** *$&"* &*"+&( 2"'' #& ($&3' "! (* +&("

&*( 8$ * 7&&333(&+4 *((#&( ! 3!%&* ("(($&&+1'& &+ 3 ($& %%&'' (* 7!"(*($ (*

$ +6 #'87&&&=& (&+

!($&'" 7"'"(816$& & *1($&&("

&'" 7"'"(8*$ '+$ 2&7&& *(&&+

%($&"*

*($&

&+"#2&$"3'&6 *

''8"*

&+$& &6 * 2 '"+ (&%& !"( ++ 6 * '*$'+"# 2 '"++ "2"#'"3&3&$& ! 3!%&* (" 6 +&+"*($&&=3&**"2&*"+& *!

'("%'"& $ * #'8 7&& %%'"&+ $& #& ($& +&3& *&+ $ * 6 #'8 7&& 3*"+& &+ *8& *16$& & *1 (($&("!& "'"# 3' "!%&("("16"

($& +&3& *&+ $ * !&("&+ $& #& * 8& * $& ! (

3!%&* (" 6 +&+ (6 +* 3* ("

!1 '** &*( (& +

&=%&*&*"* '*($&$"#$& *"+& *($& &6 *'** &*( (& *($& %& (8'& (78($&+&3& *&+"*6"($($&3' "! (*'8 A& 3' "! (*/ &*%+&(*(* 7!"(* ($ (($& 6 +% **&+78($& '"*6&'' & *&+ +($&* !&$ * 7&& ''6&+% %& %% &3" (" &2"+&3&'&+787($($&% ("&* "!"'

'81'& *

3&!% 8* 7!"(*($ ( "(6 * 3 *& 8&#'"#&3& +

'(6 *6"($($&+&3& *&+ * $&6 *(#"#($&'& (*"+& +($&'" 7"'"(8$ * "#$('87&& "=&+

%($&6& ++

&+"#2&$"3'& @& + ($& !&(* +2 3&+ 78 '& &+ 3 *&' ($& ("&* +$ 2& '*#&($ #$($&"!% #&+6 +% **&+78($& ' +($& +3 !&(* 2 "' 7'& "'& ("* '* &'&2 ((!&("$& &($ (($&% &*&( %%& '6 *

"'&+ +&' 8 :

:+ 8* *($& 6 +6 *% **&+

+($& %%& '6 * "'&+

$&'8# +16$"3$$ *7&&( 0&"($& %%'"3 (" 3+ (" +&' 81"*($ (($& %%&'' ("* %

*("3 2"'' #& 16$6 *(0&&%"##+$& '($ +6 *( 6 & 7 (% **"# ($&"!% #&+ 6 + *$"*3 *&'+"+("

!$"!$& %%&'' ( 3( 3(&+$"*3 *&'"($&!($ 81

(06 7 (($&*( ( *

($&3 *& +'8($&$&3 !&(06($ (($&3 *&6 *+&3"+&+"($& 8&

$& 1($& %%&'' (&# #&+ 3 "'"# %%& ' + +&' 8 :

:+ 8*$ +33

&+" "'"#($&% &*&( %%& '16$"3$"*&"($&

"(&(" ' 6"''

'$&+&' 8$ * '*(7&&&=%' "&+% %& '8 *"( $ *(7&&!&("&+ *(6$&($& %%&'' (3 !&(06 7 % **"# ($& 6 +78($& '2&"($ *(7&&!&("&+"($& %%'"3 ("($ (($& %%&'' (&2& *0&+$"*3 *&' 7 (($&*( ( * ($&

3 *& ( $& +&' 8 $ * 7&& * "+ ( 7& ($& % ( ' 68& 3+ (" 6$"3$$ *7&&% 8&+'8($&# +($ (($& %%&'' ( "*

*("32"'' #& +

'(6 *($&% ($&' 68& *$&+"+( "

!$"! ($ *7&&$&'+"2 " *4 +#!&(* ($"*

( *6&'' * @97'&($&%&=

(($ ("3 *& %& *$"!*&'

%% 3$&*($&

( ( 7&' (&+*( #& +6"($ (#"2"# 8* ("* 3( 8&=%' ("1$& 3 (7' !& 8&&'*& ($&* !&($ * '*7&&$&'+($ (+&' 8 + ' (3$&*$ *7&&3*"+& &+(7&2& 8"!% ( ( 3( "&=& 3"*"#($& +"*3 &(" 8 &'"& %& *"*(2"#"' ( 7 ($"* "#$(1$&"*( &("('&+ ($&+"*3 &(" 8 &'"& (7&# (&+78($&

(" 2

($ (%& *3 *&1 %& * %% 3$&*($&

( '#+&' 8($&

& ** &&3&** 8(7&!&("&+"($& %%'"3 ("7 (* 3$ & ** $ 2&7&&!&("&+"($&% &*&(3 *&"!%'8"($ *7&&!&("&+($ ( %%&'' (3 !&(06 7 (% **"# ($& 6 +" 81

+ ($& $&&# #&+ ' 68& ( "'& %%& '(3 (7&% &* !&+($ ( %& *6 '+(7($& (3( 3($"*+23 (& 6 '+('"0&(#&(($& *( ( * ($&3 *& %& "+ 7 ((68& * +($& ( "'& %%& '

6"($ (!&(""# 8*

"3"&(3 *& 3+ (" +&' 8 2&!& "(*1($& %%&'' ("*($ 2"# #+3 *& *($& !*( 3&

' !&( "*&+ 78 '& &+ 3 *&' ($& *

3& !% 8"*($ ("(6 * 3 *& 8&#'"#&3&7 ( &7 (( '

($& & $ *7&&% ( ($ ($& %%&'' ($ *(

&+( 8 ! (& " '&2"+&3&(*$6($ (($&+&3& *&+6 * '*&#'"#&( +"(3 ( ($ *7&* "+($ (($&+&3& *&+6 * '* &*%*"7'& 3 *"#($& 33"+&( $& &"* *"#"

"3 (+"

&3&7&(6&&($&3( 8&#'"#&3& +

: ($&3!%*"(&&#'"#&3&$&3( 8&#'"#&3&"*6$& &($&%& * 6$"*3' "! ( &% &*&( ("2&$ +$"!*&'

(&+(($& 33"+&(1 6$& & *1"3 *& 3!%*"(&&#'"#&3&($&* !&"* (( (&++ * (62&$"3'&*"2'2&+"($& 33"+&(($&% &*&(3 *& '*1&"($&

8&2"+&3&$ *3!& &3 + 8 !&($ *7&& "*&+($ ("( 6 * 3 *& &#'"#&(+ "2"#;3( 8&#'"#&3& &#'"#&3& '6 8*+&*(!& 7*'

(&3 &'&**&**7 6 ( * 3$ +&# && 3 & *"* &B "

&+"% ("3 '

!*( 3&* 3 *& % (83 '+$ 2& 2"+&+($&3*&B &3& ($& 9*&#'"#&3& 6 '+7&'" 7'& ($& 33"+&( %& *9*&#'"#&( 3(;!"**"6 * ($& % ="! (& + "!!&+" (& 3 *& +& ($1 ($& 3( ($ ( ($& %& * *

"#"4

86 *$"!*&'

&#'"#&( + '*3( (&+(($& 33"+&( ($& 3"

!*( 3&*786$"3$($&"4

86 *3 *&+6 '+(

+ +& &3&(($&($& $&3( 8&#'"#&3&"* %%'"3 7'&*'&'8(($& 3+ 3( %& * 6$ "* &#'"#&( ($& % &*&( 3 *&1 &"($&

&#'"#&3&($&% ($&+&3& *&+$ *7&&% 2&+ ($&7 *"*

&2"+&3&'&+78($&% ("&* 8($"#$ *7&&7 #$((($&("3&

($&

"# !&(*$& %%&'' ($ * "'&+(% 2&$"*3 *&( '8+&' 87 (!& "(* *6&''$& "+"#* &3 +&+78($& '

&6&'' & *&+ + &7 *&+% %& %% &3" (" &2"+&3&$& 3%8 + "2"#'"3&3& ($&+ 6 *% + 3&+ *=$"7"(-/16$"3$ *$6*($ ($&6 *$'+"#+ "2"#'"3&3&6$"3$6 *2 '"+ %(:

+6 *&'"#"7'&(+ "2&!( 383'& *6&'' *'"#$(!( 2&$"3'&$& + "2"#'"3&3&6 *"** &+

+&2&7& &"** "# &# '

+ "2"#'"3&3&$&7( "&+'& 9*+ "2"#'"3&3&6$"3$6 * '*%' 3&+ &3 + *=$"7"(-/ +($ (6 *2 '"+

(

-?//

"+& , !

/'& 0

"3&A +$" % 2&+($&2 '"+"(8

($&'"3&3&(6 * '*% 2&+ &3 +($ (($&'"3&3&6 *% &% &+ ($&7 *"* '& 9*+ "2"#'"3&3&(6 * ($&*

3&!% 8 + 6&

&+"#2&$"3'&(% 2&($ (($&+

&+"# 2&$"3'&6 *($'+"#2 '"+ +&

&3("2&+ "2"#'"3&3& (($&("!&

33"+&($&'& &+ '$ * '*#"2& "+"#($ (($&* "+7 * 6 * *&+ *3$'%

%*&* +6 *(7&%& (&+6"($" &

0"'!&(& *$& (&%& !"(6 *"** &+78($&"*( "3( *% (

"3& * +($& 33"+&((0%' 3&"($& & ' $"$60 )"'' #& $&

>&(""*((A +$" + ** 3$1($&7 *6 *($& (&

6$"3$%& !"(6 *#"2&78($& *% ( ($ "("&*(6 * 3 *&

& 3$ (& !* +3+"("* ($&*

3&32& (& +"*

3& !% 8 6 * ( $&'+ '" 7'& ( % 8 3!%&* (" $& ! (

3!%&* ("% "+(3' "! (*3 (7&* "+(7&($&$"#$& *"+& 0&&%"#"2"&6($& #& ($&+&3& *&+1+&%&+&38 +($& !

3!%&* (" 6 +&+(6 +*+"

&($& +* 2"&6 ($& 3(* +' 6%*"(" *&=%' "&+ 72&1($& "*!& "("($&3(&("* "*&+78'& ($& %%&'' ( + ($& %%& '7&"#+&2"+ 8!& "("*$& &78+"*!"**&+

%4 ?$&($& *%& 0"#;

& *&+ C&* ?$&($& &% ( 7'& C&*