Vijender Singh Ahlawat v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#$% & ' ()
*+,+"- ...
( &( !
) /(# +( ...0
!!"#$! !!!$ ( ( ) 0 $)( ,3
4# ( /(
(")
*+5 +($,3 ( 0'-
(!"$,3 (+1
( ( 162"# $,"
,7$/(#
( 16)4+(-"$,3 ( ( 8 % !!$ :+
1
+ 4 "1(#
* ( (
;! ++ ((
8,
<!(.=-+(4#+1" +1
(+ 4
( !> + ((= ,
<!(.=8-+(4#+
11"
+(*
+ 4
>
:+1
(11"
( - ""
!
( "1"
% $ ) ( $+ 5&$5: ($> !(
*
;
>( (
*!1
!
( "( ' (# -(11("
:+(>
+ "" > -( 1
+ 0*!"( ?( ,"" > 0?, = 8 , 1(+0?,$
+ !> $$% @.4
*A +1( +1" ++4 1
"
*- ++11"
$ > !
8$$ =@. -( A +3"! +1" - 41
-
= # $>6
* A +1( +1" 5
+> +1(
++ > !
- 1 -
> , 1(+0?,+(>
*% A +1( +1" - 4 1 4#+""
3;!"
<> +"#
"> "
*- +
( B A1 +4" > !
(
*( >+ + ( 1
+3
.1#> +4" 1( 1 $+0?,- !"4 "" +1" ( !> 5 !"
1#
* #
"> ! $+"" - "
4" 1#
( B8A1 +!"> !
( >+! ""1#> , 1("!
+0?,+"" -
(;!
( (
(!
+4!
"
* 1(11( 34!
"
*1"
-
1( #( ( 1
>>( "1( !
- 4 (-
+(#( ( >+ ( 1
5 (!> 4# + ( " +"" $<
(>< >!>1( #( !"4*( ( (
*
(!
) > "("#$- <
$ #(+$ !"4*( ( (
* >>( "1( !
$ !4' +"" +3
* >1"(
1( *
(!
"!
+ 1( 3
( ( !>1
1" ( "!( >1"# - + + (>
"" > :+("3 1( 3
+0?,((1( !4" -
!"#$% !"
!&'&
"%'( !
!!!$ )* +$ !! !% %!&
$ ' % '
% % %,-) &%./ ! (% &! / !&
*0%!% !$&!11 "22 !
/ ) ! &!$!% * $ / ! '! $
= " &&&&% 2 0%
' '!"
!0%
$&)/'%
! , !
3"(/ !
"$% & %' ' 0 ,2
)$!$4% &4!
!!' ) !&% /+% *"(/ !! 0$'& ( !% &! / !5&6 &! !"
!&' ')'!&4!
!!&
% ! "(% !$&!718"22 !' ) !'
/ ) ! $ /!')'! % &! / !!%
!'! "(/ !2
!%& $*$'4 !% 0%
%&&)' ( ! $" $!%
//%!!
&) ' ) !% '% !% *!')/ ) !40% &
"( (!
!!0%!% "$% ' 9:'(&2 &!
!! &!%
!% )&! ' ) !$% /+% *!"(/ ! % &! / !5&64!
!!0%
$'' "" $!) %!( "$&
$% * $ $$&)/"!% !"
!2 &4!
!! !$! "" $!) %!( "$& $% *&
$''
&!%
' & !"(!! ! ')/ ) !
*0%!% !$&!&'%& )&&'
,4!"
!0 ) ' / % $$&)/"!% ;2 ') &!$) !% <= % *% ! "$!% &> 56
!! &
&!$!
&!$) !% )% '% * & "$ ""$ ,')% '% *"
&0%!% "$% ' ($ $ " &&&&% '0%
$-)%$'! &!$! //$ % "$ ') !% 0%!%
"$% ' !$($& $ /!'! $ " &&&&% 2 0,$4 % &!
!!%& ! ! &!$!
&!$) !% 0%!% ($4 .! &% *$ !'(! /"! !)! $%!( $ /.%/)/"$% ' ($4% !
!!%& ! &!%& (! )! $%!(!!!
!! ) ' !&!$!
&!$) !% $$& & ( '%&
!$ 2 )$!$.! &% &%./ !& &
0'! &!$!
&!$) !% "(/ ! "$& $%'.! &% % !
!! & !+ ( !
0% * !%, &!"& $ %/"
/ !!% !"$ ? !> %2 ""$ , )% '% *"
&2 %%2
/ ! $'$& $/ % $( ' !$ "%! * '&2
8 %%%2 %
% !%)"%
)'% *") % $ &$&2 %,2 % '/$+!% *!%)"2 ,2 $ 3?)$ ,%2
( !$,*$( %$ )/&!
&( '% ,&! $@&
!$
%
% !% *&$% )& '% " %&% %!(! %/"
/ !! "$ ? !%22&,$& ! $ $* $ &&% %/% $ (4!"$% ' //
/ ! "$ ') !% .! ''(! /"! !)! $%!( $"$% ' ($ &)? !! !
!!&!%& (% *!)! $%!(!! ) ' !* % !
"$ ') !% 0%!% !$($& !'! $ " &&&&% $ $& & ( ' %&
!$ ' ! + !%, &!"& $ %/"
/ !!% ! "$ ? !2 .! &% % &) "$% '4 $
//
/ ! //$ % "$ ') !% ( '!$($&&
*$ !'
(% 1: !"$/%&&% *$ ) ' ,$*&
&!$) !' ' !%,&!"&, !+ (!
!! $!
/"
!% !"$ ? !2%/% $ (4&
'.! &% ($ $
/"
!% !"$ ? !%22 !$ )$($& $ /!'! $ " &&&&% 0%
0'% &0$!
!!& %,'!
&!A: !"$/%&&% *$ ) ' ,$* '/ % $(& $'$'2 !!&.! &% &%22 $8! ($& '! ($ $ /!'! $ " &&&&% 0%
&)? !! "(/ ! .! &% !!$!&'!$/% ' $ /!%/! !%/ '&
"( (!
!!! ! $" $!% 2 6
!!0%
'/'! , /"
!'!"$ ? !%
&!$) !&/% %/)/A !"$/%&&% ,$'$ '&!$!
//$ % "$!% &0%!% &" % %'"$% '&/ !% ' ,4 !$% &!
!% !"
! '/ % $(&"$"$ ? !$" $!
&)/%!!'(%/2 &4!$%& (',%!% % $&" ! % &!
!% "
! '/ % $(4! /"! ! )! $%!( 0%
/"! !! ' %'0!$!"
% ! '/ % $(0% & ! % &!
'& (/!$% $% * !"$ ? !2
$!% % ! /"
!% "$ ? ! &
%&&)' ( ! /"! ! )! $%!( ""
% !% (!
!!2 AB
>3 0%
/"! ! ! $&)/ "
!& % %!& % ')&!$% &!!&% &
!!' ) !&% /"
(% *0%!! !$/& '
'%!% &
!/ !!$ & $ &% *!
2$&)/"!%
"
!0%
""$ ,'(! /"! ! )! $%!( !$ *%,% *& 0 )& !% 2 "
$&)/"!% 4!"$%
%" / ) !
'" &%!'(!
!!0%
$ ) '' !$'') !% *1: ! "$% !"
!0%! )! (% !$&!2/ ) ! % !$&!"%'
% &!
/ !&4% (4&
& &! ' $ %!'2
!!0%
$! $/ ,!&!$) !)$'$%&4% (40%!% "$% ' !0 / !& $&)/"!% $'$!%& 0 &!4 % % *0% %!&
$/ ,'(!!!
!!@& &!2!/(
$% %'!!
!
!!&
! !%!
'! ("(/ ! /" &!% $ )% '% *
&!$) !'(%! !$&)/'"
!2 A2
>3 $&! $!% $&)/'"
!&
0'2 0,$4 "" &
%! //%&&% $ ')&!$%&= ,!2 $( *% &!
! $'$& ! /"! ! )! $%!( $'$% *$&)/"!% & "(= = ,
<!(.$+1!#7 ("
*(/)55$5: ((
>+1
(+
( (!!(
) ( - !"4(#4#= (+$
/-
(> + ,1( "$ - !"4+ ( 1
+1" 5-
>++1( +(#( ( >1">
+1( '- !"4 (6 - ,1( "$
:+ +!" 4" 1#> -( % A
+ 1" - !"4
> 1("# :+1
(- (;! 6
(# 1 ( >1">
+11( 31( '$ >"# 6 11( 1
$ *
* 11( 3" 4!
"
* 1" >6
*
"
(( *> ( >1">
+1( ' :+1
((1"
3 "( 8 ,
<!(.=++- (# 611(1
+ 1" (;! ++4"
3(+11(1
1" 5
+ +1
(+-+ +3
+
+1" + !" " + 3" 1> $-+ 3($+6 1" 4
>
1( 3 /$ >> "#$(
"(C
,
<!(.8 (
1
* + ""6 4
(3
-( !11"#$ 11( +( $ -(* "(
+
$
*+$
3 - +( $+- - +(-
*+
11"
8 (6
*11(
$-+ +- !"46 "#( >1"
" +4
(3 +
5- (;! +1+#
"1
+1" >#4 * 3 $(+(+ 11(1
- + ! >1"
*4
(3 +
$
+
(# 1 ( >1">
+ 1( ' !" 4 6
>> "# :+ 1
( ( 3 (
+ "( :+
(>
( 34#+1
(!
(+0:5,+( !*+"(
C ,
<!(.
(>+4 3" 1> , 1(+
(>
/:"
( +"
% $) ( + 5&$5: ($ -(
+1(
4
*($-+ +- !"4 (* D4#
C
:+( (
"(
C
>
*+
( (!!(+
- >1"$1
+1" ( - 8 "(# 3# )+!" 4" 1#> -( %
% 1" - "
* 3
+
"( 5 - "
> + +
>1">
1( +(#( 1((> "" > - !"4(6 - 8
:+1
(3 "(% C ,
<!(.% 4' + ( 1+#
"1
4
** 3 (( 1 3"#-
8
/(;! ++ ( 1
1" + !"4>( > + !" >1"
( (!!(+
!(+((;! + - +!" 1#> (+4" +"" > 1( 4
!- + ! +(*
*
( ""+ >1"
( (!!( + !(
* +"(% C $+(
"( % ,
<!(.
(
*+""+
( (!!( "
-(3 "4"+
:+1
(- 6 3
+ #- (6
*#"
*-
#1( (6
*1+#
"1
+1" :+1
(( "(8
%,
<!(.C
*+++3
+ +( "
*- ++(;!
!
(6
* (;! +1+#
"
4* 3 + > :+( -("
(;! !11"#
-@( +!" 4" 1#> +1#>
""> !" 4>-
> >1">
+1( '4 (+
:+ !
(6
*
.'! " >111( 1( (>- "
"
- ++
"( :+( 3 "(C
%,
<!(.(1"
++(;!
+"(8
%+ 4
( 4! :+1
(- (;!
( 1
+1#> 1(
+!""(#* 3
+"(
C
0
! C %,
<!(. +1
((;!
(
*+ > + -!
-+#+1" 4 ( !>
(+
"!( 1
+!> !
-
+1( ( 4 > 5- +
;! +"" > +1" +1
( = 8$+-
(;!
( 1#+4" % A +1"
3;!+"#("#
""> "
*- +
( ( >+ ( 1
%$ !> $=$C% @.- !
**
+ > (+ (
"">
:+ 1
( !4> +
(1"#
C % ,
<!(. + + -!
#
* #!" +
1( /
(+ ++(;! +( 3(" > "
3(!"
1+#
"1
* 3( +!" +4" > !
!4!
/!(+( +
>1"
+"( %
!
(6
* (;!
(+4 * 3 4#+1
( +"(
* +
- ""
*
61+#
"1
+4 $-+ +- !"#( 3
+ +(
/( (++1
(+ 4 >
" (*(
*3 "4 "
#
( (!!(+
:+( -((;! - +(-+ + -!
C % , +( ( $ + 1
( " >1"
!
( )
+
!>( (
,$C
4 (+
!>(
1! 0(
"E (!>$ +6!" ( + (F+E (!>G 8 %1"
* #
(3 +1( +(
(
*1
+
- + !1( 3
*4
>
:+ >1"
-
3 (( % ,
<!(.= :+( -(+"*!
"# #
(3 :+ E (!> + 1("(8 %$+ ( 1
+4
(3
( > 8
C
/ -3($+(3
1# +!"-
!
:+E (!>+"+1( ( +
( (
C 1 "# #6
!"4+(* :+( -( (
!+
""> +!"( +$61
*
>
++ (
""> + !"4
+ - +34 1#4"
= +
( (1 "# #6
- +(*4"4 (
:+1
(- -( @.
>1
:+ ((- ( 4 >1"
- +$-
1(
> + ( >+ >>!
5
>1"#
*- (
+ E (!> $ + (
! + - !
8 C,
<!(.8 (( !>1
1" ( (
*
(!
-
1( - #( ( >+ ( 1
1(+(>
+"" > :+1
(
+
(1"#
C ,
<!(. 1
!++ - !
4" (3
+!" 1#> +4
!4#+( (4#+ E (!> :+1
(!
( 6 >61#> -
# +1#>
+!"4
*
! = +(
!(3
+!" 1#> ,
<!(. !
( )(
""> ! (
1"
( -
"" ! : " ""!
= =%C
== = =
C =%C
8 =C
=
=(
= C =%C
=8 88
8+
C C =%C
8= 8%C%
+
= =%C
% 8=CC :+(4#$+- (;!
( 1
$
"!>1 !>$+4" % A1#>
$ 4"
< > +"#
"> "
* - + +
( +(* +(
(( 1 3"# :+ !*++1
("* >"#"+
( !" +3 4 +(*$+ -3($+1
> !
$8$C@.
=
-(
"> "($
$@.
!
(1(
!
=($8+ +
""> 8$8$
@.$8$$%C%@. 8$$=CC@.( 1 3"#- +
( $4
*+!""
"1#> ( !
$ @. :+(($+(;! 3 "(
,
<!(.C$++1+#
"1
+1" 4* 3 + >$ + + !" (
(!
>1"> +1( ' /-( # +("(
,
<!(.(;!
*+( "
3(1+#
"
+ 1" + > / "
((( +("
( "( 8 =
8 :+
- "" - 4# # +( "( % ,
<!(. 4#(*
(1 - ++ >(;!
*
* # (
+
(;! ( +
* 3( 1+#
"
$ + -
!
,
<!(.= + - !
-+#+1" "" + >4 ( !> :+( !>1
-
1( 1 +*( !
+1+#
"1
+1" + 4
6 H
*(> - + + (1 (
+ 4 <!H
(!
- ( (+1( ' >1"> -
+ 1 1( 3 (+<1 (# !( +"#( 3+(- !"
1#> +1" :+1
( !4> +
"(1"# +
+ -!
= ,
<!(.8 + !
(
*+ >$ +(
!# +( + -!
=,
<!( . (( !>1
+1" :+1
( !4> +
(1"#
=,
<!(. +
-""
:+1
(- (1(
"
+(
*4 (+I *> >> % 8 5
(" !4>
+1
( !4> "(1"# -""
/ -3($
( !>1
((
8,
<!(.=- 1
:+ (( +1+#
"1
+1" - (
C
:+1
(+ " (
(!
#-
- #( +(
$4#8 C ( ++ ( >1"> +1( '-
+ 1!"+(#( (
$8 C C$-+ +- < !1 8 C (
"!
*
#(* ("<
:+11" "4#+1
(-
>
4# +,11"" >> 3 ((= ,
<!(.=8
/ +1( -( 1
? !
" (+1
( ++E (!>+1 +1" +1
((*(
*
3 "4 "
#
( (!!(+
4# ((%
+( -((;!
(
!+
">
+!"
( + ++ (
"> + !"4 + - +34 1#4"
= 5- "
(+
( (1 "# #6
+(*4"4 (
/(*!+
>1"#
* - + (
+E (!>$+(
! + -!
8 C,
<!(.8 (( !>1
1" ( (
*
(!
-
1( - #( ( >+ ( 1
1(+(>
+"" > :+1
( !4> +
(1"#$4!+ + - !
- ( 11 5- "# = +(
! (3
+!" 1#> ,
<!(. :+1
(1
+ ( > !
!
(1( 4#
+(( (1 >>!
+( "
3(1+#
"1
+1" + >$4!- + ! #(
/(*!$+
+ (!> $+1
( !" 4 +" +33 "+(>
+"" > "( , +
+(
( !>
*+1" - ""*"
? !
" (+( + +(+ + ( !>1
((
*++1
(+3 "+(>
+"" > "( :+1
(-
>++ (
- $-+ +- "((3
$4!+1
( "
4("# 61
( + (
(!
/(*!+
+(3
+!" 1#> +3
*4
>3 "( = $+("
( + -!
C- !"4> +3 4 - +(- + 1
( !*+ +3 4 4# + (>
+0?, /(*!++("
4#+1
( + (( +E (!>
>
1" +(- ((4#E (!> (3
+ ( 1
( > "(# >>!
+3+(? !
" (+1( 1(!
+( ( ( +3 -++
+E (!>%
$ -+ ++ 4 14#4 +1( $
46 + (
*1
(>
+" > +1(
+
1
2 (+E (!>$+1
( +1" # (3 +1( (
1( 3
*4
(3 +
+1" :+( $ + +(+ $+1"$ ++ !*+
""#+ ( 1
- $ - "( (3
3 "(8 %$4#-+ ++
( (!!( "
+4 1( 3 2!+1
(- "
4("# 6
*
:+E (!>1+1" +1
( $+"+(
4*!
"# (3 -( >1
@.
5 (+(
!
"> +!" (1#> ( +$- ++
= (
"> 41#4"
=
( (1 "# #6
- 4+(*4 (
5 3 - +
(( +E (!>$+("
( !" $ #$ +1
(-( 4 :+(>
+0?,$+(($+ 4( !
(
+"
*+ + (
+E (!> :+E (!>+ (++ ((4 >1"
- +-
1( > + + >>!
/ -3($+(3
+!" 1#> -
!4#+( "# =
$( "# 4 ! >
, 1(+
+!"$+
"> - + - 4!
= $4 !- #( 4 (+
! +
+!" 5
$ + ! ( "" +
"> $ 4((
* + " -+ + -
= $-(4 (+
! +
"( 5
4 * (+
! ( !
3 "
+ (
+E (!> E!(+($3
4 (+
! +(3
1#> +!"$+(
! + - !
C +1
( (( !>1
+1" (
(
*
(!
+
$-+ ++1
((1"
2!
+( - >>!
+1
( :+1
(1 + !*+!
( 1( $+ (> !
>
+(3
1#> +!"4#
8 :+(($+(
!>( !
"(
$
% (;!
*+( (3
+ ( 1
+ 3(1+#
"1
+1" + > 2!+ "( "
(
5
$(
!!(+( + -!
(( !>1
-+ +$!" >"#$" +1
* + >1!* ((
8 ( >1(
- ++(*!> +? !
" (+ ( ++E (!>+ "# (+
! (3
+!" (1#> (++ ( 1
"
4(3
:+ ( 1
4."
6( >+ +!" 1#>
">
, 1(+(>
+0?,$+1#> + 3 ;!"
<> +"#
"> >> ( >+ ( 1
:+E (!>+3
* (+(
!(3
1#> +!" - ++ (
"> + - 41#4"
= - + +(
">
"" -$+("
( ( 1
$
"
"">
* 5
+"(8 %$-+(
- >>!
+(3
( 1
$ + ( + "("# + + 4
( (!!( "
+4 >1"+
/ -3($ +
* +E (!>(*(
* # (3 $4"
+
+ ( ++
( (!!( "
-( >1"4#
C
:+ 4
+
( 1
$++
( (!!( "
-( >1"4#+ $+3
*4 !
4 (($ !" "
*(4("
1 "
D+1
( 5 !(3 -$(+
+E (!>$ -
!>4 + ( "# >>!
( + +!" 1#> $4!"
(3
+ ( 1
"
+(- , + >1"
(!
+ 4(6 (
*"# :+!
$-( +3 -++ + -!
+ >1!* (( 1( -+ ""#(( !
1(>
4#(
*
+ ( 1
"!
*++1
(+!"
6
*1
(
* >1"
*
(!
-
>
:+
+!1 +(3
+!"= 4
* !(
+ + + - !
C - > +3 4
- +(-
-"" !
#3 !11 (+( J
,(= +1
((1"# !*+1(>
"!
*4#+
"(
= $
$
% :+(- (
+ "(
,"
$+(
* ( ( + -$+ # >+(($ +- 6 61
$-+ ++"
E!(+($+1
(
#3 $
4<1
!>+ + + -!
C- >1"
"#- +(- !1 +( 1 +(3
+!"
+( J "(= :+ ( " !*+ +3 1 ""# ""!1 +1
( 61
$-+ + 3( , (
*"#$ +
-( 1
"" - :+ ((
8,
<!(.= 8 C ,
<!(.=8(;! + :+ ( ( ( + 3(1+#
"1
"
% $) (
$+ 5&$5: (> !(
*
);
>( +1
( /4 "
>>!
( + +!"
(!
( >+ "
3(#
%!"#& %!!& ! '() $
* ,!"
++( 16
*@(
K @ ++(01 (4" K @