← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4955/2012dismissed

Icici Lombard Gen Insurance Co Ltd v. Usha Rani & ORS

2015-03-09Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg7 pages



         

 !"#"$%&%'( )*+ ,#"'", -'&., '$" //"-- '!& 0",&.&

&1  '% '#!1",&  "&/'#"'!&   23 4)

 56

 71"!1", "/,!",&)$ -"8&/ /",&* 9+" --8"#!  &""!1":.#;*"'!< 9"& +","",,"#!!1" "/,!",&,'!<9"& (71"!1",!1":.#;*"'!&1.-#+","/,!"#%'!1"%;"&!<9"& 

,"&"'!251,% :+%,5%';1=#0$ !",!1" //"-- '! 51,%5.&1%- .!1 *== ,9 '   1 --"';"%'!1%& //" -%&!1"8 ,## !"#>/ &&"# +9 & 0:!51 -= !,$$%#"'!- %*&,%+.' -= !% - 0%#"81%$1 $- %*/"!%!%'/,"",,"#+9!1"$- %* '!&8 & --8"#8%!1$&!& '#!1" $- %* '!& 8"," 8 ,#"# $*/"'& !%'  &=?=@ &=A3 '

$$.'!-&&$'&,!%.*!81%$1$- %* '! &1  '%+"%';

8%#8!1"#"$" &"#%&"'!%!-"# -';8%!1%'!","&!BC/ =,*!1" # !" %-%';!1"$- %*/"!%!%'!%-- $!. -," -%D !%'!1" 8 ,#"# *.'!  "0E%  "0%  $- %* '!    8 &  --8"#  A(,# &1 ,"    !1"

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

 ,"&/'#"'!&  !%$"!1"$- %*/"!%!%'8 & ;%0"'! !1","&/'#"'!&

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

% -  '# 8%!1.!! E%';'!"!1","#!, %$-%;1!&!,%"#!/ &&1%&$9$-" '#%' !1 !/,$"&&=1"&!,.$E ; %'&!!1"+.&1"$9$-";'".'#",'" !1!1"+.& '#!1"1" #!1"#"$" &"#&!,.$E ; %'&!!1"+#9!1"+.&  ' '!%$%'; !1"   - ,*=!1"+.&8 &&!//"#   1"/"/-"!E.!!1" #"$" &"#.'#",'" !1!1"+.& '#1"8 &.'##" #1"- +.,",/,"&"'! !1"&/!!-#1%*!1 !!1"#"$" &"#8 & ##%$!"#!%'!I%$ '!& '#1" #"-%+", !"-9#%#'!'!%$"!1"!, %$-%;1!&"#"'%"#!1" --"; !%'& * #"%'!1"$- %*/"!%!

"&/'#"'!3'&., '$"*/ '9, %&"#!1"-"; -+:"$!%'&!1 ! !1"#,%0",!1"+.&%'F."&!%'#%#'!1-# 0 -%# '#""$!%0"#,%0%';

 -%$"'&" !!1"!%*" --";"# $$%#"'!=,"&/'#"'!=!1"8'",!1" +.&8 &'!1-#%';0 -%#,";%&!, !%'$",!%%$ !"=%!'"&&$",!%%$ !" '# ,.!"/",*%! !!1"!%*" --";"# $$%#"'!1","&/'#"'!+"%'; 8'",!1"+.&=1 '#"#0",!1"+.&!!1"& %##,%0",1 0%';E'8-"#;" !1 !!1"#,%0",#%#'!1-# 0 -%# '#""$!%0"#,%0%';-%$"'$"!#,%0"!1" & %#+.& '# &&.$1=!1","%&0%- !%'!1"!",*& '#$'#%!%'&!1" '&., '$" -%$91" $!.* $$%#"'!8 &#"'%"# '#-% +%-%!9!1" '&., '$"*/ '98 & -&#"'%"# H ,":%'#",8 &%-"#

,* !1" /-" #%';&!1" / ,!%"&= --8%';%&&."&8",", *"#23  71"!1",#"$" &"# ,#"0 &&#%"#%' *!,0"1%$-" $$%#"'!$ .&"#+9,"&/'#"'!, &1-9 '# '";-%;"'!-9'H?= & --";"#<

  71"!1",$- %* '!& ,""'!%!-"#!!1"$*/"'& !%' & /, 9"#,=%&,*81*<

 ( 71"!1",,"&/'#"'!8 &'!1-#%'; 0 -%##,%0%'; -%$"'$" !!1"!%*" --";"# $$%#"'!=%&=%!&""$!< 

"-%" ? 1",%+.' -= !", &&"&&%';!1"!"&!%*'9!1"8%!'"&&"& / ,!-9 $$"/!"#!1"$- %*/"!%!%' '# --8"# & ,"& %# 

""-%';#%&& !%&%"#8%!1!1" +0"& %#8 ,#=!1"'&., '$" */ '91 &#%,"$!"#!1"/,"&"'! //" -  1 0"1" ,#-" ,'"#$.'&"-,!1"/ ,!%"& '#1 0";'" !1,.;1!1","$,#&!1"$ &"

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

#"/"'#"'$9  1 &  +""'  $ -$.- !"#  +9  #"#.$!%';   A!1 %'  ,"&/"$!    1%& /",&' -"I/"'&"&1"*.-!%/-%", //-%"#%'!1"/,"&"'!$ &"8 &H '#%' !1%&* ''",!1"!! - *.'!$ -$.- !"#8 & &IHJ &=?=A3 '!1",&.* &=A31 &+""' --8"# &.'", -"I/"'&"&=-&& "&! !" 1"& %# *.'!$ ''!+"& %#!+""I$"&&%0"1" *.'! %'$*"  &>A3/",*'!1$ ''!+"& %#!+"'1%;1",&%#" !1",8%&" -&=%'$ &"!1"*%'%*.*8 ;"& ,"! E"'=%'!1 !$ &"= !", ! E%';%'! $$.'!.!.,"/,&/"$!.&%'0%"8 .!1,%!9  

  !"# $# % 

   &  # 

'('#!#)(

* &%+ =!1"%'$*"8.-#+"*,"!1 ' &>A3/",*'!15=!1"

*.'! --8"#+9!1",%+.' -$ ''!+"& %#!+"'1%;1",&%#"  '&"F."'!-9=!1" //" -/,"",,"#+9!1"'&., '$"*/ '9 %&8%!1.! '9*",%! '#!1"& *"&! '#&#%&*%&&"#  $/9!1%&:.#;*"'!+"&"'!!!1"!,% -.,!,&!,%$! $*/-% '$"  '(  ,-. / 0  

!

+