Heera Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS
! ! "
"# $% &'('% )
$%*#("% &(O&M)
$%&(* % '
$% "% )
!"
$%( #"% )
$%("% )
$% & % )
$% &' "% )
$% &')#% ) $#
"
$% &'' % ) %
$% &''% ) &
$% &'' % ) (
$% )" % ) $#
"
$% )" )% ) ) !"
$% '(&% )
&#
$% #')% ) * !
+
$%(**)% &
$% *( (% # %
!
)'
!
+
*
+ ,-+ ! . / , - .
"
/
$'1
-
!
#
$'1
23
+/ (456 4655 8490
+/ (4680 46440 44898
84 -
0 $'1
23
+/ (960 90 90
980 940 90 480 4690 4 84
+/ (4965 84
- $#
:
;0 $'1
-
&# $'1
+/<5686<84 -
$'1
23
+/<484<84 - .
0 $'1
-
&# $'1
23
Mr. S.S. Gill, Advocate for Mr. M.S. Batth, Advocate for respondent No.3 in CWP-27327-2017.
Mr. H.K. Aurora, Advocate for the respondent-M.C. Jalandhar in CWP-24505-2019. -
$'1 (5
+/<4<84 /0! 1## 0 =
<# 4
/ # ( +/<<8430
! 1
$
( -
+ " " " !
885 1 1
*
1
>
4
;0 885
*
' '
,
!
"
#
$
5 ? 1' 1 1
1 # +/ (96 84 6 1
?
"
1
;
4 1 1
*
1 " !
= # # $ @ +
.1120./1 3 41 5 ! 65 41 7 &8*. .' # !
1;
1 46 %1# 0 889
> 1 %
/ A/ !
+ ;
* # " 1;
4 - 10 844
* 1;
<+
( +< %1# 0 844
? "
#0 1 1 1
1
"
>
4 %1# 0 84
1 1
$@
& <4
B
$
#
5 $
84
,< C-
+ 0 $#
*
A
&
B
* % * *
($ +2*3A56
% , 5A5A4
, $
#
?
-
1 + %
#0 -
+ 0 $#
(
+< % , 8A4A844 -D-B $(%:- E
;
?
588< 4898488
"
1
0
; E
1 ; ;
"
1# ,< $
1 # 23 $ 1 #
% 1
" ;
; 0 ;
;
1 23 $ + + -
%1
;
;
'
! 23 = ;
0 ;
;
- ; #
23 = 0 ;
1 + 0
1 23 %
! 1 "
)
- E
0
;
'
;
' -
%
#
1
;
*!
19:12
.46 ;<< 9 ==<9<
6 925!1666!
A< $
+## 2*13 ? +## -
+ $#
@@@@F 9 = 1 " 4
;0 8850
# + ;
?
1# "
' #
4
;0 885
(1
##
+
'
1
0 #<=0 <= "
,< C.' #
%
# ?
1 2?
1
1<==3 % + - 10 885 (A4A885<?==A8 <= @ 1
" 1
'
$ 1 8 + 23 $ 1 4 + =
"
0 .' 0
1
1
'
! "
# +
'
0 #<=0 <=0 # ;,< *
+
'
1 2?
$##3
0 885
*
# 1#
1 1 # 4
;0 885 = +
'
1
0 #<=0 <=0
0 "
'
243,<
'
C '
<=<
#<== +
'
1
0 #<==
.' # "
*;
1' "
G% + ;
1#G
.' #
1 F
1
1 .' # %
# ?
1 (A4A885<?==A8 % 0 + - 885F * 1H1
##
' #
4
;0 885
!
1
+
'
1
" "
4
;0 885 1 '
1
#<=0 <= +
'
1
*
1 1
# " ! ##
("
+ ;
?
1#
#
1 " 4 ' 1# #
4
;0 885
+
# % 1 +
19
-<5 4.:
>9 41 0 7"8. "&
# # #
19
-<, 1 2
$ @ + .-! "()' " # 5 ('# 0 846
? 1
1
% 1 #
$!"*(' )4 :120 "
.:< 6 41 5 ! . :
>9 41
" % 1 1
' '
1
.?
1#
" "
885
> F #
!
$ @ +
1
) $
2+
(++A44 84 # 4 B1 0 84 ) + #
+## ? ;0 84
?
1 %
#0 .' 4
;0 885
1#
("
% + ;
?
1# "
# 4
;0 885
;0 84
1 '
1;
;
#A
>
;0 84
= 1
" "
1 4
"
# ;
>
;0 84 " ' ("
+ ;
?
1#
48 1 1
-
+ 23 #
> 1;
8440
1 1' 1
1;
# 1 ;
' ("
+ ;
?
1# "
1!
' ("
+ ;
?
1#
B
44 = 1
1
4 $
1 -
+
.' # (
;0 45 -
+ D?
0 45
@ 1
" 1
1 4
1 -
+ $10 49
2!3
2 30
4
,< CH
;
1F #
+ "
;
# +
1
;
.' # 0
;
=# '# * 0
+##
;
1 : !
## ;
'
1I 7<8 '
1F # 1
+ I '! 1<15
1< ??1 =
!
< ?
;0
1
+
'
1
0 # ==0
# # +
#
@ "
0
# #
#
+
'
1
0 # =0 J = ,
'
'
1
+
K= +
'
1
0 # ==0
;L 23 $ 1#
#
1
+
'
1
0 # ==
# # # #0 D@1 B +
# D@ 0 H
;
# #
23 * D@ 0
1
11 1
;
"
$
@ M$N 1
/ 1
0 1
;
1
1!
0 ;
1 ?
"!:
>9 5<.15 :< < ==<2!% $;
.
'
?0 "
1 1' 0
'
'
+
'
1
;
1 1F 2#
3
4 B 1
2!3
2 3 45
0 =
> +
# H
;
'
?
;
1 1' -
+
' +
'
1
=
1! 1
1# 1 +
1
;> ,
/
" H ;
1'
"
19
-<,
2
I
+ 1' 1
>
' ("
+ ;
?
1#
O
4 19
, -< 45 = ) G 0
1 + !
# @
# 1 %
/
'
"
H
;
#
" 1 .?
1#
1
"
.' #
4
;0 885
%
/ D# ; 4 $0 4
1 "
> %
# - 10 886 * H
' '
#
#
( '
* 1
1
#
) G
,< C/ # = #
848 D@1 D 0 /
% 0
#
;0 848 '
1
# " ;
"
+ ;
1# *
;#
$@
<4 *
;#
11
1
8848 2$@
4A3 *
888480 ?
1 %
#N
1 4688 "
1
0 " "
.' # 8484885
" 1
>
84848850
"
C% + ;
1#F
# * "
?
1 %
#
=% 4848F
46 * % 1
1
4<$ +
'
1
"
'
GH
;
1G 11
,< C/ 1# 11
N
#
>
"
* ; !
B1
1
H
;
#
1!
#
4
#
1#
>
886 "
'
;
"
1# "
1 +
1# #
1 " 44885F
2#
3 49 / 1##
"
1
0 % 1
,< C? #
' 1 0 " 1# 11
# 4
>
1
H
;
#
'
44885 * "
< 1 % +
1# 2$@ <43
1 "
.' #
'
" 84848850
*
## $@ <
# +
'
1
0
#
A 1 8688 2$@ <3 *
1 ' .?
1#
1
1
.'
'
1
44885
= "
'0
" $11 ;
1 "
" !
H
1
11 ;
8688 2$@ <30 "
+ ;
1# "
(
" " !
44885
>
4 = #
GH
;
1G
1#
-
1
% 1 +
1> 1. ?45 !.:
>90 *7"8.
* #
,< C*
'
1
% 1 )1
.' #
1 1 # 0
1
'
"' 0
;
'0
" H MH
;
1N 1# # ; ! 1 "
+? # 1
MH
;
1N
1
#
23
; "
# -
? "
1
1 -
$1 * "
F
' ##
23
1
4232
0
1
'
+## "
$
48 " #
PF
* 10 0 11
",<
C4 &
"
' 1
1# 10
'
MH
;
1N
1 # !
1 + ?
;
11 '
* #
&
1
*
0 0 1
0 "
"0
;
@
;#
"
-
+1
2 (53 =
;#
1
" # "
;
1
;
"
1 *
;#
'
'
-
+1 =
;
! -
+1
"'
1#
F
4 * ;
> 1 +
* # " H
;
1 2!3 45
#
4
;0 885
D'
>
# ;
"
"' 0
;
1A
#
#
*0 ;
4
;0 885
# " + ;
?
1# 1 # 1 '
;0 + ;
?
1# "
# ;
4
;0 885 "
) 4
1
?
1 %
#0 .' # ? ;0 840 "
,< C.' # ?
1 %
#
2?
1 1;
+
13 * $ %
#0
+ $ %
+## 0
% 1
$ % ;
+##
, /
# "
+ ;
1#
1
A = A .'
/ 1 #
'0 = 1 ;
1 (6A 55A 84A 6 8884
(4
#
1 ;
#
1 " 44885 #
A
#
* 0 !
"
1 1
?
1 %
# 1
!
1 .'
1A )1
' " $;
#A
> 84 " 1'
'
"
("
% 1 ;
1# * 0
1 (6A 55A 84<6*A 6 84
@ 44885
84 *
1 1#
# 1 ;
A< :
1 ?
1 +
'
?
1
+## A $ +
1;A 1
1; $ $#
1;
'
#
A
"! ! )
A<:
1 ?
1F 8 *
# # 1 0 +
1
" ;
#
" +
19
-<, 1 2
%
B10
!
11 1 ? ;0 840
1
; 4
;0 !
"
+
;
1# 11
' B
+ ;
?
1#
#0
1 ;
;0
" Q # '
"
'
=
1' 1
#
!
'
# 45
+
'
1
;
' B
#
##
+
0
# - 10 885
1
#
4
;0 885
*
+
4
;0 885
1
*
' 45
0
;0
5 $ 1 ! 11
91:12 0 " 7/8 =1 Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No