High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7764/2014dismissed

Laxmi Devi v. Huda & ORS.

2015-01-08Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages

" #$%& '( )(* (+(,&-.% */(+ /( '

.0 2 #1 31 2 #1 3

#) ( 1()&45/(6 0&6(/.( 1( (&03/6 0&6((.0 ! 1(5 7(6 00- 6(+6((.08 1(3*0(/-6 0&6 1 *.0(5*(6 0&6((.0" /--7/.(9(./%%* 00 " !

8 :

$*( ; !<6 9/(,+ / (6 6 ( / 7(0 .(% (.0 " (=(;( ( 00,*-07.((-0-03( 8;6( (09//.-*,%0,+/0(.0 /.(--.-,(7 8>!63( 8; 6(69/(/.((07((*7(0- /* / /( /06 3*0% 77(9- 0 55/*( 9( / 9( -0 %*(7 ?"

@*( %( %.(7 5/( AB> =! % / 0 -0 9 *,C %( @* &0 0-(00!

8 >> *0*0(3A/#0 @*

6 >A 9&(6 / 0 -0 9 (-0 (% @* ,+ / ((6 9 *(+ -76 (+6 /4*- /(*7/ %%* 00(0 / 0%((6 6 (

8 >>B :

$*( ;8< / %%* 00 8 >>B6 9/ (-06(0*0( D (% +* / (0 0 *,C / ( / -0 ,-77 3/( 3*0% 77(9- 0 55/*(69//--5/(A?> =!%6%*(7?"

@ %( 9// /. /& , (*06 0 (-0 *,C/0,+/&(%(+&*( /..-/..-/0./0&-.%/(7 (07 (.& ( 7(% (. / /(7*((00&-.%0--/(0/- ,$*0/(7(06(+(*/&-(0+, *0 +* 0 /6 / ..- /0 (&0 + %.9/(7(0@*(0-0/(-+(47 (%(%/#0 @*--(6(6/% , (&(0 (% / ..- * ( (@*0 0 / 7(%/($*7/%(%/..- /(-E / 0 -0 9 70 ,+ 3*0% 77(9- % ( 9 %(+F(.0"&0700 00 8 !!

! :

$*( ;A< /*6 (.0 " -% , 9(/.(/-0(-0,+3 *(*/7((-67(%9$*0 > !!

8 :

$*( ;"< ,9 / 9( / -0 0 / &(% (+ 7 /(*7/ / ((6 (, .(%6 (+ ;*%; / 0%((6 6 /4*- (%/0/7(%6/9(/0.+0&-.% /(7 6!"6B?

=;69/(/,*-07.-9(,..(&0 (%/%.*/(+,(%%7+(*3% /(-&0(%/7(%(0*0( D:< //.(%/0.+9(00&-.%/(7 -*% 6!"6B?

=;0(%0&0-(!8 >> 00 B !!

!/(6 6((/ (--0=,*-07(+&-.% */(+0

8 / .(% / -(0+ 0.0 / ( *%

6!"6B?

=; $$ $$ :< / / .(% /-- ((7 7 / ,*-07 .- ..(&0 (% / %. */(+ ,( %%7 +(*/0-0.(&00// /&7,*-*.(**(6/.(%/--*,%/ ,*-07.-(((00,..(&-(000 -((%/%. */(+ :0< / / .(% /-- 6 $. 9/ / .(&* .(% / .(%(6 -- / 0 -0=,*-07 ( .(/(/.(%/--*/0-0=,*-07 -+ ( / .*(. ( 9// / , (-0 0 (0 9/ / .- ..(&0 ,+ / %.

*/(+0(+/(.*(.9/&( /.(%/-0(+/(.*(.6/(-0-0 9--,(;@*(0,$*(0(&+/--, ((0 * + .( / 0 -0=,*-07 / (- -0 9*-0 .(&0 %%*+ (% / .(&/(-7-&7*(/.(/ (9///*0 $$ $$ :7< / / .(%( :(+ (, &-.% */(+< %+6,+(0(&--(,-%0 (,-%((!!A/*(9(7( (*.+.(/0-0=,*-07(0/(( / .*(. (7 / / .(% / 0*-+ .((%00,(&0/0(- $$ $$ :< //.(%/---%+%*%. (-0@*(0,+/&(( $$ $$E 9&(6 *G 9//( / (+ (, &-.%

*/(+: </%.*/(+/,*-07.- (/1*.-(.(6(@*%%*00

$*(;?<00(0,+// 0%((6 6 /4*- / (6 6 (6 9/ 3*0% 77(9-

A *,%0 ,*-07 .- ( / ( 9 0&0 4/%(/--97- D:< (-0 -0 -- (--0 (6 ,*-07 .- 9--,0,+((6(,&-.%=((6 9 *(+-7.(%(7&7/7 -0* :< (-0 -0 -- *0( (7- 1*.- -%6 / .- 9-- , 0 ,+ 1*.- %% ( /(77/(-0&-.%/(7 /(-.-,*-07.-E #(0*-(/.(/-.(0*0 $*( ; B6 .+ / C*07% * ( %0(+ C* -0 ,+ 3*0% 77(9- 7 / (+ (, &-.% */(+ ,(/ &- *07 : *( &<6 ( ?

A / 0 *90(00/009(0(000/.(.0 ,*-07 .- 9/ .(0 /( %/ 0 *(/( * ,C(((C/,*-07.-6//.-%+ *(/((%0+.*(**/0(/&-*(6 / ,*-07 .- 9 0 &0 (0( 00 ! !

B ( / ( / / (-0 -0 / ..- -- 9/ / (7- %*.--% /9(%-0,/-(.0 !6((9%0/%%*00 > B!

A,+/ (6 ( / ( 9 -(6 ( / / / (-0-09//%*.--%1*.-(.(6( 0/(+9/(7(0/..(&-,*-07.-0 *,@*..(&-,4,+(,#- 0 //((.-+,+9+0&,/-(.0 8 /(*7/ / ( 9 -(6 (6 9 0 / / ,*-07.-(/(-0-09//%*.--%1*.-

" (.( , ..(&0 ,+ / (, #- 0 0 / &0 %%* 00

A6 / %( / , (%0 //7(0/,*-07.-%+,9/0(9 (.-+-0,/-(.0A;/1*.- (.(6(6&((0//,*-07.-9*,%0( ..(&- !!

"69//9..(&0*,C0.$(- &-.%/(7:<%*7 !6B!6 =;3//(7 9(0.06/,*-07.-9(C0 ..-9.(((0 ,+(.0"69//90%0,+/.*+%%( !A B!

B (.-+-0,/-(.0"6((%0 ,*-07.-,+ (..- AA?6 AAB6 A" 6 A"!0 9.-(0//0.---9/ /1*.-(.(09(-.(/(-0-0(9// ,*-07.-/,0,+ -.0*// .(/--+..(/0/*((/(* /,*-07/(/0A/-(0//0(.0/(0 - > - !"

A ( (* / %%(- ,*-07 - .0 * / / 1*.- (.( &0 %%* 00 > A!

8 :

$*( ;"="< / (%0 / / ,*-07.-9--,0,+ -(-0-0 - .-00 / / ( ( .( %*.- (6 /((6/,*-07.-,0,+/ .0 "/-/0%%*00 8!

? $*( ;

"= *,%0,+/.((7,C/(.0" &-7/(%00(--(,+ */(0 /%%(-,*-07--90/(0-(6/ ,*-07 .- 9 0 ,+ &0 %%* 00

? " !

$*(; !<6/*,C%(/--7/.( 9(. *(7/*(/(7/9(.

A6 /*(*7//(. /--97@* D H//(/(@*(9///0.-/, 0(%.((0-(I ! .(0*/-+*.-/(@* 8

9//(+09%.09/-(-7/ -0(.*(/(I A H//((%/7(%.--+-*J26J72

J26/(+(,&-.% */(+9--, ,*0,*-07.-4.7&9/-+* .-7/(IE (. /(6 / (6 6 ( / (%0&0%%*00 B !!

A//(@*( 9//,*-07.-/,00(%.((0- (#+*.-/(@*9/0/((. @*869.0*//-09(-0(/( /3*0% 77(9-055/*(/&(*0//.69/( (. @* A6 0 / (% / 7(% .--+-*J26J72 J26%/ ,*-07 .- H/&/(0-(0*-(/.(-7/00 %(/.(9(./-0@*9.(/ -0 00 , @*(0 ( / .*(. / % 9 (-0 ( / ( / / -0 9( /& (*0 /.

/((67(%/,$*0,9/-09(0 /3/(*7/ /0&-.%/(7/&,.0,+/ -0 9( / 0 / / .(& / (+ (, &-.

B *0(/&,%0..-,-/-0@*.(/(% /7(%$*0 / 0( */( /& , 47 0( 0 0( % / 1*.- (.( &0 %%* 00 >A!

8/&40//,*-07.-/,0,+ 69/(/9(%6/00(//( /06/ /0/,*-07.-6,*40/ 9(%//,*-07.-,0,+/1*.- (.( / 9 *(+ -7 .(%6 (+6 / 40// /,409/0(9// ,*-07.- /( %,7*+ / 7(% (7(07 9/ / %. */(+ 3 / -06 9// 9 .( / @* .( ( / , 6 0 (-0 0 7(% 9 $*0,9/-09(0/ 6/ -6 9// 9*-0 , / %.

*/(+ / (07 / (% 0 / 7(%6 (.(0*0 ,&6 -& %( 0*, / / ( @* 7&(0 ,+ / (+ (, &-.% 6 >BB0/ *-0 7*-(%0/(*0( /((6/,*-07.-(/-0@*/,0,+ / 0 */(+ - / ( @* / .( / (0-K.(/-+*.-*,%0,+/ /((6 /..(&-/,*-07.-%%(-%.-$,0 ,&-&/K7.-3/-0@*/,(-0 &*(/-09(0.+%0&-.%/(769-- ,0%0,.( -0/&%(,.

(&00 ,+/ 69//-//(70/0&-.

&9/,&0*6900+%(/ .( 9( . / % (07-+ 0%06 / ,*-07 .-/,(7/-+0,+ 9&(6/.(77(&0//-7/0( /((0-.(.(+0%.(06/--,./.( &-*//((%0+(%/&-*(%+,&-,-/( (09/-9

!" )%-