Punjab State Power Corp, Ltd. And ORS. v. Nbcc Ltd., Nbcc House & ANR

 





     
 






 




!"

 # $%

& $

) *+

))** - 

.(( /+

.(( 

1) +    



 

$    12 33 '*"

+4 

))** $ 45 (,3,"

+4 

66666666 
 



.3 33 4+ 3

++  

  7+3"

.,+"

+23

% )

))** +

&

* "

##



,

:, :

3 + ++   

 ))*

*+

.

* "



+ "

4+ ** 2

++

++

8  ## ,+ ** +

 

 2

,3, 1(( (,2 <0=$"

/, ,

"

.,+

 2 >+

' 

3 3

*"

)*+ +

2)*

 ##!"

*+

 

2)*

', )*+ (  +)



' "

*+

*3 )

2



03,



.

++ 8  "

%

. <) +

', ?* ++   

3 2

! * 2)*   @

A

2"

?

4

33 4+ 3 ++   



% ) + &



3 2

+2+

  7+3"

.,+

++  

+

,**3+ ))*

8  12 33 '*"

))

,*

))**  3

  7+3 '**

2)** *+

 

2"

4+

2) 

)*

))**"

"

*+

2)*

', )*+ C ++   7+3"

+23

%

))**"

2 +

4

&

"

4+



 +"



 2

2 C 2+

,+

> *2 *



** '+

*

*+3



*2



2 2

C 3+ 2

! * *

+++

 

2)*

8

;"

)+ *   

2

C 3+

))** 2;3 ) 2



"

)3

'**

  7+3 *

 +

C ))

32"

*+ %+32

+ +

)>

 



             

 !   "  #

$  % & '   " () *  
   +  ,,, - 

9 

,+"

$ 45 (,3,"

))

,*

2

 2

2"

,"

%

))** ,4

3,* +2+

  7+3

 ,4 ,

"

)

3



 C

+

))* '**



32



"

))**

 2

2"

)3 *+

 

2"

4+

2) 

)*

))**"

"

*+

2)*

', )*+

! =, > 



3, *'

'**

9 *+

)) *

4+

2 2+

* > * 4  +D

+

3



*'D

3 * * 

1*

3

)*+ %+32

+ + 

 !"

#$%&'

#(& $&# )*&+,  #- '

%,'#( & .$&%#( &+) ./ *0  %

(,  /#(-'

#(
(+%&+1223)4* )%,%5*617 &&'#8 & (, . % #( & .$&%#(#&+)122:*7 :;< .+ ( +%(-#, #,&#8' 5)12;2*4 6;
/&(-%('' %(-" #.(+ =># ?

  &''5  .& # %&=  #8 
(+%  &+  4@@1):*   )%,%5*  4;< 
(+.

(-%('' %(-"'A&%5'

&+, '5 %','5#/!'(&.& # %&=4@@1)6*

)%,%5*33@0   +

4 "

))* *"

, , 4*

 *



>   2 

3 4+

+*3 2

))**



1*

3 

)*+ %+32

+ + .

    & '     



  // $ 00+ /) 
 
$   1 1 1 

+  ,,, ,  -2  C

+ 

++ +

"

*+ *;

3, 2 '**





2 E
 

 

      



   

 







  



 

 !

 

 

"

    

 

   #  # 





 

"

 $

" 



  

" 

   

           %      

   "       

F

# 

2

03,

"

*

> *2

+*

)*+

)* *

*+ =,



, 32"

=,

+** '+ *2

** '+

=,

+*3 ?

',,

2)*3

%"

2

*+ *+ ,4  +

 =,

 34

4'

+

 & '"



  

!

$)*++    ,-.* 

      

                  



 

                         /       01 222    



      

          3   

    



 

!

$     



      4

)*++,-.*  "        

     2522 "

4

  0

  

4 # 64



    77 7 



!

   )*++"



  

 757 228,-.*    49:  

%

; 77 28     <-4  

                 =   "

  

     7228   

      # 4"

 :

            5  728              ' >!,-.*   7228 "

    



 18

  

!

$  "

 #



  

   

  "  ,-.* 

)" 228 " 3? 

 



# 5"  

    $   

 @28   '

 222 $    

    7  2225 77   2377    



!

4 

 

 

;    "



       " 33   03 $  $      ,-.* "

 

;   "  5 7   ")*++  7 22$   )*++    

  

     #

     



'

22 -22 $  "    

 



  

    

B

 =,

3,



,

*2"

,+

++



2

* +

2

2





34 +3

4

!

C +)+ **

2)*+

9 ##!"

>++ )

9 ## ', "

3, > )

###

+

++



, '

3* * 3



2)*

))**D  ) 2"



4*

/"

*+

G&"



4*

> * ) ,+"

2 3



2)*3

;"

 

4 

* 

,*+



2)*

;  ,"



+

 2

2"

)3 +) =, *'

*+

))*

  2

 

 *

))

,*

  2 34

*+ 4+ + 2

*+

*3

+3 ,*+

  

 + +"

)*

4

+

* 32 

+



C )**



++

E.

 + ,4 ,3

++

   ,"

* +

+ F C 2  

,4 3, 2

*+ 4+

, 2;3 2



4

=, 

"



+"

+4 +

2 

C 4'

4"

 + **3*

4 



+3* "

))* ,+

+2+

)
 

*

'B . =434@12   

H,,

);3I  JI

H,,

)

 JI