High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5099/2012allowed

Prem Narain And ORS. v. Vikram Singh And ORS.

2019-10-14Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur7 pages

!

#

$"

%" " ''

) "* )+"%,-& " .

$"

/ ""01*%"20#0

""

",3

045(#0

""

6 "7"8",-&#0

""

9&''

( &!

+- &

8" "

(%9"!*(#.

8"#

& .3 &1*&+"

!"

"

#.3 &1*&+8 -- 8" '

"('*%'& "-"&.&%

!

"- "

- :./6;/:/

; 8& & "

"

*(0 .

8"<& "-"& "# & 8 & !5, "'=

'

!

"-"

- :./6;/:666 #!

-"0 !5"

"& -(- % "9& %'

8* .3 1*&+ ' 8(( -

+'(

*

"& -(- "0- >* (5.

6

* ",

#6 /$ % (- 8 & $(

, ,"# .%'*"# "

.

8" ? &

0 "% # (% '

8 !5 ''

(%- 58 *((5 '

"%

(0 (& 8 (%

8 8"+-8 & "( $ #@8(8 "-

# ;/'

"% & 6 9& 9"!*(#

" "- "( 8 ((

*% "5 0

( !

#& (

8 *(

"& -(- "0-

"'"

'5!( " '"0

# A% &8#

":.# "( $ #$?

#8&

.3 &1*&+88"+-8 "( $ #@8(

; ((

'"*

("5

BA$ #8& &8*("

8"8--" ("5

# ;/ '

" % &# 8& & (* C /

((8

6 / @*BA/-" 9& 9"!*(

!*#%* 6 / &*

% &(5

C#;

;/9& 9"!*(

6" 8"'

"((0- A'

+

'-0 8

8 ;5 " - #''( %*( '( ;'"

9"!*(8" # / 8" ( "

*%%* # /

( "

&*

(*% # #CC/'5!(

8 >* *% #

&0 ( ?&( (- 8"#( " (

*!% 9"!*(& ""

C / !**BA/4" %* 6 / ( ("5 %*

;/ *!%

! &

((8

!*"

%' ("5!

-"8!5

* & %* *-& &0 !

+

8&( ( * - & -" *''"

&

#& ( 3*-% :D!( ,*'"

*"

!"#!!

$%& '"()'"( (!* &!"

+ !

$%& '"( ,-.. /,0 / 0 2-3 ( *!%

%*

&!

8"

* *"

'"'

"-

9"!*(& ""

''(5-

%*( '( ;#8&

8 ;5 "(#%*( '(

*-& &0

''( (*!%

9"!*(& 8"-(5

6" 8" '

"( (0- A'

#8& &%* *-& &0

*!%

%* 8" * "0"*& 0 "5(8

>* *% &

'

3*-%

:D!( ,*'"

*"

!"!)'"#!!

$%& '"()'"( '

"!

(4%"& %"4%"!& !

$ !

%& '" /,--50 6 .,. !& ! "!

*'%#4!

7 &'$)("!

!7 '& !

$%& '"(,-.2 /80 / 0 .--5

# '"5 %*

3*

+ &

% 9 " &# ( " ( " "

< *"

%'58*(

9"!*(& ((

0 %

"( 0

"

"&"-& (5

!*%* #8&( % &(5 '5!( . " *!%

9"!*(& - 8"-

-5%* 8" A 8*( &0

'5!( -"("5

9&

# '"5 &0

0

#

(( " ( %

"0

% ; &0 & "( " ( '"

8 "

&0 - &"*-& %'*- " " *%

8 ( 9&

*%

'*

''

(& !

'"

""

"!5 "0 "8

-0 & "!5

*"

%'59&

>*

(( "

"% 8*(!

#8&

9"!*(& ""

'5!(

!*

-" ("5

# 8& & "8 "%'"

("5

%' '

"*( ("5

BA$ #0(!(

"# &8

8 "8- -" % &(5 ("5

# ;/ *(' +- 8 #;;/ 9& % &(5("5

%'" ! '5# :* .

((8

# E ((8

0

((8

#,'

(((8

@* 8 ((+8

'"0

" -0 (

("5#&8 "#!"

+

% *'* "0"*& %+ ' +- %"

0 ,("5

"*

*"

(* 0"* %' (+ A ,("5#8& & (*

! # " ((8

# :.#

((8

#

"5((8

#'

(((8

'*

((8

# % ( ((8

!*# (( "% '"

(

("5 %'(5

+ &% #

&*"

' 9"!*(& ""

((8

!* -"("5'5!(

& 0 8 %

"# &*"

' ("5

+ '

,("5

BA$ 9& "-*% " !5

( " (

"% '"

-"("5"8*''"

"% 3*-%

(0 :D!( ,*'"

*"

!"#!(*!('/

4"!0 C :8 "# "-*% " ( " (

9"!*(& ""

%* '5!(

8" A#''

" 3* !(

%

(5#'

,("5

BA$ #

8 "8- % &(5 ("5

# ;/# 8& & (*

((8

C / 9& -" *( ("5

8 #6 /8 &

#; /

'

A ( *( " 0 5 "#/ A!( %' ,

& 8& &8*(!

(!( A # A '5!( &

!

"%-&% &(5*(-"

;

*'

#; # / 8 %'

"% A

0 % ,

&

((

(! #; # # # /#

#& 8*(!

(!( '5 A "

F# #6 /#8& ''"A%

(5 # 9&

#&*( 8*( # / % &(5 "-8*(!

C#C

*"

"%"

#0 8

8 ;5 "

- #%*( '( &*(&0

''( '"

* *"

'"'

"

F (& "

>*"

+ #+

'-0 8

3*-% ,*'"

*"

!& ! "!

*'%#4!

7 &'$ )("!

!7 '& !

$%& '"(,-.2/80 / 0.--5 9&

'5!( "

/8"+ !*(

* " /

%

.3 &1*&+

-

;5 "

0 &(5

0 F 0 !

8"

* *"

'"'

CC

G6 H ;#6; /'

"% 0

6" 0!0

8" '

"( A'

;6; /CC;H /'

"% 0 %'

( *(

"''(5-

%*( '(

I

I H6#C# ;

0 * "( A'

A %'

"( "

*% A %'

"(

9 ( 6;## ;

>* ( %5 * !0 # ''

( '"

(5 ((8 9& 8" 9"!*(% ( '5!( &((!

6;## ; %*

0 "8& 88" 8(((

JF

( ((

'5% ''( * "" " .*(

0($"

*"

&!

(- 8 & ''

( (% <&# 88 & !

%'( (&!

'"

(5

&(

(% <&#

& & "&*!#

&0 "

%"" *!

>* (5

# < &"

%

E+( & *"

& &!3

& "&"

&

&''

(-0 & "*-&

"<''

69&

''( " ( 0

'"*

"

" '5 '

* 5 %"-"(

!

& "-"'"

% "8 (( %'"% ""0 #&

''

#+

'-0 8

&<"

%

E+(

9&

''( " ( 0

& &*"

"*

** '

"-(59& &

%* &''

(8*(8!

'5!( ''

6(5 % "*-&

>*(&"

/

*&%:'".8,-.5 ?&

"'

+-"

?&

""

'"

!(