← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26887/2017allowed

Baldev Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-01-27Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar12 pages



     

(!)* +( ,(- . "

"

(/0 12( /2*     $0'

3 0(!(-( (( /2*  0 $0'

 &+ 45&  006 &

  

         



      !

0( 7(-6,8(. "         #$           !

     #    %  &! #%'     "  (()* +, - ./+0&1 2 +3'

)! #%) () ( 



3///2043/

 -5//254,//6  5.// 1 +0 ./+.

7   )  



.//8 "    (*

 * 5+ +/ ./+0&1 2+8'

)! #%1( 

 



+0 ./+. ( 1  

   1 

.





.//8 9   ( ! #% :





 #$7( 

 !

  

.//8  ( 

)

 ! #%

 ., ++ ./+0

  #   )

  

# 230.-2#;2./+,     

    )      (( )

"              ! #%    #$ .//,

4///28///  

       

          #$      7( 

   !

  3///20,3/ "   -5//254,//6 5.//

.//8  

  1     #:     (    

9

    $  )

 #$)( <  *( 



     



)   ! #% .//-    "   )  ! #%08 (/4 ++ .//- " 

      ="             #$  &        

' *

& /+> /8') 



     ?

   

#$>      )(  #$   

 .

    )(  >     >              5      

      )  (            

 

(   = " 



    ) (  ="   *

 ) 

              (    

        = "   

               )

  

" 

     @                      #$  (    )         (    (         )(  )) ((    ! #% "    /0 ./+.

7

  )       =4 " #$$(7( 

 !

        9

    

#     9   ) 

@ 3///2043/ &

@ -5//254,//6 @ 5.//A2  



.//8'&1 25'

!  #$$(! #% ((

         #$  $(      7( 

!

 9

  

 #$$(! #%  (

 (   ) 

@ 3///2 043/&

@ -5//254,//6 5.//A2

.//8' )(  #$$( 7( 

!

&1 24'

= " 



)    ! #%,, (+0 , ./+.  (  B++ "  $ 

( 

@ 3///2043/&

 @ -5//254,//  6 5.//'       (    

  

.//8' #$$( ! #%)(

 

  #$$(   &7(   ':

"             

     )

   !

 )C  "

 ((  ! #%  /5 /- ./+. #

   !

9 (   )  $

  A!

 )C   

-5//254,//6 5.// )1  #$$(! #%

 #$ $(7( 



.//8 "

 !

 )C  (.8 /5 ./+5     

  #$ ! #%$ (   $  )

  ) 

( 

-5//254,//6 5.// #$! #%  3.//2././/6  .4// 

 "  

  

 .5 /4 ./+5 

! #% "  (

)! #%



  +5 /3 ./+5 ((  )               #$ ! #% #;2.5,+82./+5 #;2.4-832./+5)  #  "  )  > ( 

 .5 /4 ./+3             > (      A!

 ) C    

 ! #% @(

   ( # %25,52./+4

(  (-( (  7  3(  1(8  5/  ( /  ( 2  9*  (:(

6,8(( /2* > (  (   

 )C   (  2 $(  ! #% "  > (  (  9

    

(    )    

( )! #%    /0 +.

./+3 ! #%  *

* +5 /3 ./+5 1

3///2 043/&

-5//254,//6 5.//( 



.//8' #$

+0 ./+. 

 ! #% ((     +0 ./+.

 "    

      

(    #*#2.4-52./+3    #*#2+4,-2./+8  (( )    .5 /4 ./+3

#;2.5,+82 ./+5 #;2.4-832./+5 !) 5/ /3 ./+0



) (    

    $       

)(

 "        # 2,5,/2#;2./+0    #;2 .5,+82./+5$(      +0 ./+0 

      (  )  !

 )9

  (

 ! #% $    

 ) 



    ! #%  +++(+, /- ./+0   ()

( 

3///2043/&-5//254,//6  5.//       (     

     

 /+ .//8'    #$$(! #% )+0 ./+.                       (     +0 ./+. 

  ( $/0 +.

./+3 "



  1 

 )   1

 ) #$

   1 

.//8 (

(   )(      0 #=  "   )      )   +39

     (        (        

*

* 5+ +/ .//0 ( )! #% ((



  

7



       ! #%(

 $ )  

 "  

! #%(

   #$ 7( 

    5-&'  #  7

7           ! #%        

 

 #$  

 .//- "        )  

            )       

  

 "! #%     (      +0 ./+. 

           )    )!

 )C  #(  

  )    ! #%  $  +, /- ./+0( 

 +0 ./+.

" ! #%   #      

)1 ((

 +0 ./+. (   7   ( 

       

(     )    

( (

    .//42/3      )  )   (     )   7    

1(  

 +0 ./+. 

  (1

  





,  1 

.//8

 ( :   ) 5-&' #   )  

    





   ( #

4<         )   9     (9

 9

$ )  7      ! #% $

 #$        

  *           

 9 

(  9

 9

$           

  ( <           " )(  ) ! #% 

   

          )  ) 1 #$ ! #%

          (              

 )(

 /+ .//8

 

  #$      #$! #%     .//0            (    2     "

  ! #%   #$ .//, "9  $() 

    1 ! #%    "  ) )$

-  

  

 .//, 7  

  

! #%       .//-   )  @  /4 ++ .//-     )( ) 



  #$

          #$         7 

     

   )  !



 )C   )      /.

/4 ./+/(    ! #%  

  )           )       ) (      (  ./+.

! )   ! #%(+0 ./+.



 )( ) 

 (   (  )

  !

 )C  (    ) "   ) #  ) .5 /4 ./+3

   #;2.5,+82./+5    #;2.4-832./+5    #         !

 )C      ) ) 

  #$! #%  ( )     



)! #% )(   (    #$ )()    ! #%

!

( $  

+/  ! #%$ (  

( (    (   

  (   )( ) 



)   ! #%  (  ((

  

(  

 *

! #% )(



 *

  

.//8  .//-    (

) ! #%

 -5(.+ +/ ./+5 7( #  (

 )

  ! #%   () $ /4 ++ .//-)(

) 

) #$  #$  "  @   /4 ++ .//- (

  )!

 )C ./+/ !   !

 )C      2 $()! #% 

 )) 

        ./+. 



) ! #% 

  /5 /- ./+.      

 ) 

 /+ .//8

"! #%$( 

     /4 ++ .//- $ ((

    ))((  +0 ./+.

!  

++       )     

     )     !

    ) C               

(  )    #    7           ) (

     ) (           )     $ ) )     

"! #% (    )(  )  

 

          #$       #$      7(  

         

/4 ++ .//-)(   "  

 

 )$  )      ! #%





(  

(  ( 

    

 +0 ./+.! #%   $1

$(  

 

 )    #$   $   )     7(

 

 $1 9 )

  ( # 230.-2#;2./+,    )      $(     

  (  ., ++ ./+0

)   #   2D2     "  1   

) ) 1     

+.

($      

"  1  )

# 230.-2#;2./+, ( 

 

    " ) 

>

.0././ &  E  '

(  > ( ; $(A  F ;  ) F