Toshi & ORS v. Surinder Kumar Gulati & ORS




    
















 




 




 !
 "#


$$%% &"# '

'# !"#
('#
)'*
 !
 "#


+$ +
, -./%
+
01
&-
0-) $#"

" 
 #



 "#2
!34"2
#
#
0
 "#2
!34"2


#
 
0

6*2
!34"2

5 !" 
 #
+7 ""

* #2
!34"2

5 !" 
8
9
 '# 4"
5 : ;
;
;





#*
 "
5#"

" 
55"*

#
"

 4"" 

45"

 6#!"!
<:
 "
#
44 !" 
* 
# <' *2
$ 4 ='*
 #

#2
> # <' *.
3 !"
6#!
!"!

"4"

#:
#
!7'!

4 "
5#"

" 
55"*
#"



8

?2
+
$ *
6

5 ** 
# !"#

#
4:4*"
<"# #"@

# 

-+, , 2
6

6


<:

#

*:
 !
"@* @" *:

!# 3"
#'
4#
<"# @
#"@

# 

$/, ,-,A 8


#"

'*


"
44 !" 2
+
$ *
*

*

"
+
6
#"@

"#"!

8

?

, , 
4* 
5" 
' !"#
"4 
AA
 "
#
&"

4*"

42 ?

 #

#2
> "
4.
6

*"!
<:
 "
6 !6
 !
'#
 #
4

*!#"


!"4"

"!
+
$ * "
# <' *2
"#
4

!"# @
 "
"3 !" 4"
 !
"# * 5*4"!
<"

#"
2
6#!"!

'



B2 2

C,
* @
6 "#"



 #"

AD
5"#
 ' 
3"
"#!
*"# "!
4'

"*
"
5#
 !
5"#'

"!
 55"#
<= 3"

<""
!

5'"!
<:
 "
5# %"# "!
4'

"*

#@'"!
 "
!"4"

"!
6

:"#
@"

 "
 "
 "
44 !" 
 !

'* 5* "#

B

<""

6# @*:
55* "!
<:
 "
# <' *
-"
'# "#
'< 3"

<""
6#!"!

*
'


8

C,
' !"#
 "
4 3"  2
"

C,
"4 #
*

4 # '2
*

"

"
 !
#
' "#*
"E5"


 "
*6"#

!"
%"# "!
4'

"*
4 " !"!
 3*3"" 


"
3"

4*"


<""
!

5'"!


* 

<""
!

5'"!
 3"

4*"
6

'#"!

'4
4 #4'  4"

2
 "
 '# 4"
5 :

'*!

3"
5 !
 "
45"


' 

 2
 !

:
#"43"#


"
#
 "
6 "#
 !
!# 3"#


" !

@
3"

4*"
%"# "!
4'

"*
5 !" 
8
9
 '# 4"
5 :

#"

"!
 :
"

 4"" 
 !
'# "#
#@'"!


4"
 "
6 "#
 !
!# 3"# 

" !

@
3"

4*"
3"


*"!

55"*2
 "#"

#"2
 ":
3"
<""

# *:
"*!
* <*"

5:
 "
' 

45"

 

,8, %"# "!
4'

"*
5 !" 

9
6 "#


" !

3"

4*"
'< 
#"

5 !" 
 !
' !"#="

!# @
"


 !# 3"#
<"

#"
"5*:

@


 !
" 4"2


* <*"

5: 
#
"
4 "  
#

"!
<:
*"# "!
4'

"*
55"** 
#"@#!

@
55*:

@

'* 5* "#

4 4"# "!2
 "

 * @"#
#"

"@#
 !

43"#"!
<:
 "
!"4

"
- .<*"
5"E
'#



        

 

?
A

2

 



        



     

        

     

!  "      " 

  #   #      

$

  



% &  %  

 



     '()

* +&   '(*

+ +%  '(%

+* &   '(

 %  '(+

* %&      #





     '(

%

%%   '(,

%* *&   '()

* *%

 '(%

** )&  -


<""
"*!
"
<3"
#"

"##"!
!"4




4 "
6 "#"
 !"4"

"!

@"!
B
:"# 2
'* 5* "#




<"
55* "!
(""5 @

3 "6

4 "
 !
 "
<3"

!
!"4

 2
*

!"5" !" 4:

#", 4*4'*"!
<:
44"5 @
 "
 '*
!"5" !" 4:


"!

<:
 "
# <' *
 !
<:
55*:

@
 "
'* 5* "#





E

E

F


B2 2

C,

,B, "

'"
6
#"@#!

6#!

@

' 
' !"#
 4 3" 

<""
' #  3"*:
!"4 !"!
<:
 "
- .<*"
5"E '#

*"


!"4


"
4
         





G5"4 *
%"3"
$" 
 *


?

BH
!"4 !"!

4<"#
8 2

2
6

*"
< "#3 @

' !"#
,
%  .                  # 

  

#  

#  /     01   2   

  0 % &&&3( #   / 0 && &&&3(



 

0 && &&&3( # 



  



      



 

      / 01    4    

#            

            #               5 !     

                 6   .

6            

    

     / 

!   

                     7  #   #

/ 

   

         #

   !  !

   6

#   

      

,,

!

         

  #   !   

/   2  

             



 

 

 



  /       0  % &&&3(  0 & &&&3(    0  % &&&3(  

      

               8    

( 

6(  !  #       #  6               

       

&9



   

   #

            

   -
 



 

   

8

C,
6#!"!

' !"#
 "
4 3" 

"

 4"!





C,

#

 "
4 "  
#"@#!

@
* < * :

5:
 45"


' 

4 4"# "!2

5"# " 

"  
 "
6 "# "
!# 3"#



*"!
55"*
@

"
6#!

< " 4"

 :

**" @"

 "
6#!

 #
5#2
 "
4 "  
#

"!
<:
*"# "!

4'

"*
5 !" 

:

<"
!7'!

4"!



@"

'"
#

"!
<:

6
#"@#!

5:" 


45"


<:
 "
 '# 4"
5 :
6
# 

#"43"#
 "

#
6 "#
 !
 "
!# 3"#
!"

"#3"

44"5 4"


'"

<""
!"*

<:

 "

- .<*"

5"E

'#

     



,A,


 
 

2

B
8
2
?2

"*!

' !"#,
:   

           #  

# 

   

6 

#      #  ,

    

6         

       

       8   

  

       ,$$ .  

/    

   #    1   



        

     

 )+   

      1               

    

   

6  

  %        # 

      



  



                      

  1       

     

          #

#        

       

   

   



  / 

 

 

  

  

 1

       

         #  

  



         

 .      



#

    5  '



;  . 



 

,,        

       

   

    4 

     #   

< #

   6        #           



    

  

  '



.            

  

        

    #    



     

     #

 

 

- 
 "
5#"

" 
4 "2
 "#"


!

5'"
6
#"@#!


3*3"" 


" !

@
3"

4*"


* 

!

5'"!
 

" !

@
3"

4*"
6
!'*:

'#"!
6 "
 '# 4"
5 :

'4

#4'  4"

2

3 "6
 #"

!
!"4

"
- .<*"
5"E
'#2


6'*!

<"

#

**6
 "
4*  

#'
#
5 **#

5 

@" 45"


#
*

<#"!
"# "#
 #
 *:
 "
4*  

**
<"

"  *"!

@"
 "
' 

45"


#
 "
 '# 4"
5 : '# 4"
5 :
6 **
3"

#"43"#
 "
#
 "
6 "#
 !

!# 3"#


" !

@
3"

4*" #
 "
#"


#"4#!"!
<3"2
 "
45"


6#!"!

' !"#
3# '

"

 4"!

5"#
 "
<*"
@ 3"

<"*6
, -"!

6#!"!
<:
 # <' * 6#!"!
6
<:


4'# %

!"5" !" 4:

B2B 2

C,

B2 2

C,
 3"  

8

C,



C,
*

B2 2

C,

2B 2

C,

, , 
3 "6
 "
<3"2
 "
6#!
!"!

!

"!
 "
"E" 
 "
45"

B2 2

C,
6#!"!
<:
 "
# <' *

 4"!



2B 2

C,

**
<"
"  *"!

 "
"

 4"!
' 
* @ "#"



 "
#"

AD
5"#
 '
#
 "
!"


* @
 "
4*  5" 
 **
#"*

"
'  "
55"*

5#*:
**6"!
#"

!
"#   !"



# $
% !7