Sanjiv Kumar v. Siri Chand And ORS.
! "#!$% & '
' '()*)+
,
-*.*
/ 0
' '()*)+
,
-*.*
+1
2%3 $! 34
#3 #*+
! "#$ %&&#
'
( ! )$* %&&#
+ ! ,- .
! # ! "#$ %&&# ! ,& ! )$* %&&#
34
#3 5$ '+ / ! )$*"#$ %&&# . / 0 .+ .+
/ 1. .+ ! , / / . .+ 2 ! )
3 0/ . 4 0
52 6 + 4 .
0 //.0 7
6 4
. . 0 0 8 9 ,#*$7 6 / .+ 0 +/: / .
.+ 0 0 .+ /. . 7 6 /0 / .
/ . +.+ +/ / + 0 . .+ ; / /0 .0
/ / +7 6 6 . .+/ 0 /07
/
+ 4
2 0
/ .+ .0 2 + 0 ; / 0
80. 4 . 52 6 ! ,2< ' =0 / =0 + 7 . 6 = ; / .4 / + + / ' =7 " < = %* # ,#-$
/ + ..+ = 00/
/ ,& - ,#-$ 8 < = 0 .
+ 8 /+ / /
; .+ = ' = / / = / .+
' = / < 0
00.
=( = 9 / + = / .
0
0// .; 0 +52 > ?
?
?
?
=( =
?
?
?
= ?
? 0 2222222222222222222222222222222222 ?
?
?
= !
@
?
?
?
?
?
?
+ < 9
. = ! ) / / /
1 0 .+ ' =
0 . / = 30 < =
0 30
00
/ +
/ 0 =( = 0 .
/ 30 =0+
0 = ! ,' =0. =<
=
0 = 00
3 + .00 3 0 .+ ! , =
0+ <
A
< .
/0
/ // (/ + ..+< =
3 0+ /
+ =
/ + 0< =
.0 /
3 ( = ! ,' = + / .
0 0 .+ <
00 ! ) ' = / . / =
3 0 0 A
/0 0 ! "*
= ! * 0 /+
8 + ; / . ' = 00 +
+ 0 0 / 0 . %& * ,#** 90
0
+ 0 ; @62, ! .
/ . + . / . / 3 + .
+ %- ,, ,#-B
0 . .+ / 0 0
/0
0 0 / / 3 ( ' =. . /
' + <
. ' =
8
/ C/ 90 /D; C <. + .
0 0 / / = .+ ! , / + / .+ / . / 0
8 D;
=6-:
.
.+ =
C '
. > <. + = . (
/ 6 3 +.
/ . = 4 0 0 /+ . ( .+ = // 0 0 . 6 8 . 4 = . ( / 0 / . A
/0 6
. .
. A
6+ C .
0.<. + D; 8
; ! " # $%
&& ' '
' ( & ) *)%*+,
- . $% '
" # $* $*/% && ' ' ' # 0 - . $*
$*/% 0
! 0 .
> <. + . @62- 90 0 ( =,&:
. / 9
( + 4 + / / 0 .
= 4 0
/ 1 / 2;
.
.+> C/ '
.
. A . ( 6 =; / 6 1+ D; 1+ 2 3 45 60 "& 8 6$*/% "& 1 6% * ) "& (
6$% "& ( 1 & 8 0
&& 8 ' ' ' ' &&& 1+ 7 8
&9 '5 9 4 : 1+ 3
1+ ' 9& 1+ 7 8 ; 9&& 1+ ' 9&&& & 3 3 3 3 3 ' ' &< ; 1+
% * ) ( = (
'> < 1+ % * ) ' ( = (
, <& ( = ( 1% ' ' ' 1 D;
=, %- - ,#-$ .+ /= +,& - ,#-$ 3
' = / = . 0/
30 + =0
D;
=)=+= + @0 $ ,& ,#-B0 / 3 ' = / = + < = =
. . 0: .+
A
< .
<
@ 0(
3 ' = / < = D;
=$ .+ + +/ ' = / = =(
8 0 .+ +
+/ / D;
=B + ,#*- 0 ..+ . 2+ < 0 0 009
0 /
! ' = 0 / / <
D;.=6B:
.+ = .( / ' =./ / 8
,B $ ,#-$ D;
=B:' ,* ,% ,#-$ 9 1 '
/
> /> '( /
/ + ' = =B:
.+ ' = / 0
,) ,% ,#-$ +.+
D;
=- + / . .+ + ,#-&2-,0 +
00
/0 = < . 00 +
< 0 9
0A . /
D;
=6,,:
/ < =
0 D;
=6,%:
/ .+ ' =/ =
/ 0 0 .
0.+= # $ ,#-B D;
=6,*:
+
0 = . 0
D;
=6,B:
C/ 90 /D; 0 . = .( / . = 0 . .( 3 +. / / '( 0 . = 0 ( . 8 + / A
< . 0 ' = / =
,) $ %&&) 8
+ (
E= F%- ,, ,#-B 0 .+
/' = / 0
(E='F ' =//> (0
/ 0 / F !0/ / 8 .
1 ; 9 ! =62%/. 2/ > =62) 2/
< =62"
' = =62* 9
/ <
=62$ = 0 .
220 < = + 0 0 + / 0 ==62B
+/ 0 = / .( > / > '( =62,& / =62%& . ' =
; C/ 90 / D; 0 / : . ./0/ 8 ; .( .( .+ = 20
0 .6 ./ 0
/ 6 = C += + ,#-,
/= .0
8 ; / /
0 'D;
=6,-:@ /
. ' =2 ! , /.; =6%&
8 .+
/ ' = . A . 8 .+ 0
80 0 ; / / 0 ,& % %&&B .
/ / + 8 0 ; 52 6 =. 71@@ 6 ' = / 73 1@@
8 / / + / . .+. =0
' =0 /
30 ' =0 /
8 / .
.+ 8 / / .+
/ /
1 ; / .+
// + 0 . +
/
.+ 0 / A /0
3 0
0/
52 , 8 .( 0.; /0 0
= + . ' = / .
% 8
.+ 0 .
/ ,* "
%&&- ) .+ . / +
.
/ + =4 /
" = .0 /+ .+
* 8 / .+ /
78.*)*(.** )*)**.79%.)':))* .; .9':))< 3 ' =
/ / <
90
. + + ,#*- 0 0 .0 8 D;
=# + + ,#*- 0 ,/ =00 + < 0 9
0 A . / 8 . / .D;
=- .+ + ,#-&2-,0 + /
3
D;
=-
/0=.+ C 0 +. .+ /
7*;)** =9));7 1 39%.)':)7*.; ':))7*>>?)*) )*>.< D;
=,%- - ,##$ 0 / %- - ,#-$ 0
= ,& - ,#-$ 0 9 .
' =
/ 0 . DD;
=)$ ,& ,#-B
0 =+= + .+
+ ' = / = .+ A
< . /0 6
D;
=$ .+ +
0 + ' =0 /
.
+ / = =(
D;
=6B:
,B $ ,#-$
.+< = / '( 0 = ' =0 . ./ /
D;
=6B:' .+.(
/ .
/ 0 ' =. / < = ! . : 0
0 / + 0 . . + . .+ / <
0+ ,#*-
78.*87)*()**.7':)) =(.;)**9) :. )*.;%.)':) 8 D;
=6,,:
/ .+ 00 + A 0
A
2 ! * . ( 0 0
0 =62,) ; / 6 .+= ! . A
0 =62, 00 0 . 8 0 C/ 90 /
0 D; A . ( . C/ 90 /D; + 0 + ./ 1 ./.+ C/ 90 /D; ; .+ 90
+ + ; / ; . +; .+ . ./ 3 .0
/ 0 . ; =62,) 0 0
0 . =62, + 6 /
9 A 6
!.
8 2 ./ .; =6,"
0 60 / .+ A
< . 0 +(0 2= 3 2 ; ;0 +(0
0 / 0 0 ( 90 + A . + 0 . A
8 .+ C/ 90 / D; + 0 . ; 0 .
0 /
> D; . =(/ .
= 4 0 0
/ / . .
. / . 0 = C
D;
=6,:
0 . .+
+ + . .+ 1
+ / 0 +/ : 3 0 . 0 $- D
,-B% 3 +. B, D
6 0/0 ; B, D ;
& 5 5 ' '
?
3 / 0 ; . .+; / /0 . 6 / .
/
!0/ /4 0
@.*)) GA (.9? :)( )* B.) C > )(9>)*8:)(7)8()); 8));)C7>)*< 84 4 . 0 + .
1 + / / .
6 + +/ 9 4 ! 0
@.*))) A )* B.) )8 (. (8)9 C (C(87C?.8*.((**)<
/ 4 +. 0 4 / 0 89
,#*$ 0 . ; + 8 0 +/ / + 8 0 /
00
0 +
/+ 4 ! 0
@.*)))) DAE.;9>**C? )*>>88(. 7).8?F);G)*(.**);>*.C9)C? 8 )8 (. 7)( 7* (88 8 )* >>88(.))8)**.*:);C 95 (C*.*)< 1
/ 0 / .
/ 0 / 8 .
. / .+ 8 4 ++
, / .
.+
/ 90
/ / 3 . / .
.+ 0 .+
9 4 ! 0 2' =
@.*)*):: A*);7)** ;)**9( C >9) );* C )()? C?
?);*) ;)**9>)(.88?
7 *9 * C >: C? =9)); *( *); 7)**5 ()C * 788 * ;)*); .)?< AA)88(C>:C?8);:)( 7*);7)**)**)< 8 / . + /0 8 /0 / . . .+ . +/ + 4 $- D 4 . .+; / /00 4 .+./0 ./0 .
. // 1 $- D . + / 0 ; + ; 0 .
0 3/ ,#&- ; .+ .+0 .; + ; $# D 0 0 /0 . 90
B, D
; . + /0 ; . .+ B, + + : + . / 0
0 ! . .( + /0 0
/ 00 .+/ /0
0 /0 .0 ( .++/ + .+ +0 /
/+ 4 ! 0 2' =
3 ' =+ / = 0; /
9
! "#$ %&� 4 + ! )$* %&&# .+
< + / . 0 @ /1 0
, 34
#3 9H* $!'
A*>H);G*+ &*G A>C8+ &*G