High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26965/2017allowed

Baldev Singh v. Oriental Insurance Co Ltd And Others

2019-11-08Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia3 pages

"#$$%&'&()*

"+,$-.&(/0 1 $#&#&($2 34' 2&$(#"+('52"(%$6#,"(,#0$2'

1 $'7(,$(#'

) 86 ...6

2$'$(#)9 2 ",":;"(#<&-$,&=,-%"#$ 2#0$7$#&#&($2 2>5:"2=,-%"#$ 2#0$2$'7(,$(#'

!"#$%&" 0$7$#&#&($20"'&+$,#0$7$#&#&(5(,$22#&%+$'4 #0$('#&#5#&((,&"'$$;&(/?$($&#&(#$2$'#(#0$,$+"@$,7"@:$(# #0$2$#&2"+,5$'/2"#5&#@"(, +$"-$$(%"'0:$(#2:#0$,"#$ "772-"+&$A *##0$,"#$"%#5"+7"@:$(#(

#&'#0$%"'$#0$7$#&#&($2#0"#0$<"'<2;&(/"'''&'#"(# <&#0 #0$ 2$'7(,$(#9&('52"(%$ %:7"(@ 0"-&(/ $"2+&$2 '$2-$, <&#0 #0$ (,&"(2:@ $,&%"+!"(,<"'72:#$,"',:&(&'#2"#&-$ &%$2<$ AB"(,<"'$(#&#+$,2#<&(%2$:$(#'20&''$2-&%$2$(,$2$,&( (,&"(2:@&(#$2:'"#&("+:$2/$(%@.$2-&%$ 5+$'= 0$ '":$0",?$$(/2"(#$,#0&:2$#2'7$%#&-$+@<$#0$@$"2 * 0$ "2$'"&, #< &(%2$:$(#' <$2$ <&#0,2"<( C5'# 72&2 # 0&' 2$#&2$:$(# 0$2$"#$2=0$&+$,"%&-&+'5&#2,$%+"2&(/#0$2,$2',"#$, "(, *A (5++"(,-&,=<0&%0<"',$%2$$,&(0&'"-52(

(($D52$ !"(,,&2$%#&('<$2$"+'&''5$,##0$2$'7(,$(#'#2$5(,

#0$":5(# '=49"+(/<&#0&(#$2$'#E *F7$2"((5: #&'(#,&'75#$,#0"##0$"77$"+<"',&':&''$,( A

(($D52$ 4!"(,"'7$2#0$2$7+@#0$2$'7(,$(#' . * 4 <"'"+',&':&''$,( B 0$,$$(%$#0$2$'7(,$(#'&'#0"#"#$22$#&2$:$(# ( */2"#5&#@##0$#5($A==49<"'7"&,(A *0$ ?"+"(%$":5(#/2"#5&#@<"'7"&,(*

"(,*

0$ %::5#"#&(7$('&(<"'7"&,( B"+(/<&#0'$##+$:$(# 6. 6$"-$ $(%"'0:$(# =*=*49 <"' 7"&, ( ** "(, #0$2$"#$2(

"(,

0$,$+"@&(#0$7"@:$(#/2"#5&#@ "(,+$"-$$(%"'0:$(#<0&%0<"'7"&,&(#0$@$"2

&''#"#$,#?$( "%%5(##0$"%##0"##0$'5&#<"'7$(,&(/#<"'"+'#0$%"'$#0$ 2$'7(,$(#'#0"#"'5:==A

*&($D%$''0",?$$(7"&,<0&%0= 0<$-$2=0",?$$(2$5(,$,?@#0$7$#&#&($2&($+$-$($"'@&('#"++:$(#' .&:&+"2+@&(#$2$'#(#0$,$+"@$,7"@:$(#+$"-$$(%"'0:$(#"(,&(#$2$'# (#0$/2"#5&#@<"'"+'7"&,##0$#5($=B*

"(, =**=AA 2$'7$%#&-$+@(

#&'(#,&'75#$,#0"##0$'5&#<"',$%2$$,(

"(,#0$ "77$"+<"',&':&''$,( A A0$2$<"'2$"'("?+$%"5'$"''5%0 2#0$,$+"@<0&%00",%%522$,"##0$&2'#&('#"(%$"'#0$'":$0",#?$ %"+%5+"#$,(#0$?"'&''$2-&%$2$(,$2$,"(,#0$&(%2$:$(#',2"<(<0&%0 0",?$$(<&#0,2"<("(,<0&%00",+$,#,$+"@&(,&'?52'"+#0$":5(# <$-$2=(%$#0$"77$"+<"',&':&''$,( A A?@#0$6<$2 77$++"#$52#"(,#0$2$<"'('#"@?@"(@52#&(%+5,&(/#0&'52#&(

$/5+"2.$%(,77$"+ "@:$(#/2"#5&#@<"':",$(*

##0$ #5($ =A=*49"(,'&:&+"2+@7"@:$(#+$"-$$(%"'0:$(###0$#5($

=AB 49<0&%0<"'7"&,(

<"',$+"@$,5(($%$''"2&+@

$'5+#"(#+@=2$'7(,$(#9%:7"(@&'+&"?+$#7"@&(#$2$'#(#0$"2$'"&, #<":5(#'2: A A##&++ #0$,"#$'2$+$"'$2$'7$%#&-$ 7"@:$(#' 0$ 5++$(%0C5,/:$(#&( &( )*(+($ ,-).

& )01 ( , 2(34

5 (1 16 )(7'8' 0",+"&, ,<(#0$+"<2$/"2,&(/&''5$&(#$2$'#(,$+"@$,7"@:$(#2$#&2"+ ?$($&#'%%2,&(/+@=&(#$2$'#":5(#?$%"+%5+"#$,E*F7$2"((5:( #0$"2$'"&,#<":5(#'2: A A##&++#0$,"#$'2$+$"'$ 2$'7$%#&-$7"@:$(#'"(,#0$'":$?$7"&,##0$7$#&#&($2<&#0&("7$2&, #<:(#0'2:#,"@(%"'$#0$":5(#&' (#7"&,<&#0&(#0$ '#&75+"#$,7$2&,=#0$2"#$&(#$2$'#'0"++/# F7$2"((5: 0$<2&#7$#&#&(&'="%%2,&(/+@=,&'7'$,

..6!

-$:?$2*=

0$#0$2'7$";&(/42$"'($,)$'4 0$#0$2 $72#"?+$)$'4