M/S Ganeshgarhia Construction Company v. Union Of India And ORS




  
    

!"# $% &' (!)* +,#

"# $ &-*( *./(.( *0) 12( 3

  4*0*

 !
5(( 5.* 

*2 5 *
 



 
 
 


 



* + & &( *065)(6!.2  & ( 7(802(65)(!

 !
5( & 7( 655 5)( (6 8(9 & (81( (16: 5)(;. & 9.0( : /(65)(6!*2 5  <<<< 
% ('

*2 5   " * . 09) 7* 2(1 6 8(96 *2 5 * ,6=( (..! / 6>)0 / ( .:02 5 / / !*2 5  "?*2 5 * $( 5@( .>)0 / *( 5. / ( !!)!.& *3! (56 ( *2( 5/.;(3?*2 5  *.2(*2 5  ;.* !(0.;7.(*9 /( 5 . 2  .(* ).( /5 . 5)*  ! . !!)( *2 5 *) *5 /.*959 A*2 *( 5(;(5 /.;7 *2 5  ."

5*2 5 **05(B C0*! 2*(D%

'! .!; /;7+A B
  


    

   

 

  

 ! "#

  $ 

% 

&    &  &  !'( )*

 = . )   /  5* ;(* **05   @ "#

 .* C0* 2( !.!; /)(0**!.  +A



  

    +     ,,

 , ,-  ., /0 

 $

1  /!2 ! ,

 -  ,  $ 3 3 1   , -! , ,  !4 ) ' (,/2   5 , , 
5 )-  !   '''  (, ,      

  !      6  7  /68  -  ,   !!

5  -2 / 0   

 


 7    !

,  !  

  ! 9,,

,-: /2 &)(,       ! 7

   !

   !.,
 ;

!- 9,,

7 ,-   )  ., / 

 

 2  

     )   (,  

  7

   /2  /2 /

 2 < ,   $   ., ,  !! ,  1  ., !   , ,  -
  ) ,   
 ! !

 !

,      

 4 ) 4.,: 

  

  
  



  
  


  

 
 



 



!"



  

 
 



 




!"
#$#
%
  

 
 



 



!"

&
  

 
 



 



!"
#$#
/2 9 9,,

 , ,-  , !  4 )  ' (,    , -
, ) !8473

) !    )-  !

,  !  /=    !2    ,  ! 

 )  4., &,  !  , 4 )  ' (, /2 +   !6+': !"
<,  ! (,.,)-  ,  -

 ) !( 1 (,,    ) ,      !      (   !    ) -      

 />2<, &  -> ,! 1

% 
5 !  )/2 

  ., )- 

 1 

 .,)-  , ) , !  ) -   

 />2 !"
%  ,
5  ,   )  (,!  

    <,  "     >.

<? >  ,
5
 ,

 5'61861+361&61@,   1 !

, 

1 !

,
51 9 1 $9 !

,
51  -   1
51 ,   ,1  

 )   1     ,1  , 
5 !) 51.

 1   ! ,

 1    8%9 ,  , ! "#><1 - - !
5 

   )  !,1
5 !  
5

1 , ,  ! ) @  @ 

1,1  ,!

  ),  !

"
9
5 ,  <   6 A

-
5 /<6A'@<6A21;

-

), !   ,,

 , ,- B /> 2C )   !    ,  
5/B />2C !

"
' (,#
-, 

, !

!     ! ,     ,  -  ! 

 ) 1!: 
D @ , , @    
5  "#@&#   -,  - !  5 76+1<&7@4<1&>63'1ED4 
D @ , , @    
5  %36


  , !   



,  $89) 1 
D @ , , @    
5 !  %,

,     1, ,  !$- 1 
7 ,  ! F

)168$1 
  
E 8%9
5 !"#><@%869 # !"
9 (,
  !6<3+1'%G&H 1 5 1 ,- 1

 1, @,

- 1$!    - 1
5 !      /)@ 21 

   (,
,       @ , ,  )  ,   - ) ,    -

& !

"
< ,  )     ,  !  (,   ,  !  (,  1,  ! (,

),  ! 

  6

  

 , 

!

  - !    !  

   ,  .  

,   )) )-> *

. :( E ).

)( (0(  11 ) *55 .2 F*959).

)(3*2 * .).

)(95*!(. 955*;!0.>(1 593.:)  /11!.& *3 .:)  /11 5.(.2 1  5 *).

)( 95* ; ;7* ;.). ())5 /   55  !( ;.  )(0* "

%'%5'


 5 .( . ; ;7* 1  5 93 . 2 * (  &(8*) (5*%& *'( 5.!6!( .)(/3%=' )(0*

 ))5 /36 . :)  / 11 )1205 . 2 F* C0595)(2()3(
 ,= , )*;.).;(***.( .)(2()3!

)**20(5 )(0*"

1 . :)  / 116 . 1( ;   . (0(  11 ;.). (! ( 5(5 ) *5(  ( 5 ( (3** !0 5.2 F*959 A*2 * $ .C0* .(!(*!) *5( 6.!6*;.. .;7*1  593.2 !(;. )(0*"

%'%5'

. )(1*.(!(*;. )(0*"

%'%5'%'

@ . ;7 !5  93 . 2  *   &(8 *)

(5* 
 ;(*6 .;6  ;. . (  (***( ) !1 10(( (/ )*  &6   . !1  55 93 . 2   *   *(59 G F9(**

9( 5.( !1.0* /( 9( 21  2(  E15 %  '

 . C0*  * ;..

$   !(* ;.  . ;5* G10(( (/ )*D  . >2** G10(( (/ )3F *  5! 5  . *2 5 * .( 5 02  ( ! )  10((  *0 *   ( 209)(  **05 93 .  1  !
5(6 2(1  ! ) 1) !!(* 
 !*  . /( H( * *0). (* 5 ( 76 (136
 6
6
6 &
6
:
6 :
 4E & I ( 5
 ( ( 5 ! /)00(21 %
'( 59(  1  ()3% '

&0(((/ )*(22(! 13  590(/02!   ( ( (/ )* *0). (* .  * ((53 1  5  . ;9* *(*.(. 1 !
5(())***! ( )(***( )!1(0* 10 ( ((/ )*;.).;.(((53 (156 (1365( 7 0266


.* . / 5)(.(  *( 10(( (/ )3  . 2  .(*    (125  *7 ( 3 2  !1  (*;..) *5**!(10(((/ )3 J *02 .)(0*) 5.(!0!* ./93)( 
;(*6.!6!.2 *(9*..(* !0 5 / (/ * ( 10(((/ )3  . 5.(*9  **0593 .

09)7*2(1  
*6(* (96.!62*01.(;.( .  1(  93 . >2**  G&0(( / )3F * ;.( .  1  !
5(6 2(1  ! ) 1) !!(*6 ) *5*  9 10(((/ )*

0.6.2 .(*  1  5 .!1.( .>)05.;7  9(** & 6( 5)0 *(22( / 9.(!!.2  !0. ) 55 .(   (**01 / .( . 2  ;(*  5  ( 1(7! 3%#

'( (1(7!% '6**(*!*.95)(!

 )*  .* **0 ;(*  (*5 . 9! . (0(

11    . 2


 * ** (3 ( C0*  ! !()  . )(

 ;9215(*.*(1

*())5 /35*1**5 %:

 4K
 ' 

  :
 ,#

"# $  %

 EE
' G( 5F   '

  


 




√(

)