Ranbir Etc v. Harpal Etc
! "! ##$$ %!& '!#$ "! #
(!
!)! *!+," ! ! *+ ! - ."*+ !"!# ////
).$"! ! .&$! ##$. " &!! . !!+ 0"1&! $, 2"#$
" $& 3 " !"! !,!, ! "$ 4&! .5
6 $
4!$2"#$
"$4""$.$"! " $"!"!"#$
+!.!$ 7
7
2" " $& !$! ."4$+ 2" !&,4 0 "1&! 8
59,"$""# " ##$$ "! *,#!4+2" $ !##$,$$
.&$! ##$',+!* &:! ##$ ##$,!!! 42"#$
"! ." "$$4 ."4$+ , ! #!#!0 $"#! & " !$ * #$ " " & !! 0 $4 9,$!"4)$, ", !
&!"!#&", !"#
2" "+$ #&", !"# 9,!"!. $ !,4)$,"" &!"! 4$03 ,!*" *3"., (! 9,!""#$
"+ $0#&!"" #!#!0 !43 !4$$ &! 2"$!
!$1&! !##! ."+ +$ $ " $!"& $ 0"#$
+-&.4
##$ $ !":!##$$1&! 0$.$"!
, $ !! 4 )! :! ##$$1&!!##!"+ +$ $ " $ &#"$ "-&.4 "!$1&! "& 4" $$, & $;& $,! "#!
!
!
5 !!
!
!! !
"
" &!"!& 4"
," "+#!
"!$ 0,0 +! # " -& "!$!& $ 0" , $0,"!# ! $# "&, $ 44$0*" *"& !! 0$4 <"!$!
!"!# "&##!" -&.4 # 0"1&! $, " ""! &!! . +&!
";&
$,#!# ! "#! =& ,"!.!"$4 2"!.&4
$" 4)$,, !*"" &!$.$"!
4$0 3 ,!* (! * 3"., " 2" #$
"+ #&!""#!#!0 $0 !43 2"! !*"& ;&,, ! 4$0(! 3"., !! 04 9"+"!"& 4 $',+!*" !.&4 !$0 ,! .&4# & !""
4)$*4& "! , $0 +&!
3 2"$ #&& %$$.>!2"6" 2" !$ 4&! .5
6 $
4!$,4& +&!
#!"4&
?@5 "!!
7 $$ &!"!*," $&$4 ."4$+ "+ 4, *, $ $0 . 3 2""!,$.$"!,! #!0" !$!& "!$!&* #&", !"# & *$.$"! (! $ ##$ & !
!! &$ 1(1 #!0 "&',+!*" !##$ ,4 0"!$1&!9 "
"(! ! !"4!3".,+!$4 0!." "#!#!0"! ! +, "& 4 +*","$ !.&4 &$$0 !! 2" ;& $,#! 0"$!
$
,"!.!"##$',+!*&! ."&! !.&4 * 4 &$!.&4 ,! "&2" #$
" $ 4#$! & ! # "
!"#9 "#!+&$. *" ,!"$
#!4+# 2" #&", !"# " *"! !*" "+ $&#&" !"# !"4!*"#$
,"! ! !' *" !## !4#& "4#$, !"# "$ #&& %$$.>! 2"6"*"!3 ,!!" !"#$
2""!;& $,,"!.!"#!+!0
-&.4 # 0"1&! $,',+!*$!
!" ##$$ " $## 0#!+!0 "+,6 0" 1&! $, & $ " &!"! & 4 " " ##$$ " $ , #!
"! $ 0 ,0 +! # 9"+! &$$0 !"& 4 $
',+!*94& $.!9 #&"
!$! $. * " " $ & $4 "4$+"+ 4, +!# 2" !$1&! & "" ,! #!4+ # ' *"&,4 8
5:!##$ $ 0" ,4 5
.&$!
##$,4
9"! !"#$
," $&
#!0" "$ #!4+# *"4!$ ." # ,&$ $"
&"#!0$4", !"# 0#!!# 42"!.&4
& $ ! " ##$$ " " !$! $. * " -& , $0,"!# " ! $# " #$
&$"+ $& !$ 8 " "&$ " " )4 #!+ !$4
0!," "# " 4+!"#$
9 "* "# " 4+!*"! !*"& $ 0"#$
,"!, !," $4
8 :! $" .", !"# 0,0 * "#$ #!+" !4,"""!#
4+!2"0,!!;&!# $$0#$ !4,"" "!# 4# "$ ,! $.
,""#!!
&#"0!
," ".&$!
##$,4 "& , $ !
&," #! $" 0!2"! !*"& 4
# : . !!! "-&.4 # 0"1&! $,* "#! .&$! ##$!! 4 0# .4$$ &##$ # !4 +-&.4
!
"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./