Gurinder Singh And Others v. Chandigarh Administration And Others
!"!
!
#
$!" "% #' (
) #*" + #,-$#*!-" & "!
!
#" & .& -$#* ,$ -*/ # &! $!
#$#*!-" & "&0#*"#!& 1'
!" "
#"$%"
&' ()'*#+, - % '
+ , .
()'*#+ ) '%
'/+0/* ,
1
!
"#
$"
&!
' ()! &* + , - ()!-.
/*!
!
#012+
$"
4 '
' $ !!* *
' $"
"
'!
%' !!% 4
5
'!
%'
4 '
% $"
6 '
4 6 ' $"
) !!*
!
* 7!
* % 4 $ !
*
* % !!
* 8)!
)! 4 !
'
9(9 :!!
( 9 % $"
" ) ' '
)!
% ( )!
' '
4 !
4 !
4 4 !! 4 !
)!
6' ! ' ( 4 !! 4 4 * ' ;
* *
)!
% ' 4 4 )
% 6%
% * 6 * 6 '
6%
6 '
* 6 ) 6 '
4 "< "# $"
! "0 "# $"
2 ) !
' '
' $"
"
!!
*
) '! 4 * ) # 9 $"
"
! '
*)! ( 4 !
=
! ' 4 )
< "3 $"
"
))
' ! !
> )! ' (% 4 !! !
)! ! ! ' ( 4 !! 4 !!
4 4 8) )!
** )* ( )! ! 4% #"
4 !
5' ) )! '! !
! 4
*
!
6 ' * !!* ' )
3 ! 4 4 !
! ! )*
' )* (9 '
!*
/*!
! ) ' ( !!* ()!
* ) *
!% * 6
) 4
% ) 4 *!% ; * $= ! * *!
* % ! )
* %
)
4 * )
4 !!% < ) 4
! '
!
$"
$ ) )! 4 ! !!
' $"
!
)! '
% ) 4 )'
''
!
'' = !
) !!% '
! ! * ) 8) * ) 4
!
"
5 ()!
"#
$"
; !'
* ) *
* !
) ) % 5 )!
8) )'
) *
/ ?
)
:!%
%'
9 8)!
5' 8)!
* '
* + @A%
8)! 4 9(9 ( & @>'@:! '
* )
8)! 4 > 8) )'
5'
) / )
(' B)
)2
!! :!!
9 8)!
4
,.
') * 8)!
'
* + @A%
8)! 4 !
&
,.
9(9 ( & 5'@>'@:! '
* )
:8)! 4 4
% !
&
,.
3@
% B!
' :!!
:** '
* 9)@+
,.
>@!
'% B' ;)* )!%
$ 9
)! '
)* :* :!% / &! !!
4* !2
"#
*/#/ 2)" / /!"/ + "* $3&/ %"4)
+ 5 +
5 5 "
!
"# "
$%&"
"'
'
()*+ , ()*+ - & .
*
)/0 ,
1%( ') ) 2"
))"
)0 *
+) "
+ &3 "
-
"
",* 4 "
" 5 6
)7 "
)"2 "
' "
8+'
0 * - - ,
)
9
1)
) " )"2
+ "
"
8+'
:
"02 "; + <& !
=
=
"# "
$%&"
"'
'
()*+ , ()*+ - & .
*
)/0 ,
1%( ') ) 2"
))"
)0 *
+) "
+ &3 "
-
"
",* 4 "
" 5 $56
)7 "
)"2 "
' "
8+'
0 *> "
) *7 ,
) *
" .$5 - - ,
)
9
1)
) "
)"2
+ "
"
8+'
0 * > "
) *7 ,
) *
" . $5
?7" 1)
)1 2 " )"2 "'
+ " $'5
) )
& / & * ?7
"<+2 * + & "
*7"
"
!
-*7 ) &8+) "
"
*&"'7"
* +
* 7" "
" * " "
) "&)"
'0 -* ?7
) * +& " ) "
"
& "
*& "8+) "
%7 )*2* * *
4 +7 ) & * '
"
&*" 2 ) 2 -* @ ' + "
&"'
'0
0 &
" 2& ) +)"+ A
+% * ! ! )!
4 8) 4 B' ! !!
4*
!
'
B'!
)' ''2 > ( 1"
!
(
# 94
# CCCCCCCCCCCCCCC ( !
""
* ! )!
)!!% * ' 8)
4**@ 6 !!
'
1"
* (@> ( !!*!!% *
!' ) )!
# 5 )!
'!% *) *
*
( !
* '
!!** ' )
!4
5 )!
! ! )
"( 6)#" ) " 7 8
"
7
-99:;.< -=>1 * ' ) * )! !
!
)
9 ! !!*
9 '
'* '
'
' ' ! )!
!!
B !!
( )8)!% * !!*
)
)%
'!
* )
8)'
)!'!% ! ) )!
!
*
)
)%
' 8)
)% !
' ) ) ) ' )!
) % !
!!*
< ) ) 4
4* )!!% 4!!
'!)
) * ! )'
!
"# "+'""7 8
+/
/7 -9.;:< !" .=> 4 -! 6 )
4 4
* 4 ' )
)8) * 8) !%
!%
)! ) * !
' 8)! '')'
'
' ! !! 4 ( B' )'
! !'
8)! 6 * '')'
8)! '
!* *
= 9 4
!*
* (@> ( * ) )!!
!!** '!!% * ( )! )! 4 *
!' !*
* (@> ( ) ''
!4)!
''
! )'
! )' $"
D* %
)
!*!
4
4 !!*!% '' ()!
'* /*!
!
* )
! !*!
( 4 !!%
' *!% ' 51+6 51 76
E)%
< $"
/