Virender Singh v. Joginder & ORS
! "#$ % $
$&''())*
+
*,#- ." .
# !/''&
! !
" # $ !
# "/0
+1+2 )
% & & " ' ())'
+2 )
% & & " ' ()*'
.
+' &,
& " -.
)- -)(-
.$.! + )( -)() " &
/ "
+ & / 0 1 2 # 34($40456*7 " "
& " &"
2()$) &
"
'
/& &2'4
" +
8 & 2 # 34$94+4$9)5 2 2'
&" " & / & " & &
& '" / :
, / 2'&2'
, %,# 5)5)- -)() -96 $$9,:;
<" : & /
;<'
&4 & 2 82
!
...
..
$#% + 82 '4"!
:=4( 0> :
< # ' & "
"42>2 & :=4(
82 ,# ( &4
:=4$ ?
@ + 3
:2+
#" 8 "& 3 #" )( -)() " 2' 2& " ' 4
3;8 " A & $ 5 !5 2!" &2 2
+ 2 " / 8 "
' )5 -)() "
& 2'&/ " & 2'
"
@
0> :B
:=45 '
3 :2+
#"
2 && & :B 8 + "& 3 #"
)( -)()"
@ )5 -)()
-* 9-)A4 & 7-)A4
B:
& 20> :: 0> ::A(0> ::A* &"
2' 82 & $* )))A4"" &
2' " 9 *C& & D 8 &2' 82 2"4 ./ '
0(30&) (
+0> :: 0> ::A(0> ::A* 20> :?:?A* -.
$*)A4 42
: 5 42 $
&0(67'&)8/' + 42 2 ' "42> 2 &'
:=4 - 0> :-
< :=4.
/ B
& 0& '
, 3 #" 2 && " & " 2& " 3 #" ,
3 & "
"
-( )$ -)(( 0> :#A-
&&'
40> :#A$0> :#A* B:
:=45 '
3 :2+
#" " :B
8 +
3' "& 3 #" )( -)(( "
(5 -)() 8
)9 *))4 & &
&
2
.
*6)A4 8 2 )9 *))A4 0> : 0> :A( :A* " '& .
*6)A4 0> :A7:A(*
:=4* # & + ;/ ,
3 #" 2 && " && ,
3 #" &(7 )$ -)((-( )$ -)(( "
5.
.9) .-A4 D 2 0> : 0> :A( 0> :A- " & "
())A4"B:
2A 0> :A$0> :A(-
B 2 2' 82 ,# $
&4 8 & "
2' 82& * *7 )))A4"" &
2' " 9 *C& & D 8 & 2' 82 2"4 ./ '
0(30&) (
8&
(7 )))A4
:'& 20> : 0> :A(0> :A- *7 )))A4 $
+0> ::A-6 *.
7)(A4 *6 )))A4
: -* )))A4 *
&0(67'&)8/' 42
& &4
&'
:=4- 0> :-
< :=49
?
+ ; # '
, 3 #" 2 && "
4
"& 3 #" " 2" & 2
2& 4&>' 3"
)* -)() 2' 8 "
(( -)()0> :A("
&&' 4
8 B: 0> :A- 0> :A$ 4 "4 &
"3B: 0> :A5
:=4* # & + ;/ ,
3 #" )$ ' &
+ "&, 3 #"
&)( -)()(( -)() 8
-$.
7-A420> :8 0> :8A(0> :8A* & &
8 "
($)A42A 0> :8A7 0> :8A(6
B 2 2' 82 ,# 5
&4 8 & "
2' 82& $ 5.
)))A4"" &
2' " 9 *C& & D 8 &2' 82 2"4 ./ '
0(30&)
(
8&
)))A4
:'& 2 0> :A$) :A$( -5 )))A4 $ : *) )))A4
&0(67'&)8/' +
42 % " & "
&4 &'
&4 &'
&4 &'
,
& , 2 &4
, & & &<24
'
& 4 4
!"#$!% !
:=45 '
3 :2 +
#"
&4 & & & ' & &4 4 ./ '
0(30&) (
+0> :: 0> ::A( 0> ::A*20> :?:?A* -.
$*)A4 -6 )))A4 (
* )))A4
@ & * )))A4 $ : )))A4
8
* )))A4 *
-
!
. 9 $ $
42
:(' 63& (67'&)
42; + 42 < 42 ! !"&$!% !
:=45 '
3 :2 +
#"
&4 &'
& & &)( -)()(5 -)() :=4.
/ B
& 0& '
, 3 #" &4&&
&)7 )$ -)((-( )$ -)(( 2 &4 & & > &
'
&
&44 ./ '
0(30&) (
8&
(7 )))A4
:'& 20> : 0> :A(0> :A- *7 )))A4 $
+0> ::A-6 *.
7)(A4 *6 )))A4
: 5) )))A4 *
-) )))A4
(* )))A4
8
-) )))A4 *
-
!
. 9 $ $ 5 42
:(' 63& (67'&) 5 42; 42 < 1 42 ' "$!% !
? " :=49
?
+ ; # '
, 3 #" "
&4
&'
"
$45' " )* -)() 2' "
(( -)() &4&& & ' 3 & &4 4 ./ '
0(30&) (
8&
)))A4
:'& 20> :A$) :A$( -5 )))A4 $
: *) )))A4
)))A4 *
8
)))A4
-
!
. 9 $ $ +
42
:(' 63& (67'&) +
42; +
42 < 42
& & ( &%%% 2 '2 &4 &'
( )%%%%*+ 2 '2 &4
&'
( !%%%%*+ 2'24
& &'
" "& & ' 8 & & 'E6C & & & D " & 3F2 &; G,-,
$ ./
.
+ &
2 & &
'
"& 2 > '" # " $