← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20065/2022dismissed

The Punjab State Cooperative Bank Ltd., Chandigarh Thorugh Its Managing Director v. Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (C), Chandigarh And ORS

2023-12-13Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages



    

   



 !"

!

$!!

! !%!

 &&&&

%'( )* %(+ , ) - -



          



 !    "  

!  ."/ -

0 !

0 "



 $% ! !  &'

 ( )'  *  $    + &'

 )'  * %, ----- !

0 "



- CM-13851-CWP-2023:

Prayer in the present application is for placing on record the short reply filed by way of an affidavit of respondent No.3. For the reasons mentioned in the application, short reply filed by way of an affidavit of respondent No.3 is taken on record, subject to all just exceptions.

Application is accordingly disposed of.

CWP-20065-2022:

1.

The present writ petition has been filed & ')../*..0   1 !

!   !  2/3/.3.. &4(25  2623.3.3 &4(6   &)) &    7 &'

260. 

   ))!  &            7   &'

 260.

'

)  +    (        '

    )   !   %,+  8239  &                     !       2/3/.3..

&4  (25         2623.3.3  &4  (6  !

'   +  .  )  %, &  !  '

 ( 223:2663    '



!

 !    5: ,33;.326

 

%, ) 4   '   

7  1 '

              +    +  !  4 ' + 3235.326 ,33;.3.31   

 )7 & &'

.32:  4

) !   )  )   7 &'

260. 

   < 260.&'

<   "23 ' ".3  ' + .63,.32:=+  7   

> ' '

   )'? @



     )

     2,36.326  &4  (,  '

!  ))  A* *&4  1  ')! ( 

  +  +  )

 % '

  .63,.32:  )7 '

'

;

,

260.&'

+' 4 ) !   )  

 )+ '   "23 ' ".3 ' ,  '  (   7

1 '

 2,36.326 &4(,+    (    ! ' ')  '!  '!   B     )  !  

 260.&'

+  1 

 (   1 '

  7   !   )) ) + *  *!4

     '    1 '

     2,36.326  +   ) * !

)   ) 260.&'

  &  (   %, ' ) .6   ' )   + ) + "2 3. .,0*(  ''!)    '

;

. 260.&'

  )! 

 %,'  "20 23 53;*( + !+  7 1 '

 2,36.326  (    )   "23 '  %,)   3.30.3.3  &4  (5  1        (     

 %,! !' "23 '  !  &'' ,33/.3.3 ; "  %,  )    )'

     3236.3.3

&4(/ 260.&'

 %. ! '

  (  ) !!  +'+  '       ( B  +     ))!&     260.  &'

 '              2623.3.3

&4(6'

!  (    ) ' 

!     "0 23 53;*(  )!  +     )  8  239  

3235.326 +     ' 

1 5 !  +    2623.3.3

&4(6   (  ) 

  ) '

 0    260.&'

   &))  &   %2   +'  +   )            2/3/.3..

&4(25&''!)  (  )   + 

    / " %, '    +  )!

 ) .23:.3., + ))+!       ! %0#( C



    

   

  



 

  

 

 

 

   !"

  #  "

 $

%& '   ($  ) (*+,- "(.( *$ $ *  /

"(  $#$ $$  (("

* $00  .   , /

.  

  

, /*(   

  

    

.     

    .



 



 $

 .   % ,    $#$ $$ ( 0   



  

$ (  $(. 

D 0  ')  %,



 ' )

 233..3., &4"(,*,    ! 

 )     %, '  ' 

!   &  &'

.32: +   4

)   )   )+ '   "23 ' ".3 ' + .63,.32: : &  ! ) ')   



 )

 233..3.,  )! ' (  '

  ) 8239   !  

%,    )+      ' 6 '  ) ')  %, 

 

  ) ')   '

   )1 

   )+ ! ) !   8239      )7

% '

 322326:0 &4"(,*2 +'  #( C1/- &2'34

   .



"( " & *'  -   ($  ) (*+,-

& , ,- '+

)

$ 

"(    



 $  $ 

("  

$ "

"(



 .

 (.    



 $      "  )5  D 23  ')  %,     !

 =< )    

     !"#$$ %&'( )* + +   )   )   !

,3 

       B 

'   ) )+       4' ' 

 )+  )  ) )  22 1  ) ')     ! !

  +   )  ' 2. &!   )'

)   260.

&'

 %,''    ')  )

  233..3., &4"(,*, 

    )  4  '

   #(

 C6 ) (*" 

  

 7  

..



  

, /

   ($ (

*$ *  /

  .     .

  

      

, /"

.

  

, /"(

# 

 

    ($   (

*$ *  /   

 .    

      

 D 2, 1+ 4  '

  '

 260.&'

   +)  )'

)  '   %,   ( ) )   !     '

;

, 260.&'

+ 4 ) ! +  '  "23 ' ".3 ' + .63,.32:  '')  %,  

',33;.326 2; >   !  !     239   ''   %,   ) ' '  ' 

 '

     322326:0  &4  "(,*2         ) 7 +    '  239    )  ))   )  )  ) '  +!   +  '  (     ) +   '

+   

'   25 >    '     

  ) #(    - 4   $  -& '  ( "

$ (" +

+.

(

 "

$ +" 

$ $   (  .

 

.$

 (    ("               (   ( $ (9

-& '+



 ( $ (.

( $  "

$ (" 9

 " 

&*'  -+  $ ("(

. 

    " & '+

  (+  $        .     (  "

$ ("   .+$ 

 

 #

   "(

)

$

$  $    $  

($       

$   7    

"

("    (  ($    

        

  

   "   

$    .

  $  

   (   ( ($    :

$  $  -+ $$ "



$

(  (.

   $ (

  ( ($   (;

"  $

 

$($ (. . 

  $("

<.



+

  -& *'+ 

"

("   (($ (

    





   "   

$    .

  $  

   (   ( ($    9

/+ $  



(  ( ("

*+ "(

.



"

$    



$   (.$ 





 



( $  

 *         $      ,    ($     ( ($ (. . 



 $("

   $ 

"

   ($   "

 #

(    "

       "

   (    

 2$(





$   "   ( ( "  (($ ($ "

 .  ( ($  

.  .    =

>1   $";(( ?,/6 &6':@0%6A2 

.   ($  

  ( ($ ( " & *'

.   - "($ $ +.$   .

 $1"

+,/-4      B  # *

?,//&6-':@06%

A+ .   .. C D

.  *  ($  

 .  $ .E   "(  *  ( "



  .    

54 +     

.   .*

 ,/-"

 " 

    "  &*' -     D    ,4 $. #  " $

    F    

    (   ($    (.  (   

. " .

 .  (+    + . 

   



  (  E  (   F      .   ($ (.

     (    

       (   ($     (

  -& *'  *4.    

   ( ($   (.

    

 " 

$.

 $    (   ( ($   * " +

 $     -

   ($      ( .  $     ( 

  ( ($ (

  



$ (.$

2 

 $ ((" ."(



$  /  *

 ( $ (



$    

-& *'+

.  ( 



 "

 ($ (9   (+

       <  

+      

 .   

+  

.

    F  

  $ 

 ( ($ ((    



 "(   F    "

"

 " (4      . " +   F   

      

 

  

      

$ (   -  *

   +    

 +  $$    

    $   F   





 $

 . 

  



 . " (G 2/ E!+  )! )  ) + 1 '+  %, ! ) !  ! )!+  )1 8239  ) '  +   2/3/.3.. &4(25  2623.3.3 &4(6   &  )+&''!)    +   !



      20 &))! )'

      )) ) ') - -

3!

0 "

 *



% 2F  !*  # G*% .F 

) G*%