Shaminder Singh v. Punjab Agro Industries Corporation And ANR















 !" #$%$& $!'$$$ $& $!



 &

(( ) * * 


 



  




  
 



  


 
 


 



  




  
 



  
+




 



  




  
 



  
,

 




  




  
 



  
+

 !"
 



 

 




  
 



  
 +

 #




  




  
 



  
+

 $
 



  




  
 



  


 !"
 



  




  
 



  
,




 



  




  
 



  
+++,

 !"
 



   




  
 



  


 !




  




  
 



  
 



% "
 



  




  
 



  
+,

 &




  




  
 



  
!$-) .%/ -!*# 0
$!0-!$0

0 

 '

$
&  
!(
) *

 
+,
-
% ./012(
03334(
.1505(
.0036

.37./
*
.576

$

 
#
8

(
) *

 

-
% (7./2.
*
.572
 -
% .774/(.77/0

.7713
*
.576

$


#
9 (
) *

 

-
% ..3..
*
.572

$

&

(
)
*

 


-
% /374
*
.572

, $

% #
$)(
)
*

  
-
% .0.25
*
.576

$

 :
#(
)
*  ;

 
- <.767/
*
.576

$

# 
 "(
)
*  ;

 
-
% .774/

.37./
*
.576

$

!


!"(
)

*  ;

 
-
% .77/0

7646/
*
.576 
-
% /374
*
.572

$


 
#"

(
)
*  ;

 
-
% 03334
*
.576

$

8  

!(
)

*  ;

 
- <.0036
*
.576

===

$!0-!$0

0  1#* !>

)
 (

)
*

 (
 "
*
) 
 
 


  (

 
 
*

""

  
"


? 
*
"

"
*)



 ) (
)

   
>

  +,

  

 (


""

  

 
)

  
*

))
)" 
*
   
>
""

 "
 >


 ) (
 >

*" 



 


 )
*
 (
)


 
)>

 ""


 
) 


)>
*

  
 


"
 (

 )
 ; 

** 

  >
"(
)

  > "

 "


  +,

"
) 
)

 

 
>

"   
) "
*

  +,




 


" 
 

 ) (



 )


 <

  



)" 
 

  *
 >

"

>



)

)" *
   

@

 
*

 (
*)

 
 
* 
- < % ./012
*
.576
" 

02(0(34*567$3 5( 8 (  



 ) (
)

   
>
  



 



  
* 
 )
 


*
 

07 .573

*  (
 )

 

 
  



.1 .573

)"
.0
+7, +,

+,

*


 
*




  
 


""

)
*


)(


)
 
 ** 
"

"> 
*

 
   
>

 


  
 

 )  


" (
.57/( + * *



A.57/
" A,
"
70
*


" 
 "
  " 
)


 '< B70
9)" (
" 

 "'

">

  >
 )
)  

   
 
""

""
 )" >
)



 
*

) * 


 
*

 


 
"
 ) 
"  

 )
*

 



 

   

)

 
*

 (

)" ( )

 >
 )
*

 ; 





"
)





 



)

 

)) )" >
 
 
>

">


" 

 
 ) (
 )"">(
 



)

 
 

(


< "


  D
)
*
(
 

*" 
">(

)
 
 
 

 
* 
"
70
*

A.57/
" A(

"

 ) 
+  

 ",
" (

"
")"

 "> 
*

 ; 
(
 * (
)
*
)

 


 
*

 

 ""


 )
* 
 ;
 

"
.

.
+,
*


"
 )  +  

 ",
" 
  

">



)

 



">

 ""

"
.

.+,
*


"
 )  +  

 ",
" (


"
(

)


")

 
") 
>

 ; 


 '<
B
.

.
+,

8  
*  

  " 

  *
"

 

 

>
 
*
(  
  ">

*

 )* 
 


 
* 

) >
* 

 
*

"

 
*
>  ) >
"
) 

8  (
*

 

.
*
/ *

   "

)"
 (


 

">
*


))



) 
 ) >
"
 8  
>
))

 " ) (


 ) )"
 )
 

< "> 
*  

 
<
+7,)
   "
 (
*
 
"

**)



 )
 
 *

 



< "> 
""
*

*"
 
*

**) (
   






"

""

)  
))" 
>

 >
>
)


) ) 
 




*

**)

) 

 )

+.,
)
   "
 (
*

 
"
 **)


>

 *  

 < "> ('<
+,
""


 



)
*
 8  '
+,
""


 )
*

 
)

")




*
>  
 *


*
)
 E


+ +,
""

)) 
>
)
 >


)
")


") 


8  
>
 )


)) )

 ) 
")"

   "
 

)
 
*
"
* 
 )
)"

 E
+0,
)
)"
 (
*

 
"

**)



>

 *

 


 "> (
""

 

 )
*

 

   

"
+,
*
 
+.,E

+4,

")
 )

""

)" 
 *

*"
 

 


FG"<
@

 
*


" <
+7,
   "

""

  


   
 

)


*  
 

 


 


 (
*

**)

 
") 

  * 

 "
 (

)
 E

+.,
&)"
 
""

  


 
 < +,


)
*
) "
 (



)
 )"




)""

 


) "
) E 
+,


)
*
)"
 (




)
 "

   
 (


)
>
 (

")

 
)"
) EC  "
*

  +,


) 
 
>
 ) "
*

 ; 

"
.

.+,
*


"

 ) 
+  

 ",
" (

(
"



  )


 


)

 



">
 

"

)" 


)


)" > 
 
*    
) "
*

  +,

 





"

")"
">


">



 


"
.

.+,(
">
 
*

">
)
  
 "
*

 


 

"
.

.

+,
*

 "
 ) 
+  

 ",
" (
)


")" 

 




)

 




<

  "
(
 * (


*)

) )) 
*

) (
"

.

.

+,
 


>
 ; )


 ;  

 
 

 
*

 



  
"   
) "
*

  



   
) 

 
"
)


< 
! )
*

 

"

>
) 
 "
? 
*
"
"
 )
- <.13.6
*
.574
" 


5(0(34*567$3 5(
8 ( 9$
:/  ) 


.4 .573





 (

 
8 

 

 

)

 

*

 


*
? >
 
)

 (


 


 
*
) >
>

 >

 < (
)


)""  
>
8 
 
> *"
-
% .13.6
*
.574

)

 

 ""


*  

)""  
>

 
 






 ; 


)  


)

 

 ">
*
;  

))
)" 
 
 (


 

" 
 

 ) (
 

"
*

" 
 

 ) (
 


 
)" 
*  


 (
*
)


 
>


 ; (
)




 


  
  

"
.

.
+,
*


"
 ) 
+  
  ",
" (

(
"

 



 

 )

 
*  (


 
 "
>

 

"
.

.
+, 

")"

)
*

"> 
*

 < 


 


)

">



(

< "


  
* 
 "
>

 




 " (
)
  ; )


 ; 


 

">
*
;  (
 ) (

)
*
)

 



">

** ) ) >
>
))

)" (

 >

 )
*

 


 


" >


 ; 

** )
) > 
)) )

"
>
*"

)"

 " 



*
   


 '< 
 




FG )





   
 

+ ,


* 
 )
 .57.

*

 (

)

< 

 
 .57.


F? >
H**)

 (

)   
* 
 

 

 ? ">(


) )

 


 

 * (

   
 
75 .574
+ G <6,

 (
 )(
) >
*
 74(54(5/(607;<

 



) 
* 

 


 

)""  








 )
" 
")"


(

)"


)

<  
*

 
 )

 ">
)"


 

 

 


 




"
04
*
 
H (

 "
" 
 *

 
*
  


 
(
 * (
 


 * 
 

 )
)
*

 


  






  
 

  )  


" 
7227
"
70
*

 "
*
7227(
  


 

""
 )" >
)

">



H 

"  
>

  (



"
 ) 
" 


"
")"



 

 
"
 )  " 
.

.
+,(
 <(
"<(

   

)  
 

   "
 
*

 
*
 ">
  


 



")



 *
>  
 *


*
)


   
"   
) "
*

  



  


)  "
70
*

" 
*
7227

) 

 '<
B70 9)" (
" 

 "'
 "> 

 
>
 )
)  


   
 
""

""

)" > )



 
*

) * 



*

 


 
"

 ) 
"  C



*

 
*
)" 


H (

"
 ) 
" 


")"

"
04
*


H
   




 >
""

 $
9 )

 
*

  ""


 ""
 >  
) "

) 

*
*""
*

 
  
 
" 

 
  



 ""  >


! 
*
9 ) "
.

.+,

) 

 '<
B.

.
+,
I
8  
*  

  "  
 
*
"

 

 

>  
*
(
 
  ">

*

 )* 
  

 
*


) >
* 

 
* 
"

 
*
>
 ) >
"
) 
 8  (
*

 

*

   "


)"
 (


 
">
*

 ))



) 
 ) >
"
 8  
>
))

 " ) (

 )
)"
 )
 

< ">  *  

 
<
+7,)
   "
 (
*  
"

**)


 )
 
 *


 



< "> 
""
*


*"
 
*

**) (

  





"

""

) 
 ))" 
>

 >
>
)


) )  





*

**)

) 


 ) +.,
)
   "
 (
*

  "

**)


>

 *  


 < "> ('<
+,
""


 



)
*
 8  '
+,
""


 )
*

 
)

")
 

*
>  
 *


*
) E

+,
""

)) 
>
)
 >


) ")

") 


8  
>
 )

 )) )


 ) 
")"
    "
 

)


*
"

* 
 )
)"
"

 E
+0,
)
)"
 (
*

 
"
 **)


>

 *

 




"> (
""

 

 )
*

  

  

"
+,
*
 
+.,E

+4,

")
 )

""

)"   *
*"
 

 
FG"<
@
  
*

" <
+7,
   "

""

  

  
 
 

)


*  
 
  

 


 (
*

**)

  ") 

 
* 

 "
 (

)  E

+.,
&)"
 
""

  


   <
+,


)
*
) "
 (



) 
)"




)""

 

 ) "
) E

+,


)
*
)"
 (




) 
"

   
 (


)
>
 (
 ")



)"
) EC %(

  "
)

< 

 
""



"  " 
 

 


 
 " 

)

*

>
 


 " )
* " 
*

 
*
 > 
.556<.552(
.552<.575(

.575<.577

@(
"

 


*
J32(46(7.(.41;<

 
** 
>
  



 



*
  


 "

"
.

.
+,
" 

> 
 



 (

 


" (

8  
*
"
 ? >(
)


 

 

 
*
(  ">

*

 )* 
 
)


* 
 


 " (

) >
* 
  
)


* 


 
) "
*

 
  



*

*

? >(

  ""
*"

)"
 

*

 

"

? >

*G 
"">






  


 )" "




) (
 
*
) >
)"


 
 "
.

.
+,( 


*

 


 " (
 * ( 
  

75 .574
+ G <6,

  
">


G 
*


) >

  (

""
">

 


 


">


? >


*"

)"

*

) >(
 )

 
 
*

" )"
"



))  ">(
 ">
"" 

 
) "
*

 
 >
* ">
))  
   

5(0(3.958:

"

>
 
*"> 

"
 
"    F 
  (
*  (

G


 
"
  

 

 

"
 " (



 )*)
" (
)
 


 ; 


)

 



"> (
 )

 
)

 

 

)

 
 


"> 
 ) (
)
)
*

 (
" 
" 
 

 
 )
G 
 )


 






 " 
 )"
*
"






)

  


">


)
 
*  (


"


 )*)
"


" 
 

 )

A"

 
 
*

"
 )
"
 "
% .757
*
7222 %3((#4*% 

&( *0*"*
*
 "


)




 


" 
 

 )
*
)
* )" 
*  
*

"> (

 



 )
* 

"
  *
)




 
*


 
)"">
" 
 " 



*


  
 
 '< B
     



       



  

    







 



     

      



  

       

   

      



  

   

        

   

        !"# 

       

       

 

 

  

  

    

     





   




   

     



 

  

               $
A"
 
 
*





0(34*0

!6 

9:0
 ,
"

 "

>
 ( )

 
  
*

 
 ) 

>  >

 )

>

 

 )


 
*  (


 
>
 


,  )


">



** )

"">

"
 "  


*


  


 '< %     

   &'





   &

() 

  

    

  

 

*  

   

   

   
 

    

 +     

*   

,

    

 -  

    

 


    

 



      

 .  

         

 





    

   

/



   

          

        



  


   

*  

,

    



  

  

   &

()  $ 
 

"
 ) 

? 
*
"(


  (
 ">


"

>

* 
 )
)

)

  

 )

 
 


">
"

 )
)

)
*


 (
"
 )
-
% 7/.43
*
.577
" 

0*
*#(4 -3(3&( 
 (

 "

 '< B
 "
*

* 
 
)"  ">


  " (

  
*


" (
)

  ">


"> (


 
" >(

  
  >

  


 " (
)
)
 *") (





"
*


)
)
 

">

 )
%
*

 (
 G ) 
 (





)

 
*
 ">


* 
 )




 

    "
 (
 
*
 
 
 ">

 ) (
)
)
*  




>
A"

 
 

 
 A )
+ ,(
 


 



 )
*  )*)
"


** )

)

">

   
(

 
)
)

 
*
> * 
)(
)

 


" 

  ) (

 
*
)

 
 
">
)

 (

>
(

)
*
   


)

< 


  
*
 

 


 )


""


 



))  ">
- "
"
  *
*
   

"  


 @  (

)< 
! )
*

 
>
">
   

0*
*  #(. 
  958: "
 )
& 3(  !2  ;*

<  0  "(  


52. 
8(4   == 0 1 ,9,:/!,  "

 '< B3
H
 "
*
* 
 (


)" 

  " (

  


" (
723/(
)
  


"> (


 
" >(


 

  >

  



"
)" 



 ">
)

 
">


">
 *  (

 
)

  

 ">


)(

 ">
)

*") 
 




 

   "
 )

 
 

">
*  




>
A"

 
 


 0(340

!6 

9 :0

,

*

 

0*0*$<4  <%(6=( ;((321>5= 

9:0/!
/0


 "


* 
  


  )
*
>
 )*)
"


** )(

 )

) ; (
)

">

   

"
 

"
 "


  
* 0*
*#(.958:*

 
*

*)

"


    (


)" 

 



 

 " 



)
*
)

 


  ">


">
*  (

)

   


 


 )


 
""


 

))  ">(

  
 

"" 

   
)

 
 
7.

.57.

 ""

   
*
""




)

 
  7.

.57.

 


 

 ) 


 

" 

"
  *


 


  *


* 


*
) 
*
) * 
)>
* 


C


 "
*


"


? 
*
"

 

 
 


"

>
 
 ) 


)
>
 A"
 
 
*



 ""

>

 
"
 

 

>
 )*)
"

 )


">
 
)" >
 
*  


)
 )" >
 
*  (
">
)
 )" 
 

">


"

>

*  )

)
)

 
 

*

   (




 
 


 )
)

 "
 

 "*
*

 ;

 
 > * ">
))  




" (

*
(
)
 


 ; 


)

 



">


" )" >

H)





 "*
*


 ; 




" (
)
 
  


)

 



">


)
 
*  (

)

 
 


  +,( )

 
  

 

 


 )
 
)" 
)

 "

 )


)

  

 

 "
*

 ; 


 


 

 
 
 )


)" >
 
 



">


 

 
""


" > 
)

"

)
>
">

) 
(
>
;
)
*

+ ;)(
>
*"
  
 
 *

"

 
*

) >
*




 

"

>
 
 " "
 )
-
% .13.6
*
.574
>

 

 



 





 

 
)

 " 
 )


** 
  >
"



*
>
">


;
 )
)

 

   

# 

 

 (

)

 (
)

   


  +,

)" 
*


 


" (

 

">


** )

 )" >
)

 
 

  +,



*

 )

 

)" 

?


""

 ""




)

 (
*
"

>
)"  
""

  


*) *
? >
">



*)
*
? >
""


  
 )" >
? >
*

 
*
>

*
  
 
 
>

 



*

  
)

 (


""
"


 
** )





*  

 
*

 (
)" > 
)

 

"

>
))" 

 )
*

)

 
""

  

*)
*
? >


) (



*) *
? >(


  
 
>
 )"
">


 ;
)
*
)

(

 

** 
>   >
"(

 
""


" >



 >


)



*
"

)) )

"
>
*"

)"


-




"
  *(
)
 

   "
>

 



*

  )>
*

)

  (




 >
*

" 
*



 
  (

  
""


" >

 )


 ; 
*

" 
*

  *  
) "

*

 ; 

 >
* ">
 


) (
>
)

 

*" 
>

  +,

>
" *
*
" 
*
   >
  *(
)

 
 "



  )>
*
 )

 (
 >
""
)





  

 )) )

"


 
*


* 


*
)  *

 


 


 
>



 (
) "
*

 ; 
 
  


 ) 
*
 

" 




 )
 
)" 
 


">

 ""

 )

)" 
*  
!



>(
 
 


  



" 

** ) 

  
 * ) (


""

G 


" 


  



 
 


 

 
*
" 
 
 )


G
>

""


 

 
*


 

$!0-!$0

0  :

.572 # &



- 
  ;<  K L ;% .

-  " K L ;%