Joti Ram v. State Of Haryana & ORS


 

        

 ! "#$ %$&'(')*
+
+ #' ", $#'#')$- (!

.$-(/( 0#"#$ "-1")"")%#2$-(  $()%$)# (!

 *  34  0 5 40  -$($)#*6 --"#$$7 /#"8%9&"#$8 -8 -0")%$$ /%:';8%9&"#$8 -#2$$#'#')$- -"9$$)02$-")8$/#1%9&"#$ $)$-";8"-1")" --/)02"-,"8%9&"#$8 --$()%$)#(")%<
 2$#2$-#2$ $-#$-( ;&";)$=("$-,"1>$";;=$%# ($$#2$?/%:,$)#@  >$-$ $--$%##2$ $-#$--)# < 2$#2$-#2$?/%:,$)#(2/;%>$-$-#$%')#2$%':$(#@ 66 66 40 

4!

$"-% #&,$(/##2"##2$$#'#')$-?')$%#2$($-9'&$"("$)') #2$-$:/;"-&"%-$')#2$'(#-'&#-',"-1 $-"#'9$:-'&/;#/-$")% /-";

$9$;,$)#")74','#$%8":"%2-'8'(#-'&#",/)"":"-4"#$-)8') #2$1$"-+2$="("')#$%"(""

#-'#";(&,$(/##2"#;"#$-)8 #2$&"%-$ ";;#2$'(#-'&#-',"-1 $-"#'9$:-'&/;#/-$")% /-";

$9$;,$)#")74','#$%')#2$0#"#$=$-$,$-:$%'))$&"%-$")%9'%$ -%$-%"#$%
A
BB2$$#'#')$-="(>-/:2#)#2$&,,)&"%-$

-$()%$)#')"-1")"0#"#$ $-"#'9$ :-'&/;#/-$")% /-";

$9$;,$)#  ")7  4','#$%8  #2/:2  2$  &)#')/$%  #  =-7  "#  ",/)" ":"- )#2$-$C/$(# #2$$#'#')$-2',($;

8#2$:-"#/'#1 -#2$$-'% 2$=-7$%='#2-$()%$)#<'$'(#-'&#-',"-1 $-"#'9$

66 :-'&/;#/-$")% /-";")74','#$%8":"%2-'8'(#-'&#",/)"":"-8 ",/)#'):  #  ( 
8 6
8  ="(  -$;$"($%  #  2', )  

8  9'%$ 9/&2$-<+<2$$#'#')$--$#'-$% -,($-9'&$ -$()%$)# )<


)#2$-$($)#=-'#$#'#')8#2$$#'#')$-($$7(#2$=-'#

,")%",/(  %'-$&#'):  -$()%$)#(  #  -$;$"($  #2$  "1,$)#    :-"#/'#1 ",/)#'): # ( 8
8 <6";):='#2')#$-$(# "##2$-"#$ 
D$- "))/,8&;"','):#2"#(,$:-"#/'#1'("1">;$ =$9$-8#2$(",$'( -$('(#$%>1#2$>")7)#2$:-/)%#2"##2$:-"#/'#1 -#2$$-'%=2$)2$ ="()#>-/:2#)#2$&,,)&"%-$="(";-$"%1-$;$"($%#2',) 

2$,"#$-2"(";-$"%1>$$)&)('%$-$%>1#2'( /-#')  AB 8#'#;$%"(0"#"-"').$-(/(0#"#$ "-1")"")%#2$-(8 %$&'%$%)


8')9;9'):(',';"- "&#(2'( /-#2"(>($-9$%"( /)%$-*6 %,'##$%;18#2$$#'#')$-="(=-7'):"($)')#2$ ")('-")&2'(#-'&#-',"-1 $-"#'9$:-'&/;#/-";")%

/-";  $9$;,$)#  ")7  4','#$%   2$  $#'#')$-  ="( "')#$%>1#2$-")&2 ")":$- #2$")('>-")&2")%="( #=-7')")('-")&2);1%,'##$%;18')#2$1$"-
BB8 &,,)  &"%-$    #2$  $-"#'9$  :-'&/;#/-";  ")%  /-";

$9$;,$)#")74','#$%="(&-$"#$%")%#2$$#'#')$-="( >-/:2#)#2$&,,)&"%-$ $)'$ ;"((. "-1")"

0#"#$ $-"#'9$:-'&/;#/-";")% /-";$9$;,$)#")7 4','#$%")%2'(($-9'&$#2$-$"

#$-="(-$:/;"-'F$%>1#2$ /;$(  #2$("'%")7  %,'##$%;18#2$",/)# :-"#/'#1;1'):

='#2#2$-$()%$)# ="(#>$-$,'##$%##2$2$"%

'&$8 =2'&2="()#-$,'##$%#&,$(/##2"##2$$#'#')$-="( -,#$%"("

#-')<

+#'(";()#%$)'$%#2"# #2$$#'#')$-2',($;

2"%";'$% --$;$"($ :-"#/'#1>$ -$ #2$  $-'%  2$  ="(  >-/:2#  )  &,,)  &"%-$8  =2'&2  ="( -$;$"($%

6<6 =8#2$C/$(#')=/;%"-'($=2$)#2$"1,$)#  :-"#/'#1'(#>$-$;$"($%@ 0$&#')  #2$"1,$)#  -"#/'#1&#8
B+8 ;"1(%=)#2"##2$:-"#/'#1'(#>$-$;$"($%)-$#'-$,$)#- -$(':)"#')   #  &")  ";(  >$  -$;$"($%  ')  &"($    %$"#2  - %'(">;$,$)#%/$#"&&'%$)#-%'($"($ )$  #2$("'% :-/)%(=$-$"9"';">;$')#2$1$"-+8=2$)#2$:-"#/'#1 - #2$$-'% -,
B+#
BB="(-$;$"($%##2$$#'#')$- 2$-$ -$8  ""-$)#;18   -$()%$)#     >")7  &,,'##$% ';;$:";'#1")%9';"#$%#2$-9'(')( "1,$)#  -"#/'#1 &#8
B+8=2';$-$;$"('):#2$:-"#/'#1 -#2$$-'% -,
B+ #
BB9$)#2$&";&/;"#')(2$$# ))$G/-$6 A!(2=(#2"# #2$:-"#/'#1="(&";&/;"#$%)#2$>"('&"1 #2$$"&21$"-8 =2$-$"('#="(#>$&";&/;"#$%)#2$;"(#"1%-"=)2$("'% $---2"(>$$)"%,'##$%>1-$()%$)#')#2$>$##$-"

'%"9'# =8"C/$(#')=/;%"-'($=2$#2$-#2$$#'#')$- '(#>$"'%#2$:-"#/'#1 -#2$$)#'-$$-'% -,
B+#';;2'( -$#'-$,$)#')#2$1$"-
<)#2$;"(#"1%-"=)-#2$:-"#/'#1 '(#>$(;'#/ -#2$$-'%
B+#
BB")%#2$-$"

#$- -,
BB#
<@ ", #2$9'$=#2"##2$:-"#/'#1="(-$;$"($%>1 -$()%$)#  >")7  )  <+  &)#-"-1  #  #2$  "1,$)#  

-"#/'#1&#8
B+ 2$-$ -$8#2$$#'#')$-'(-$C/'-$%# %$('##2$("'%",/)# (
A6
";):='#2')#$-$(#H BD$-"))/, -,<+#';;'#(%$('#='#2-$()%$)# >")7")%#2$-$"

#$-8#2$:-"#/'#1'("1">;$"($-;"(#"1 %-"=))#2$%"#$ -$#'-$,$)# #2$$#'#')$-8 (')&$#2$ ($-9'&$( #2$$#'#')$-=$-$#"7$)9$->1-$()%$)# >")7)"&&/)# &-$"#') &,,)&"%-$I 2$-$ -$8#2$ /-#-%$-$%#2$$#'#')$-')#2$("'%&"($# %$('##2$:-"#/'#1";):='#2')#$-$(#"##2$-"#$ BD$-"))/, -,#2$ %"#$'#="(-$&$'9$%>12',#';;#2$%"#$ %$('#")%-$()%$)#(=$-$ %'-$&#$%#-$6&";&/;"#$#2$:-"#/'#1"1">;$##2$$#'#')$-)#2$>"('(

;"(#"1%-"=)>12',")%-$;$"($#2$:-"#/'#1')"&&-%")&$='#2-/;$(#

="( /-#2$-%'-$&#$%#2"#'

#2$$G&$((",/)#="("'%8#2$)#2$(",$&") >$"%?/(#$%')#2$("'%",/)#2$$#'#')$-')#2$-$($)#=-'#$#'#') (#")%("##2$(",$ #'): )9'$= #2$,"##$-8#2$-$($)#=-'#$#'#')'(";;=$%2$ $#'#')$-'(-%$-$%#%$('#>"&7 (
8 6
";):='#2')#$-$(#"##2$ -"#$ BD$-"))/, -,

#';;#2$%"#$ %$('#")%"

#$- %$('# #2$("'%",/)#8-$()%$)#((2";; -$6&";&/;"#$#2$:-"#/'#18 "1">;$##2$$#'#')$-)#2$>"('( ;"(#"1%-"=)>12',")%-$;$"($ #2$:-"#/'#1')"&&-%")&$='#2-/;$(=$9$-8' #2$$G&$(("1,$)#'( ";-$"%1,"%$##2$$#'#')$-8#2$(",$&")>$"%?/(#$%')#2$("'%",/)#

40 !

  
+
+ (?7( 2$#2$-($"7'):-$"()$% * $( 2$#2$- $-#">;$ * $(