Suman And ORS v. Hardeep Singh And ORS

 
     

 !"# $#%&'&()  * +,-!(!($".#/' 00#11!("' 2#/',' !/$##0+&(3.!($".#/' #'0($#("' 



 


/#'#(") /4&"+&.!35$6%!"# /".#!00#11!("' /+,7.!'.8!15$6%!"# //#'0($#(" 






.&' !00#!1 .!' 7##( &1#$ 78 ".# %1!&-!("' '##9&(3 #(.!(%#-#("   ".# %-0#('!"&( !:!/$#$ " ".#- 78 ".# 1#!/(#$ "/ %%&$#(" 1!&-' /&7,(!15 &'!/ ;/&7,(!1< / './" 6&$# !:!/$ $!"#$    ( !%%,("   $#!".   +!($##0 =,-!/ &( ! -"/ 6#.&%1# !%%&$#("(>  .#%1!&-!("'5 :. !/#".# :& #!($ 0!/#("' ".# $#%#!'#$5

&1#$ ! 0#"&"&( ,($#/ +#%"&( ??   ".# "/ 2#.&%1#' %" '##9&(3 %-0#('!"&( ( !%%,("   $#!".   +!($##0 =,-!/ $,# " &(4,/&#' /#%#&6#$ &( ! -"/ 6#.&%1# !%%&$#(" :.&%. "9 01!%# ( > 
  $!"#$> :!'/#3&'"#/#$,($#/+#%"&(' > 5  @!($ >  !" 1&%#+"!"&(+!$!/&'!/!3!&('"/#'0($#("":!'01#!$#$ ".!"".#$#%#!'#$!"".#"&-# .&'$#!".:!'!0!/"(#/&(!6#/(-#(" !00/6#$-0!(8,($#/".#(!-#!($'"81# A' /#-("/!%"/'!($ :!' !1' !( !3#("  /&8! /&6!/ # :!'  8#!/' 1$ !" ".# "&-#  !%%&$#("-0#('!"&(:!'".,'0/!8#$ /

 .#1#!/(#$/&7,(!1(%('&$#/!"&( !%"'!($#6&$#(%# (/#%/$.#1$".!"".#!%%&$#("&(B,#'"&("901!%#$,#"".#/!'.!($ (#31&3#(" $/&6&(3   ".# 

#($&(3 6#.&%1# 78 &"' $/&6#/ .#/# &' ( $&'0,"# /#3!/$&(3".#!76#'!&$ &($&(3 ".#1#!/(#$/&7,(!1(".&'&'',#5:.&%. .!'!""!&(#$ &(!1&"8 C#!/(#$/&7,(!1 ,/".#/%(%1,$#$".#$#%#!'#$"7# 8#!/' 1$!"".#"&-# .&'$#!".!($!''#''#$.&'!((,!1&(%-#!''

A@ 0#/-(".#$,%"&( A /$:!'#

#%"#$":!/$'".#0#/'(!1#D0#('#' 9##0&(3&(6&#:".#(,-7#/ $#0#($#("' "#/!0018&(3!-,1"&01&#/ *5 ""!1$#0#($#(%8:!'!''#''#$!"'5 A@',- 'A@#!%. :!'!:!/$#$":!/$' ,(#/!1#D0#('#'!($1'' #'"!"#(".#/',- ' 5A@:!'!:!/$#$":!/$'1'' 16#!($!

#%"&(.,'5%1!&-!("' :#/# .#1$ #("&"1#$ / ""!1 %-0#('!"&(   ' *5 A@5 /,($#$ 

 " ' *5A@!1(3:&".&("#/#'"E F0#/!((,- /-".#$!"# &1&(3 %1!&-0#"&"&("&11/#!1&'!"&( C#!/(#$%,('#1 /".#!00#11!("'!/3,#'".!"&"&'!-!""#/ /#%/$".!"&(%-#"!D/#",/(' /".#8#!/'  @ !($ @ D > !($ /#'0#%"&6#185:#/#0/6#$(/#%/$'0#/&(%-#"!D/#",/( / ".#8#!/  @ D >5&(%-# ".#$#%#!'#$:!''5 ?5**?A@!($ !' 0#/ &(%-# "!D /#",/( / ".# 8#!/ @  D 5 &(%-#   ".# $#%#!'#$ :!' '

A@ (%-# /- ".#/ ',/%#' :!' '

A@ C#!/(#$ /&7,(!1 .!' !''#''#$ ".# &(%-#   ".# $#%#!'#$ !" '

A@ /- ".#/ ',/%#' .!' /&3."18 7##( &3(/#$5 7," &( ".# !%"' !($ %&/%,-'"!(%#' ".#%!'#5&(%-# ".#$#%#!'#$'.,1$7#!''#''#$78 "!9&(3!(!6#/!3# 7".".#&(%-#"!D/#",/('5D >!($ (%/#!'#&( &(%-#(!%%,(" ,",/#0/'0#%"''.,1$7#!:!/$#$#!3/#!-,("

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

#($&(3 6#.&%1# 78 /#'0($#("  ' 0#/ &(%-# "!D /#",/(' / ".# 8#!/  @  !($ @  D >  5 &(%-#   ".# $#%#!'#$ :!' '5 ?5**?A@ !($ '

A@ /#'0#%"&6#18 /-".#/',/%#':!''

A@:#6#/51#!/(#$/&7,(!1.!' !''#''#$ ".# &(%-#   ".# $#%#!'#$ !" '

A@ (%-# /- ".#/ ',/%#'.!'/&3."18 7##(&3(/#$7,"&( ".# !%"'!($%&/%,-'"!(%#' %!'#5&"&'4,'"!($#D0#$&#(""!''#''".#&(%-# ".#$#%#!'#$78"!9&(3 !( !6#/!3#   7". ".# &(%-# "!D /#",/(' D > !($  (%-#   ".# $#%#!'#$ &' ".,' !''#''#$ !' '5 *A@ 0#/ !((,- ( 6&#:   ".# 3,&$#1&(#' 1!&$ $:( 78 ".# (<71# +,0/#-# ,/" &( !"&(!1 (',/!(%# -0!(8C"$2' /!(!8+#".&!($".#/'5 > &6&1 5 F &(%/#!'# &( &(%-# .!' " 7# !

/$#$ ( !%%,("  ,",/# 0/'0#%"' #$,%"&(   A /$ ":!/$' 0#/'(!1 #D0#('#' .!' /&3."18 7##( #

#%"#$ 9##0&(3&(6&#:".#(,-7#/ $#0#($#("',1"&01&#/ *.!'/&3."187##( !001&#$9##0&(3&(6&#:".#!3# ".#$#%#!'#$(6&#: ".#4,$3-#(" ".#(<71#+,0/#-#,/"&(!3-!#(#/!1(',/!(%#-0!(8C"$2'

 !(,!-!1&!'.,./,!-!($".#/'5&(&6&100#!1 * * $#%&$#$ ( *  *5 !00#11!("  &' #("&"1#$ " ' 5A@ ":!/$' '0,'!1 %('/"&,- &('"#!$   ' 5A@ !:!/$#$ / 1''   16# !($ !

#%"&( !($ %('/"&,- !($ !00#11!("'   !($  !/# #("&"1#$ " ' 5A@#!%.":!/$'1'' &1&!1%('/"&,-.#%1!&-!("'!/##("&"1#$ "'5A@ #!%. /1'' #'"!"#!($ ,(#/!1#D0#('#'&('"#!$  ' 5A@#!%.!1/#!$8!

/$#$":!/$' ,(#/!1#D0#('#'!($1'' #'"!"# 00#11!("'@%1!&-!("'!/#5".,'5 #("&"1#$"%-0#('!"&(5 :.&%. &'/#@:/9#$!',($#/)@
 

      '5 *A@0#/!((,-

 "!1&(%-#!

"#/!$$&"&(!"".# /!"# F(!%%,(" ,",/# 0/'0#%"' *G

?>5 *D F H5> 5>*A@  (%-#!

"#/$#$,%"&( A /$( !%%,(" 0#/'(!1#D0#('#' 5> 5>*I>5 5> 5>*A  H55 A@

 "!1$#0#($#(%8!

"#/!0018&(3! -,1"&01&#/ * 55 *H 5> 5

A@  C'' #'"!"# 5A@ ? C'' ,(#/!1 5A@ > C'' %('/"&,-":&$:!($ 0!/#("'E' 5A@#!%. 5A@

5D H5 5A@ 
 

A@ .#!-,(" %-0#('!"&(!1/#!$8!:!/$#$"".#!00#11!("'5 (##$1#''"'!85'.!11'"!($$#$,%"#$ /-".#!-,("%!1%,1!"#$!'!76# 00#11!("''.!117##("&"1#$"&("#/#'"!"".#/!"# >F0#/!((,-(".# #(.!(%#$!-,(" /-".#$!"# &1&(3 ".#0#"&"&("&11/#!1&J!"&(

 00/"&(-#("   !-,("   %-0#('!"&( !-(3'" %1!&-!("' '.!117#&(".#'!-#/!"&!' &D#$78".#1#!/(#$/&7,(!1&/#%"&(' /&7,(!1 &( /#'0#%" " -!((#/   $&'7,/'#-#("   %-0#('!"&( !-,(" " ".#%1!&-!("''.!11#(,/# K&".".#!76#'!&$-$& &%!"&(&(".#!:!/$$!"#$  5 0/#'#("!00#!1&'$&'0'#$ 




  %"7#/ 5 * '.:!/ K.#".#/'0#!9&(3A/#!'(#$)@ #'A K.#".#//#0/"!71#)@ #'A