High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5989/2016allowed

Gurdeep Singh And ANR v. Financial Commissioner Appeals - 1 Punjab Chandigarh And ORS

2023-05-08Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj5 pages

!"#$!%&'&"( ) )

FINANCIAL COMMISSIONMER APPEALS-1 PUNJAB CHANDIGARH AND OTHERS * +,*)- .

-) /////

! !" "#"$ %& '" ( ) " * $$ +( , ----- .

-)0)1234 ". &" //!" 010023 45+

16 ,) " 7 & / 8** / +( ,$ 8" ! " 2091:020 % ."&" " % '/ ,) 3 9 ! " ;2002045+

<6 " 01009" , //. ."+ '' ! )+)'" !"

& " "

,+ 20021 % !"$ %& "

&," /''

3909021 "

+!"*'//)"* . " ' (+ /)+*+ "&+/ ! ," /''" $".%$&" 210202;$

-2- =+* > " $ %& '/ " . ' ) ," /'' 39 +!"*'//)."&". ! " '$%" &+/ !"* %+ //)$ " '& ' " . +&# ' % 0100 " * . (+ 0030 ' '+" &

/& ' & //!" 0100 ! #!' '&" ,*% )" & ," /' ' 3 9 " &! " * / " ) 021$ '+" . .+/ , (+' " . "&" * < 8+/ ' " & " " + " & " &'" ' . !"."

2000+ ;3'%// ! /. ? #" $"/ ? / $ & + + . " & '

" !" 4,"' . !"6. & "

" !". ' "' 39"",(& " &' *+ ' %+'

" !""!"' +! >//

2;2000$% ."&"" ' . !""

%/% + " .// @

" !""5'" /' " ."/ 39"

,% .""* !" /' " " ' *+ ,!& $" 8//&$ $' " * <" 8//&$2 $? / 3 " !,"" $ 8//&7 $ & "*+ ">// 2;2000%

-3- 01009 1 !!% ,)" $" 39" ' /,'"8//& ;0;00;$" /. //. " '" 8//&$2

01009. +/ /)$".& '/ %+ / 10'00;,'"

/8** 4 /6$A / " %$A / " " /. && ,) "8** "*+ . , & *' ">// 2;2000 9 " * *$

" !" 4. & 6 ' " ' 3 9 "

/ ' 8%/ + 13< ' 00 ' * (+& ! "" //!!" "" ") +'* . !",!","" ". ' " ,% +."&". +/)& "!"'" ,%>// 2;2000 + 2. ' * "'//.!''&

B2C>"" . !"" 5&+ /! / % / >//

2;2000' %+' ' D (+ !* & 03202$ " 8%/ A+ ! 4A+%6 & " ,% +' %+'" " " >// 2;20 00 . +&&'+//) ,/" " ,+ ''. "+ &" ! ,)"" ;

." !" ' &" %!, ,)" 8%/ 8+$ " ' ,' " 7 & / 8**$ / +( ,, ! 2091:020" . //. % 010023."+ '' ! )+)

-4- '" !" 20 E &+/ !," /''"& " &2146'" +( ,E %+&$29$ /& ,/ " ' +( ,$* " ' ) ,)"+, +",% * ' )& ! ,' " 7 & / 8** / 2$ " * " // , & + ."+! ! +)'" !"." /#/) , ''& & " + /'"*+! 5+

29' /*" )&. %+ " "+ % " " ,)" +, +"+"/ ! " *+ , & " , ' " +! >// 2;2000."&"" /,%,'"8%/8+" , //! / * ."+ "! " % ' "

+ (,E %+&$29 /& ,/" ' +( , 22

" % " / &+/ ! ," /' ' " " % ! "+!" " &+* % / ,/ & + / ' " *+! 5+

29 ". " " %* & " F+ +! & " 7+"$"%&' / " " " % / &" ,' " 8+ &" +8F+/)$" //! /%/ " * +&% "8+"+" ,+&* &&/+" 7 & /8** / 2"

+ )&" " "*+! F+ . ."+ '' ! )+)'" !" " &'" &/ /)%/ '"&/'

-5- + /(+& &2146'" +( ,E %+&$29 /& ,/" ' +( , 2 >"+ &**! '+" * !! " &%)%/% "& )'+"$". //. " 010023 ,) " 7 & / 8** / +( , 2091:020 / B * /

!" "%++ !" "C "* * " 7 & / 8** / +( , ' '"

(+ & ' ! ! +) ' " ! " && 2 E " & , / ,' 7 & / 8** / +( , ) )."+"7 & /8**

/ 2" //'+"& "* '" ". //. 1.

-)4 * 0 >"" #!: G:

>"" ,/