High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8071/2014dismissed

Raj Kumari & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli16 pages

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -1-

!"#$%

"&"'

!"#% ()* +,-&)+.+"!*/

(*+* +2+"++"!*/

3"!

"* 4# 564 ( 1(- 7 ( 564 (

"*#8 4 )+"*(+."7! '+* 7*/

4"9&4.**+:7!!:! '+* +:7+2+"+;.*/ 4(+&+</4+=7

*! '+* +:+2+"+7+"! -& /+:!

3-4+"'/+"!+

3"!

"* +"! 4 +)6+:+!+ 7! '+* 7 469

/(."/+:7! '+* 7

3"!

"*%8( / ."

*+"* 3 *.*." /+ <

" .:

! ':+.)."= */+* */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

'+.

!&* .!

"*..'+*."

!&"!

( '*." ?@ */ 6+"! '>&.

.*." '*7 $ !+* ! AA +"! @@

'*.

:2B::;

!<2*/ +;+!!+* !7*/

<2+'>&.."= :+"!+3&<:.'3&3

7"+) :2*/ !

"*( '* A$ +"! @ C

"*.+:D (".3+* ." */

*+* .::+=

+"=+: -+:+"7* "++"!(

+7 / .:+"!.

*.'*("

3+*B>&+*/ :+"!*/

/+ :+3

!." .

;*/ 3 .

( '*." CD*/

.=/* * +. )3 +*." +"! +"

3+ "'2 ." 6+"! '>&.

.*."

/+<.:.*+*."+"!

**:

"*'*%C /*7E*/ '*%FD ;."=**/ '"*

2 &3* !+ =+!

."* *+*." 3 .

."( '*." CD*/ '*%7:.9 )+"2*/ ;.* 7*/ 3'

."*/ ."

*+"*3 *.*.";

9 3*."+< 2+"'

+;+.*."=*/ !

."*/ (&3 &*/ '"*

2;+ ."+::2 3&* +*

* <2 */ "

*.*&*." "'/ */ (&3 &* ."

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -2-

"&:*.)+* 3++=+3/;/.'/.

3!&'

."< :;#8 "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2

& % & % / 9 & - &

& * (% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * ( ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & &2 &,

& '(% & % *

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -3- ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1 % / &)+"! &< *+"'

*/ ."* *+*."( '*." CD*/ '*%<2*/ (&3 &*.

*/+**/ .

*+"! ) *'"!.*." *

9 :+3 ."= .

*/+* <*/ */ '"*."= "'.

3 .!

! . 7 +<&* */ 3/2 .'+:3

."+"!*/ 3+2) "*')3 +*."+ *< &:.::

!7 +"."=*/

<27. .*/ */ '"!.*."

"* +*.

!7*/

;&:! < ":+3 ."= ++ <:.=+*."*)+9 3+2) "*.":.

&*/ :+"!+'>&.

'"'

!7.*/+

"':+..

!*/+* &'/<:.=+*."* 3+2.

')3:

<2* "!

."=*/ ')3 +*.";/.'/;&:!) +"*/+* ')3 +*."+)&"*;+ )+!

+ +.:+<:

**/ :+"!;"

+"!./ /+ "*+''

3* !*/ +) 7.*;.::"*< + +.:+<:

*/ :+"!;"

* ':+.) */+* */ ')3 +*." /+ "* <

" 3+.! (.).:+:27 */ ;!

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -4G! 3 .*H/+

"."* !*) +"!

3 .*."=;.*/*/ 6*/ + &2 */

&* +;."= 3+"'/"+)+ /+ <

" '"

!*< + +:.!3*+9."=3/2 .'+:3

."+"!"'

:+"! *+"!

! ." */ (*+* 7 */

" !.

*."= 3 .!

! &"!

( '*." CD*/ '*%/ (&3 &*/+ &*/ ':+..

*/+* */ 3 .! ;/.'/ +"2 ."* .) !

;+ ." 3 +*."7 ;.:: <

I':&!

!;/.:

')3&*."=*/ =+33 .!.

2 + (.).:+:27.*/+ <

"':+..

!*/+*( '*." CD*/ '*%!

"*=.

* +"

;'+&

+'*."*>&

*."*/ :

=+:.*2'"':&!

!3'

:+"! +'>&.

.*." + .* +33:.

* ":2 */

." */ 3'

;

"!."="*/ !+* "'

"**/ '*%

3&**/<2*/

7*/ 2;"+=.'&:*&+: :+"! ) + &."= % -+"+: 4+:+ ')3.

! ." -/+ + @JJJ C8$D7 J C%8@D7 J C@8 D +"! J C%8D ." 1.::+= +"=+: -+:+"7 / .: +. +"! .

*.'* ("

3+* / (*+* ") "* " AA

!"*..'+*."&"!

( '*." */ 6+"!'>&.

.*."'*$ +'>&.."= */ :+"! ) + &."= -+"+: % 4+:+ ." .::+=

+"=+: -+:+"7* "++"!(

+7.

*.'*("

3+**/ 3&<:.'3&3

"+) :27 !

"* ( '* A$ +"! @ C

"*.+:D7 ("

3+* / +.! "*..'+*."+:

."':&!

!*/ :+"!.">&

*." &+"***/ +) 7*/ (*+* ") "*.

':++*."&"!

( '*."@*/ '*$ +'>&.."=*/ :+"!) + &."=@A$-+"+:."1.::+= +"=+:-+:+"7 * "+ +"! (

+7 .

*.'* ("

3+* +

! ." */ 3 *.*." + )+, 3*." + + ;+ :

! ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

&+"'

':++*."&"!

( '*."@*/ '*$ /

+* 7 ") "*.

!+"*..'+*."&"!

( '*." */ '* $

<2 ;.*/!+;."= */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

>&+ */ :+"!

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -5- + &."=A%-+"+: 4+:++"!&:*.)+* :27+;+!;+ +""&"'

":2+"+ +) + &."= $-+"+:4+:+." .::+= +"=+:-+:+" 3 3

7 */ )+,.*2 :+"! . A% -+"+: 4+:+

*+"!

! ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

+"! )+, 3*."

!+ +) 3+*.*2+*-&"!:. A * +""&"'

"* +;+!7 "*2 ;+ )+!

." */ +3+*

K"+)'/+7 /;

7 */ 3

/+ *+."

! */ +'*&+: 3/2 .'+: 3

."*/ :+"!

"+* +""&"'

"*+;+!;/.'/+'* "* ) */ '3 *+"!."= " */ :+"! ." >&

*." + .

!)*/ -/+ +.!+;.

*/+* 2 /+ <

" !.

'.)."+* ! + )+,.*2 3*." :+"! ;+ :

)*/ .*."3'

+*!.

"* *+=

+"!+ +'"

7 */ 3&<:.' 3&3

&=/* * < +'/.

! <2 */ (*+* /+ & *+* !*.

&*/ '+

*/+*

"*/ +)&"* ')3 +*." /+ +:

"* <

" 3+.! * */ ) +'>&.

! :+"! +"! .*/ +) /+

3 .* !;.*/*/

&*/

7+ +'"

'*& +) "+''&"*&:.::) "*<*/*/ '"*."= "'.

"*."

! ." ( '*." CD */ '* %7 */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

>&+*/ :+"!.">&

*."/+ :+3

! @

'"*+ 4 "9& 4.**+:7 :

! '&"

: +33 +."= */

3"!

"* 7 &<).** !*/+* */ +'* "++* !<2 */ 3

! "*

+:+'*&+:+'*&+:3 .*."*/ '+

+*/+"! /+ '"* "!

!*/+* <2.

&."="*..'+*."&"!

( '*." */ '*$ "AA7 ") "*."* "!

!*+'>&.

:+"!) + &."=A+'

9+"+: % )+:+ .::+=

+"=:+ -+:+"7 * "+ +"! (

+7 / .: +"! .

*.'*(".3+** '"

."=*/ ')) "!+*."

6+"!*/ < .'.+2 !

3+*) "* . (7 */ (*+* ") "* .

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -6- !

':++*." &"!

( '*." @ */ '* $ +'>&.."= */ :+"! + &."= +'

A9+"+: .::+= +"=+:-+:+"7* "++"!(

+7 / .:+"!.

*.'*(".3+*(."'

3+*) "*;"+"!&"*2

:+""."=/+!=+"* !:.'

** ."* "*

**."=&3

"*.+: ':".

&"!

+2+"+

"*+"!

=&:+*." <+" + '*7 $A +"! >&

;

! :

:+"! ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

7 ( +"! (*+* ") "* !

'.!

! *

@ +'

A 9+"+: @ )+:+ :+"! +"! !

." ;+ *+9 " * +""&"'

+;+!*/ )+."."=:+"! &*/ !

.";+ +:

*+9 "*;.*/!+;)*/ .*."3'

:+"!) + &."= $ +'

9+"+:)+:++::."=&"!

"& + *+ 7;/.'/;+ "&

**/ (+"!+''!."=:27"*..'+*."&"!

( '*." */ '* $ ;+

!*/

<2;.*/!+;."=*/ .*."3'

:+"!) + &."=@A%+'

@9+"+: )+:++"!+;+!;+ +""&"'

)+."."=:+"!"/ 3

."*/ !:+"! ;+ *+9 " .!

+3+*$!+* !+"!;+ /+"!

! * ( <2 67 (".3+* =+!

*+*& ')3 +*." /

&<).** ! */+* "*.

+;+! )"

2 */ +'>&.

! :+"! .

A7%7@A7A%J8;+ !

3 .* !."*/ +''&"*6<2( .!

) )!+* !AJ@+"!$/& 7*/ +)&"* ')3 +*." ;+ !&:2 * "!

! +"! .

*.:: + +.:+<:

B /;

7 */

""** +) /& 7." .

; */ :+; :+.! !;" <2 */ (&3 &* ." */ '+

"* &*/.*2 C &3+D7 ""

*/ '"*."= "'.

3 .!

! ." ( '*." CD*/ '*%+ &:.::

!+ 3

."*/ :+"!

*+"!

!&:2 *+9 " +"! */ ')3 +*." +)&"* *+"!

!&:2 * "!

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -7- +''!."=:27"!

':++*.":+3 ."=*/ .*."3'

'+" < )+!

=+!

+ !.

'.)."+*."7 4 4.**+: /+ '"* "!

*/+**/ !.

'.)."+*.".

."=':+.) !<2*/

"+''&"*

:+"!)+!

&"!

( '*." */ '*$ "@ *.

+)+** +'**/+**/

/+ "

.*/ '/+::

"= !*/ +;+! "*/ "*..'+*.".

!&"!

( '*." */ '*$ .:."=*/ ."

*+"*;.*3 *.*."/.

+:2.)3:.

*/+**/

!**/ .*."3'

&"!

*+9 "<2*/ ") "*+"!+ ":2*2."=*+9 &3*/

&"!

=+< ( '*." CD*/ '*%."!

*."&

:. ."*/ !

+!'+&

+'*." &<).* */+* &'/ 3:

+ ;&:! "* ":2 < /.* ;.*/ */ 3."'.3:

H<&*+:

;/.'/) +"

=. ."=*+'.*+

"**+'**/

/+ &*/ +=& */+**/ +'>&.

.*&+::2 !

*2 .=/* +''& !."+ &

) "

<2;+2)+."*+."."= .:

7.*')

."*3:+2;/ "+3+*2 /+ ."= + .=/* *+"!

<2 +"!

+"*/ !

+:."= ." + )+""

."'"

"*;.*/*/+*.=/*7;/.:

+'*.

."3=

+"!+* .:+*." ')3:

!7;/.'/'"!&'* :

'* /.

"*+''!+"!/ '+""* +* ;+!

')3:+." /

":2 "

3*." * +33:.'+*." */ !'*."

+'>&.

;/.'/;.::') ."*3:+27.*/ :+3

*.) ".)3*+"'

>& ++ '+

:+"!+'>&.

.*.".

'"'

!7 */ !'*."

) .="..'+"'

'.+::2 +* :+"!/+ ."=<

!."*/ 7+ +"23:

+< ."=+.

!+=+."

**/ +'>&.

.*."+**/ ."

*+"'

:+"!;"

;.::/+ *'

/&!:

*/ 3++)

;/.'/+ ) *."= "* */+"*/ G

H7+ .*!

*2 "*":2*/ !2<&*+:

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -8- .=/* /+ &*/ +=& !*/+**/& ."+'+

'/+::

"= **/ :+"!+'>&.

.*."7*/ '"

"* .

;*/.

&*+ ;

::+ (&3 &* .

*/+* . ) "

+==.

! ;.*/ */ +'*." */ (*+* 7 /

*+ +.:/.

!2+**/ .

*."

*+"'

+"!'+""*< +::;

!* .* "*/ +"!*,&)3."*/ .

:!+*+:+* *+=

."=*/

&:*." + &+ .).:+:2 .*&+* !3

" /+ &*/ +=& !*/+**/& 7*/

**:

!:+; ."*/.

=+! .

*/+* . + :+"! ;"

+==.

!;.*/ */ +'*."*/ "+"2+''&"*."':&!."=!

3. +*."/.

=+: .=/* +"! +:

+"2 3'

!&+: .

=&:+.*2 . 7 +"2 !

'* ." */ "*..'+*.".

!7"33 / +."=*/ <, '*.".:

!&"!

( '*." A*/ '* *'7+.=/*+''&

."/.

+ &*." 9 ,&.

!.'*." */.

&*7<&*./ )+."*+."

+"!+::;

* /+33 "+**/ ."

*+"'

*/ 7+"23:

+ &'/:+"!;"

9 >&.*+<:

;.::/+ *'

/&!:

"*":2*/ !'*."

:+2 +"! :+'/

<&* +:

*/ !'*."

+'>&.

;/.'/ .

&.'.

"* * !

*2 */ .=/* /+ :.

! &3" */ "* ,&!.'.+: 3"&"'

"* */ (&3 &* ." */ '+

*.*:

! + =0

>3% ?? +

7 /* % @ !

'.!

! " @ ;/

." ;/.:

:.< +*."= &3"*/ !.

*."'*."< *;

"G H+"!G H.* /+

"/ :!*/+* !

*2*/ !2<&* .*&+::2 !

*2 .=/* */

'+"< .*/ !.

'* ;.*/&::9";:

!= +"! I3

+33<+*."7."!.

'*;/

" /+ ."=*/ .=/*7

+"*/ !

+:."=."+)+""

."'"

"*;.*/*/+* .=/*+"!."

3.* */ +::

= !."."= "*7*+9

"+'*."B).."= +''

3*+"'

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -9- 33:2."=*/ +.!3."'.3:

:+;"**/ +'*&+:)+*.I*/ ."

*+"*'+

7/ /+ +=& !*/+**/

"*3 *.*."/+

".:

!<2*/

."*/ 2 +

9."= :.

&"!

( '*." CD*/ '*%7;/

+ 7*/ +'*."<2;/.'/*/

+ +==.

*/ 2 + / +333.+* *.) '/+::

"=."= */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

;+ .*/ +* !

':++*.";+

!&"!

( '*."@ */ '* $ .)) !.+* :2 +* +""&"'

"* +;+! ;

7*/

+.:

!*+ +.:*/ . !.

+"!";+* +'>&.

.*."3'

/+ +**+."

!."+:.*2+"!*/ :+"! *+"!

." */ (*+*

) +:: "'&)<+"'

7 / &<).* */+* */ ."

*+"* *.*.".

"*)+."*+."+<:

<2 .*& !'*."

G+'>&.

H /+ 3:+'

:.+"'

"*/ ,&!=) "* 3+

!."*/ '+

% A % :

::B 7 A ?) , *

*B ;

C '(

% D B

%07 E !'

(

9 $ /+ &*/ +=& ! */+*

" */ ;.

+ ':+..

! <2 */ (&3 &*.""!

"*&*/.*2C &3+D7( '*." CD */ '*%!

"*=.

/'+&

+'*."+"!.

+ +.:+<:

*< ." 9 !":2."

'**/ '+

."*/ 3'

;

"!."=+ "*/ !+* ')."=."**/ '**/ '*%/& 7 .+"2:+"!;"

*." 9 3 .

( '*." CD '*%7*/ +) '+"":2< '"."

!*!

*+* */+**/ +'>&.

.*."3'

/+ :+3

!+"!.*!

"* "*.*:

:+"!;"

* *+9 &3 +"2 */ 3:

+ ."':&!."= 3'

!&+: .

=&:+.*27 !.

'.)."+*."73+.*2 *'7+ ).**."=*/ +) ;&:!) +"."* ."= ."*/

**:

!')3 *."=.=/* */ 3+*.

+"! .*&+::2;.::+ '**/

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -10- :+= 3&<:.' ."*

* +"! .

<&"! *

&:* ." */ :

* */ 3&<:.'

I'/ >& /& 7 + *.'* !&*2 :.

" */ /&:!

*/ &* *

)+."* "+"'

*/ &3 )+'23&<:.'."*

* 3. +* ."*

*;/ "+'":.'*+.

"*; " ) .* / /+ &<).** ! */+* */ !

." */ (*+* ") "* * ;.*/!+; ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

'+""* < !&<* !"!3+/+*/ !

."*+9 "<2*/ ;.*/!+;."= .*."3'

;+ +'"

'.& !

."/ !

"* 3'

." :

+.& *+9 /:!

+"! */ =+"* :.'

<2 */ (*+*

**."=&3

"*.+:':"2.

=+:3'

+ 3 .!

&"!

+2+"+

=&:+*."+"!

"* <+" + '*7$A /&=/*/

"<+

"."+'>&.."= &'/:+"!;/.'/:.'

**."=&3*/ ':"2/+

"=+"* !<2*/ 7/;

+**/ +) *.) ." .

; */ ."* =+* ! !

"* */ (*+* ") "* .

;.*/." & '"

:+; * *+9 + '"

'.& !

." I )3*."= *+." :+"! ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

;.*/&* + '*."= */ &:*.)+* 3&<:.' 3&3

&=/* * < +'/.

! /

7 */ !

." *+9 " <2 */ (*+* ") "* * ;.*/!+; ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

>&+ '

*+." 3+'

:+"! +* '"

."= */

')) "!+*."

67( *'7.

+ +:.!!

." + ."= / +! */

'*.

+=&) "* 7 =."= */&=/ */

'*.

+!."= +"!+< +::*/ I3 .*.""!

"* &*/.*2 C &3+D7 ;

+ */ '"

! 3."." */+* */ ."

*+"* *.*.".

:.+<:

*< !.

!) */+""

+ " / 3

." */ ."

*+"* 3 *.*." /+ ':+.) ! * < ." */ 3/2 .'+:3

."*/ :+"!.">&

*." .*.

*&3<2*/ )

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -11- */+*

"*/&=/*/ +;+!;+ 3+

!"+"!*/ 2!.!"* '/+::

"= .*."3'

<&**/ 3/2 .'+:3

."/+ "* <

" *+9 " ) */ ) " */.

=+!7 */

3"!

"* /+ .:

! */ ;.** " *+* "* &<).**."= */+* 3

." ;+ *+9 " <2 !+;."= 3+"'/"+)+ ." */ ) +3+* K"+)'/+ $!+* ! ;/.'//+

"/ :!+ + +:.!)!

*+9."=3

."*/ :+"! ( '*."@*/ '*$ 3 .!

*/+*+* *+9."=*/ 3

." :+"!7.*

."*/

)+:: "'&)<+"'

." */.

=+!.

)+!

**/ ::;."=3++=+3/ )*/ ,&!=) "*#8

! " ! #

$ %

! #

$ &'( %

* % '( +,* -

$ %

% % '(

! "*

/ % !

# ! )

$ %

! 0)

% % ! % "$

%%& +) )&

& % / + - 3,

& % 03,

& % * )

3, & % C

A &2 )

% 3, + 3,

& % < ,&3%

))&&2+ A

&%& &

- % %)& -&2 #

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -12-

! " ! %$

$ !

) * $ 1

* *

)

% ! % # !" /& 7;

+ */ '"

!3."."*/+**/ 3/2 .'+:3

." */ :+"! ." >&

*." *+"!

!&:2 *+9 " +"! */& 7 */ 3:

+ */

< ."= ." 3/2 .'+: 3

." */ :+"! ." >&

*." .

;/::2).

8'"'

!+"!.

:.+<:

*< , '* !

# # $ % $ /

3"!

"* /+ '+* =.'+::2 3:

! ." */ ;.** "

*+* "**/+**/ +)&"*')3 +*."*/ "*.

!:+"! ;+ )+!

+ +.:+<:

*+::*/ :+"!;"

*+"!*/ */+* +)&"* ')3 +*." + =+!

:+"! ." >&

*." ;+ !&:2 "!

! +"! .

:2."= !

3 .* ! ." */ +''&"* 6+"! '>&.

.*." ::

'* /

7 ." .

; */ I3 .*." ." "!

"* &*/.*2C &3+D*/ <:.=+*."*/ *3+2*/ ')3 +*.".

'/+= ! . */ +)&"* ')3 +*." .

* "!

! ;/.'/ /+ <

" ."* ! * ) +" */+* */ +)&"* ;+ )+!

+ +.:+<:

* */ :+"! ;"

+ <

!." ++%;/.'/.

3!&'

."< :;#8 2+, ) % ,'(

! -

3 4

% 4

D) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, .

* !

,,,'% !

! % 5

! $

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -13-

% * "$

(

# * "$ *

0 ,* %

+ +, ,

+ +,%

7 8 %

-$ ,'(*

! D) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 6

7 8 "

, 9 %* $

5 /

7*/ '"* "*."*/

*/+*"')3 +*." +)&"* /+ <

" ! <2 */ ) .

) .*:

+"! */& 7 .

, '* ! $$& '()'* '+!"$ A / (&3 &*.""!

"*&*/.*2C &3+D/+ ':

+:2 <

! */+* !

! :+3 ."= +'>&.

.*." 3'

&"!

( '*." CD*/ '*%7<*/*/ '"!.*."

. 3+2) "* ')3 +*." +"! *+9."= 3

." )& * "* < &:.::

! . .

.*/ */ '"!.*." .

&:.::

!7 */ :+3 ."= '+""* /+33 " / (&3 &*/+ <

!*/+**/ ;!GH''&."=."( '*." CD*/ '*%)& *< +!+ G+"!J"H

+"*3++ )*/ ,&!=) "*+ 3!&'

."< :;#8 2

. 8 %* $

% '(* % $

! !) * *

* $ %

% +,

% $

) * %

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -14-

% $ ! *

! ---- ---- ---- ---- + . :;

) < . = &&* 8

> !

% $ * -

! ?

! .

@ ',(.

* !. *3 3 3 33 3 .

=- 4 $ % 3 3 $ 3 $ % '

(% *

! %% 3 .

* 3) -

! -$

! $

6.)9673 *%

3 *33 3 .* * ! * % $ % * % !

!$ .

! - $ *+++ !

'(.*

%* $ *

! ) % 3 3! %

% %

%$ ) $

. !

! % ! !

- 7 *+++5 '0( )

@ .

! $ A .

)

! !

)

( 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

#1 @ "*/ '+

+*/+"!+ :

'* !)*/ 3:2.:

!7.*.

"* */+* +* +;+! ;+ +""&"'

! " 7 */ 3/2 .'+: 3

." ;+ *+9 " <2 '!."= +3+* K"+)'/+ $ !+* +"!*/ ')3 +*."+)&"*;+ !&:2* "!

!(."'

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -15- */ '"!.*."

'.< ! ." ( '*." CD */ '* % + &:.::

!7*/

7 +.!3 .

."'+""*< :.

!&3"<2*/

*':+.):+3 ."=*/ .*."3'

17.

4 "9& 4.**+:7 " */ "=*/ */ +'* 3:

! ." */ ;.** " *+* "*7/+ / "*:2'"* "!

!*/+**/ !*/ :+"!*/ 3&<:.'3&3

"+) :2!

"*( '* A$+"!@ C(".3+*D / :+"! ." >&

*." .

2 )&'/

"*.+: * +'/.

3&<:.'3&3

+ +) *< 3:+""

!+"!!

:3 !."+''!+"'

;.*/*/ :+2&*3:+" /+ '"

!*/.

3+*+=&) "*+.

!<2

3"!

"* +"!;

+ ."')3:

"*;.*/*/ +) + */.

+" .)3*+"* +'* * < 9 3* ." )."! ;/.:

+:."= ;.*/ */ '+

."=&**/ .*.":+"!*+'/.

3&<:.'3&3

+"!.* (*+* J.* +&*/.*2 ;/ .

." */ <

* 3 .*." * !

'.!

+<&* &*.:.K+*."*/ :+"!+'>&.

!7+* .*/+ ."=<

!."(*+* 18.

=+!

+ !.

'.)."+*." < ."= +.

! <2 */

+**/.

*+= 7;

+ "*."':."

!*+''

3**/ &<).

+ ." */ '+

."= &* :+"! +'>&.

.*."7 */ '"'

3* "

=+*."= + '/+::

"= " +''&"* */ !'*."

:+2 +"! :+'/

;

:: +'9";:

!= !*+

) .="..'+"'

;/ "*/ 3:

:+2+"! :+'/

*+9 "+=+."

**/ :+"!;"

*."=/+ *+9 "3:+'

." + &*/ *.

;

::+'9";:

!= !3."'.3:

:+;*/+*."!

* 3:

+! ."."= "* * ':+.) >&.*+<:

7 */ :.*.=+"* ;/ '/

* +33+'/ */ &* )& * "* /; :+'9+!+.

.'+: +**.*&!

"!&<* !:2*/ '"'

3*!'*."

+'>&.

")&'//.=/ *."=;/.'//+

"'"

!*< &.'.

"**

*2*/ .=/* + ."+=

"*;.*/*/ +=&) "**/ */+**/ :+"!

CWP No. 8071 of 2014 -16- ;"

"* "*.*:

!*+.

+!.

'.)."+*."7"+''&"* !

." */ (*+* ") "* * ;.*/!+; ) */ +'>&.

.*." 3'

7+*+< :+* *+= 7+ !'*."

+'>&.

;.::') ."*3:+2;/.'/.

&.'.

"***+9 +;+2*/+*.=/*"2 &'/< :+* 3:

+ )& * < , '* ! +* */

/:! &*/ 7 ;

! "* ."! +"2

"*!.

'.)."+*."+ !

."*+9 "<2*/ .":."

;.*/ '"'

3*."* =+* !!

"*+"!*/

/+ +.:

!* +

" + ."=:

;! + * /; */ 2 + .).:+:2 .*&+* ! * */

:+"!;+ :

*&*)*/ .*."3'

19.

>& : */ +< !.

." +"! ." .

; */ :+;

&))+.K ! ." 3++ %@% "!

"* &*/.*2 C &3+D7

'..'+::2+* /+ ."= '!

!*/+*."*/ '+

+*/+"!7*/ 3/2 .'+: 3

."*/ :+"!.">&

*."/+ ."=<

"*+9 "7*/ <:.=+*." 3+2) "*')3 +*."!.

'/+= !+"!+:

."=*/+**/ :+"! .">&

*.".

2)&'/

"*.+:*+'/.

3&<:.'3&3

/+ " /

.*+*." * /:! */+* ." */ ."

*+"* '+

7 */ (*+* /+ &::2 !.

'/+= !.* <:.=+*.">&+<*/*/ '"*."= "'.

''&."=."( '*." CD*/ '*%+"!.*< ."= 7*/ ."

*+"*3 *.*.".

! + ."= !.

! */ )+." ;.* 3 *.*."7 3 "!."= +33:.'+*."7 . +"27+:

)

+) +* (*+*& >&7.+"27 *+"!

+'+* ! C 1(- D ( C

66D % "!, / +9."=J + "

J / 3*+<: