High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/662/2009dismissed

Panchayat Balmik/Janj Barat Ghar And ORS. v. Ashiq And ORS.

2019-09-24Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

! "#$ %&'$ ()$*+ ,-($ "

...**$"

/$ "+"

"0" (+1"2"-($ "

...$"*(-$"

!-31 1 4 ...**$"

/$ "+"

"0" (+1"2"-($ "

...$"*(-$"

#$(5#$"(67.. $"$6

., &-8($ 5( $**$".

..9. ( &-8($ 5( $"*(-$3(..

::::

"( -$ &;"-"*("$(5%(".$.

5$-(4$5(5**$".

$5 "$-& 5" (5 $ "$ $ *55 ! "#$ <&'$ ()$*+ ,-" $"-$2&$ $ "0&/$ $"-$ & ($ $ &,"$ + & $4$ " & "&

"" - - 4 (+1 "+ 5( *(""$""( - -1$"$"$* (5 $"*$(5 ! "&#$ <&'$ ()$*+ ,1"-$5$-".$."0 " & 9 & 4+ 2 - 44& "(" (5 4& $"-$"(5$ 4".

" *$ $ 8$ "( (5 $ *55" " $$"" 5( (" +((5 ! $ $%"4$15$"$ (1& 8 - - (1 ( + 4 $ =$ ( - >+ $ "(%$-4? 1% $( ?1((%"$54 $+( $"5( (" +((5 ! @"$*%"1( "($-5 ( +*,($$'$4 + AB4+-+$( (55+-"$(" +((+-(4$" $-.?(%$8$ &$ $"-$"(5$ $($$-5+-"-1($*5$-%$ @ $$ CA&9 -$5$-- "$--"*+$ $$1 $-"5$4$ "%(+- "$(" +(($"$ $ 5( (" +( (5 ! & $ $5( $ $$1 (5 $"-$"(5"#$ %%"$-(..CA%$ "-9 %""(* $"$.;%"1 $$-((" +(%(+-

4$ "$- 4 "- 9 - " 5 $4$ " $ "$@ $"(+(%""(*""$-$ $1"$ (5&%%" "1$- 4 9 D -$5$- 3(.@ -$"*$ 9 - ($ -$5$-" 4 (+1 4 " - ($ 4+-1 $ $ $ -"*+$- "$ 5( "1 (" +(& (%$8$ & $"-$" (5 $ (&$&!+41&E$ &2&1 $.5$- ,8 + 4$ 1 3(.BB.. 5( 1 (5 *$ $ +(1"$-$5$-"&%%"-$-$-58(+ (5$ *55"@$-$5$-"$ $-5$-**$1"

+-1$ - -$ $$@ -+ 1 *$-$ (5 **$& "$+ * ($$-1" +-$ $(" AB , ..,. - +-$ $(" 7B7, ..,.%$ $$-@# , &'$ ()$*+ *""$-$1 ( -$ (7.B.A5( -$8$ 1*(""$""((5$-"*+$-* (*$ (-$5$-3(.&%-$5$-3(.-($ -$5$-" $++( )$-*(""$""((5$* (*$ &%$ $4$ (8$-*$"$* (5($+$(5".&*$ ( 5 (B.B.A-$.

4$1*+(($&$-$5$-"**$ $--5$- % $"$$($"1$"+($-1*55"8$ ( 1( ($ %$"+* (*$ @5-$5$-3(." *(""$""((5"* (*$ 81" $"-$(+"$$ $&%$ $ $"*+1+*(1%"5$4$ "5( "$ "@ $ $ $*(%"*(""$""((55$ (5"%$ 1-$5$-"

7 5( $ " 4(+ 7 $ " 81 4$$ *+ "$- 4 ( ..5( "+(5".C&5 (? 41% $( ?1 (( - 5$ " -$ $ "%$ 1 -$5$-" $ *(""$""($ $(5-$(" +$-%( $"-$ (("(8$ $*(.#$1$ $1$1("&$-$5$-"* $- 5( -"""(5$"+.

E$ *55" - 5$- $*( ( $ % $ "$$ ( (8$ 1 $ $1(" $ % $ "$$ %$ $" $$ 1$8$ $"$*.

$*$-1"(5$* $"&5((%1""+$"%$ $ 5 $-6 . <$$ $ *55 " $$- ( $$5 (5 *(""$""( " * $-5( F .

. <$$ $*55"$$-($-1$"( $"$* (5 "* $-5( F .

. <$$ $*55"(+"$(5(F .

7. <$$ $"+"4 $-4(F #.

B. <$$ $"+"4-5( "

(-$ (5$$"" * $"F

. <$$ $"+"(* (*$ 8+$-5( $*+ *("$(5 ,(+ 5$$- + "-(F .

A. $$5.

;( -$ (* (8$$ "$&$*55"-$G$-

B <!+ $$9+ & < &<!+ 1&<7 ? ,-&<B9"&< 1-" &<A2 #""-<C+.

$($ -&$-$5$-"-$G$-"0H * -$5$-3(. "#<& (-$ "#<-+4 1"#<.

5$ $ 1$$ $-(+"$5( $* $"&$ ,(+ 8-$ +-1$--$ $$-$-B..C-$ $$-$"+(5 $*55"%(""-*55"%$ $-$ $-$$-($ *(""$""( (5 $ * (*$ -"*+$ - $ -$5$-" %$ $ - $$-(-(8$ $8*(""$""((5$"+* (*$ ($ *55"%%(("(5$-$(5*""1(5 +-1$- -$ $$.E$*55"%$ $5+ $ $-$$-($"$* (5"(5 ".& *$ ( 5 ( B.B.A + -$8$ (5 *(""$""(4$-$5$-"(1%$ $"$ $(5I*$ +.

+ +-1$--$ $$$5$-$5$-"11 $8$- --$5$-3(."0" 4 (+1**$4$5( $ #" +-1$&'$ ()$*+ &%%"""1$-(--(#"

+-1$&'$ ()$*+ &%(8-$ +-1$--$ $$-$-..C $*$-$**$-"$"-$$ +-1$--$ $$*""$-4 $ ,(+ --"""$-$"+(5$*55"%("". E$"- +-1$--$ $$$5$*55"11 $8$-

-$8$5$-$* $"$ $1+ "$(-**$4$5( $" ,(+ &($(5%%"""+$-($ $"*(-$"- $"*(-$ 3(."**$ $- (+1(+"$.

; 4$ $($- $ $ "+4"$0+$ $ ($+ $(5$*55%"1$-( 1 4- "$* $**$%"5$-+-$ $"(4$5( $",(+ $11("$8$ +-1$--$ $$"$5 "**$ 5$-.

;8$$ -$ $-(+"$5( $* $"4$"-$"1(1 (+1$ $( -.

E(+1$*55"-$-$"$"+ 4$(1$-($&%-4$$18$($4%(5( 15 4+$ $"$$ ($* $181(5(84$* (*$ 4 %(5( 15( (1$-(81$8-$$* (-+$-4 $*55" $1 -.E$*55"8$5$-(*$(5$ -(+$(5$($"+* (*$ .E$ $ $1$8 +*($ +-1$--$ $$*""$-$ $ 1(&"+5$- 4!+41&E$ &2&1 $.%$%$ $ 5(+-(4$*(""$""(4+ +-1$--$ $$-(($* $*55"+* (81$ $"$$* $" 1( %$ $ ( $ "$ - $""$ $ 0+$"( (5 *(""$""(%"8(8$-.?$ $"*$ (%"$(5$*55"&$ *(""$""((5$"+* (*$ "$ $%$-$5$-"&(+1

A ( -1($# "% (1-$8$ $-$*(""$""(($ -$5$-"4+$1 $"$*(""$""("%$ -$5$-".E$-$5$-"8$(+1$1$-$ 5$ - *+ "$-$"$0+$"(5 ( ? 41% $( ?1 (((..5( "+(5".C&4+$8$5$-( * (-+$( $( -"$-$$-( ($ -(+$(5$ 58(+ (5$ 5$ &%&4($"-$" $"1$ "$4(" $1 -"$$($"+* (*$ "($ $-.; 4$1"(&5$*55"%$-(1$*(""$""((5$"$"+ ($4""(5* $8(+"*(""$""($$ "(5$((5$ *$5$$5&&$"+"(+-8$4$$5$-%"G ("(5$-"*(""$""(.?(%$8$ &$"+"-$-4$$ 5$-5$ *$ (-.

$ $*55" $(* (8$-(4$ (%$ "(5$"$"+&$("$$ *(""$""((5$"$5( $"( ($-1 $ ( 5( 51 (5 "+ 5( *(""$""( " $ "& $ $5( $& $ "+ 5$- 4 $ " ( 4$.E$ $$$ $$-(*(""$""((5$"$ "+( ($"$* (5"5 ($-$5$-". 2$ $---(#" +-1$&'$ ()$*+ "-$ %$"*$"(5$"$8$ * (*$ -** (* $ $ %$ $ $1$(5$*55".

C 4$$ $---(#" +-1$&'$ ()$*+ .

E+" ; -( ( 5- $1 ( 5 $

+-1$*""$-4$$ $-' "**$$,(+ .$ " 4"$-+*(* (*$ ** "-** $((5$8-$$-( $ $ * $((5%. 3("+4"0+$"((5% "$"$**$". '-1 ( $ $ **$"& $ "$ "- -"""$-.

7..

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#