Nirmal Devi @ Nirmal Verma v. Union Of India And ANR

 

     !
"##
# $#
# # #
 # 

 '( )

 *    
 




  

 



 

  

#+ 
,- +.

".  #  
,- + .

". +#
.## #   

  

  



!
!"
  



  


#
 

$
! 
!"
% 



   &&& +#
.## #/"

 '

(

 
 )"
*
+ 


% 
, 
 
,-

  
,-
,"

 

  

 
,



 
  

'.

./ 0..1

  

 
 )"
 
 

 



  
 
'233
4

5

 67
(

  
% (,

4

5 %(67
* 
 
 

 

 9.

...:;

!
  

%

  
  

,-
"

<$
 0.'1

0../

   
.'

.3 0.'3


*
* 

 

*  




 '= 00':;
-,
*
  
/>
  


? 
 
 
,-
 
, 
%(





%-
  



 '0 '33:;
*
  "

(!




'.>
* 


,
 '

2'2:;

( 



 "
 
(


  
- 
4 @ 7
0.'2;0.
, A -

*  


-
?




 '1 91':;

!

- 
 


*


  ,-
 "

  

  


?

  
,-
,"



*
"
    

 "

,-
 


  

  
,-
 
  

 - 
- 


 

 
  


 
* 
*

?, (
  


 -
 
,-
 
  


 
  
,-
,"



*
   


   * 


  
*




 
 
* 
* ?,

*
 A 

,
   
 
! 
'2=;


  (?
 
'29'
4

5 
'29'67

*
, 


     
 "
 
 

 


@
0.'2;0.

 "
 

  
  
,-
 

?

*

 

 "
 



  

 
 




 '.:;


?

  




 
  

, 
" 

 
*  "
 
 
 
! 
'=1
4'7


 
'29'

  




 
  

 
 
 "-

   - 




  B  
 


  
" 


*
  
 



   

?


  

  
,-  
"
*
 

* 
,-

%


%(
   
*
* 
 

 
* 
 "
* 


  
*
?
 "
*

 
C
, 





  


 
* 
*





 
* 
,
  


*

 




?,-
 

,
 " 

 
,

?





 

  
 
  

 
 

0
1 #)) (

-2 3 .3  3  2

0
%
 983=

0.'9
  
 .= .= 0.'3D



 ) ( 45 6- 23 "

%
 910.


0.'9
  

.3 .3 0.'2

1

8 2 )9)

8 ''

(3  ( 4: ''

(
(
 =2/

0..2
  

1.

.1 0.''
,- %;
E   


%D
0
   ) ( 45 - 23  0 ' ))

 ' ( 4:;.<

0.00
4==/7
( 1..
F

5)0 )04 7 .003)

 ' 
0.'2
!%%
$B E,-
/'3 =  

  
 


  
" 

 
%-

   
?


  
 
  ! 
'2=;


 
'29'
* 
G 
 
  

   
 
 
*
"
*"



  
!
 
"  

  

  
  
 '1 91':;




"

 
 

 




 '.:;


, 
  


  
 

*
   
!

" 


  
  

 *
 
*
 
 
?",

?


  

  
*

 

-
   / E 
 "


 
 
,-

     "
,

 

*
,


  


    


 

 
'29'

! 
'8'


 
* 
 (,

*
  




 

 


 
)"


(
 
  
 

 

 


=

 



"
 -

 

 

+-

  



 "

 

 
 


,-
*- 
"


*

 



 

  








* 
 :
*

, 







+-

, 
  
H
 "


  

  
  

 

 
 
   

,
 


 

-
,
  


  I  J
* 

  -
  

! 
0
40=7


 
'29'

 

 
I  J

 
! 
0
4037


 
'29'

  

 
I  J


  
-,

-
 

  
 -
 -
 - 

 ,
  

  
-
  


  "

  


 -
" 

 ,
  


  

-  
 -
* 


, 
G 
! 
/9
407
4 7


 

'29'
-

 
,-
*-

  
  

 
  
 

,
" ,

 
'29'
 

  5 

 
 6
< 
! 
'=/;E
4'7


 
'29'

"" 


  
  
,-

 

-
 
  
 



-
,

,
  

,
  


 
- 

* 


   
*

,
  

  
 


 

!  '2=;


 
'29'


 
!,
! 
4'7


! 
-
  
, "

 


C
  
<-
*

 ,
 -

  
-
 
,-
*-

  
 

 
,-
*-
   

  

  
?




 

 
 
 
 


-
!,
! 
1
4?7


! 


 * 
-

?


,
   

 
 
  
,-
*-




  


 

* 
,-
%(
!,
! 
1
4?;

7
-

?

 
 

,-
*-

  

  
* 
,-
%(


,
   
* 
 
    
"
 
- 
 

? 
 /.

...:;

(
   


 


,
) 

 
) "

 * 
,
  
 

* B 

*
 
 

A 


*  

     
,-

  




 :    
*
,

  

?

  

-
 

  
 

  


" 


 "
 

   





 
, 
 



 


   
,  

+ 
(
  

 
*
"




*

,

 
'29'



*-
 

,   
  

*

 
 

   

,
 " 

 


  

 
*
 
,
  

 

 "
 


  



   


 "
   

,



92+ .3 ( - 2 2

03  + > ?)14  2 0)

'290
!%
'

*  

CJ,
! 
%

 


  
  
* 
,-
%(

,-
*-


 

   D


))

 ' ( 4:3     ) (

45 6- 2
  

40.'07
08
? 
03
47
*  
  
E  

C"
%

,

,  

*
  
 

  


,
 " 

  
 

  

 
*


,
  

 

  "
 


  D


5)0 )04 7  .00@)  

A

4!7
*  

 
E  

E,-
C"
%

,  
  

 
 


  

 

,- *-

 ,  





,
  

 

 
  
* 

 
 





 

" 

*




 


+" 

C"
%

   
*

,
?",

?


, "

  D


+ 8

 ( /4 
2. )5  5 

;.4<- 23

2
  

40.'97
8.
? 
/1
4 7
*  
C" %



,  

 
* 


    "
  


 


, 
* 
,-
%( 
,
,+  

(!


(?
 



-
 


 


  
* 
  
 

  

 
I  J

  
 

 
'29'D


1

 2 )9)

8 ''

(@) 
4!7
*  

E  


%
  

 "
 "



 

 

 
*  


 
 






 

  
+-


,
 

,




 
   
 
,


0
   ) ( 45 6- 2@) 
4!7 * 


 



C"
%

#+

*  
 ,  
* 

 
 "
  

  
C" % 
 *



*


*


,
   
 


 




 
*   

 
,-
%(


  



 
 
,
  

 
C*


+ 

 
  
,-

  


  
  

 





,

(!
 
! 
'2=;
417
4?;7


 
'29'

 *
  

! 
'=/;E
4'7


 
'29'


,
  

,  "

! 
'=/;E
4'7
 


-


  
  
,- 
 

-
 

 
 


 -
,

,
  

,

 


 
- 

* 

   
C*




 
 

)

   " ,

?
*
 "

*  
 
  

 
 
  

K
(
 
 
*

 

 "

 

""
 
(
-
 

! 
'=/;E


 ?,-


 


"

?,-
H


?,

 
?,
 

! 



-
*

?

,
 
   
 

 "
* 


?,


,
  "
,-

 
"
  ,-

-
* 

 
 




 

 

  




 

 

 

 
  

,
? 


, 


 
 

! 
/9
407
4 7

(
A 
*
   

0
   ) ( 45 6- 2@)

4!7 ,-
C"
%

#+

 ,
*  

*
,  

   
* 


  

 




  


"


*





 

 +" 


C"
%

 
 
*

?",

?

 , "

 

*
 



*

" 

  
%
4,7

! 
'=/;


 
'29'



  
,- <
 
0..2


 

!,
! 
4'7

! 
'=/;E

   
 

*
 

! 
'2=;


 
'29'
*
-


*

 

  

?





" 

?,-
 
 


A 

  

?


*

 -


- 
*




 


-


 , 
,  


  
*


" ,

?

,- ! 
/9
407
4 7


 
'29'
-




  
  * 
 
*
 

 
 

 *


 
  " 


  
" 

 

   
* 
,-
%(


%




"

 
 




"


*

+" 
,-
C" %
*




, ) 

 

*

,
?",

? C*

 *

 

! 
'2=;
417
4?;7


 
'29'

-




  
 
* 

  

 
 * 
* 
  
?  
 /.

...:;





  
*
,
?",

?

(
  




 -
" 
?

 

  
* 
*
  
,-

  
"
*
 

 
" 
,-
%(

,-

%

<$
  ,-

  
,-
 "



 


  
!
 


 


,



?
*
?",

 ,
   




  
* 


  
,-
%( 



"


 




"


* 
  
* 

 


 
,-
C"
%
 
 
 
,-

  


+" 


C"
%
 

, "
 
  

?

 


   
,- 
  

,

,
  


  


    "-
(
*
 

* 

 
 



&

  

  

 



   

?

   
*






 

 
-

  
( 


 


 ; # < ;+#
.## #<  "

"








 *  + H  
 )":   @ : H  
 , @ :