High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9084/2013allowed

Punjab State Power Corp. Ltd. And ANR v. Ombudsman Electricity Pb. And ANR

2018-02-01Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath9 pages

! !"#$#%&

'%()* ! +!,,-, #%.#/# !0%0% 1!, ! # #%!,$ 2 /)'0$/%3!" ,#"# 45 '%()%0% 1!, !$-%0!% $

67$*')1%1#3#%8!% ,!%0% 1!, ! # #%!,$ 2

'%()* ! +!,,-, #%.#/# !0%0 1!,$ !$-%0!% $ 6 9.6 * :*:

6 ;

!"#$% &

' "()*

+!"#$% & '

!"#$% ! # & ' # , * !"#$% ! #

:*:

6 5< ,3=& -# ((# . +

(# / '%()* ! +!,,-, #%.#/# !0%0 % 1!,2 /)'0$/%3!" ,#"# 45 '%()%0% 1!,9& /

' # (# 967$*')1%1#3#%8 !% ,!%0% 1!,2 '%()* ! +!,,-, #%.#/# !0%0 1!,$9& /%# '! . $. (#

% ((+# #.01*.#* # #.01*.#* #%# #

#.0 (( -%(2 ,(*** & / **/'! $ % 3# ( 4* & / 4*/' #1*.#* $.% ((+#5$!

%$%!

% .+6 %# * 3 # 7,. ((+ (# (%%0%%##*,% (&,'8# ( +0 %#( 9 )0 : -(%%0 %% (# *)( *;.

, (0&;,'

4#.% * # #:9* 3 # + #.

:9< #%.(( *4. 0 : % 5$!#+ %% + %% .0 " "%% 1

% &""1'7 3$!.=% # ((+ ((0 $#+.

:9<!

% 0%%( #%$0 3! !>7 ##- %6 # # #

!"#$ %

' ()**& +

',, - . #/

& *

' ()*%

, % & -0.' '

1 % %% 23

-0 .' -

2 !'

3 # % ((+# #* # % . **- # !$! #*# > - ($ .$ * # ## #%# 562 *' %6*372

%*& #

% 1 %% 23 8 '

9* * & * 9: ; %; < %6+

) ; ; '

*6 < & . '

% ' ,

' '

' ()* =% & . %

.' -0

', ) ,

' '

*23 *23 *23 9. )? % ** 9@,A ** %9 % *'

<,<

;)<* $ B %) * 888%) 4 ,((* #! # (# (. 4*% (#*#

3 #

(# (1*.#* !?(%%0!= .!$# ## # (0 ((# #.

:9< #%# < - !! ++$# + # *.#* .0%.

.#%# *:9<<

# %# ++$# + #

#.0** #4*.0%.

#%(# :9< #1*.#* #%#.

*:9< @ # %( .*# ( %% *;,4# $(( + $##( 9! 9 ! 9 # 9 %+$#.0, ( 3+( #0 !% ( #%#

, &' C3

D: 2 &5 & :

)2&

' & E 7 , E',:

, , 3 .2F

D: 2 &5 & :

)2& , '

*, % &%'

#$ 3 . '

#$', '

'& , ,3 %73$;2. , !

! #$

)

', ' (' )

*, , ,,

& + ,

' ! % &

)22$ ', ' '

&% , : & &

' F

#$ '

#/D&

E &

5 8 & ' F

' ',0

4 - *+ (% $# (%%0 ;, 4#

( 9# (( %% * ;, %% #.0#9 * # 8.*# %%( # # 9 * 5 # %%( # #

.0% .%( # .

:9< $ ( .(%* %%( #* ) # (0( +) - #%%( ( #%# # #0 % = 9 * %)*9A%)

% )'* 9 ,A % ) 6 "-

*'C & ' G-0

, 7 ('

= 3* 1 37 )

, !!2213 2F

8 % ' -0

#$ & ,

#/&

, 7 (' )

*, * * 1 7 7 *23 <

2* % 92 %)*9A%) 4 @ #%( !

> .*# # (+.(.+ #.

:9<*%(.

< .#.01*.#* .0 * #+ $ , (3+( 5 (.*# 1*.#* %**# (0+ (

, (3+( %# (

.% +#8 .*# ( ! (#.01*.#* #%+.

*:9<< (% .(;,4#

(#.+( #.0( 9! 9 ! 9! 9 # 9 , (3+( 1 #!( #%( # %# .*# ** # 4* $%**# #%(+.

:9< # #( 9

$##, (3+( !

% # '!! 3 8 1 * %8 =

% *

6* ,

#/ ' -0&' &

& ' 0 ' &&A E 4 8.*# + ((+ (#, +8##.0( #%( # .*# # ((# * ((8+ #!( #%( .*#

(#. (% .(.% # (0 ;, 8 ( $! ( # %( # .*# 1*.#* + #<.

: +# ,A #% * ((# $( % !* . ((# )8%( (0 # #$ + #*+.+#) # $( * # # ?,3 9 #% *( %% #.0, A.

.+ # %% * % + 8+ #!( #%( ! ! .*# 1*.#* *( *# * +## BC0 *%( %% $.+$ (0@- $()!%( # .%%( # *)(.0 ((+ *# * %* #@-$%% .( # ((+* $(5 + # .

*( % .+ ((# # (# 0 #

D 8!!.*# % *( %*.

%1*.#* # ##%+.

< 8 $ #( #%( # # %# .( % -% # !

#*#(0 $+ * #(%%0%%9 * (#.

:9<$<E "#*#(0! # + , 8# ( +0?(%%0% $+ %#( # ) - * # !%(%%0%% .

$##!:9* $(( +3 # . ((#.

:9< #%.((+ 4. 0 :(( # 0 # # #.

#*.(- !

%$0 ## 3 # %(#%%#. ** #4*!$!1*.#* + +# .

:9< ((+ ((0 + #.#%#<3 # .

% ((0(#

$##, (3+( # 9 , (3+( # '

, 7

' -0& ' & ,

#/4 "+* #

(% .( % (%%0 (0 $###;, 8 .*# .

;,%%#! $##, (3+( ( 9!% ( #0. #%# ( #- #( 9 4 # ((%%0%% $ ( .(#;, 4#,%* 9 * #

+ #+(%%0%% $##.0#9 *

- ## %%( # #

# *$ 0.=%#. .+ .

:9< # %%( ! % . % ((+# .0 # ! % % +% ((0 $# .

:9< #*.( %* $%%( # * ) # (0 $( +)!#

, (0,%* , (

3+( ( 9 # 9 ,% (0%%( #

# .$ ) 9 ) # %%# (%%0 (0 )

, (0,%* %+( #.0( # 8 * !%%( % #%**%. .((+ #0

# .((+ # : ! ! #%%( (% .( (( % F!!(#. # %(# + 0( *

%#( $##, (3+( E -

%#(% # # ( # 9# ( (0.0;,- (0.0 ;, % % ((0 $##, (3+( !% . #%# .$-# 1*.#* *( (

< . $##*( % ! *(

% % *# .$-!( + * 0 +(!# 1*.#* % ((+# (0((+ ( # # * .0 # # (#.0

((# " %C% !%#

( # .0#*# " % 0 #. ( %#%%#% ( < :*:

6 = ,

+73 # G7 3 .( G7