High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6927/2015disposed of

Hawa Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-08-22Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

"#$$%&'&() *

"+",&(-.

// $#&#&($0 1$0'2'

,#"#$"03"(""(4#.$0'

// $'5(4$(#'

0$'$(#)/ 06"3."24."03748%"#$0#.$5$#&#&($0 0 "8& 0"#"5,&(-.77"03"("

:$"4&(-' ( 0$%04 +2:4 &(4&%"#$#."# #.$ 5$#&#&($0 +"' $(-"-$4(;2'#$00::'2(4$0#.$ !0"(%.(#.$5'# $:4"0420&(-#.$5$0&42($7 <#2($7 = &''$08&%$'."8&(- >$$(4&'$(-"-$47.$0"&'$4":">204&'52#$"(4&(#$0;'"+"04."8&(- >$$( 0$(4$0$4 >3 #.$ 0$'&4&(- &%$07 ?">20 20#/%2;/(42'#0&": 0&>2(":7&'"0.$+"'.$:4$(#&#:$4#0$&('#"#$;$(#+&#.%(#&(2&#3 '$08&%$":(-+&#. @>"%A+"-$' $#&#&($0&:$4

= '$$A&(- >$($&# 0$-2:"0&B"#&( '$08&%$' "(4 #.$ '";$ +"' 4&'5'$4(

=4&0$%#&(-#.$0$'5(4$(#'#%('&4$0#.$%:"&; "(4##"A$"&(":4$%&'&((#.$:$-":(#&%$'$08$4>3#.$5$#&#&($0 .$%(%$0($4C$%2#&8$(-&($$0&''2$404$04"#$4*

0$6$%#&(- #.$ %:"&; #.$ 5$#&#&($0 .&' :$4 # #.$ &:&(-

&;52-(&(-#.$0$6$%#&(04$04"#$4*

(

+"'4&'5'$4(

4&0$%#&(-#.$0$'5(4$(#'# 0$%('&4$0#.$;"##$03$#"-"&(&(#.$:&-.#624-$;$(#0$(4$0$4&(%"'$

// .$&('#"(#5$#&#&(."'>$$(&:$4"''"&:&(-#.$04$04"#$4 *

7 5"''$4 >3 #.$ ,25$0&(#$(4&(- (-&($$07 &'"0 &0%:$7 !"#(($C20$ /=&(#$0;'+.&%.#.$%:"&;#.$5$#&#&($0 '$$A&(-0$-2:"0&B"#&(."'3$#"-"&(>$$(0$6$%#$4

$02'":#.$&;52-($404$0+2:40$8$":#."##.$0$6$%#&(&' 50&;"0&:3(#.$>"'&'#."#8#."'&''2$4&('#02%#&('4"#$4 =

7 +.$0$>3 8"0&2' 5:&%&$' &(%:24&(- 5:&%3 4"#$4

< 0 0$-2:"0&B"#&('$08&%$'"4.%D%(#0"%#D4"&:3+"-$$;5:3$$'."4>$$( 0$'%&(4$4 (#.$&;52-($404$0&#'$:&#."'":'>$$(>'$08$4#."##.$ 5$#&#&($0 #.$0+&'$ ."4 >$$( 2(4 $:&-&>:$ 0 0$-2:"0&B"#&( +$

<2(4$0#.$5:&%34"#$4

<&#'$:"(40$%;;$(4"#&('0 '"(%#&(($5'#$:4"0&(#.$5"3'%":$ ' < /<

."4>$$( 0+"04$4##.$&%$(-&($$0/&(/.&$#+"'":'>'$08$4#."##.$ ($%$''"03'"(%#&(+"''#&::"+"&#$4 20&(-#.$%20'$.$"0&(-#4"37&#."'-($2(%(#08$0#$4 #."##.$,#"#$8#."'&''2$4(#&&%"#&('4"#$4 *

="(4

= &(#$0;'+.&%.#.$8"0&2'0$-2:"0&B"#&(5:&%&$'#."#."4>$$(0$'%&(4$4 $"0:&$0 &( 5&(# #&;$7 '#"(4 0$8&8$4 .$ #+ (#&&%"#&(' 4"#$4

="(4

='#"(4"55$(4$4"(45:"%$4(0$%04"#(($C20$'

/ "(4 /* ":(- +&#. #.$ 5$#&#&( $02'": '2%. (#&&%"#&(' "# (($C20$' /"(4 /*+2:40$8$":#."#"4$%&'&(&(50&(%&5:$."'>$$( #"A$(>3#.$,#"#$8##."##.$:$#8$0025"(4$;5:3$$' +0A&(- ( "4 .%D%(#0"%#D4"&:3 +"-$ >"'&' "(4 +. %2:4 (# >$ 0$-2:"0&B$42(4$0#.$50$8&2'5:&%&$'("%%2(#"4;&(&'#0"#&8$0$"(' >2#+$0$#.$0+&'$$:&-&>:$7+2:4>$0$-2:"0&B$4+&#.$$%#0;#.$4"#$'

/</ #.$3+$0$$:&-&>:$00$-2:"0&B"#&( (#.$:&-.##.$(#&&%"#&('4"#$4 *

="(4

= (($C20$' / /*!&#+2:4>$%:$"0#."##.$>"'&'5"''&(-#.$ &;52-($40$6$%#&(04$04"#$4*

"#(($C20$ /=4$'(#'208&8$ 8$(:$"0($4,#"#$%2('$:8$03"&0:3'#"#$'#."#2(4$0#.$:&-.# #.$(#&&%"#&('"#(($C20$' /"(4 /*#.$;"##$0"'0$-"04'%:"&; #.$5$#&#&($0'$$A&(-0$-2:"0&B"#&(+2:40$E2&0$0$%('&4$0"#&( %%04&(-:37#.$50$'$(#5$#&#&(&'4&'5'$4&(#$0;' '$##&(-"'&4$#.$04$04"#$4*

(($C20$ /=! .$;"##$0&'

0$;"(4$4>"%A##.$%;5$#$(#"2#.0&#3D0$'5(4$(#(#%('&4$0#.$ %:"&;#.$5$#&#&($0"0$'.0-0"(#>$($&#0$-2:"0&B"#&(&(#.$ :&-.#(#&&%"#&('4"#$4 *

="(4

=(($C20$' / /*! #&'20#.$0%:"0&&$4#."#'&(%$&(#.$&;52-($404$04"#$4 *

&#."4>$$(>'$08$4#."#"0$%;;$(4"#&(."4>$$(;"4$0 '"(%#&(&(-($5'#$:4"0+$

<"(4#.$;"##$0+"''#&::

5$(4&(-&(":4$%&'&(70$'5(4$(#"2#.0&#&$'"0$4&0$%#$4#$8$(520'2$ #.$;"##$0 ?$#"&(":04$0>$5"''$4+&#.&("5$0&420;(#.'0; #.$4"#$0$%$&5#"%$0#&&$4%53#.&'04$0

$#&#&(4&'5'$4

:2%A3 .$#.$0'5$"A&(-D0$"'($4) $'

.$#.$0 $50#">:$)