Jasmer Singh & ANR v. P.O., Central Govt. Ind. Tri.-Cum-Labour Court, Chd & ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH CWP-6956-2015 (O&M) Date of Decision: 12.10.2023 JASMER SINGH AND ANOTHER
...Petitioners
Versus
PRESIDING OFFICER, CENTRAL GOVT. INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL-CUM-LABOUR COURT-1, CHANDIGARH AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :
None for the petitioners.
Mr. Anil Rathee, Advocate for respondents No.2 to 4.
HARSH BUNGER, J.
! "
#
$% $&
' ()
*+ ,( - ! . / * ( (0* ( 1 . /2! ! *+ *
+!
!
4 . /! / * 5$6 $$ ' ( " 7 ! * *++ *+
( " ! / ( * *+
&$8 $&
+! ! " *+ / * * & *+
! + 0*
$%% $)$5%% !
+ . 9 / ! 4* /
! 7 ! 5$ %%% + + !
8(: ;
+ +
6$+ <
* !
+ " + " ! + !
# + *+ 4 *+< 2*
! "
# *+
! * + + + 7
8(< ; !
+!
( + * " 6 / (
*+
(9 = 7 ! *4 + ; ; / ' * > " !" 13
,02 3,0 $$ $$$
! *
(
*+ =; + 9*
*+ = ; +
*+
(9 =; *+ = ; + * = + " + *
+
*+ + *+
+ = + *+ ( 7 !
+ + *
(
6$+ / *+ ( + * 7
+! +
8 = * ! / * *
$% $& ' ()
( " *+ " * + + *
(
(
! * * 5 **+
/ * *
* / * * * +
+ + * =; *
( " " (
+ *+ * *+
( ! * *
!
+! 0* ? * !%5$ 1 !%5$2
* * !
( " * * + ( !
+!
* ; 7 ! * * *
(
+
* " ) - ! ( =;
*+ * + +
" 6$+ " ! 8(3 ; *
( "
* ! + + *+ =; 0
( =;
(' 9 0 ' (8 " +
*+; + *+ " *+ @ + * ;-< + 4
" ; " 0
*
!%5$!
! +
*
=; " ! *
!%5$! * ! + * "
*
+
*++ 8(< ;
+! + *
% *" *
*+ , 6 $ + + * " 9 " *+
" *+9 6$+ + + 6$+ !
( ' 9 0 ' (8 A(
*+ + + @'B ' ' ' ' ' ' 3+ 3** ! ! "" # $
" %
# "" " % # ""
& '
($ %
) " * % # "" & "
#+ +
, $
" - % " #+
" " % +# $
" "
$ " %
+# % $
" # % #+ $ #
" " " " "
#
$ "
. " #
"
'
$ " #
" #
" '
%
+#
# # "
/0
$ '
%
$ " %
+#
#
1$
#+
#
$ " % +#
" " % +#
!
" % # " 2334 " 2334 #
"" %
"
# % +#
# $5
# #+
$ 7 #
'
! ""
% # 1$
" !# #
#+ $ %
#+
888 %
93334
" #+:
(
(' 9 0
' (8 +
*+; + + *+ " *+ @ + * ;-< + + *
+4
C
& -
+ + *+ + *+ + + ! * + + *
=;
( *+ = "
* *+ " " 6$ + + + + * " 9 ! * 4 *+< D*
$ % & '
'
( )* +!+"
'','
! ! < D*' A
) " % 0
"
"" $ 1$
"" & #& "" %
" %$ $
"" $ 1$ " #
$ " # " #
#+ );3 " #
" %
)2* %$ '"$
& 8;.&
#+ #$
$ "
)2* "$ #
$
"
,-
< #
# $
,- " " ($
" "
$$ " =
=
9 * "$"
<>$$ <
)26
% $ ,)- )2 #+ $ " #
" # #
$
& $ #+ $
" );3 # " & #
$$
"& $&
" + " .2882
* "$" $ #
#+ " );3 # &
#& & $
$ "
# 2?88;
@2882 #+ "
);3
&
$ " #
#+ *
# ""
#+ $ #
$"" " #
($ )26 %$ '"$
"
= $""
"$ $
"" $
$ % " " #+
$ #$
"
$ $""
$
"
$ $ #
""
$
#+ $
" A =
# $""
;
>$ # # "
% 0
"" &
"$
"$ " " "
"$ & #$
& #& #$
# "
$
# $ " "$ # "
# ($
+
+$
"$ "&
$&
$
# "$&
$
= $" # $
"$
$
1$
$ % & %$
$ #
"" % # # 1$
"$ $
$
"
2 !
A >$
# = 1$
$ #
# % $&
& A >$ = "# 1$
#& #$ #
$ $ $
B:
6 : ! -
.
% % '
.
/ * !0"
! < D* ' A
8 % & #
#+ "$
"
$ #+ # "
);3 $ " #
"
#
"
#+
"$ "
#+ );3 ! " "
# #
"$C #+ # = C
$
"$
"
%
" #+ # #+
# "" $ " #$
" $ " $
" #+ $+
# " & # "
#+
$
# " );3 $ " )
>$
# # #
"$ #+
" ($
$ >$ #
)
"
($ $
"$" )2* %$
'"$
#+
# $ "
$$" " ($
$ )26,-
% $
# $ 1& #
#+ " "
" )2*
#
"
" )2D )2A $
# E =
""
#
" # % $
" #+ & "" #
="
"
# "
" =
$
" "
>$
$ #
"" # # "
= "$
>$ %
>$ # $$
" & >$
$
= $
"B: 8 (
!%5$ !
*+< 2* *+ 4 1&
2
'
'
( &
4 5* !+"
, ! A(
); $" $ $ $
,- ,- 6 /$ )?& 8?@&
($ # > D
D """ D
& # "& #
=" F""" D F
>
& # $ ($&
$ $
$
$ > D "
" $ C
# &
&
1 "&
+ $
" % # & >
D #
""" D C
#
D # #
$& #$
""" D
, -
# #
="& # ($ &
$ $ ,- )
%$
'"$
& ,- > D
" 4$+ $+ $
& ,- $ ,-
$ $ > D & , -
# " C ,-
"
$ & > D #
""" D #
& D #
$& #
""" D
,)- ,-
$ 3,- >
" " $ "&
" #+
$
""" D
,- $ # >
6
6&
& C
,)-
,- #+
"
$ ($C
,- $
$ ,)- 3C
, - $ "$ $
> D '
8& 8.@
($ 3
($
$ # ""
1$ $ 1
1$ " +
1$ &
($
$ $ $ A >$
#
4
"
,9"
(
% 2
%
%* )
7 &
%
/& % * 2
/ % 2
% % &
- %
8 /
% !"
2 % *
- /&/ 2 % % & *
%*
)
& /'
9&
% & /&
%
9
2 % % &
) -
%% & /
,;-
$ 1$ $
%<
,$"- ""
$
$ 1$4 $ $
A >$& " $ #
1$
%< ,$"-&
&
1$ # $
,2-
$ " $
3,- >
" "
$ #& $ "$
$
$
& $ 1$ #
($ #
"
$ $+ "$
$ $""
$ #+ $
$
$4 $
" $
" #+
$ %
$
$
$
$& $ #
" "" " #
$
$ $ 1
"
"$"
" @ $
,@- % $
$ "
$ 3,- >
"
$
""" D & " "
$ "& " #+
# $ "& "
#+ "" "
" $ #+
" # $& #
$ $ & &
=
= $
"""
+
#+
"
=
($
($
! ( ! %5$ *+ ; 3 :&)
-
'
;
<&%
% : * !+"
'','
#! * A(
@ $
$ "
& $
#& # $
+ $ "
"
"
$ $
#+
C $
#+ $ " $ ""
" B:
5 : !
'
> 4 + =4
'
>'
'
6 4
*
6
+
/
+ *
< D* A F. ($ $ 1$
A >$ $ # $
))@
($
>$
$ "
$
#
$
1$
$
$7 # "
$ $ # $ 1$&
= & $ $ =
1$
#
$ #
= 1$ & >$
$ "" & &
($ # $ ""$
& "
& #
"$ " # "$
"" "" $ 1$ &
#& $ 1$ $ #
$" 1$ >$
=
"" >$
>$ $ $
""
"
($ # "
# #
""
#&
$ & #
""
%
$& #
$ #
& $
$ $
& $
# $ "$
&
&
#$
# #
# % #
& #& #
$ #
$
" #
$
$
$ # $
($ $ "$
($ $ "
#
# =$ 1$ $&
"
# >$ %
# 1$
A >$ $
))@ $ #
=
?
% & $& ($
# # ""
#
#C
$
$ #
# ""
$ #
>$
$
$
"
$ "&
&
& & ="
$ # # #&
$
# %
& "$ $ $
" # $ "
$ ="
A >$
# ""
%
&
"$ #
$ "
$ >$
$ C
$
$ #
#
#
$&
# &
$ #$
# ""
% $ " "
# $ $
"
>$ $& $
#
"
# % $ "& "
"
($ #
""" # ""
"$
# # #
"" &
$ # "
$" $ $"
$ " " #
$ : ) , * % E *! ++
$% $& ' ()
*+ . /! ! + *+ '
4 ! ! !* * + !
$ = ! +! Ocober 12th, 2023 .
(HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No Whether reportable:
Yes/No