Ved Parkash v. Central Administrative Tribunal Chandigarh And ORS
!
"
# $%
& '($( %
%() &+!
(,
!-$.!+!
(,
! %!
" "/0 12-3/"454675/"/3 12-3/"45"/"4 $% / 7
($,!/ &(+ ).
%+
/ 8/# ,(&+
&9+1
:
/ ($ !
+ ).
%+
$% ;;;
- ( &: % +.
( %!
%!< 88($%
%78 ($%! $%.(%:$ =#* >#$%&:+)( &%%
?= +!< 88($%
($%! $% .(%: <(%!
.%
' = 1( < .$ #.% '
($
%(
.% :! $%.(%:( 8 :($, (@ '#$% ?+A08
'$%!%%!8%(%($ !(
:+<! '8&:+$ '&:
!
+<!( & < ($,
+( ,%%($,
:($ #&&8 :
.
&!
:<!(.!( *($,8 ( )$&< $%!
% B$$@# 0 C ( & & %!
$%!
: #&&8 : .
&
1$.+%!8%(%($ #*'(%% $: 8 $% %($ %%!
$% ($%!( ,
+& %*($,$
B$$@# 0 C+*#%$
.%($ < % $ !
+ %! 8%(%($ &, & $%(.
B$$@# 0?C$%! $% +*#% &&($) ($1$.+$ = +%!8%(%($ (& .()(& #(% ,
($,!(
.& ('+*#% %! '< )( D# ,'$%
B$$@# 0C ! (& *:%!8%(%($ ($ %%! D# ,'$%<
<(%!
<$)(
= B$$@# 0C!
+%! 8%(%($ (& (,($ & 88&(.
%($ B$$@# 0=C * $% 58$$%(.+%! $%.(%: (& 8&:B$$@# 0 C
!
($,&
%( + $%)(
B$$@# 0C %! B$$@# 0=C %! 8%(%($
1$.+%!8%(%($ (& %!($ % $%8%(%($#$ %(.&
B%!#,!%!.
.%8 )( ($( %(.&
C %!$ %(%#%($ $
( # $. (%($%!$ %# . %(
(%># !%!('8#,$
B$$@# 0C# %! +( # $. (%($%!$ %#
'# !
*$ #,!%% .%%! $% %8 :%! .
&
!<(
8 "
% <(%!($% %E=F8
$$#'
'%!
% $%(%&'$%
3
.#$ & %! 8%(%($
,# %!
% )( %! ('8#,$
8 $%+%!!
*$
*($,$%'
*&+$%!, #$ %%!.& ('
:*$ D.% *:%!.()(&.# %$' (% + !.
$$%')
'
$&, #'% %8 !( .& ('$%!( ,
+&
.#$ & #*'(%% %%!.()(& #(%< (& *:%!8%(%($ #%< $,
)(
($. %! .()(& .# % < $% !
)($, D# (.%($ %
D# (.
% %! .$% ) :*%<$%!8
%( +%! +($ %
( '( ($,%! #(%$ ' (% +(%< ($.#'*$%#8$%!.()(&.# %% %# $%!8& ($%%* $% * %!8 8 .# %$ #88 % !( #*'( ($+! &(
#8$
" ?=
.( ($ %!( .# % ($
B?C""B()(&C !(& &:($,#8$ .( ($
%!( .# %($ !
"!#$% B"
?+ .( $ C+&
.#$ &
,# %%! ($, .
# %<!(.!& . D# (.%($
$% *($ ($,#8$%!8
%( # %! +<!(&8 ($,.& (' $ ' (% &:($,#8$&' ()*)
+ + B C
!# ',-
. ,! B#8 '# %C+B()(& 88 &$ .( $ +&
,# $%!8 &< 2+%!8%(%($ ( $%(%&
%!
:># &%%!
%*($,
<$*:!
+!<(
? $%!%! +&
$%
,#
%!
%%!.()(& #(% (& *:%!8%(%($ $' (% %! ( # *(&(%: %! #(%< .( ($
)# )$%! (& *:%!8%(%($ ($ %%!D# ,'$% %!.()(& .# %< & <(%!
<$ $&(* %:<!
% )
$% % .! $:%! #'! &<
<(%!
<$$%! % %'$% %! $% <( !%8 . <(%!%! &! +&
&<!(&
0?0
( '( ($,%! )( %!('8#,$
(,!%&:!&
%!
%%!8%(%($ .
$$%.& ('%! ' &( #,!%*:!('* %!()(&.# %+<! !& %!( .
!8 < 2( $% 88&(.
*&($%!($ % $%.
+ !
'#.! $(
%%!8%(%($
D# %
$
% ($%!
$%.(%:($4 $#
:+ + *$* *:%!.()(&.# ($8
? (% D# ,'$%
!
) ,()$ # %!#,!% #& .$ (
%($ % %! () .$%$%($ &
%( 8 # & %!D# ,'$%
8 *:%!.()(& .# % ) & %!
%%! $% $%
( %!*D.%($ D# (.%($ %!.()(&.# % <!(& ( '( ($,%! #(%$' (% +%!( #
'
*(&(%: %! #(%< .( ($
)# )$ <!(&<(%!
<($,%! ($ %%!
D# ,'$% %!.()(& .# %+%!8%(%($ ('8&: % %! $%<( !%8 . <(%!%!
&&(* %:< #,!%*:%!8%(%($ %
( !( .& ('* %! $%
& '($( %
%() & $:%! #'$%! .( .#' % $. + !.
$$%* &&< % 0 ,(% %!( .& ('+$%!, #$ %%!.()(& .# %< $%!
)($,D# (.%($ ($ %
( '( ($,%! #(%+%! 8& ($% !#& )*$ %# ! .( ($ ($ / / ! / B #8
C+ &( #8$*:
&
%! $% &) $%%%!
.%
%!($ % $%.
1$.+ $%!
(,!%&: %!
%!8%(%($ *($,$%'
*&
%!.$%$%($<(%! ,
%%!8
00 &< 2( .$. +< $% $:' (%($%! '! .
!
+<(%!<!'%!8%(%($ ( .& ('($,8
(%:+( $ *%% %($,!
D# %
$
% ($%!
$%.(%:($4 $#
:+ +<! 88($%
9 %78 $ =
$= 1$.+%!
.( ($ ($&' ()*)
+ B #8
C !#',-
. ,! B #8
C
$!&8%%!8%(%($ ! .
$$%* &&< %% %!*$ (% < 2 = $)(< *)+< $% $:(&&, &(%: 8 (%:
($%!('8#,$
8 $% %(%($( + ..
($,&:+ ! "
)'*
!# $"
!%! 8 ($,A $
6 A !%! "8 *& 6