Gopal Krishan v. State Of Haryana And ANR
!"#"
$%&''
(% )*( ' +, +' -----
! "#!!
!$ %&! '( ))))) , +' .'/ 012 ( *%+,(!-'+ " &+ ../'(*"' !01"!&'!2(!" ' ! !#" 01 & ' 1! ' &# ! '
3 +!0( ( ' ( " %+! ' ( '" !#!+ 1( ! %!1 -4 ( 5"
1 6&( ' (
"
#*"(#!'7
8.9:;<: **:
'"( !4!+#!
' &1( : !! !01 (+1!+& !
9= 9> .9..#' &=8:<8 <'(1( '#!&$ .993 .
! &"+!
!1-(!+''( & (!!+&!#'? ; +&''&!+! ! !&(
( !+! -" #'( :@ 9;
.9.9 ( &'(+ !1 !$&(+ $2#! ('!#+4 ##-( A(!(4(!
&% !&'#!(! ( 2!"1!-"' "!(-"!
.
!+ # 2%$++1!+!&%42!'" - " !0 !&('( #'( & (!!!"+'(!#$( "!! 1 2++'( (## !1(-"( (!"'' !%B+ & (!1( %!&4!1!+ !'&+.:'(*" ' !$:;39! (!!&&"'-!&(('$(+ &+!# &# ! '# ( %1 '"( "1 (! !
! ( 1! ! 9= 9;
.9.9 2! (
"
'+&$ !!0!&!1! 2((!
% '!+'#!(+& "-C"# 2 !+1%$(2%$"&(!&(!-!0 "+!+4$!+1!+ & ! 9= 9> .9.92!( "
'+&' !1 & 1" &:?.'( !!+* $ :?/9 !1! ( !++1 & '# 2( (!
1% '!+ '#!&!"B"4( @ (!%(! +! &"+!
!1-(!+''(
!+1( = "!+ ' ( &"# !
!+12( (
(2(!!&('( #2!& "& -4(+& (-!'!&'#! ( (!+%+ !4 !++1!'#&('#!+&!1!( %1!11&4!4 ##-D''&('
("$(*"(!!!"#(! (! (!
-" !0!-!' -+'$!&& 1+4$ (!&!'#!0 4!-!' #!0( !'
(%1!!1&4! ('#! ( & 1&#!++!2!C" -!
@ !1! ! '#! " & :?. * ! &! ' &&"#!& &:?.'( *!
("
!
"
#$ %
!
& ! !
% !
& % !
&
!
!
# '(
%
!
% %
% & !
'!(
!
"
!
) )
)
!
'(
* +% ,
-
!
+%
! %
%
-
& %
!
& % !
&
+% , *
'!(
*
!
,
!
& %
!
& %
&
.
!
,
, *
' (
*
! !! % !
% /
! & !
&
.
&
= .
%
% *
/ (1 (" &- '&##'''& !
< '#!-1%! "-+&%!E < '#!02('#!-'!+( -(!%-'!+E < '#!1%2(!(!( "-+& %!(!++ ##(12(&(("1($' "'!& 1"&('#!!02E %< '#!1%2(!&!""&( "-+&%!"+!2'"+ 2(!4!&' !4 > &$-' &:?. * -%0 $( &!4 1 ' 02+ 1 2( ( '#! !-" ( '#!-1'!+#"A &$#!"1(- !&% +!4 +4-&!"#'#!2!&&&! - #!(!('#!02-'!+(!
!-+%-'!+ &!-!0 - &"
#+4-&!"!'#!'"( ( +&%"!++4 '" -&& ?
"&(!+1 $!-1"11 -4( (! %4'#!'(%1!1!1&4"1(- &"
" &:?. *$'('#!'" -&& 2"+ 4(%1!#&(!#'(%1!1 !1& #"-'1(!('#!#!4!+2!4- ( !4 ++'(!1&4! #'!2!&('"+&F
"&(!2!&! -4(+!2'&1!1&!
&F(!(4#" !++" &"(1!&%( %&41(-"(
('#!("C" 1%!
''#! $2(!(' " &"! ' (+!2'&#!1&!0!!
!!&( '#!&%
('#!#!4("-+1" !
-!' -+%(!('#!1%-4(#&&! (! ( &(!11( "!! -+&F ;
%02+ 1'('!+4'('#!'
&&"''&" &:?. * &$%! '#!#&!+$(!#&!-(-!&"(! '#!1%-4"&( 2!02-+% -'!+
"&(1C"#(!- &- -4(+1+!"2( !-B&!'1"! !'#!!1! &"''#1 2(!(-+% !( "4'# :9 ( !++1! " ( $ ( +4 &&+"(!&!-' (!('#!'"( ( %1!1 !1&4 2! '" - && 2%$2(! G&&H &!- "# ! G02-'!+! -+%-'!+H 1+!"(!&&"+4&(("' 2 G'!+ ! G&&H ( 2 #!4 " #+! #!1-"!" ''&A! #!4!+2!4-!
'&"-" (!'% &(!-0 # !
-B&-4(+1+!" ::
(!#2+!
(AC"'(!++1 -!&( '1( %!&4! (&+!#'&# !'(!++1
-!&(('
1(!!-+"1(! (&!
/ & (!"(4' !&(1('!
+#1(1( %!&42(( ! !'&+.:'
(*"' !< %'#(& !'&+.:'
(*"' !
!(!(1(&!- %
GA& !&& 1( & "!-+( -4+!2 :.
(1( %!&4(!-(&A'!
+1#! ! ( I-+ "
#*"(!
(+ (! ( C"# ! #! !4 ' &1 G+1#! ! H%F :< (#"-!+!2 .< (#"-!+1#! !!# (+1#!!# &!-!4(1$'#!#!!+&"4 ! '(*" & 2(((!# +1#!-"+4&"F2(("+!% @<(#!#"B"'4(
:@ (&!("-!("! !'( !&"- (1( %!&4'!&F! !&(&!(!-2 % "!+'!& !-!&'!&"!+!%+!' %!&4 &!+!2 !!1'(+ 1!!-+"-!&('!1( := (B"&"$2"+ ("- #!"'(*" (+ !2(("&(1((!-'1 #!'!&( !&'(%1!1!1&4'"(!&(+1#!! !#! +!2! &!-(+ (!(2! !+4 ( +&!& ((!-A# '!+&0 2 # (!&(' #(+4 ! (! - $!%'& ''#!1! 1# "+!2'"+!&%4
> :3 ("-A!# !4'"(!(B"&" !( "'!&"!+ :/ "($ 2 *" 2"+ !+ - &! C"!'&! ' !#!1 ! ( !# ! C" ' '!& -
# -4!*# *"!'& 1'% & ( !+2"+ -!"'+#!'+ 11'&+!#(!2"+ - C" -!&!
#!!+!#A C"'+!2J '!& && 1(!#"+ +'!&"!+ "!%+% $2 #!4-!''&%# 4&(!''&!&"!+!% # 4!%!+!-+( '!1!
! & 1 -'(*%+D*#!+*"(!!
! !
!'& 1'% &-4(&& *" :> ( K-+ "
#*"(!(+ (#!'
3 40"#3$ $ 5# 0"
# 6 0#5# +
"7!31 0 #3 !828+99!"
01
% 1 * 4 5 ! )
%
!
1 /%
5
7
/%
5
!
%% 6
18 9)
'(
!
% !
56 '!(
!
" 6 ' ( %
" 6 '(
?
%
%6
1:
*
!
/%
5 * 4 5 %
!
!
6
1;
$ % !
!
% %
!
!
! &%
* 4 5 )
6
14
.
/%
5
" /
/%
5 !"
. ) "
!
!
!
5 <
=% '>>8( ;
55 8??
@!!
+ "!
A
@
'?1:( 55 1>:
<" 9@
'>>(
;
55 48 % B :?
2"+ +2((*"!(B"&"1 ( " C" ' '!& ! ! 2(( ( '#! '"( -4 ( & '# 2! '!+ && ! ! 2((( & 1C"2#!+&"! '#! 2!02-'!+J"&(& "&-!&(' & "'+!2 (!(&+!#2(+#!&(!++1!'-!$ #!+&#&('+%+ -4( (
;
!1!( +&''&!+ :;
&$( # !(!1 -4 (2%1! ( !0&"(!+!% # 4!%!+!-+(#!&& !&2(+!2 # !&& 1+4 /, +' 2 + ( &. C
,(( !01D!
D ,(( !-+
D