← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8231/2014allowed

Sunita v. Managing Director Indian Bank And ORS

2017-02-07Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

   

      

"#$ %$&'(')* +,#+-)'#"$.'

$#'#')$/ (!

0$/(-( 1$ ")"2')2'/$&#/3)%'")")43")%#1$/( $(5)%$)# (!

 *  67   + 8 7+  /$($)#*9 /").'/+ 1"-1")3%.&"#$3 /#1$5$#'#')$/ //':1";")+')2<"3%.&"#$3 //$(5)%$)#(  1$#1$/#1$$5/#$/( <&"<)$;(5"5$/,"=:$"<<;$%# ($$#1$>-%2,$)#?

 :$/$ $//$%##1$$5/#$//)#  1$#1$/#1$>-%2,$)#(1-<%:$/$5/#$%')#1$%'2$(#? 99 99 7+ 

7!

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

1$"/')2##1$5$#'#')$/ )#1$/$5<=3/$(5)%$)#(&<"',#1"#"

#$/#1$%$"#1 +1/'

"<;")#+')21 1"-1")3 A9 ")"2$/3&$/#"')($/'-('//$2-<"/'#'$( /"-% &,,'##$%:=1',;$/$%$#$&#$%3;1'<$1$;"(;/4')2"#8"'#1"<:/")&13 %-/')2#1$&-/($ ')(5$&#') #$/#1$').$(#'2"#')3'#;"( -)%#1"#

99 (,$/$&$'5#( ;$/$,'((')2 /,#1$ ').$)#/= 1$(#")%#"4$):= /$(5)%$)#(')#1$;/'##$)(#"#$,$)#'(/$5/%-&$%"((-&1"(-)%$/*9 F!

1"#"

#$/#1$%$"#1 "

/$("'%$,5<=$$+1"<;")# +')21  1"-1")3  #1$  /$(5)%$)#  :")4  &",$  #  4);  ":-# &$/#"')  ($/'-(  '//$2-<"/'#'$( /"-%  &,,'##$%  :=  1',  ")% #1$/$ /$3#1$')(5$&#')&$<< $(5)%$)#")4&)%-&#$%"

/$2-<"/')(5$&') #1$8"'#1"</")&1")%%-/')2#1$&-/($ ')(5$&#')3#1$:/")&1/$&$'.$% -/ $/,$5('# $&$'5#(!  5-/5/#$%<=  '((-$%  :=  <"#$  +1  "<;")#  +')21

1"-1");1'<$;/4')2"#8"'#1"</")&1:-##1$(",$;$/$ )#  "55$"/')2  ')  #1$  /$&/%(    #1$  :/")&1  ")%  "

#$/ ').$(#'2"#')3'#;"( -)%#1"##1$($/$&$'5#(;$/$,'((')2

/,  #1$  ').$)#/=  ")%  /,  -/#1$/  $)D-'/=51=('&"< .$/'

'&"#')3'#;"( -)%#1"#EE$/,$5('#$&$'5#(;$/$ ,'((')2 /,#1$(#&41"##1$:/")&1&-<%5/&-/$)<=  $/, $5('#  $&$'5#(  ;1'&1  ;$/$  '((-$%  ') #1$  )",$ 

,$,:$/( #; ",'<'$(")%#1$ "#$ ,'((')2$/, $5('#$&$'5#("/$)#(#'<<4);) 1"##1$/$;$/$,")= #1$/(-(5'&'-(#/")("&#')(')#1$$/,$5('# &&-)#( )#'&$%:=#1$')(5$&#')#$",1"#-# $/,$5('# $&$'5#(;1'&1#1$:/")&11"%5/&-/$%%$#"'<3;$/$#/"&$% ')#1$1-($ <"#$+1"<;")#+')21")%;$/$&<"',$%:= )$  -5#"  ",'<=  ")%  -/  :=  ")#1$/   ",'<=  '((-$% &<")%$(#')$<=:=#1$%$&$"($%$,5<=$$ )"%%'#')3 /$&$'5#(1$<%:= -5#" ",'<=;$/$5/$9&<($%')#1$&,5-#$/ (=(#$,  )  ."/'-(  %"#$(  ;'#1-#  /'2')"<  /$&$'5#(  :=  #1$ %$&$"($%

'&$/")%#1$5/&$$%(;$/$"<<$2$%<=('51)$%

:=#1$%$&$"($%

'&$/:=5$)')2 /"-%-<$)#(".')2"&&-)#( ")%#1$/$ /$3#1$&<"',1"%"/'($) //$&$'5#( G G!(

"/H 1$/$ /$3'#'((#"#$%#1"#"(-, (3391"(:$$) 5"'%##1$&<"',")#(3"(5$/#1$")4')2 ,:-%(,")/%$/ )($D-$)#<=3 #1$:")41"((-

$/$%"<(( (339( "/5"/# /,("'%<((3

99 ')$.$)# &<"',("/'(')2)-)#/"&$%,'((')2#$/,%$5('#/$&$'5#(")% 5((':<$-)"&&-)#$%#/")("&#')')#$/,%$5('#"&&-)#(')#1$:4 #1$ :")43#1$##"<<(('(,-&11'21$/#1")#1"##'( -/#1$/(#"#$%#1"##1$/$'( (#'<<-#(#")%')2<'":'<'#= (3 3C9"()")%#1"#(#'<<"

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

(,$/$&/%'(,'((')2")%#1$:")4'( #1$.'$;#1"##1$%$&$"($%$,5<=$$1"(&,,'##$%(,$ /"-%;'#1#1$ :")43#1$)"#<$"(#(,$')#$/)"<')D-'/='(/$D-'/$%#:$1$<%# 'A#1$ /$(5)(':'<'#="

#$/2'.')2")55/#-)'#= 1$"/')2##1$5$#'#')$/#'( )<="

#$/#1$')D-'/=&"):$1$<%"(#;1$#1$/#1$:/")&1,")"2$/;"( /$(5)(':<$ /#1$<(( #1$("'%$/,$5('#$&$'5#(/(,$#1$/ $,5<=$$;"(').<.$% $/$<=)#1$:"('( ')(5$&#')")% ')%')2#1"# $/,$5('#$&$'5#("/$,'((')23#1$:")4;"()#>-(#' '$%')

>-,5')2##1$&)&<-(')#1"##1$:/")&1,")"2$/'(/$(5)(':<$ /#1$ (",$1$5((':'<'#='(#1"#(,$,'(&1'$.-("&#;"(%)$:=(,$#1$/ $,5<=$$ #1$:")4")%#1$("'%$/,$5('#$&$'5#(,'21#1".$2# ,'((')2  ')  #1"#  5/&$((   1$/$ /$3  #  ;'#11<%  ")  ",-)#    ( 339   /,  #1$  #$/,')"<  :$)$ '#(    #1$  %$&$"($%  $,5<=$$  '( -)>-(#'

'$% 1$<$"/)$%&-)($< /#1$5$#'#')$/ -/#1$/&<"',(#1"#) ')#$/$(#1"(:$$)5"'% /#1$/$,"')')2:$)$ '#(3"</$"%=/$<$"($%##1$ 5$#'#')$/3;1'&1;$/$;'#11$<%:=/$(5)%$)#( /"/-)%E=$"/( )#1$($&'/&-,(#")&$(3'#'(1$<%#1"#;'#11<%')2")",-)#

(3393;'#1-# 'A')2#1$/$(5)(':'<'#= #1$%$&$"($%,")"2$/3 '('<<$2"<")%'(1$/$:=($#"('%$ 8$$5')2').'$;#1$ "&##1"##1$/$'( "<<$2$%%$ "<&"#')3/$(5)%$)#("/$);2'.$)#1/$$,)#1(6#',$ /,#1$ %"#$ /$&$'5# &$/#'

'$%&5= #1'(/%$/#1<%")')D-'/=")% 'A#1$ /$(5)(':'<'#="

#$/2'.')2")55/#-)'#= 1$"/')2##1$5$#'#')$/")% #1$/$"

#$/)<=#1$",-)#3 /;1'&1#1$%$&$"($%+1/'"<;")#+')21

1"-1")3  A9 ")"2$/3  '(  1$<%  /$(5)(':<$3  (1"<<  :$  ;'#11$<%  ")%  #1$ /$,"')')2",-)#(1"<<:$/$<$"($%##1$5$#'#')$/;'#1')#$/$(#"##1$/"#$ BI5$/"))-,',,$%'"#$<=#1$/$"

#$/;$.$/3"##1$(",$#',$3'#'(

-/#1$/1$<%#1"#'

#1$:")4'(-)":<$# ')%-##1"#+1/'"<;")#+')21

1"-1")3 A9 ")"2$/3;"(/$(5)(':<$ /#1$("'%"<<$2$%<((3#1$",-)# "<)2;'#1  ":.$,$)#')$%  /"#$    ')#$/$(#3  (1"<<  :$  /$<$"($%  #  #1$ 5$#'#')$/+')&$#1$/$,"')')2:$)$ '#(1".$:$$);'#11$<% /"/-)%('A =$"/(3#1$/$ /$3#1$:")4'(/%$/$%#5"=BI5$/"))-,')#$/$(#)#1$ 5"=,$)#"</$"%=/$<$"($%##1$5$#'#')$/3(#"/#')2#1/$$,)#1( /,#1$

9C9 %"#$ %$"#1 #1$%$&$"($%$,5<=$$#'<<#1$%"#$ 5"=,$)# 1$5/$($)#;/'#5$#'#')'(5"/#<="<<;$%

7+ !

 

 (>4( 1$#1$/(5$"4')2/$"()$% * $( 1$#1$/$5/#":<$ *