← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8232/2014disposed of

Kulwant Rai Sharma v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-10-07Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages



    

!"!#$!%&' () * +,!!-.".&'(  * /012+&, +.34+#5+ !,.,.&!# 7!#"0"

3,+,!+#8+&+,4!#"

!"9&%!&,"

 

  

      

#!"!&,'6 #348+5/05+#34+#5+:%$-+,!# ,4!9!,.,.&!# #!!9+;+18+&:%%1:+#8+&+ #!!9+;3+<4+#2+1:%$-+,!#  =#!"9&%!&,"&, >>>       4!.&",+&,9!,.,.&."%.#!-,!%+?+.&",,4!#!"059,.&+& .&%0",#.+191,<8,4! +0,4#.,.!" 

+-,""!,0,&<!4+1,4!9!,.,.&!#+#!,4+,.&%0",#.+191, &: 4+"!6: +&-4;01++%5!+"0#.&?

"@5!,!#"2+"+11,,!%$.%!

+11,5!&,1!,,!#%+,!%

A )).&+$0#,4!9!,.,.&!#0&%!#,4!  @0,+4!!&,.#!-","0-4.&%0",#.+191,",+&%"%0189+.%+&%%!9".,!% +&%+""0-4&,4.&?#!5+.&"9+8+<1!, .&"+#+"-",.&?."

-&-!#&!%  $!&  ,40?4:  -1+0"!  (    ,4!  +11,5!&,  1!,,!#  ",+,!"  ,4+, 9""!"".&,4!91,2+"<!.&?!#!%+1&?2.,4,4!+11,5!&,1!,,!#<0, +-,0+1948".-+19""!"".&2+"%!1.$!#!%& ))*&",#0-,.&2+"

#+."!%<8,4!9!,.,.&!#.&,4!8!+# ))*.,"!1+&%--09+,.&-!#,..-+,!

%+,!%  ))*2+".""0!%<8,4!",+,! .-!#: : +&-4;01+:

#!"9&%!&,& .&#!"9!-,,4!?#0&%1#+,&&!B0#! 6A,4+"<!!&

66 +$!##!%,4+,,4!9!,.,.&!#"!,09,4!9.1,9#C!-,.&,4!8!+#" ))6))# 5+&0+-,0#!<+,,!#8!1.5.&+,#"<0,&+--0&,5+#;!,-&%.,.&",4! 9#C!-,  <!-+5!  0&$.+<1!  +&%  #!"01,+&,18  ,4!  9!,.,.&!#  2+"  #-!%  , +<+&%&,4!9#C!-,-!#,..-+,!4+"<!!&91+-!%&#!-#%+,&&!B0#!

,+""!#,,4+,#5!-!5<!#: )))+&%#+9!#.%+15",8!+#":

,4! 9!,.,.&!# 2+"  "0!#.&?  #5 #!&+1  +&%  9#",+,!  +.15!&,"  +&%  2+" 0&%!#?.&?#!?01+#,#!+,5!&,.&+4"9.,+1.&,4! &.,!%/.&?%5"9!# -!#,..-+,!  +,  &&!B0#!    ,4!  9!,.,.&!#  !$!&  0&%!#2!&,  #!9!+,!% .&$+".$!9#-!%0#!"#,#!+,5!&, 1,.5+,!18&  +#!@0!",2+"

#2+#%!%,#!"9&%!&,& #-4+&?!9#C!-,#5<+,,!#8!1.5.&+,#" ,&#5+,.&!-4&1?80".&!"" #-!"" 0,"0#-.&?    &.,  2!$!#:.&,!#5" #%!#%+,!% * 9+""!%<8,4!

",+,! .-!#: : +&-4;01+=#!"9&%!&,& :,4!.&%0",#.+191,.& @0!",.&  2+"  #!"05!%  &  ,4!  ?#0&%"    5."0"!#  .!  <!.&?  0"!%  # #!".%!&,.+190#9"!"+&%&+--0&,9#%0-,.&4+$.&?&,-55!&-!% 9+#,#5#!"059,.&:#!.,0#! D,4!-&".%!#+,.&5&!89+.% ,2+#%",4!91,2+"+1"%.#!-,!%4!#%!##!"059,.&",+&%"+.#5!% <8  ,4!  99!11+,!  +"  2!11  +"  !$.".&+1  0,4#.,.!"  $.%!  #%!#"  %+,!%  A &&!B0#! ( +&%

&&!B0#! ) #!"9!-,.$!18

!"01,+&,18:,4!9#!"!&,9!,.,.& * E!+#&!%-0&"!1+99!+#.&?#,4!9!,.,.&!#4+"$!4!5!&,18 -&,!&%!%,4+,.&,4!+-,"+&%-.#-05",+&-!",4!-+"!,4!!B,#!5!",!9 #!"059,.&,4!.&%0",#.+191,.",,+1180&2+##+&,!%,.""0<5.,,!%,4+, ,4!,,+1-",,4!91,",%%!9".,!%2.,4,4! +0,4#.,.!",!# ,+;.&?948".-+19""!"".&,4!91,.&9#.1: ))*:&,.5!2+"1",+&% -&",#0-,.&2+"#+."!%,4!#!09&2.,4.&+#!-#%,.5!+&%2+"-591!,!%

66 .&,4!8!+# ))*.,"!1$!&--09+,.&-!#,..-+,!.&#!"9!-,,4!?#0&% 1#2+".""0!%<8,4!-59!,!&,+0,4#.,8&  ))* ,4+"<!!& +#?0!%  ,4+,  ,4!  #.?.&+1  9#C!-,    <+,,!#8  !1.5.&+,#"  4+$.&?  <!-5! 0&$.+<1!:+#!@0!",#-4+&?!9#C!-,2+""0<5.,,!%&  +&% 2.,40,!$!&,+;.&?+&8%!-.".&.&,!#5"+--!%.&?,#%!-1.&.&?"0-4 #!@0!",+&#%!##!"059,.&%+,!% *4+"<!!&9+""!%"9!# -0&"!1"0-4+-,.&"5+-;"+#<.,#+#.&!""+&%,4!#!"9&%!&,"0?4,, 4+$!#!"#,!%,,4!!B,#!5!9!&+1,8#!"059,.&&18+"+1+",#!"#,, 2+"+1"+#?0!%,4+,<!#!,4!99!11+,!+"+1",4! !$.".&+10,4#.,.!":

,4!9!,.,.&!#4+%!#!%,"0<5.,+&0&%!#,+;.&?,-55!&-!.&%0",#.+1 9#%0-,.&2.,4.&+",.901+,!%,.5!#+5!<0,"0-4"0<5."".&4+"<!!& $!#1;!%"#!?+#%",4!?#0&%5."0"!#:-0&"!1201%"0<5.,,4+, &18&!#5&,4!?#0&%1#4+%<!!&0"!%#,4!#!".%!&-!+ 2+,-45+& +&% ,4!"+5!201% &,  +50&, , 5."0"!.&,!#5"  ,4! +#8+&+  #<+&  !$!195!&,  0,4#.,8  #!-,.&    0.1%.&?"

!?01+,.&": )():24!#!0&%!#-$!#!% +#!+09 ,  D ,4!91, ."

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

-1+0"!

  ,4! +11,5!&,  1!,,!# ,4! 91,  +"  +1" <0.1%.&?  -&",#0-,!% ,4!#!09&-01%<!0"!%&18#,4!90#9"!#24.-4.,4+%<!!&+11,,!% +&%#!+%+1&?2.,4-1+0"! 24.-4",.901+,!%,4+,<0.1%.&?2+",<!

-&",#0-,!%2.,4.&8!+#"#5,4!%+,!9""!"".&+&!-!""+#8-#11+#8 201%+#."!,4+,.&%0",#.+1+-,.$.,84+%,-55!&-!2.,4.&"0-4,.5! 9!#.% 0#.&?,4!-0#"!+#?05!&,"#3+<4+#2+14+".&$.,!%0# +,,!&,.&,+&",+,!+&+?!5!&, #-!%0#! 1.-8:* 4!#!.&+,!#,<!

#!!##!%+" 1.-8:*  "0<"!@0!&,18#!$."!%.&,4!8!+#")+&% 

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

-,4+"<!!&,!#5!%<8,4! -0&"!1+"+5!#!!8!2+"4+&%+&!B!#-.",?+.&,.5! ( +$.&?4!+#%,4!#.$+1-&,!&,.&":2!+#!,4!-&".%!#!% $.!2,4+,,4!$+1.%.,8,4!.590?&!%#!"059,.&#%!#%+,!% * &!!%&,<!?&!.&,<80"+,,4."",+?!,."+.,-+"!##!5+&%+&%# #!-&".%!#+,.&+,,4!4+&%",4! !$."&+10,4#.,8.!,4! #.&-.9+1 3!-#!,+#8,$,+#8+&+:2&+&%0&,#8 1+&&.&?

6*6 !9+#,5!&,=#!"9&%!&,& &,4!112.&?.""0!"'6

.

!#0"+1,4!#%!#%+,!%

9+""!%<8#!"9&%!&,&

%!-1.&.&?  ,4!  #!$.".&  9!,.,.&  9#!!##!%  <8  ,4!  9!,.,.&!#  +&%  ,4!#!<8 +.#5.&?,4!#%!##!"059,.&201%#!$!+1,4+,,4!"+5!4+"<!!& 9+""!%<8#!!##.&?,-1+0"! ,4!+11,5!&,1!,,!#+&%09&9#-!!%.&? &  ,4!  +""059,.&  ,4+,  ,4!  9!,.,.&!#  2+"  #!@0.#!%  ,  -591!,!  ,4! -&",#0-,.&09&,4!91,+&%,.591!5!&,,4!9#C!-,,4!#!09&2.,4.&+ 9!#.%8!+#"#5,4!%+,!!#9""!"".&+&%4!4+$.&?+.1!%, -59182.,4"0-4",.901+,.& ,  201%  <!  +99".,!  ,  #!!#  ,  -1+0"! 

 +&%      ,4!

+11,5!&,1!,,!#%+,!%

A ))+&%,4!"+5!#!+%+"112"'6 

 



    

               

                     

 

   

 

  

   

   







        

         

  

 

   

 

                       

  !  "            

     



 

  

   

     

 #                  $      

 

          %   

                      !   " 

        

  

& 1+0"!

",.901+,!",4+,,4!91,=<0.1%.&?."&,,<!0"!%# +&890#9"!,4!#,4+&#24.-4.,4+"<!!&+11,,!%+&%-1+0"! 

6A6 5+&%+,!",4!+11,,!!,-591!,!-&",#0-,.&2.,4.&8!+#",4!%+,! !#9""!"".&+,!#?!,,.&?,4!91+&",4!9#9"!%<0.1%.&?+99#$!% #5,4!-59!,!&,+0,4#.,8+&%"0-4,.5!1.5.,<!.&?!B,!&%+<1!<8,4! ",+,! .-!#09&<!.&?"+,.".!%,4+,&&6-&",#0-,.&2+"%0!,#!+"&" <!8&%,4!-&,#1,4!+11,,!! !.,4!#-1+0"!

&#-1+0"! 1+8"

%2&+&8,.5!#+5!#-55!&-!5!&,.&%0",#.+19#%0-,.&0&"!1 +99!+#.&?# 4+"+1"9.&,!%0,,0"+&8,4!#-&%.,.&=-1+0"! -&,+.&!%.&,4!+11,5!&,1!,,!#24.-4201%#!?01+,!,4!,.5!#+5!# -55!&-!5!&,-55!#-.+19#%0-,.&#,2+#%".591!5!&,+,.&,4! 9#C!-,2+#%"C0",.8.&?,4!+-,.&#!"059,.&#&&6.591!5!&,+,.& ,4!9#C!-,,4!  1.-8:*4+"<!!&#!1.!%09&<8,4!-0&"!1 0#.0"18:,4! 1.-8:*4+"&,!$!&<!!&+%$!#,!%,<8,4!

!$.".&+10,4#.,824.1!9+"".&?,4!.590?&!%#%!# -98,4!   1.-8:*24.-44+"<!!&9#%0-!%.&0#,:#!-.,!",4+,,4!"+5! "4+11<!!!-,.$!2!

* ""0-4:.,201%<!.59!#+,.$!#,4! !$.".&+10,4#.,8, 4+$!+#!61;+"#!?+#%",2+"9!-,"2.,4#!?+#%,,4!.59".,.& #!"059,.&&+--0&,&&6.591!5!&,+,.&,4!9#C!-, .#",18-1+0"!

,4!+11,5!&,1!,,!##!!##!%,<8,4! !$.".&+10,4#.,8.&,4!

.590?&!%  #%!#  &18  ",.901+,!"  ,4!  ,.5!  #+5!  #  -591!,.&   -&",#0-,.&.!2.,4.&8!+#"#5,4!%+,!!#9""!"".&+&%%!" &,  ",.901+,!  +&8  ,.5!  #+5!  ,2+#%"  .591!5!&,+,.&    ,4!  9#C!-, 3!-&%18:,4!+991.-+<.1.,8,4!  1.-8:*201%.,"!1<!+ 5,9.&,+",4!"+5!4+%<!-5!!!-,.$!2!

*:24!#!+",4!

#%!##!"059,.&2+"9+""!%<8,4!-59!,!&,+0,4#.,8!+#1.!#.&9.&, ,.5!.!& *

6(6

..

"  #!?+#%"  ,4!  "!-&%  ?#0&%  09&  24.-4  ,4!  #%!#   #!"059,.&4+"<!!&9+""!%.!F5."0"!#G !?01+,.& ,4! 

#!-,.&    0.1%.&?"  !?01+,.&":  )()  201%  <!  #!1!$+&,  +&%  ,4!

#!1!$+&,9#,.&,4!#!."!B,#+-,!%4!#!0&%!#'6   



    

    

  '( 

  

 

    

  

   

 # 

     

                

 !"#$ %& +B.5059!#5."".<1!

-$!#+?!&?#0&% +B.5059!#5."".<1!1# +#!+#+,. +B.5054!.?4,,4!

.&%0",#.+1<0.1%.&?

A9!#-!&,+#!+,4!

".,!

*9!#-!&,  5!,!#"

"        

)     

   

   *      + ,      

 

                    

 '       ( 

     %#

 

      

   *   -           %       .

$/ 

  

 

0 

       1     

       

   $   & &,!#5""0-4#!?01+,.&AD,4!+#!+,4!".,!.",4! 5+B.505-$!#+?!9!#5."".<1!&,4!?#0&%1# 3,.110#,4!#:0, "0-49!#5."".<1!-$!#!%+#!+09, D5+8<!0"!%#+&-.11+#8+&% #!".%!&,.+1@0+#,!#"#!""!&,.+12+,-4+&%2+#%",+1!+#18:#+?#0&% F5."0"!#G,<!5+%!,4!0&%+,.&+#!"059,.&#%!#:+.&%.&?

66 201%4+$!,<!#!,0#&!%+?+.&",,4!+11,,!!<8+9918.&?9+#+5!,!#"1+.% %2&0&%!# !?01+,.& .,"!1 "0-4.&%.&?4+"<!!&#!,0#&!%

!-&".%!#+,.&  &  ,4!  ?#0&%    F5."0"!#G  ,  "0",+.&  +&  #%!#   #!"059,.&201%:+""0-4:<!#!@0.#!% 

# ,4! #!+"&"  #!-#%!%  +<$!: ,4!  2#.,  9!,.,.&  ."  9+#,18 +112!%,,4!!B,!&,"!,,.&?+".%!,4!#%!#%+,!%

&&!B0#!

) :9+""!%<8,4! !$.".&+10,4#.,8.!#!"9&%!&,& +,,!#."

#!5+&%!%<+-;,#!"9&%!&,& ,#!-&".%!#,4!.""0!#!"059,.& ,4!.&%0",#.+191,.&,4!1.?4,,4!<"!#$+,.&"-&,+.&!%.&,4."#%!#

!"9&%!&,& 201%<!<1.?+,!%,+#%,4!9!,.,.&!#+&99#,0&.,8 5+;.&?2#.,,!&"0<5."".&"+"+1"+9!#"&+14!+#.&? ) !4+$!<!!&.&#5!%,4+,,4!9!,.,.&!#."",.11.&9""!"".& ,4!91, 9!#+,.&,4!.590?&!%#!"059,.&#%!#%+,!% * "4+11<!;!9,.&+<!8+&-!#+9!#.% 2!!;"+&%201%<!"0<C!-,, ,4!9+"".&?+&#%!#+#!"4<8#!"9&%!&,& +"%.#!-,!%4!#!.&+<$!

 ,.":42!$!#:5+%!-1!+#,4+,&,4.&?-&,+.&!%.&,4."#%!# 201%<!-&",#0!%+"+&!B9#!"".&0#9.&.&&,4!5!#.,",4! -+"!4!#!"9&%!&,"+#!+1"+,1.<!#,8,.&.,.+,!+-,.&.&#!"9!-,,4! +11!?+,.&,4+,,4!9!,.,.&!#4+%!&,!#!%.&,+&+?#!!5!&,#"+1!,4! 91,+",4!.590?&!%+-,.&2+"&,<+"!%&,4."?#0&%

!,.,.&."%."9"!% 

!"

#$ % #! %&''

% ( "

)* %&'

#+(* )# + &#  ,-.,/,.0 10-;8 4!,4!#,<!#!!##!%, !9#,!#H!"