High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25600/2018disposed of

Kartik Saini(Minor) Through His Father v. Union Of India & ORS

2018-11-22Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma3 pages

!"#$%& "%'%

($%$%)'(# (#*+* '%)'),'-%""'-)$.(#*

(*/)'-('$* 0

1 0

1 #(*('$

#(*('$

# "#%*. ."#2" -3)4"$(,)#$.(/($%$%)'(# 565656 565656 565656 565656 ($%$%)'(# !"#$%& "%'% 7.%8( *$+-9%': %' )$+* '$(#'"$%)'"8 4.))8 %'"'":"# %*$#%4$ +#-"*/+#;#(*/)'-('$

) <"//("#(-%'$.(2"$#%4+8"$%)'(="2%'"$%)'4)'-+4$(-+'-(# $.("(:%*),('$#"8)"#-), (4)'-"#9 -+4"$%)' (7(8.%%'

$.( 9("# > +'-(# )88 ) ?@@ ' $.( 2"$#%4+8"$%)'

4(#$%,%4"$(%**+(-A9$.(('$#"8)"#-), (4)'-"#9 -+4"$%)'

'"2( ), $.( ,"$.(# ), $.( /($%$%)'(# ."* A((' 2('$%)'(- "* "B(*.!+2"# "%'% '*$"'$7#%$/($%$%)'."*A((',%8(-*((&%':%**+"'4(), -%#(4$%)'* $) $.( #(*/)'-('$0+$.)#%$%(* $) 2"&( '(4(**"#9 4)##(4$%)' %' $.( 4(#$%,%4"$( /(#$"%'%': $) 2"$#%4+8"$%)' (="2%'"$%)' ''(=+#( "'-A9#("-%':$.('"2(),$.(,"$.(# ),$.(/($%$%)'(#"*"B(*.!+2"#!"8"%'*$("-),"B(*.!+2"#

"%'% ("#'(-4)+'*(8*+A2%$*$."$,"$.(#),$.(/($%$%)'(#%*

"'(=0*(#3%4(2"'."3%':*(#3(-$.('-%"'%#)#4("'-%'.%*

(#3%4(%*4."#:())& ('*%)' "92('$ #-(# -."#"#-"* "8*))$.(#-)4+2('$* '"2(%*2('$%)'(-"*"B(*.!+2"#!"8" +#$.(#+#:(-$."$,)#48"%2%':A('(,%$*A(%': 7"#- ),"'(=0 *(#3%4(2"' 7.%8( *((&%': "-2%**%)' $) 3"#%)+* (-+4"$%)'"8 4)+#*(* /($%$%)'(#7)+8-A(*(#%)+*89/#(B+-%4(-%,$.(4)##(4$%)' /#"9(-,)#%*')$"88)7(- $%*A#)+:.$$)$.(')$%4(),$.%*)+#$ $."$ "' "//8%4"$%)' -"$(- ?

''(=+#( ."* (3('

A(('2"-($)$.((:%)'"8 ,,%4(

"'4.&+8"C"#9"'"D *((&%': $.( '(4(**"#9 4)##(4$%)' A+$$.(*"2( ."* ')$ A((' #(*/)'-(-$)$%88-"$( $%*$.(4)'$('$%)' #"%*(-A98("#'(- 4)+'*(8$."$$.(4)##(4$%)'/#"9(-,)#7)+8-A(4)3(#(-+'-(#$.( #(8(3"'$ ="2%'"$%)'9("7*,#"2(-A9$.(('$#"8)"#-),

(4)'-"#9 -+4"$%)'

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

< 44)#-%':89 7%$.)+$(3('"*4(#$"%'%':$.(4)##(4$'(** ),$.("3(#2('$*2"-(%'$.(/($%$%)'"'-7%$.)+$:)%':%'$)$.( 2(#%$*),$.(4"*( %'*$"'$/($%$%)'%*-%*/)*(-),7%$."-%#(4$%)' $) #(*/)'-('$ ) % ( $.( )%'$ (4#($"#9 ('$#"8 )"#- ),

(4)'-"#9 -+4"$%)' (:%)'"8 ,,%4(# "'4.&+8";4)2/($('$ "+$.)#%$9$)(="2%'($.("//8%4"$%)'-"$(-? ''(=+#( % ( *$"$(-$)."3("8#("-9A(('*+A2%$$(-"'-$)-(4%-(%' "44)#-"'4( 7%$. 8"7 "'- "* /(# #(8(3"'$ "//8%4"A8( #+8(*; %'*$#+4$%)'*%**+(-A9$.(

"'-$)4)'3(9$.(,%'"8-(4%*%)'

$)$.(/($%$%)'(#7%$.%'"/(#%)-),$7)7((&*,#)2$.(-"$(), #(4(%/$),"4(#$%,%(-4)/9),$.%*)#-(# ($%$%)'-%*/)*(-), C D C D C D C D

)$(

.($.(#*/("&%':;#("*)'(-

(*;

) .($.(#(/)#$"A8(

(*;

)