← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/176/2021dismissed

The Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Central), Ludhiana v. M/S Arora Iron And Steel Rolling Mills Pvt. Ltd.

2023-11-02Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan6 pages

 



 !"# $   #   

%&#&'(( ) * 

    

 



   !" 

 $ "



)+", !

- --#., +",-!

- 

/

!.  %

& ' "

!!

# 

  

  --#.,0!1 2 (   )# 

 * 

  '

(+, (+- ./.(0 1

#2     

  !"#$!%&'() !!* +, !

-.$%/%% 0+ %% *$'$) . ' (+, ./.( 1   !

.,/  (3,(#

 .-/4./.(

5

  16       

      #  

   7  7

' (.3(89./(3 

6./(45(, !

6' (+- ./.( 1   

6./(,5 (+#

  $ 

16 

   #    

  

 5( /./+./(3

516

# 

 



   

 *







 

 

 1

 ;  

$ 1 

1 16

  



  

 

#  

   #$    1

6  * 

      * #

  



     

    6     

#6  

    $     1 $

* #6 $  * 1 #

$ * 

 $

16

5





" 6

   6

* 

   

#  :  

 

#           1  )

#   

    <  #1  16"$ *  

    6    2     

  $      

7    * 



  *  " -,(  " (3,. 1 #1     ;  



 * 

*

16

 

#  1 = 

 ,   6

#

 

 

  

#.   * 

#1





*    

 * 

 *

1 #     

6$  2

1   #* 1 2  *

 

  # 

1 2  

 $   1 2   

1 6

1 2  

*



 

6$

6

  $ # $ 1   

16 

    *

#

%5       

                

  

  

  

    !



  

 " ! 

#  $%& '

(   !

 (         )  

         !  

  )     

) 

  ) 

       )   !    (    

*(      

    

 )    +,                  -

     .  &/$0$'   )    12 $&%&34 3&/$% 

  

 *     )   !   

 ) 

2 )                 1 $&%$34 3&/$%* *  ( 

  

 

* 

 

     5 - 

  *

1 =

 *  # 1

%5

!6    

  

 *4 -  ( )  )







   

 

#

!

 )

  

           *    

 )  

  *(  



)       # 

 (  " $!     

  #  *  $%&

!6    

  

 *4 -  ( )

  )      

 

#

!

   )  

 

 (     )      

 )  ) ) )                 (    

          

  )  (             ) 2

        (          

 

#

! 



  " 7!     

  #  *  $%&

!  6             

    *4 -  ( )

   )    



        

 

  # 

!  (      

    



 " 7! 

# *$%&

!  6    )      &"/8&/&$*        4 - 

  #

      (       5 4 :

/3/../.< 5 

> 

  *

* ) 

%5  



9 

       )  

          )  2

*  (

            

3

(      (

       

   

  # 

!0$*        

     &"/8&/&$   #  07!            

(      )2

   &%/7&/&7

           

   5 ,  .4/+./.<  *

# *

%5  

 )



 9    

 :

  (   

*

()  

  )

 ;

  /&$$&/&7

           

   5 +  6  

 





  

   *



 

#

$ 1   



  *1 #  16

 ; ?$ #  #  

6 *



6



: 2    



    1 1 # 6 1

  

5

$ 



   $

 !

(<<," 6 



  



* 6

   16   

6            

    

 

 



 1)

# 

  

 

   



 "

.4;-++/..5*

 1 3      

*  #  

 *





  



 "

# 1 1 2 

    6

 * 

#





 $!

 1 $

$ 1   )

#  *   6

# $  

6   



   * *    *

  

* $   

1  1 6 

 6* 

 $   *      1 $ 

    1   (/  

 1 =

 ** 

# 1



 6  " 6





  

 &!!'98? @A9&B /.((./.< 8""BBCA"@BB?'

$

@A9&B ?



2

D

? 1 '