High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3585/2022dismissed

Baljeet And Others v. Prem Chand And Others

2025-02-20Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages

! "# $%&'

"%(%) $%&

& *+

,-.

! "

% & ' ((( -.

/+0 ) "

*+,-*,**

.! # 0/ "10 23 4 .

# .! # 15 # % +3 / 6 +/&& #

/ &7,81#

9:3#

* ) #

" #

## 1

3 % & ' 3 # / #

$" # " #;

;*; " !

#$%& ' (

"! $

)# *

# #

+ ) $,-. $.

-- ,- ( # /0 $. -%- ,- 1 ! (" 1 # ( ) "! 2

)# *

$,-$ ,2 1 #

""! $-

)# *

# #

" (

) !3 -4- 4- $2 4. ) !

(

"! ) !

# #!')

# ) !

(# !

" ! #

" !

" #5

! (

"0(

) !

# #

! 7 8( !

" ( ) !

9 < ) /

.! # .! !

15/ ;*3 ' 2/ " ! / 15/ ;<3 / 6 + / && #

# "

/ 5 *-&,&78< /"

&',&*,,<

" / % *

*=,+&7*+ / " #) /"

. "

/ / .

" ,',&&7=, / % *, *<&&&78+

> ,8&,&78, ?

## / # #

/ ! " !

!#. .!

@ ./ "

" #

/ " #

;<;

## / # / .

.! - )

.! ! ! 15/ ;'3

" . . # !

5 A/ ## #

/ .

/ ? #/

/ #

/ ##

" " / " /

# .

*,&-

! / !

0/*,&= #

# # ## ?

/ ? #/

/ / .#

# ## /

? #/

. #

#" / . ! ! # /"

" #" #

= B

/ #

+ B

/ "

! / #

# ! < - #C #

/. # " "

/ # !

/ # B

/ /. "

/ /"

. .

;'; 8 "

/ ! .

.! #

/. #" / .

" / B

/ /. /

/ /

/ !

? /

/ : ;"" ) /& $-$$<= ;:;<:)=$,> $ ?( )@ )(& !<+

=<?= * A;'6 $-$-<2=;:;<:)= 4> 2 ;" / 0'@ /"B" ( '6 $-$2<$=@:;<:)=$4.> & @0( @ ) & C" & ' 6 $-$ <$= ;:; <:)=$4.> % *@ )")*/ <

.=::,.> ,

!)"&'6 $-<2 =;:;<:)= $-, . ; ) 1 )A'@ /;@* #:

$- <=;:;<:)=$%- 7

/ "

/. "!

# ! /"

" # / B

/. /!

/ /.

/ . A/ .

/ #

/. /!

/ ! ## / # # / C

/. /#

. # #

/ . # B

;-; / / # # B.

" #

. /# / /!"" /

"5 / C /. /"

# !" # #

? /

/ #

; /@## ) &!" $-%<=;:;<:)=,.> $ C !

A" ) ; # $--$<$=;:;<:)=42> 2 B B)@ !

6 A D ?

?E$$$,$ ! (

0 A ) & # ,2 A;,. &, ?

/ " && #

" / .

5 A/ .$ " / 6 ,+/&&? #

# !

.! ; # . ! #

# . / " # D&! # /0 "#B F$-.@;:% 2? / "

/ # ? #

/ &* "

/ # / A/ # #

/ # # . / " #D

#; ! ) A"

;=; / 0 F$-$$<=::%.$ / " / / " / #? #D"? @#( 6 /" 6) *00 6 F$-$ @;<:=%$$% /. ! / #?

#:;""//& 6 F1 / 3 ##

. .

" / # .!

.! ) .

/! / # .! / #?

?# / # # #

.! A/ .

/ ! "

/ / A/ #)

/ #? .

/ 12 # % 34 5# "6 %3! 5%$ 577 8539%! 9% 34 :759%3 ;934 " !: )3 3 "5($ 5" %3 !(::"3 $ <= 5%= ("34 " 5# "6 %3! 5%$ 577 8539%!4;34 "5($45!< %)66933 $>:75= $ " !3539%89% 34 :759%334535"5($45!< %:75= $9!%3 %(845%$34 577 8539%! "5($6(!3< !: )99)577=5# "" $9%34 :759%3034 ";9! 6 " 7=<= (!9%834 ;"$?"5($?034 :759%39!;(7$3"=38 334 !(93!;9349% 34 79693539%0;49)434 ";9! 65=< <5"" $<=79693539%4 " " 0 # %934 !(<69!!9%%< 45734 " !:%$ %3!@"989%57:759%39! 3453%7=34 5# "6 %3!5%$577 8539%!9%34 :759%3!5" " A(9" $3< )%!9$ " $5334 396 $ )9$9%834 5::79)539%(%$ " "$ "- (7 BB 9! 5)) :3 $0 9% 3453 )5! 57! <= !()4 #58( 577 8539%! ;934 " !

: )3334 $53 C%;7 $8 034 :759%39!)5%%3< : "6933 $3 )4577 %8 34 $)(6 %3! 53 " 5 : "9$ B = 5"! = !()4 5 )7 # " $"539%85%$(!9%834 ;"$?"5($?034 :759%39!45# 3"9 $3<"9%8 34 !(93! ;9349% 34 : "9$ 79693539% 9%#C9%8 , )39% B2 34 79693539% )3 4 :759%39! )5%%3 < : "6933 $ 3 <"9%8 34 !(93! ;9349% 34 : "9$ 79693539% <= )7 # " $"539%80 ;49)4 34 ";9! 9! <5"" $<=79693539%3349!!358 05" ) %3$ )9!9%349!("39%34 )5! 584; %$"5,45"5%,9%84 !(:"59!" A(9" $3< " "" $3 % 34 !59$ $ )9!9%0 349! ("3 45$ ))5!9% 3 )%!9$ " 577 5"79 " $ )9!9%!% D ")9! :; "!(%$ " "$ "- (7 BB 0;49)4 5" )%!9$ " $<=349!("39%:5"58"5:4!'3E5!

(%$ "&@ G, * @ )" H* @ )" ) */ < ..= :: ,.

;+;

) 6 .;! : :

% ( ) ! J<:: .-= G%3 ) # "#

" "

! !#"

7#:

! #(

D ! 8:

# "!

)# * ! "! " "( " # !

" #

" ) 1 ! "

# # ! ! 1

! 6 .;! : :0# #

!" ! @ ) # !

(! #( 1"# #! -: :@)B!#

( !G ,% :!

: : ( * ! ' K! : ( H:!

: : ( * ! ' K! : ( ) ""K! * ! <$-$=4::.-,I:

2 ( ) ! J<:: .%= G2 3 !# ) " ( ! !

* !

( " #)

# # K)

) ( " # !( ! "

! " #

G@!

"!! " ( (

! !

( ! G ,, @: A" < = A )@ @# H< = $ ::,2I:

1 " #

J<:: .- $= G$@!

" ) ) !(

)

# !#"

( " #)

# # "! ! " ( (

! !

( ! "

;8; !

# "

# ! (! ! "

! "

)

) ! (! )

) ( " ( K) #

) !#) # ""

!#" "!(

! ) "( !

(

G ,.

!0 ( H

!0 ( ) : :

<$--=2::2.I $:

( ) ! J<:: ,= G*:A)? (; ) @

* (!H*: A)? (; ) @

* (!<

4=$::.-I ( L! ( #

! 6 .;!

( !

" #

( ) # !

6 . ;!

$* !

"! " "( " # !

" #

" ) 1 ! "

# # ! !

! 6 .;!

0# #

! " ! ) # !

(

(! # ( 1"# #! 6 -

< *@ )") */ H< ..=::,.I=G ,4 !

;": !

H !

;" : !

) B <$-.= 2 :: .I :

( ) ! J<::

.4.

.= G. * (

! 6 . ;! !"

) ! ( )

! 6 .;! : : ( 1 ( !

!* ) (

) "

" # !

! !" ) 1 ! "

# # ! !

! 1

! 6 .;! : :

" ) !"

! 6 .;! : : 1

) (

;7; * ) "

) ( ! ) " !

( ( ) L! !(

( ! !

* ) " "

"" #

K) # " 0 (

)! ! (

(

! 6 .;! : :( ) #

(! ( #!# # G , ;"#H;"#)+ " &< 4,=::2,I:

( ) !(

(

( !")

) ("

) # ) "

!" ( !(

(

" G 2E::7=9%8 34 75; 759$ $;% <= 349! ("3 9% 34 5" !59$ $ )9!9%!% D ")9! :; "!(%$ " "$ "- (7 BB 334 5)3!34 )5! %45%$5%$34 5# "6 %3!9%34 :759%3!0; 5" 34 :9%9% 3453 <34 34 ("3! < 7; 45# 653 "9577= "" $ 9% %3 " F )39%834 :759%3!9% D ")9! :; "!(%$ " "$ "- (7 BB $ 4 " !: )39# !(93!45# < %97 $53 "5: "9$B= 5"!"6 34 $53 D )(39%34 " 89!3 " $!57 $ $!39!3< %3 $3453 % !(93 ;5! 97 $ <= 34 69%"0 ;49)4 ;5! 97 $ 9% 34 = 5" 0 9% ;49)4!6 34 :759%39!4 " 9%; " 57!:5"3=334 !59$!(935%$ 9%34 !59$!(93034 " ;5!5!: )99)" " %) 334 ,57 $$53 $ BEE5%$34 !59$!(93)56 3< $9!69!!

$9%34 = 5"B'5%$ 966 $953 7=34 " 53 "34 :" ! %3!(93!45# < %97 $4(!0"634 5# "6 %3!9%34 :759%35%$34 <(%$7 5)3!!353 $9%34 :759%30; 5" 34 :9%9% 3453 <= )7 # " $"539%80 34 :759%39! 45# 3"9 $ 3 <"9%8 34 !(93! ;9349% 34 : "9$ 79693539%0 ;49)4 34 ";9! 5" <5"" $<=79693539%4 " " 0)%!9$ "9%834 $ )9!9%!349!("3 9% 34 )5! "9#5%$5%$56 !(:"5 5%$ 34 " $ )9!

584; %$"5 ,45"5% ,9%84 !(:"50 5%$ 5! 34 " !: )39# !(93! 5" <5"" $<=34 75;79693539%034 " !: )39# :759%3!5" " A(9" $3< " F )3 $9% D ")9! :; "!(%$ " "$ "- (7 BB

;&,; $.! / #?

#D?( )@ )(& !<+

=<?=* A;' F1 / 3 &< " # # #

# # ! "

." /

# #

#" / /.".

.! "

/ #

/ "

# "

. #

? / !

! ## / # # / C

#/!

## " ## /

/ #/

## !

/ ? # /

/ #

# /

/ . ! # " ) #

/ # / . ## &' "

/ # !

5 A/ # #

. "

/ )

. $" / " / # D: ;"" ) /&

F 1 / 3

# 6 ,+ /&& 123 ? D:;"")/& F1 / 3

5 / .! ## ) ! # # / ".! ./ # / "4/

"5 / ## #

#&, !

? /

/ /

/ !.

.! #

;&&;

" /. 15/ ;&3 #

.! #

@ 0/ &7*+ !

" # / *=,+&7*+

" ,',&&7=, . #> ,8&,&78, *<&&&78+C

$ ## ! !

/ ! $ .

/ / # "

*,&-? ##

/ . /"

# # # % & <

/ / /

! "

) / .

.! " 4/

/ / .

.! " E

! "

. / !

/ . / !.

/ . ) / " #D:;"") /& F 1 / 3 D?( ) @ )( & !<+

=<?=* A;'6 F1 / 3 D;" / 0 '@ /"B" ('6 F1 / 3 / #

? #D&@0( @)&C" &' F1 / 3 C F. /

#6 ,+ /&& 5 / #

5 "

/ ? #"

"/ / # "

/ .

? / . /

;&*;

/#" .! #" ) .

/! A/

5 # " .

/ . / # " 5

# A/ . .

/ / >

# #

/ # " ? # ! ! # " C

/ .# # " " #

5 ? # / . /

."5

# " 4

/ / #

/ " #D !)"&'6 F1 / 3 D; ) 1 )A'@ /;@* #:

F1 / 3

/ #

/ ". / ! # &- /

" "

# !

" # .! ? #

? # !

" 1 #!

"%(%) $%&

"9%) 45;75 > $" G % >

. G %