Vinod Kumar v. Devishwari And ORS
!"# $ # #%& #&'()(*
+(,-./%0&/) 11&22%) +&/)-) #&3()04/(%0&/) &)1&%)
#&3()04/(%0&/) 11&22%) +&/)-) +(,-./%0&/) &)1&%)
*
!"#!
#
! $% !""% & ' (
! $% !""%
# )
!"#!
*(
+ , *
! $% !""% * * (
*( -
)
! $% !""%
.
!"#!
- / (
$
!"#!
1#2 -
!"#!
- *(
-
3
! $% !""%
3
- - *(
45 6
#" #! !""
/ '4( / 5 8 9 '4( 9: /
45
1!2 6
4 5
(
"$ " !""$ 3 5 5
/;<"#<=<)$%)
(
4 > 7 4 (
(
7
+?<"
<'+<$$)# 4 5 ( 7 ". " !""$
( ( ,( / 7
3 833: ?
5 @5
8 :
4 5
( #$ < -
1 2 '4( 5A
35
(
4<
7 + ""B<
3 ( C+ 5
D( - *(
# 3 3
+
#< ?
5 (
( D(
# - *( +
!
3 C
( /
E
( /
D( +
;
5
<(<3
+?< "
B'+<$$)# +
# - *(
(5
(4
+
#<
3
;3
5 5 3 D(
#
;
( +/ "! ". #%%$ +
!
5 (
A< <A 47 ( /
+
!
5
3
5 4
5
5 5
5
+
1)2
5
35 ( 3 <
!
"# $ %& '&
'( )*+ $,-)+ . ( /0%% !
' 11
/0%%
( ' ' ' 1 1/0%)+. .
)
/
3
F #
4(5 C+ &G #
4 5 &G ! (
7 &G
5 &G ) 6 +
F
3 7< 3
3
+
#
#< 3
7
+
!
1$2 > (
# '4( 4 5
"$ " !""$
3 ( #$ < - C(
!
3 5 - *( 5 3
(
7 &G +
# - *( 4
(
( /
4
( 4 (
7 3 5
( #$ < -
3 5
( #).
- ;
< ' ( 3 ( /
4
1.2 '4(
5 + ""B<
#B ( 3
G 47 ( 5 7 7 + !!""B< + !$ )""B<
( * 5 3
5
7 ( #$
+ )!!)""B<
( + !"""B<
3
( + #""""B<
3 ( C 7
(
+ ) ))""B< E 47
# - *( G
'4(
#%
1 2
!"#!
5 3
4
# - *( 3
4 '4(
! $% !""% 4
3
5
( /
( D(
1%2 +
# - *(
#< ?
5 ( 3
(5
5 4 '4(
!
( /
; 5
1#"2 C
!"#! ;5 /( "# "
!"#
3
(
)# +( !.
//
'4( 5
5 5
(7
#< ?
5 (
"# "
!"#
(<
- 0 . )!3 4%4 5 66+ 6+!1
' ( 47+ +8+. ".
6 66+ 1 3 !
!
* 6
) * 1 6 6+!1 !3 !
!
- 5
!
*
1 166+ 6+!'
0 ' 1
6 1 : 5&6 4 -14
' ' + 6* 1 -1 '
% -!9 $ !
: -1
"
"
!
1##2 5 - *(
7 ". "! !""$ ?
5 ( 8
#<:
5
?
5 (
7 !. "! !""$
"$ " !""$ (
( ?
5 (
6
#
#< 3
C 5 ( 4(5 5
'4(
(4
;5 /(
!"#!
1#!2
'4( ( ?
5 ( 5 3
/ #. "% !"#
( (< ; 1 -
' ( 47+ 8+. ". ' ( +6* 1
-1 ' ; 7< 7 41
' ( 47+ 8+. ". ' 1 - * =1 0
7<7 4
"
"
!
1# 2 C 3 (4 '4(
!"#!
7 47 - *( 3 ?
5 ( ?
5 (
( /
( 5 '4( G 5 ( /
! $% !""% D( G ( /
47
5( (
7B
(7
3<(< C( 7 3
3
C
7
3 7 3
(5 (
5 5
5
D( 5 4 5 (
C
5
9
(
D( +(
/ - +( #% %
1#)2 C ( (
7
5A
( 5
5
5
7 C(
7 ( 55
7 + "B<
(7 3<(< 5 4 5
(
&G ) 3 ( 47 3
55
7
1# (
( 3( 3 (
( #$$ -
3
( #$ < - 1#$2 '4( G ( /
( B
7
7 3 5 4(
<
<
4 ( 3 55 D( 3
( 3 3( (
7
<47
(
-
3 7 ( ( (
7 3( (
3 55
1#.2 +
#
#< 3
4 '4(
!
(
C ( 4(5 3 43
5 3 +
43 3
4(5
1# 2 C
!! " #$%&' ()
$&" "
)*'
+&# $"
,-. - / 0.1
#$ < - G
3
57 3 3 (
47
!! " #$%&')+ )&-)*2' .
7
!# ,(5
(< !
.3 &>6'
'
' ' ' '
1#%2 C &3 "
))*'
+&#!2 4$"
() !&)% 5*! '
"#$%&')-.67 86-79. (
7
7
(
(
8:
3< (< (
4
!#
!! "
#$%&')+ )&-)*2' . 3
7 ( (
47 3 ( ( ,(7
(5 3
(A
5 ( (
(4
( 3 (7 3<(
(
4
1!"2 C '
& $ 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"() #
:
"#$%&')-. - / 0.6-79. 3 3
3 43
5 3
7
(
4
$ # 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"()
$% "
#$%&') -. - /
0. '
& $ 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"()
$% "#$%&')+ )& -)*2' .
#% $ # 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"
()
$% "#$%&')+ )&-)*2' .
35 ? "
- 1 1 ' 1 0
' 1 @ 1 =1 '' 7 ' ' ; 1 +;4 '
1' '
- 1 1
' 1 1 - - 1 1
1
' 1 1
5
1 1 ' ; 1 1 1 1 4 0 ; 4 A BC - ;' '1 ' ? 1!#2 C ( (
( $ # 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"()
$% "#$%&') + )&-)*2' .
43
3 ( 4(5
3 3 7 3 3 C( /
(
( 3
3
3 7 43
3 C( /
5 ( +
43
3 4
(
( 3
7 5 C C( /
45 B 3
7 C( /
5 ( C( /
4
1!!2 C ; ;00
<& &' 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"
() )!&'
% " #$%&'-.7 6-79.
7 (
( ( ( '
7 / 3
(7
(7 ( C( /
( 3 '
7 3
47 7 3 (
F 4,
7 3<
5 G 99
7 4 G 5 47 5 3
7 5
5 7
7 4 ( 7
7 47 ( 4(
3 5 3
(
1! 2 C( 7 &G (55 (7 3<(<
'
( 47
7
3
C(
7
(55 (7 + "B<
7 3<(< + #"""""B<
1!)2
3( 3 (
( + "B<
83<(<:
(
8(
:
7
4 <(<3 H +5(
$ 3( 3
4 7 5 3
3 5 5 9<(< 39 7 5 3 3
4 5
5
7 4 5 3 ( H +5(
$ 3( 5 5 G (7 3<(< 5
3 $ # 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"() '
#% "
#$%&'6-. - / 0.*)% 0 3=#0 $&% *
0
"#$%&')() 7 : ; % ;
" #$%&'-6.
- / 0.
# ,#> *'& "&')#
#>;
$() % ?
'
% " #$%&'
#. " !"#.
1!
H +5(
$ 3( 5 5 (7 G
6
4 7 5 3
3
5
3 93<9 H +5(
$ ( (
3 3
4 5
5
5
3
5 3
$ # 0 )*'
+& #!2 4 !
$&"()
$% "#$%&')+ )&-)*2' .
'
& $ 0 )*'
+&#!2 4 !
$&"() #
: "#$%&') + )&-)*2' .
3(
H +5(
$ (4, ( D( H +5(
$ 3( (
1!$2 C
# 8 #> *'
"&' 5 *' ()
% ! "#$%&') " "
!"#
# 6 #> #!? '"& &' 0 )*'
+&#!2 !
$&"() *
$ "#$%&') " "
!"# /( H +5(
$ 45
4 7 5 3
3 5 + 3<
H
+5(
$ ( (
3 3
4 5
5
C (
3
D( 3( 3 3< ( (7
3
5 3
' /(
5
( 1!.2 C ( /
+
#
#< 3
C 7 (
!"#! (
#< ?
5 ( 45
47 - *( ?
5 (
47 ( /
( /
G
43
3
( '4( 4(5 5 &G ) 3 4 ( ( /
5
5 C
4
( /
7 5 (4 G
1! 2 +( 7
!"#!
'4(
47 - *(
3 ?
5 ( 1!%2
D( #$ < - 5
(( (
5 ( '(5 (
( 3 ( ( ( 4( 5( 3 1 "2 7 4 + ""B< + %$""B<
( C ( #$
5
( 3( ( + $ $""B< C ( G #B 3
G
( + !##!""B< (
(5 5
( 3( ( + )!!)""B< 3
( + % ""B<
3
( C 7 3( ( + ) #%""B< '4(
7
( + ) ))""B< &
/(
'4(
( (( (
( (
(
1 #2 C 3
4
'4(
( 5 ( 3
5 7
! $% !""%
57
"% "% !"#% !7 %
!
# 80&%0&//&)&9)1&:(; $&)9 80&%0&//&1/%<2& $&)9