The Jat Education Society And ANR v. Presiding Officer And ANR

 
 !" #$ %#
&'('
)'$*'
''

'
)"'$ 










 ) +),



 
 






















!"!

 #
$$ 
  %
& %'('

% &
 






!)

!

$'


.(/! $0&#1  !1'
&'*2'11  ! 
(
+,
"-+
*, .+
/ 
0
)


(

(+1 2

*, .+
3 (
+ *)
0"11
*, .+

!)


 

44444 1'
&'*2'11 3&0

 

!
5 6
0
+
*".+

 7
 0+2
+

6
11
 +
+
!
(-

+1
 118
 0+2
59

(+ 6
0+,
/ 1*
0
)!


+!!+

8
0
+3+* *+*
:;<5

="
'>6
)+!!*
97
 +1
+1'."-'

%+9 "
 0+2
3097
/ .
 
;:
/

/ 1*
"

.


56
5.6
/
0
 +1
 !)"!
.
?<
5/ 
!0 
@0

/
?<A6
0+!
9 !3*

/+, "
/
!)


 '"

"-+
53 6

  !

!
0
".

-
/
0
!.

/
1 8+

8+*

0
 +1
 !)"
+ !*
97
0
3 


/ !

.

+1
* !)"
+ !*
97
0
3
3+!

*.

**
97
0
1+ +1
, *
+3+*
*+*
;
97 + !3

8
0
/ .
+8+

!
0 -
0+/
0
3

.0+11 8*
0
!+ *
+3+*
97
/

8
B
 <;
/

9/ "
5"

C+9
+ +7+ +

80
 "6
0
!+-
3+!
+11 3* , *
C"*8- 
*+*
>
97
!

8
+!

*
0
-)"8 *
+3+* + *
* .*
0
%+9 "

*.

*
0
/ .
+/!0
3

)

/
!

=
-

0! 0
)+ ,
)+
-)"8 *
+3+*
!
) *".* 091 3 "
.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that vide Annexure P4 dated 5.12.2007, he submitted an application for summoning witnesses and records like muster roll/payroll and other service records pertaining to the petitioner. On 2.7.2010, one Raj Singh, Clerk of Jat College, Rohtak appeared and sought time that record would be made available in future date. However, the same was not complied by Raj Singh, Clerk. Ignoring the application for summoning service records relating to the petitioner, the Labour Court proceeded to pass award. Therefore, award of the Tribunal dated 4.3.2014 is set aside and the matter is remanded for consideration of application for summoning witness as well as production of records like muster roll/pay roll and other service particulars of the petitioner. The Labour Court is directed to decide the reference afresh within a period of six months from today. If any LCRs are received by the Registry, the same shall be returned to the Labour Court at the earliest".

;

..

817
/ .D

+1
* !)"
3+!
!

<>
 !

+1
"-9
/ !
'*.

 ; $+.!
)1+**
97
0
3
+
0+
0
3+!
+))

* +!
!!


 -)"
)+ 
3 0
0
+
*".+

 7 5(+ 6
3 0
//.
/ -
??>
!) 
0 !
3 2
+

*".
9

8
!+ !/+. 7
0 !
!, .!
3
-

+*
,9+117


3 "
+!!

8
+ 7
+!



3+!
/"0
)1+**
0+ !
+))

- 
3+!
+8+

!
+
8"1+
) !
+ *
0
E"

*
3

)

/

*+7!
/
!, .
0+*
9
.

-)1*
97
0 -

0 ).*

8
+1 *+
7+
/ -
0
*+
/
0 !
-




.
0 ,

/
?<
3


+*0*
 
!+-
9

,

1+ ,
/
.


$
/
?<
+ *
0
)

)1
/
F 

 G
3+!
+1!

3*
.+"!

8
,

1+

/
.

 #
+ *

/
0
.
/
?<
0"!
3
.1+ -*
0 -

9
*.1+*
+!
"

!"!+

+91
+!
)
1+3  
0
3 
!+- 1*
97
0
(+ 
0 )1+*

8!
+ !*
97
0
3
3
.

,*
97
!+

8
0+ 0
3+!

8"1+
+ *
!+ .

*
) !
/
!!


 -)" )+ 
+ ,
+ 7
+*, !- 
3+!

)"91 !0*
/

,

8
+ 7
+))1 .+


B
3+!
+!2*
97
0

)+1
/
0
!)

'.

118
 2
+!
+
)+' -
3 2
+
+ =*
!+1+7
/
!D'
)
-

0
 $"0
=)1+

*
0+
)


0+*
3 2*

17
/ ??<

;;??<
>:??<

;;??:
+ *
>???:


:???

3+!
/"0
)1+**
0+
3
0 -!1/
! ))*

8
0
!, .!
9.+"!
0
,

!0 3*
")

0
// .
+/ :???
0"!
(+ 
)1+**
0+

!+*
/
.+11

8

+
.+!

/
-



.

"1*
9
!+ *
0+
0
3
0 -!1/
+9+

0
!, .
(+ 
+1!

*

*
0
.

-)1

/

3

*+7!
+ *
0+
0
3
.

"!17
3 2*
")
 > 
0
9+!

!
/
0
)1+*

8!
0
1+ *
+1 /+-*
0
/

8
3 !!"! "  Whether termination of services of Sh.

Sunil Kumar is justified and if not, to what relief he is entitled? OPW (

 Relief."

..

817
 ,
0
!!"!
)+ !

0
lis 1* 0 
, .
+ *
1+ *
%+9 "
+.0*

0
.

.1"!

0+
0
/ .
3+!
3 0
9

8
+11 3*
+ *
0"!
**
/ 
0

!+- 

0
!+-
) !
3 0
.

7

!, .
+1

H
9+.2
3+8!
+ *
+11
0
.

!E" +1
9 / !
%+

+1
/ *
0+
0
3 !!
+-17
+C


80
12
30

+))+*
+!
(B
-+*
+
+*- !!

*"

8
0
.

!!'=+-

0+
3
0+*
.

"!17
3 2*
3 ??>


+!
!!


 -)"
)+ 
+1!

+*- *
0+

.

 .0- 
.

-) !+

3+!
8 ,

0
3
9/ 
-

8
0 -
/ -
!, .

$ -
0 !+- 
/
0
!+ *
3 !!
1+ +1
+1!

.

.1"**
0+
0

 E"

*
3

8
/

*+7!
3+!
+1!

,*

0
).*

8

7+
/ -
0
*+
/
0 !
-

<

.1+
0
* "9
/
0
+."+1
3

8
)

/
0 
0
3+!
* .

*".
0 -)1
.

*
!".0
+!
0
("!
11
+ *
0
+ *+ .
8 !
.

5+!

.*

)++8+)0
 

/
0
+3+*6

3,
0
!+-
3+!

,
) *".*
+ *
!"1+ 17
+*,!

/ .
3+!
*+3
97
0

+1
0"!
*+3

8
/
+*,!

/ .
3 "1*
-+
91 ,

0
.+!
)"
/ 0
97
0
3 *
* !91 ,

8
0
*/ .
)" 0
97
0
(+  :

**

+117
+C


80
12
5(B6
+1!

+*- *


0
/+.
0+

!

7
1 !
3+!
))+*
+
0
 -
/
- ,+1
0
)


+ *
0+
+
3
+))

- 
0+*
+1!

9
-+*
+/
0 - ,+1
".0
+
*)

! 80 !
0
)1+
+ !*
97
0 *
0"!

!
+
.+!
/
.1+
,

1+

/
.

!

$
 #
+ *

/
?<
? "

8
0
.

"!
/
0
0+

8
(

(+1 2
1+ 


 !1
!"9- !
0+
0
3 !!
0+*
*) !*
"
/
0 .

*
+ *
+8+

!
0
"0
0"!

0

!
/
C"! .
0 !+- 
E"

!

9

*
"



+8- 0
!".0
+
.




/

0
+!

0+
+C


80
30
+))+*
+!
(B
!
0
3 !!

*".*
97
0
(+ 
!1/
+ !
!")) !*

!)+2
"0

> ,
0

+!

/ 
0
 "

.

.1"*
0+
0 *)

!
+8+

!
0
"0
 
0
0
0+ *

!
3

0
* -+

/
0 (+ 
 *".
0
!"--

*
.

*
0 "80
3 !!
+C 

80
7
0
3 !!

.+!
+C


80
5(B6
3+!
*)

+8+

!
"0
(+ 
.

"1*
8
0
3 !!
*.1+*
+!
0 ! 1

3,

!".0
+-)
3+!
-+*
0/ 
(+ "1* 9
9 *
97
0
*)

/
!
3 !!
+ *
.+

881
"
0
!+-
1+



3
 ( ,
0
)!

0+!
9
/ 1*
97
0 (+ 
+8+

!
0
+3+*
)+!!*
97
0
1+ *
%+9 "

/+, "
/
0
3 
B
0+!
9 "
/
0
C 9
/ 
0
1+! 
0+
;
7+!
+ *
+!
!+*
97
0
.

!1
0
9+.2
3+8!
"

.

<'&
/
?<
0+,
,
9
)+ *

0 -
0 3+7
(+ 
0+!
*) ,*
0
3 0
0
1 /
8+ * 97
0
%+9 "
 
, 3
/
0
+/ -

*
+!

!
.

**
97 1+ *
%+9 "
+ *
+1!

+// -*
97
0 "

*

+ 7
+!

/
3 0
0
/

8!
.

**
97
0
1+ %+9 "
B0 1
-+

+

8
0
!+-
0
)!

097
* !- !!*
41'
&'*2'11 5

1

  &#)"!

rashmi   B00
!)+2

8D+!

7!D

B00
) +91I 7!D