Shiv Kumar Sood And ORS v. Union Of India And Others





















1
 


 

    

!
"#$
#!%#
&'("
&)
'*+
,
#(-

















"
#,!%(#
, 

,./  





















  
































 / 0
   
 
















 









 



















1

 11

 

 

 



  









 























 1

  !


 



  









 
































/


   

 
 











  









 





























1

  

 !

























2
 









 































0

310

   "
 




















  









 
































3

10

  #
$ !







 









 



























2

12

 

#
 







 









 
































  %

$ 
 
 
& !'
#  " 











()
* +,-,.'
+,/-0

+1-2.
+,+,
$ 
 
3

$ 
# !
 '
#  " 








45

()
* +11-67+,+,
$ 
 
 '
#  " 






45

()
* +1..67+,+,
$ 
 
(

'
#  " 








45

()
* +1,667+,+,
$ 
* 


 '
#  " 










()
* 18610

+,+,
$ 

 ! '
#  " 











()
* 160

162

+,+1
$ 

9

'
#



!
#  " 
3 !'



$
# 
(  '


#  " 



$ 
* 
$  '
#  " 





457$(





















3
$ 
 :
 !
;  '
#



!
 !"

3 !





$
 
*   '
#  " 





457 <

&(4.5
#&6+7$
4(
*'8"!$
'%'8"!$
%$&(%$
48!#

#&6+7$
4(
*'8"!$

8#&9
9'4(
$(4
8#&9
9'4(
$(4:
*
1
9

!!
 

()
* +,-,.'
+,/-0'
+1,66'
+11-6'
+1-2.'
+1..6'
18610

+,+,'
160

162

+,+1

"



=


!

 "

  !

!!

"

" 



>


 

:

"

  "'

!

"


 "
 
 



()
* 
+,-,.

+,+,





:
 / 0:
 11:
 1:
 :


1:
310

  +

9



 


"

( 











=  


" 


++1,+,+,
4#

? 785
"

"



! 


!

 
 
 :


" !



"

  

 ! 











$ " !
(





#"'
120.
4




@#"

120.A5'

&! 


)


$ " !
(





<

4



B<


122/C5'

&! 

#"'
120+
4




@#"

120+A5'
( 
#"'
12-8
4




@#"

12-8A5'
( 
!'
122,
4



@!

122,A5

( 
D
4#5


(








 


 
" 


"


1.,2+,+,
4#

? 
705
  :







 ! 




'





















4

  

'
 ! 

'
"

:
"


$ " !
(





'
   

10

12

 


9











 
" !!  

" 


1011+,+,
4#

? 
7+5
 :






 
 
" 
!! !!:

  !






1+

16


-

/'
"!:
1

"

!






 '


 
 
 !!


 

%7 5

 
 
 
 

 ! 


 "!

 !
"


 

" !




:
 

"



"


"

F    

45





> 

'




 




 

 :
 

!
 
:

" !




5
* " 


++1,+,+,
4#

? 
785
 :




* +

!! !




 "

"

7 !" 






" !






 
 
! 



$ " !
(





'
E  




 
 :
" 






":

:
" 


 ! 



#
"
 
! 




= 


9
 "




7 "

 


 ! 

7" 


  " !
 F

:

 




 

 



  
! 
61,0+,+,
4#

? 
7.5




 

 

#"'
+,,/





















5
5
* " 


++1,+,+,
4#

? 
785
 
 

 ! 




" 


,21++,12
4#

? 
765

#
  !

" 

4#

? 
765
 
 


  !
/,

1+
 
  



"


!

 

" !
( 
" 

:'
6.
 
  


3 !
( 

:

 


 


 "

(! 
" 

:
"


)  


" 

4#

? 
785'

 
!

 

" !
( 
" 

:
 

 "

 



1+

16

 :

 

!

 

3 !
( 

:
 
 "

  '
"
!
 

= ":

"


!

 

3 !
( 

:

$ " !
(





'
E   

5



  :

!

"

!






 

* " 

4#

? 
785

 


  ! 








( 
D4#5


(






 '
 "
# "!
+-645


 

 


B ! 

C

"  


! 
 " 
" 


"

! "


  (  '
!

122,
 

 
"




 


 



" 



 G

  




!

" !
 

"



   :

( 
( 



9
"



" !




  






(  D4#5


(










* " 

 ,21++,12
4#

? 
765'
"
 





5


 
 
* " 

4#

? 
785
 






  

)



 





# "!
6+.


(








!

 !" !






















6






    


)


 
! 

 !:
"
 "
 

 
* " 


" !




 
7" 

 F




)


"

   







"

  
 





"

!

!

" 

 

 



"




 

 
!


"  5
9



 


!



!
 
* " 

4#

? 
785'
"

 




 "
 

"

$ " !
(





!
 !
 
 !

* /+
 
"

 
!"


!!

!



!

! 


   !


" :



* /

 




!!: 

   !

'
* " 

4#

? 
785


!! !!:
 "
 


" 


  " !
 

5






! '


 :

!

"

!






 

" !



 
"


 !
 

" 

 !" !
 



-

<




'
!

"

!



" !




 '

 
  

 !!


 

%
5



 





! :



"

" 

9
 



 


" 

 +011+,+,
4#

? 7
7+F15


 !


3 !
H!"

F :
!"




$ " !
(





F( "!


& "








 
 
 
! 
,11++,+,
4#

? 
7+F+5

 
H!"

( 

'


 
"!





















7



 F 



  


!"

!

!!
"

$ " !
(





F$ " !
( "!F* 
 " : 

5


 
 

* " 


++1,+,+,
4#

? 
785
 

! !!:

 




# "!
+-6I3

(






 '

 ! :
:
!
!  



! 


"

 "'


 

 
 
 


# "!
+-6I#
 !!


=

 :
(


"





! :




   

!

5
9 


=


 ! 


 "!
 !

"

 








!
 




 !

 

 :

 

!
 




"

 


"






&! 


)



5




 











 !

* /+

,2,6+,+,

"

"

'

 
 
 



$ " !
(





'
E  

 
 !

* /+

,2,6+,+,




"

 
!"


 
!


 
!

! 

'

!

  



 


 


! 



"



"

)

$ " !
(





<


122/



 
 


"! 

 

 !

  :

$ " !
(





! 


 






 
3 

 
 ? "

 








 F !'



!  "
 !!
  !

9


"
! 

 

"

 



"



&! 



"


"

 

:


!
0


<


122/





















8
5

 

  :

!

"

!




" !



 

! 

? 





:
+,1-
 

" :

  ! 



> 

'

$  :

E 
#  

! 
188+,+,
 
"


! 
 

?



 
"


" 


? 





'
 
!! '
!'
 "
"
!!
611++,+,



 
!

:
  !

:

( 



18,2+,+,
 :
 "  

  
 :




()
* 11.12

+,+,
!

! 

 









!




"

"
" 
5




 









  !
 
  

""


 !" !
 


"

"

'

 


 !:
 :

" !





   

"



 !
   !
 

! "

"



:
 !
 
  


 

5








 
 

'
!

"

!

!

 
  :

( 


 3

 
 
 


 







"

1.1++,+,5'

(





#$
E 
GG 

:
#
128/
(
1+66'
#  
*
 


 




4122.5
.
((
6,6'


* 
 


 



'
#
1220
4JE5
6,2'
 !




 



'
4+,,25
 
1
4JE5
6//'

 
 !
3 : !

9

(

 

:
#
+,10
JE
+2
"





















9
/
)
 

 !
"

 



 


 :
!

"

!



 

 

 



!

"


"
 



" :

!

"

!



 




.
)




:
 


 



!

"

!







"

!



 
 
!:
"



 
 


 ! 



 "!
 !
"



"

 :




 
 !:
"

 :

&! 





 
( !
 
 



!  


"





  !


  "

'



 

!:


"





'



"

 :

 !
 
!  !:
"

 
0





"






$ " !
(





'
E   '
 :


* 1'
+

/

()
* +,-,.

+,+,

"

"

'

 
 
 !:
"

 :



"

!"




" 
  '


* 6

-
 


 


"





"






>



"

'

 
 
 
 
  !
 :


"

 :

 

$ " !
(





'
E   '
!!
"
 
"

 :












"





$ " !
(





'
  '
 :




()
* +,/-0

+,+,
"

"

'

 
 
 !:
"

 :



"


!"




" 





















10







"

 :


* 1'

 

 

()
* +1,66F+,+,

"

"

'

 
 

 !:
"

 :





#! 

""
"

 


 



"




+7!


 '





  !




" 





'



 
 



 
  "



"

 :
  



 '
 



 
!
  "






"




+
!

 
:




9

"

 :




()
* +11-6F+,+,




$ " !
( "!'
  '
& "
  '
 
!  !:
"

 :



'
"

!"

  !
* 
1





" 



9

"

 :



()
* +1-2.F+,+,




$ " !
(





 

'
 
!  !:
"

 :



"

!"

  !
* 
1.

6+





" 



9

"

 :




()
* +1..6F+,+,




$ " !
(





#  '
 
!  !:
"

 :



'
"

!"

  !
*
-




" 

2

"

 :

 

$ " !
(





# 
 
! " 


9

"

 :




()
* 18610F+,+,



$ " !
( "!
"
$

'
& "
 

 
!  !:
"

 :



'
"

!"

  !
* 
1

-





" 





















11



()
* 160F+,+1

162F+,+1'




 
     


,81++,+,

1.1++,+,'
"!:






"  

 



$ " !
( "!
; '
& "7>

  





$ " !
( "!

 
 




 


!

"


 



 
!  !:
 

   

'



"

 :
 


$ " !
( "!
; '
"
 
 !:
"

 :




 
!"



  !
* 1

8




" 

8
# 



 '





  


 
!

:
 " :

( 

(;

 :
  :
 

 

!




%7

       
  





 


    
   

 








 




  !
"



##
# #$ 
%

"
 %

 "
  # &     
#  
'
 (
 )* +, 

- 

)*+, . 
   "
    

#  
#
 
 "

 /
01 

  
#


  

        

 
# 
 )*+(
2

  3





















12
01
 %


 
 2
 '    
 

   
 


            #
   4

(
 )* +,  
  "
 

   
#




    

    
#    
 )*+(
2

      
    %


    
 2
 '    
 

    
 


    #
5

# 
# 6
 

# 
    78 (' "
 (# 
 
#8  01    -

)5 

 
9 ( * * **:& ( 
# 
 


     2

'
    (
 )*+,   "

 



         "    5
   .; "  5 

    
    # 5  
 
     


        


 ##'
        #  

 (   #          


,<=
      
     


  
#   
 
 ( 

;
">"  

=























13
   
        
4

* 6


#
(
 )*+,01  "

   ? .  
 "
 &

 @=8  -



(A
A %

(  
 
   


      ,    
 * (0 1   %

 (5

 !
 "

5>
> 

 
 

 

 5 

A
2
A A
A 
#
A
A  
 (


9"

 B
@ #
    

 #    

#  
 

    

!
"

(  **(


(


9 "

 =#7> "   
 
   
  
 

     
 
   


    %

 (    #
   
#   A
A   =

          
 

 B   "
 
  
     

  '   

 ' 

 4

) 5

 
 '

#  
 =


   
    "

."
%#=C





















14
D


"

 (B@ E9 "99E
  2
#




  
 0 1      D


 "

 ( 

E9 
   


  
 &
   (  


    %  & 5 
 

  

   #   (
 * E01   "

   
 


    2

 52

   78 (' "
 & # C 

 F G 01 
 #   
   & 
 :&

-

)HB
, 

       


   


B
  
  
 
     I4
 

H C
#

 


  78('" ?. 
" 



 

   


    
   
 


 





 






 !
"



# #
##$ 
%

 "
  %

 "
  # &  (   

  E



    

   
  





     

# 
  =
  
     9



  *



 
 ?



H 

 B 

" 
'

=


 (


9   "

  
 #  
       ##  
#  
  

  5 =   

  " BJ (
 





















15
"

B
  )"

( EE  $





#  
   

   2
    !
    

  #    

 


 ;
# 
 

##

  (  
   "   


 
        



 





  

9 5 

   =
   
  




 =; 
#
52
=
 
 2
   
  

   
#   =  
#  
     B       
   


          
#  
 =
  ##
   #
   
   %
  ( 

=
 



 B

 

=
 2
  
#   #
 
      
  ;
 

 

#






  

 B =



   

K








  

 


  
 
B
;



  4;





4 6 
  

 


    
   

  
   5




 $




#
 


4





















16
2

!

!:'


  
" '

 
H!"

( 

'


 
!



 


  

!"

!

!!

$ " !
(





F( "!F
* 
 " : 
 

! 
,11++,+,
4#

? 
7+F+5'
 


 

 

H!"

( 

 
!


 !

3 !F:
H!"



$ " !
(






"



  
!"

!

!!

 
 

 "

,11+,+1


= !: 


9


 


  


!"

!

!!



%7

B<3#$$H 1
  


H!"

!
 !!
%

,21++,+, +
& 
 !" 


!"

!

!!
%
1,1++,+, 6





! 
"! 

%
1.1++,+,
<

"

 -
&  !

"! 

"

:
%
+61++,+, /
> !
 !" 


H!"

!
 !!






%
,/,1+,+1C 1,
E  






  "

'



  :'



'
!! !:





!:


"




" !



> 

'
!"




 "

"
 ":
 
! :
 "

  

  
 


 "
 "

!"


 !


"

"

 !:

  !




" !
9'

!"



"
"


!!

 
 !! '





 " :






























17
11





'





 !


""

!:'




"




8#&9
9'4(
$(4







'%'8"!$
%$&(%$
48!#
















*',%$














*',%$













/
 















4)9 6;
#$    L 6@     L