Union Of India And Others v. No 13859527n Ex Hav Jagdish Chander
!" #$%$!&!&'
!" #
$% (' )*( ++
+ ,
)*( +* , &%'() * + ,+-+. +/#/ 0,$1 *,"/.%23++% *4+( ,+.%23+ 0$% +
+ ,
-.
*/ ,&, , + 6 $. , $ , $+(0,&+%0,%%+% 89:;
+$+%'(,/+%-%3 '+/33%.6,'( , $% 6+ &+% , '0 0 %& 00. , 0 3-$&,%+'/(/-2:+:2%+'/($
# 0 1 #234!0&5
$%6+//%,-( 7
+%6+%3,+&%0-23607 77#<, %3,+& 0- , 23. , $% 6+ &+% 0//6& %+'/('0+/&6,,%
!"
#$"%#" #" &# &"' (%) #)") "
,$%0/%.'0, '+/33% +,0,&+0'00'+%'+%&1%&00%+'/( /-0- 7= 7=6077> 77 ,+%+$$/3+6+ +//6%2%%%+% 89:; ,$+2 $+0,+%%9+3%,+0
!
"
# "
$ $
%&'(
)
* + )
, * + - # . .
/0$
> /& +&&2% 0- , +0 %. , $: 0%+,+0/%,+&+,+6$ +067$%%$!&%!" 8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!4 8 9 $ $!& 4%
,.,/+%3/0,$: 0%+0,%8;02+4%&-'(, ?'/ $9#.6,'(.
. 0,'-,+260 ,9$/+0/+6-+%,.,/+% '+/33%
,/%,+23%,&+0++,$%0, (+ @ +//(.+03<%'-+%$++&+$, +%@0,2%3%%'(, ?'/$9#3+ /%+
*&&' ++++
,* - ./,0 '
"1 2"
"3)4
5 .
-).%3%%7 77 ,+%$++&+$, +%@ '3-9+3%,+0 "
- .
2
. * .
.
+
* .
.
- +
#
3
.4.
2.
(
#
#
.
5
6 #
. 5 #
. . .
(
.
.
7
8
.
7 .
89 :
8
.
.
;
. ;.
8 - 9 : 2 .
;.
.
.
+%&0$++&+$, 0,2%38$+;3/+/( %3,0+3,+3++(3/+-,'(,230%/+( +%/+3,.,/-+/(+003&,+$$2%%0+'/ &,<+,+-($/.'/+&/($+(-:09+ 0 $+( $. ,'(. , +% %/+(% 3/+-. +, ,+ '3-&+&,6+(43%.,.<%'+//6%.'6, +0,+,++0$'&3%$+$%0, (+$,%+00/&0,6$ ,+%3+$++&+$,@,0.,$9# %3/+%,+, &,#6+40%%3,/+0 ++0$32&+$%0@(++%,+6,
,+%26+/+$$+,+2'+33$%+ 4%&-'+&
*&&' 6
6,* - ./ ,
0'
0 ".) 4 1 2"
"
3)("# ""
,/2+$++&+$,6,0+ 9+3%,+0 <
.
-
+
4 .
2& "
"& ") ) % "7#) #) %) #) # "-"& " ) - 9 : #
9 :
.
- & "8#"
-) ) "& )% & 3 4
# .
, .
9 :
.
- .
.
+067$%%$!&%!" 8 1 4& 5#!0&% 1"!4 8 4 %9!&5 & 7 ,,,+%.,/+%3/0,$% '-,+,+0+%4%&-++$$/3+'/,+ 3+. + , --' 0 , %03 3-'++ +'/,- 6+ +/+%(3$0,%+'/($+%,+,%6-0 ,+$$'0,3,&,-+A&0%&8;00., 6/%/(/+40+'/3+$ $$0,+&-.,$/+3%/+3+, !%& B3, 4%&- $+% '( , ?'/ $9 #.
77 7@.3+/%+ :$&5 4+$&38;% &$!&!"&5$ &5 8 4%.6,3, $:$199 1!<< !" +&% , /2+$++&+$,0,+%2%3+9+3%,+0 -
.
6 - ) ( :
. = 0<
<<;
- -
2 2
.
.
.
.
-
.
#### #### 3 .
.
.
-
#
.
.
- & ' ,
.
.
.
<<;
/0$
2 2 . . .
3 .
.
<<;
>
<
.
. = &" 4 &# %!" 8$%!04 ,&,.2'/(3++(%/+(%-+%'(, +&&2%6,'(+3,+//&3+%+%3/&%$+%
6 '(,33%.,$.,+&0+%/+(%-'-+A ,+-','(,230%/+(+%/+3, 62., 93$,+'2$3$/.+/%,&,2%33%%'( ,$9#3+/%+1 2"
"3)4 5
.
-), &0+%3+/%+.) 4 1 2"
"
3), &0(,+.(,%03$/33%.'3-& /%:09+0$2:+:2,-.'6,+0,% ,+,+%'3%/(0+$%0,(+0-, %+00/&0,$ B,++-+(.+0,93$2,$+ 9+3%$++&+$,.+33,2%38$+;%%'(, $9#.,9.,+3++%0+'/&,'3- 2%,+&&2%.,$.,+%2-0+%0+'/ &,,+&&2%.,6/%0/+3&+3 3+ 0 +3 2:+:2 , +&&2% /+/(. ,'( , %/+(%+&0+3/+-.
,6/%++3,+,,'+ 0/-+,'(+($$%230%/+(+%/+3, 6/%0032/(03++-'/&'/3A+&+,&+&0 ,0///0,+&&2% > %-&6,,,3+0+36,3,+33% 2:+:2,$$%,6++3&+3 3+0+3'%0%-&6,,+,2(3$. +%0+'/&,2%,$$%.,'(. 3+('+-%,0+3-,+.
+33%,$$%.$.,-+A&0+2%3'(,
?'/$9#3+/%+) &$!&!"&5$ ;%
7:
4?.
$% + &1$& =.%3%%7 7>.6,.
+%3/++-+%,9.,+,'00%&00. +, ,+ '3- %6% , 33% , /2+ $++&+$,+33,2%38$+;+9+3%,+0
(.
*+
8
.
.
.
5
. - *+
: =
* +7<>7?*@5:+ .
A . ? B
!
. 6 @
.
. 6 @
"
3
;
3 .
2 *+
*+
5
.
> -
4 .
9 : .
-
.
.
9 ,0.3,+%%0+'/&,'3+-2% ,$$%.$.,-+A&0,2%3'(,$9 #.3+/%+ ) &$!&!"&5$ ;%
7:
4.%094 / </.,%3/++0/+6-+%,2%38$+;.6,% +0032&,'3-%6%2:+:2,33%., '2% /+/(.,%6-0,+%&,.2:+:2, 33%. , '3- , 3 0 , ,0- %-&. 6,, $-$ </ , +, , $ $%+%+3/+-.+%.+%-,6, @
3 , 2%3 8$+; '3+- $3% 7 7>+%,$%+%-0,+%2%3.,+ -'0, '+/33%.,(+ 7 ,&,., $%-0,2%38$+;%%++$-$- $+3,.'+%+-/(+0+%/+(0+'> (++A&$/+3 62.6,,%6--+%,% 2:+:2,$$%.'++//(30%+%0+'/ &,<+,- ,0.6,,%0+'/&,2%, $$%+,,&,2%38$+;'33-+/( +/30%+3+%3&3+0+3<+, $$% /+/(+/,%+%0+'/&, '3+- 2% , $ $% 0 , A& <+ , +$$%&00'&-+%,0+2
2 ,6 3 , %3/++ 0 /+6 -+% 2%38$+;-+A,+%%3/++'+9$/+0/+6
-.,'(.,9$/+0/+6-.+-+%2%3 8$+;+/-+A,,%30%'02:+:2, %03 $/ 33%. .
. +/ / , 33%.,++(-A,&+&0,%6-+ -+%,%.+%,+.,0//3-$/-.+$/ ,%.'%$320,'+0%/+(+%/+3,
$& 1 45 4!" 8$%!04 +0-+,.,#0%-,6$ +% 6, , '2+ +0+%. , +- %-% , -$&%%-++%+%+00-%
3,-+3+/0,+'%3%%.,.+//, $%&+$$/3+8;.0+(.+/+%8;%$%0 .+
+ ,
/ .* ,/
A+2&, 8 8 4%9 2$&3>4 %!& 5 '
%>!
8 8 44 9!4 '
%>!