High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9260/2013allowed

Gurdial Kaur v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2017-11-15Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!"##$%&%'( )

* +,-%!./!+, #"%"%'#, 1#,&+& 2"!"# +'3!4!'-"5#,& #&6'-#'"&

,#&#'"(0 ,2+,%'-#,!,78-9$!"#,"5#6#"%"%'#, ,9%'%"9!&"5%88 +'3!4 :::

5#%'&"!'"6#"%"%';!&%'&"%"+"#-%'"5#<#!,

;5#'"5# 6#"%"%'#,;!&;,=%'7!&!.!&&01#>6.<##;%"5"5#2&6%"!.8 5!.% 5# $5!..#'7# %' "5# %'&"!'" 6#"%"%' %& " "5# ,-#, -!"#- ?

86!&&#-4<"5#%,#$",8#!."52#,9%$#& 8

+'3!4!'-%'"#,>&;5%$5"5#6#,%-;#

-!<& 5!&4##'!66,9#-!&.#!9#;%"5+"6!<

#"%"%'#,!&&#,"&"5!"&+$56#,%-&5+.-5!9#4##'$+'"#- !'-!66,9#-!&.#!9#"5#=%'--+#

!$"&"5#$!&#!,#%'!9#,<'!,,;$>6!&&

#"%"%'#,!66.%#-,.#!9#'>#-%$!.4!&%&,"5#6#,%- ;#

'>#-%$!.7,+'-&!'-&+$5!66.%$!"%';!& &+66,"#-4<!>#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#-!"#-

%&&+#-4<'#, +,!'

2%'758;5;!&,+''%'7!6,%9!"#$.%'%$&6#,&+$5$#,"%%$!"#6#"%"%'#, ;!&&"!"#-"4#&+#,%'7,>AB%>4&$%!@%!CB;#,B%>4D!'-;!& !-9%&#-4#-,#&",>

.!$#-',#$,-%&>#>

00 -!"#-

0 ,>"5#2#'%,#-%$!. %$#,'$5!,7#8 2&6%"!.85!.%8;5#,#4<"5#.#!9#!66.%$!"%'&+66,"#-4<"5# 6#"%"%'#,;!&,#"+,'#-!'-&5#;!&!-9%&#-"5!"!>#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#,> &>#9"5&6%"!.4#+,'%&5#-5#,#!"#,8.#!9#'!$$+'""5#&!># >#-%$!.!%.>#'";!&!66.%#-,,>

';!,-&!'-"%..

!'-"5#9!,%+&!66.%$!"%'&;#,#!7!%'&+66,"#-4<$#,"%%$!"#&5!9%'7 4##'%&&+#-4<"5#&!>#9#,<>#-%$!.6,!$"%"%'#,%#, +,!'2%'75

#"%"%'#,,#&+>#--+"%#&' *

!'-5!&&%'$#,#"%,#- +6'!""!%'%'7"5#!7#&+6#,!''+!"%' 5#6!&&%'7"5#%>6+7'#-,-#,-!"#-? ''#@+,#

!'-"5#,#4<",#!"%'7"5#6#,%-;#

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

+'&#. ,"5#6!,"%#&5!9#4##' 5#!,- !" .#'7"5!'- "5# 6.#!-%'7&',#$,-5!9#4##'6#,+&#- 5#%&&+#;%"5,#7!,-"7,!'".#!9#'>#-%$!.7,+'-&%& 79#,'#-4< +.#?

! "5# +'3!4%9%.2#,9%$#& +.#&1.8 !," 5# +.#%'F+#&"%'%'"5#&"!"+"#4=!&'"5#-!"#6!&&%'7"5# %>6+7'#-,-#,%&#@",!$"#-5#,#+'-#,(0

!" ! #

$ %

& #

)

* !,#6#,+&!."5#,+.#>!=#&%"$.#!,"5!"!'!66.%$!"%', .#!9#'>#-%$!.7,+'-&4<!9"#>6.<##5!&"4#!$$>6!'%#-4<! >#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#7%9#'4<! #7%&"#,#-#-%$!. ,!$"%"%'#,,!1!%-, !=%>,!>#6!"5%$ ,!$"%"%'#,-#%'%'7"5#'!"+,#!%.>#'"G%..'#&& '!$!&#;5#,#"5#9"#>6.<##%&&##=%'7",#.<+6'!$#,"%%$!"#" 4#%&&+#-4<!#-%$!. %$#,"5#9"8"5#!66.%$!"%',.#!9#5!&" 4#!$$>6!'%#-4<!,#F+#&","5#%&&+#!,#F+%&%"%',#@!>%'!"%' 4<&+$5#-%$!. %$#,+'-#,"5#2"!"#9"

0E0

,9%& " +.# ? ! .#!9#& %" " "5# -%&$,#"%' "5# !+"5,%"<$>6#"#'""&!'$"%'.#!9#"#9#';!%9#"5#$'-%"%' 6,-+$%'7!>#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#%'"5#$!&#!!H#""#-9"#>6.<##% "5#.#!9#!66.%#-,-#&'"#@$##-"5,##-!<&"%># 5#.!'7+!7#"5#,+.#%&$.#!,!'-+'!>4%7++&"%&6#' ,!9"#>6.<###9#'">!=#!'!66.%$!"%',.#!9#'>#-%$!. 7,+'-& !$$>6!'%#- 4< ! $#,"%%$!"# %&&+#- 4< ! ,#7%&"#,#- >#-%$!. 6,!$"%"%'#,,1!%-,!=%>,!>#6!"5%$ ,!$"%"%'#, '"5#%'&"!'"$!&#"5#$#,"%%$!"#&"5!";#,#,#.%#-+6'4<"5# 6#"%"%'#,!.'7;%"5"5#.#!9#!66.%$!"%'5!9#4##'%&&+#-4<'#,

+,!'2%'75!'-;5-#&$,%4#&5%&F+!.%%$!"%'&!&28 2

B'-' !'- $.!%>& 5%& $,#-#'"%!.& " 4# !' @ >#,7#'$< #-%$!. %$#,89"&6%"!.82#$", 85!'-%7!,58@>#,7#'$<#-%$!.

%$#,89"#-%$!...#7#82#$", 85!'-%7!,5!'-@ #&%-#'"

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

0)0 ",#!">#'",>!6,%9!"#>#-%$!.6,!$"%"%'#,;+.-'"&+%$#"$'$.+-# "5!""5#6#"%"%'#,5!-6,-+$#-!!.&#>#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#!&%&&+75""4# $'"#'-#-!&6#,6.#!-%'7&$'"!%'#-%'6!,! "5#;,%""#'&"!"#>#'"

#F+%,#>#'""5#,+.#;!&,!'!66.%$!"%',>#-%$!. .#!9#"4#&+66,"#-4<!>#-%$!.$#,"%%$!"#7%9#'4<! #7%&"#,#-#-%$!.

,!$"%"%'#,,!1!%-,!=%>,!>#6!"5%$ ,!$"%"%'#,"%&'""5# $!&# "5# 2"!"# "5!" , +,!' 2%'75 ;!& '" ! ,#7%&"#,#- >#-%$!. 6,!$"%"%'#, >!"#,%!.5!&$>#,"5!""5#5!'-&"5#2"!"#,"5%& +," " $'$.+-# "5!" "5# >#-%$!. $#,"%%$!"#& 6.!$#- ' ,#$,- !" ''#@+,#& !'- 0E" 05!9#'"4##'%&&+#-4<! #7%&"#,#-#-%$!.

,!$"%"%'#, 5#%>6+7'#-,-#,-!"#-?

5!&4##'

6!&&#-!7!%'&""5#>!'-!"#"5#,#.#9!'",+.#%# +.#?

! "5#

+'3!4%9%.2#,9%$# +.#&81.8 !,"5#,-#,8!&&+$58$!''"&+&"!%'

,"5#,#!&'&,#$,-#-!49#8"5#;,%"6#"%"%'%&!..;#- ,-#,-!"#-?

%&&#"!&%-#%,#$"%'&!,#%&&+#-" "5#2"!"#9"G$>6#"#'"!+"5,%"<"",#!""5#6#,%-;#

-!<& !&.#!9#"5#=%'--+#&+43#$"""5#.#!9#!$$+'" "5#6#"%"%'#, ,#&5,-#,%'&+$5,#7!,-4#6!&&#-;%"5%'!6#,%-#%75" ;##=& ,> "5# -!"# ,#$#%6" ! $#,"%%#- $6< "5%& ,-#, '&#F+#'"%!. 4#'#%"& #>!'!"%'7 ,> 6!&&%'7 "5# ,#&5 ,-#, !& -%,#$"#-;+.-4#,#.#!&#-""5#6#"%"%'#,;%"5+"!'<+,"5#,-#.!< %&6&#-

.+$=< 5#"5#,&6#!=%'7G,#!&'#-( #&G 5#"5#, #6,"!4.#( #&G