Kalsi Warehousing Corporation v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And Others




   
  

 !"#$%"&'('#)*+,,
 

    
 



 

   



  

   
  



    * -.

, /
0
 /,  

!

 "

#$%#&'($ )"

*

$%&"++$)$%#&'($  ,' 
#"

.$*$#$!

/$0 ,'

'1
*$#*$#&'($ ,'

'2$ #3 '4 11111 0
 /, 2, 3 4 *$%% +"

+  *  '#  #$ #   52521526  $ #   24531523 -$

#  0.  *  

 "7-'

+  - $% .  ,'  !

+    %(

8

.$ +'.9"

$#', $ +'. *-

)"

- *$ ,"%# 1 $ #  "'  ('!

%  ,'  *  -   ('

-  -$

 *"-,"7"

') ',45:$( ',%$ # !$ #"

"%%$+ "70!$* "%$$

""

"( $+$
'*$%"* $"#%$ #)$

$+"(!% !$%*-  -$

 *"-,"7$--%"# *#-$

', ')  $ #  '!

.  %$

+  !

/$0  ,'  (*$ +  ',  *  %$ #  !

  ,' )$*'!

+-!-'

)*"(*)$ +$

#'

2;5<155;%$$ (,'7

*!

/$0'%%!

'

'%'$#,'

$0%"

*"

+$ $*'!

)$ $%

 '0 $"

#!

*"8&

='

'%','%%!

9( 2>;2$ )%%  $ 8&

='

'%','%%!

9( 2><6*# ("- ',

*-'- .)$ -(","($%%.7

?+'#') $"('

@"

$%%

'.,'7 #$--'&$% ,  $A"

(

$. (

-7"

,'7 *('7-

$!

*'"

,'!

*-7"

$" #  )$*'!

  *  -   !07"

#  $  $--%"($ ' 

"

"0!

"(

,'%$ ',%( .('

-7"

!

#8

"$%$ +'.9%% *# $"% )"

* -( %( .  ('

!7-   "

(%!#"

+  *  B!"-7

 "

$%%#  *"

  )$

,! *#$ ##(%$#0.  -$

 *"-,"7*

$0%"

*7

', *%$

',15 ($-$("

.$(*)$ $% '#"

(%'

#*)$

*!

 '('

($%7

',$ .-$( ',$ . !'

*-$  ,"7"

7$A"

*('( #"

(%'

! %.$0'!

!',$(

0"

0!

$% '$0'!

*B!"-7

$%%#$ "7',

!07"

',CC=CC,'7 3

 ('

"#$  ',  *  $"#  $--%"($   *  

"

"0!

"(



"7$ ',$((- (&"#%

#$ 565<155;  )*!-'

*  B!"

  &"(  ('

 (*$+   $

#7$ ##)$% '-$"#0.  ,"7*-7"

B!

)$ !0 B!

%.  %$ #  '!

 0.  *  -  ,"7  '  '

*$7$(!

"($% "7"

#&"#$ ##$ #525>155;,'$-"'#', ,"&.$ )*"(*('

!# "%% "7)* *-

- ,"%# 6 *'0/( ',%$ +'!

$"#-'- .)$ ,'

'(A"

+$

'"

+-*$7$-'#!(

#7#"("

','

$ ) '0 7$ !,$( !#  "

  *"  !

!$ #  $  $##"  "7$(*$%  $# *  * - ('

,"7# '-$.$ * +.('

!7- (*$+ +!%$%.

 4 *-  ,"7)$ *')& &#)"

*$ "(!

( 21:', %( .( 1553$%%+"

*8

"$% $ +'.'

9($ +'.)$ 0"

#"

*#"

-!

#-7"

)*$ *  $--%"($  '!+* '  *$&  0 !07"

#  ,'  %(

!

* $ +'.$ '7$ !,$( !"

+)$ 0"

+#'

$

*#"

-!

#-7"

-'&"

$%$

654:<1< )$

&.#  ,"7&"#'##$ #5<511523 : 

* '  ,"7 !07"

#"

'0/(

#$ #2;511523- $%*$"

+)$ +$

#  ,"70.

*$!

*'"

5:531523$ *$, $,"

$%'##"

7"

'0/(

)$ -$

#'

5;531523!-*'%#"

*'#',-'&"

$%

 < ++"&# *',  ,"7*$#-,# 

'.

$--$%!

#( 21<', %( .( 15530,' *##"

$% -!

.'77"

--%%$ !

*'"

.8!

%( .( 15539   $+$ 
'*$%"  *  $"#  $--$%  )$  #"

7"

#  0.  *  --%%$ !

*'"

.&"#"

'##$ #52521526!-*'%#"

*'#',$



( *-

- ,"%# ; $+!#0. *%$ # "'('!

%,' 

*'#',$

$(('!

',!

$!

*'"D#!

',%( .*$

0 )'

+%.-$

#0.

$!

*'"

*$--$%*$

7"

#)"

*'!

$--("$ *'0/(

$"

#0.  ,"7 #  '%%.  '

*  +'!

#  '  7$ !,$( !"

+  $( .  )$  0"

+  ,"7$ *-7"

0"

#'

%.

,'

'(A"

+ ', * -*$7$(!

"($%-'#!(

 *$( . )$ *!

"+ $('77("$%$( .*'%#"

#"

%#,'

  %( .('

!

# 8

"$%$ +'.9 ('

*)$ '('

($%7

',$ . !)*$

'&0.  ,"7 "7', A"

+%$ ',%( .('

,'7

$, $%$- ', $%.,"&.$ 

*$& ')$"

*"

 $0"

$.  #7$ #  0.  )$.  ',  - $% .  !

#  (  21:  ', 

%( .( 1553 > ,! *$+!# *#"

-!

#-7"

('

!# '0 #'((!-"#,' $7-!-'

,')*"(*"

('

!(

*)$ '(*$ +',!

$+', *-7"

' *%( .0. -  ,"7$ *$

'#)$ -$

#0.

0.($ +'"D"

$7$  8($ +'.('

9!

*($ +'.

?"'

#%$

@"

7"

-%$(#$ #7"

("&# 25 *7$

*$#('7!-,'*$"

+'

', *#$

"5;221513%$ #('!

%,'

E "

"0!

"(

)$ A# ',"%$

$,,"#$&"

(%$",."

*"

)* *$ C"'

 $*'!

C)'!%#,$%%)"

*"

*#,"

', ?

.@'?'77("$%( .@ 22 ! !$

* '$ $,,"#$&"

*$#0 ,"%#0.

0.-%$("

+%"$ ('

* $%'

',$",,$ #(*#!%',

$",,$ -)*"(*$ C"'

# $*'!

C)$ *')

(*#!%($ +'."

$"#"

!(

 ($%

)$

 "' F(!

"&

+"

"

"0!

"&"

$%! *"

("-$%

+"

'77("$%$ "$%$,' A"

+(%$","($  $ ($ +'."

)*"(* *('

,'?"'

# $*'!

@)'!%# ,$%% 

* '&"#%

#$ #5;541516"

,'7#

-  

F!    ',  '77("$%  "(!%$  '  2<1513  "

!#  0. 

 '-'$ ?$ $"('

-%$

@,$%% !

* ($ +'.

"'77("$%$ +'. 21 $+!# & *'!+* *-'&"

$%$

'# #$ #5<511523)$ &#!-'

 ,"70!

*F-%$

0"

+-!

,' *0.

0.-%$("

+%"$ ('

*'77("$% "(!%$"

!#"

*.$1513$ $7"

)"

* -( '$ ("(!%$ $",,'# ,'($ "7)* *$

 ,! *('

)"

*

*%"$ ('

$"# ("(!%$"

&"#

*$

+"&

,' $ +

*%( . !--%.', !

* ($ +'.0.-%$("

+ %"$ ('

8229"

7"

("&#*(*#!%',$",,,''

"#

"$%!--%.8 9($ +'.$--%" $"# $",, (*#!% '$ G" '

+ %$

H$7'

+

&$"'!

* "#

"$%-7"

!(*$ 0!

*'!

("

7$ (%!0 ',,"( *'

% 7'

% 7$"$+ -%$( #-$

$%

'  ( !07"

*F-

?" '

+%$

@*$ '0$#"

*('

F !', $( *$&0 7

# *!

#$ -

F!  ', * $%'

$",,$--%"($0% '$+!--%.

"$% '

!7 89"

*') 3 (I$( '" ($ #" ='%# '$+ )  ('&#  !

#  *  

"$%  $ +'.  $  & -$(A$+"

+$

'$+!

$% ',%%"

$"#"

"$%(*#!%

!07"

"7"%$-'&"

 )$% '7$#"

*
#"!7!--%.

"$%')8
9($ +'.)*"

*'%# '$+(I$( '" ($ #" ,%%"

($ +'. ('

*? $*'!

@*$&"

+ 0  %$ #  '!

'  $  -*$7$  "

.  ,'  ?

'$+  ',  *" 7$ !,$( !##!+ !

#('

'%%# 7-$ ! @"

*!

7'$A"

+ ($ +'.',$

'$+!

$#',0"

+($ +'"D#$ "'

%$

   !

#  *     ($ +'.    ,! *  !07"

(%$

","($ 7$#0.

)'!%# 0'  '!

',$

%%"+"0% #",,

"$

($'%# '$+"

('&#!

#$ 

"$% ,'

!--%.',%( .)*

'$+',-"

*$0%"

7 #'

 *"

$ )*.$7-$ !'

'%%# '$+ "'

# ,'

$7'0/( 0!

$#",,

-'#!( )'!%#0#",,

"$ #7%.'

*0$ ',($ +'"D$ *'%# '$+' !',-'#!(

'# $% '$+!# ( 21:', %( .( 1553#,"

 $!

*'"D# ', %( . !07"

 & &"'%$ .', $"#('

* %( .'

')* 0"

#0.*"7,'$-!-'

'

* ,')*"(*!

%(

*$#0 $!

*'"D#'$ .-7"

'

* )*

!--%.*$ $!

*'"D#%%,$( ' *$&"

+0 #"

(%'

# '($ ,'$

$!

*'"D#!

',%( .)$ &7$#'!

 23

  ,! *  ('

*  -7"

 *$#  +!%$%.  0

-( ##!"

*-"'#,'7%$ ',('

 "%% *'#',

&#!-'

 -$

+7' ,"&.$  '#,"(" (.'#,( & "(#$ '#7$ #)$ $"

#,'

*

"#!$ ',,"&.$

 ,! * !07"

&

!7"

*'#*$ '07$#,' $A',$+!7



('!%# F(#0.'

#217'

* ,'7 *#$ '

)*"(* !(* 7$# 26 $ #  ('!

%  ,'  *  

"

"0!

 "(

 *')& !07"

*'#',$

*$#0 "+* %.-$

#"

$(('#$ ()"

* *%$) !% #+!%$

$--%"($0%$ *G"

5 '

  -%$

H $('&#!

* ($ +'.)*"% %( .  !--%.  %$ #  '  *  -   )$  !

#  *  

"$% $ +'. * $"#')$ # # *(*$+)$  $

*  '0/(

 ,"%#  0.  *  -   )  #!%.  ('

"##  $ #  ) #(%"

#    ,! *  !07"

*  $(('!

 ',  *  -   )$

'&*$!%#'

%.,'$-"'#',217'

* $(('#"

+!%$ 3:',

%( .!--%.'#= %$ #
$

 +!%$

155<$#)"

* 

F!;8298$9$ ,' *

"#!$  $% !07"

#

- %( .!--%.

!(

1525 *(*#!%', $",,,''

"#

"$%!--%.8 97$ #$ #"

-$$212 "'

)'!%#$% '0('&#!

$"#(*#!%" * $ +'. 24

,! *('

*.$% '!+* -(","((%$","($

,'7 ,,"(',-!

.*",

+"

$ *.,# * $% '

 ',  $",,  $ #  (*#!%  ',  $",,  $  "

!#  0.  *  *", '77"

$ -)*"(*"'

 $*'!

)'!%#,$%%!

($ +'.', $ !--%.*$ "+* %.$

# 2:

0"

+('

,'

#)"

* *$&7

7$#"

-$$3', -%"7"

$.  !07"

  %$ #  ('!

%  ,'  

"

"0!

"(

 !07"

*# ("- $0'!

'&*$!%"

+0"

+'

%.,'$ -"'#',217'

* $(('#"

'+!%$ 3:', %( .!--%.

'#=%$ #7$

 +!%$

155<"

,$( !$%%."

('( $ $(('!

*$ '&*$!%#,' *

"#!$ $,  %$   ',  %( .  ('

"%%  *  '#  ',  *  $

   *')&('

*%"7"

,'$-"'#',217'

* - ("0# )* "7-"'#"

# 7"

$0%$ )* !(* "7-"'#"

( "0% *"

"0!

"(

"



%# '%&. $% .,'



*

"-"'#,')*"(* !(*!

$!

*'"D#!

*$ ('

!# 2< ''

*$+!7

*$ $#&$ (#'/!#+7

("

#0. ('!

%,'"

*-$  2; *$&*$#%$ #('!

%$--$"

+,' -( "&-$

#*$&+'

*'!+* *('#)"

* *"$0%$

( 2> *('B!

)*"(*$"

,'('

"#$ *"

'!

'  )* *  $  ?"  '

#   '$+     $*'!

@  ,' -*$7$(!

"($%('7-$ .)'!%#,$%%!

#$ 

"$%$( .'*$ '0

$ G ($ +'.H!

#$ "'

#

%$

 15 #"

-!

$, ('7"

+"

','(', *%( ( 1553'

%.$ $--'-"$ ('77"

('7-

'($.'!

F("

,'# 7"

$",,!

:1', *%( .$( 1553$ #"

#&"

!(* $",,$(%$

","($ '($ +'"D$ ($ 0 7$#0. *$--'-"$ ('77"

- ("0"

+#",,

$",, (*#!%,' #",,

.- ',!

$+*

"$%$ # ($ +'.$ '7', #",,

($ +'" *$&0 - ("0#"

*$",, ","#  - %( .!--%.

!(


$ !$%1525?$'%# '$+@ )$ 0'!+* )"

*"

*$70"

',$

"$%$( .*(%$

","($

)0'$#%.0'!+* '!

*)$ ',! * !0 ($ +'"D$ 0$ !',-'#!(

'#'

( *0'$#($ +'.',?

'$+@E)* * ('%#

'$+' ,'-$(A$+"

+  ( ) (%$

","#!

*

"$% $ +'. 12 *  ('

#  $+!7

 $#&$ (#   $ '  7$ !,$( !"

+ $( .)$ 0"

* ( *('

!7- )'!%#0#7# 0$('77("$%('

)'!%#,$%%,%$ %.'

*$+!7

*($ +'"D$ #'

0. *7 (& $G'%# '$+H

6 )'!%# ,$%%"

$($ +'.)*$ .7$ !,$( !"

+$( )#'

 *!

 *$ ++"& '),' !(*(%$

","($ #' )"

*

*"') (!

.*'

*(%$

","($ ,' *($ +'.('

,! *)"# #"

(%!#

'$+$ #-$(A$+"

'

"$%  '  7$ !,$( !"

+  $( .  )'!%#  $% '  0  - !7#  '  0 $G

'$+$ #-$(A$+"

H$ )%%*!

*F-%$

-!

,' * 7!

&'%&$7$ !,$( !"

+-'(

0,'$

"$%

($ 0%$ ##' *'%#+'!

#*/!

","($ 0*"

(%$

","($ !

* ($ +'.+"&

"

0$

'%%.'

*!

', *F-

?"'

#%$

 @)*"(* *')&"

0"

+$#$%'

+)"

* *-(#"

+$( 7

*!

#($,!%$#"

+', *(*#!%',$",,,''

"#

"$% !--%.8 9($ +'.$ -  1522 *') ,' !--%.', %( . '0($ +'"D#$   !--%.,' *G"'

 %$

H*$# '0"

"#

"$%-7"

!(*$ 0!

*'!

("

7$   (%!0   ',,"(   *'

-"

$%  $ #  -"&$   #!($ $%  "

*'

% 7'

%   #-$

$% 

'   *'-   +!

 *'!

 $ #  

$!$

(%!#"

-'

,$("%"

(%!#"

++.7 "!7  (*!

 (%$

","($ ', ($ +'.)$ *0$ ',"

$%%$ ',$ " '

# '$-%$

#$ * *"

$%%$ *$"('

-%$

*$# '0"

$-7"

)* *(%$

","# !',$( ' $( "7"%$  '  "

 )  0"

+  !

  *  (%$

","($  $ ($ +'"D$ !

$0'& *') *$( !(*$

'$+ -$(A$+"

+)$*'!

+ (#' ,$%%"

*$0'&($ +'.!

# (*#!%',$",,$ #"

(%$

","($ 22F $( #*"

$, 0%') ?

 



  
 








      

  

       

 

       

 

                               

   

         ! 

         

        

    

     

      "

11 ,! * #"

-!

*$,' $"#!--%."

!(

)"

,'($ *.$1523)* *-'&"

$%$

&.# $ *,"

$%'#',$

-$

# $A"

+$ (%!,'7 $"#(%$

","($  "

$% ' &"#

!(* ($ +'"D$ ',$

'$+$ #-$(A$+"

#$ )%%$ *('%#

'$+

0"

+-$ #-$(%',$

"$%$( .7$"

#"

$(  13 *($ +'"D$ ') '!+* '0#'

0.

"

0$ #!-'

$('( $#"

+', *"') ("(!%$ )"

,'($ *%&$

-'"

"7"7"%$($ +'"D$ $% ',%(

(*#!%',$",,',1513'

*0$ )*', *"

$,,"#$&"

*$

0 ,"%#* $7$#  *!

#   



 $ %                             & 

 &                                     

           

     

        

   '

() 


         

      

  

 
    

              *       +     

,  *     

    

   

         ! 

    

  

     -
.
$ #    )

   /

  *  #    

    

  

     "

01 *  $,' $"#  ($ +'"D$

$

 ,'7  "#

"$% -7"

!(*$ *'!

("

7$ (%!0 ',,"( *'

% 7'

% 7$"$+ -$%$( *'

7"F$#.7"F-%$

#-$

$%

'  *'- +!

*'!

$!$

,'%"+*

,$

-!7-"

$"('

-%$

%",

)%#"

 7$%%%$ %( "(#"%% *$   ( ( *"

$%%$

',$"('

#-%$

*$ '0"

!(*$-7"

 %

*$( .',

'$+$ #)$*'!

+"

-!

$"#($ +'."

($

0 !0/( #

*  $",,7%.'

$(('!

',"

$%%$ ',$"('

 14

&"#

%. $",,($ +'"D$ *$ #'

'

*0$ ',

*$( $0"

0,'$-$ "(!%$ $",,"

$--%"# *$( .)*"(*"

0"

*"

?

'$+)$*'!

+  !

@  ,'  )*"(*  $  %( .  !--%.  *$#  0

'0 $"

*B!"7

',

$0%"

*"

+$ $"('

+$%-$ ',?

7-$ !('

'%%#

'$+!

@  '0#-%'.#,'

'$+',?-*$7$@$ #"

"7"%$ '?('%#

'$+@B!"-7

B!"# 0"

$%%#,'

'$+',-"

*$0%"

7 #"

("7"

7%.'

0$  ',  *  !  ',  -'#!(

'#  ,'  !0/( +  $7  !0

"$% $( '#",,

$","

& *)"

0' ,'7 *$#"

+',

*(*#!%',$",,$ $--'&#0. *$--'-"$ '77"





"

%$) &

)* *($ +'"D$ '(%$

","($ *$ '& %$--"

*$# "

$",, (*#!% ","#0. *'77"

$'! ', $))'!%##$)$-$$%%%$ #+$  "7"%$"

."

!',$( 0,'# 7"

+$ ')*"(* $",,($ +'.)'!%#$('

!7,$%%

' 1: * !',$( .!

"

$A"

'$

$( . )'!%#,$%%"

*($ +'.',G

'$+H$ #G('%#

'$+H$

$+$"

G$"('

#!

-%$

H ( $",,$--%"($0% *,'7 )'!%#0$--%"($0% 1<

& *)"



0"

*$!

*'', $"#

!(

($

(%$"7$#&$

$+ *7 %& ,'$ .%$-  ,"

', !(*'7"

*$ '0F ##"

,$&'!', *('

!7)*'*$

7$#$ .('

($%7

',$ . !)*$

'&$ "7', !07"

+

*$--%"($ ,'%$ ',%( .('

('7-% #"

(%'

!$

+$# *"

$%%$ *-%$

*$#0 7$#$ #$-*.

"($% &","($  )$  $% '  !

 0,'  *  %$   ',  *  %(

*!

"

($

0('

!# *%( .('

0"

#,'$ .-!-'

'

* ,')*"(*"

*$#0 $!

*'"D#* ($ * (#' ,$%%"

*($ +'.',$ !

$!

*'"D#!

',%( #( 21:', %( .( 1553 1; I' *$0'&

#$

,"

*'#-$

#0.

 !

#  (  21:  ',  *  %( .  (   1553  %&."

+  $ ,"

- $% . ',

654:<1< "

0$#$ #"

0$ #!-'

('( $--("$ ',,$(

$% *-'&"

%( .!--%.

!(


$ !$%$ )%%$ * $%'

',$",, 1> *-

)"

- $(('#"

+%.$%%')#*"7-!+

 #7$ #"

"#*- #-'

",$ .7$#0. $

"7',-,"

'.$--$%!

#( 21< *$%%0$#/!

#0.

$%'

+)"

*

'."



)"

*"

$-"'#', *7'

*

',("- ',$( ","#('-.', *"

'# +,,

0
 /,  / !7 8 )   * -$A"

+$ J ' *-' $0% J '