Vijay Pal Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
125
**** !"!#$%
& '
&($#!)*+ ,-./*$!
01$2
& 321"2!4 ..#+ ,-./*$!
& ( *5*# 1#62+ ,-./*$!
*8891/*#$
& : 1 4+ ; * <*#*
==== 2!"!
(#,!
,!
(9!
!*, 01$2
!/$1.#"
!*, 01$2 $1/9!
.#"$1$($1.#
#,1*
3!2*97 8!$1$1.#! "
*6*1#"$
A 3(#/2 /*"!"
1#/9(,1#6
!* #!, /.(#"!9 !-1!0*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#! "
/.#$!#,
0219!
,!*91#6 01$2 9* 6!
1""(!
02!$2! ..8! *$1-!
!61"$! !, (#,!
* <*#* ..8! *$1-!
./1!$1!"
/$+ C 0.(9, 7*99
01$21# *531$ $*$!
.
*#< 9./*9 *($2. 1$< $*$!
(#,!
$1/9!
*5!#*39!
)( 1",1/$1.# "8!/171/*99< !D(!"$
5*$$!
3(#/2 8!$1$1.#! E"
!-.9-!"
* .(#, ,1"$1#/$ * 6(5!#$+ 2.0!-! + 21"
$*4!# ,!/1,!, *9.#6 01$2
3(#/2 /.( $ ,.!"
8! $*1#
*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#!
$ * 6(!, *8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#!
/9!* !, 3.$2 0 1$$!#
$!"$ 1#$! -1!0 8."$ 21!7 #61#!!
*,, !""!, (8.#
$1/9!
/.#$!@$ 1#,1-1,(*9 "(6* 5199"
02! !*"
.9!
(6* 7!,021/2 ,1 !/$!, 8(#1"25!#$ *6*1#"$ *8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#!
#!!,"
-1-
*,)(,1/*$!, "!8* *$!9<
!
7( $2!
( 6!, .551$$!!
7. 5!,
.-! #5!#$ -1,!
1$"
!8. $
"(88. $!, 8!$1$1.#!
7.(#, ,!71/1!#/1!"
0. 4 &B"
15*#1 :.19! "
021/2 7( $2!
7. $171!, /.551$$!!
!162$ 1#,!8!#,!#$ 5!53! "
"(88. $1#6
*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#! + 2.0!-! + ,!"81$!
2!
"(3)!/$!, 5*).
8!#*9$< 3!"1,!"
!/.-! 1!"
!* , 9!* #!, /.(#"!9 !-1!0*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#!
21"
/.#"1,! !, "(351""1.#"
*,-*#/!, 9!* #!,
/.(#"!9 !-1!0*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#!
$.$*99< (#7.(#,!, 51"89*/!,
8! ("*9 !/. ,
$ "!!# * 6(5!#$ !6* ,1#6 "!6 !6*$1#6
/*"!+ 7*/$"
-1!0!, #* .0 /.58*""
5*1#$*1#*3191$< 1""(!
.$2! 01"!
0.(9, 2*-!
,!*9$ 01$2 1#"$*#$
8!$1$1.#*"
0!99 719!, !-1!0*8891/*#$B8!$1$1.#! "+ "1#/!
8 *<!
5*,!
1-19 1$ !$1$1.# D(* 1""(1#6 ,1 !/$1.# /.#"1,!
8!$1$1.#! ?"A 8 .5.$1.# 2!
*88.1#$1#6 ($2. 1$< (#,1"8($!,9<
&*#*61#6 ;1 !/$.
!"8.#,!#$
. $2!
*90*9 ..8 $, *#,+
8 .5.$1.# . ,!
*9".
"*1, ($2. 1$< "
7*
D(*"21#6 . ,!
A *9.#601$2 /2* 6!"2!!$
A
/.#/! #!, . ,!
2*"
*9".
&*#*61#6 ;1 !/$.
!"8.#,!#$
.
$
*//.(#$+ 2*"
".(62$ 3*"1"
158(6#!, . ,!
A
&*#*61#6 ;1 !/$. + * <*#* $*$!
!,! *$1.# ..8! *$1-!
$,
?(6* 7!,AB !"8.#,!#$
.
3*"1"
/2* 6!"2!!$
A 2*"
1""(!,+ $.$*99< (#7.(#,!, *#,3*"!9!""+
8! ("*9 9!$$!
A /.55(#1/*$!,
-2-
!"8.#,!#$
. B(6* 7!, &*#*61#6 ;1 !/$.
?(6* &199" !"8.#,!#$
. A .#9< "$*$1#6 F
G .#9<
D(* "!!41#6 *,-1/!
*#,+ *,-1". < #*$( !+ 3($ 31#,1#6
9162$ 7*/$+ 1$ /*#+ !*"19< /(99!, .($ ##!@( !
158(6#!, /2* 6!"2!!$ + 021/2 2*"
*,51$$!,9<
1""(!, !"8.#,!#$
. B(6* *6*1#"$ 021/2
8!$1$1.# 2*"
719!,
21"
2*"
162$9< *,)(,1/*$!, D(!"$1.# 5*1#$*1#*3191$<
1#"$*#$ *9.#601$2 3(#/2 /.##!/$!,
01$2.($ "!6 !6*$1#6 "*5!+ "1#/!+ 1$ *9".
1#-.9-!"
1,!#$1/*9 "1519*
D(!"$1.# 9*0 &. !.-! + *6*1#"$ 158(6#!, /2* 6!"2!!$
> A+ !5!,< 8!$1$1.#! "
*9".
*-*19*39!
0*< *# *88!*9+ 021/2 91!"
3!7. !
:.* , ;1 !/$. "
&199
7*/$ /.(9, ,!#1!, & *0*# '(5* &($#!)*+ 9!* #!,
,-./*$!
,( 1#6 /.( "!
2!* 1#6
7*/$+ 2!
1#7. 5"
"(/2 !5!,< *88!*9 *9 !*,< "$*#,"
!@2*("$!,
8!$1$1.#! "+ 021/2 "$*#,"
,1"51""!,
!91*#/!
/*# 89*/!,
!
!
"1# 021/2 1$ 2*"
2!9,
8.1#$ 2*"
2!* , ,!/1,!,
7. 5 6 .(#,
!-!# *""(51#6 $*4!# (#,!
! .#!.("
*#.$2!
8 .#.(#/!5!#$ (8 !5!
#$
%&#
!' (')H
-3-
"/.8!
8!$1$1.# $! 5"
. ,!
I
02! !1# -! < 9151$!,
6 .(#,"
* !
*-*19*39!
8! $*1#1#6 8 15* 19< ! .
*88* !#$ 7*/!
!/. , 8!$1$1.# !#$! $*1#!, 5! !9< *//.(#$
7*/$ *#.$2!
8.""139!
2!
!9!-*#$
8. $1.#
(#,! %
!"
! " # $% & ' ( )* +
!"
!" ,
!# (
+ -
!
/*"!+ *8* $ )(,1/1*9 8 .#.(#/!5!#$"
,1"/(""!, 2! !1#*3.-!+ 7*/$(*9 *"8!/$"
2*-1#6 ,(9< /.#"1,! !,+
$2!"!
$0.
/1-19 5*,!
.($
A )("$ 8 .8!
"*5!
*7$!
!@*51#1#6 5*$! 1*9 !/. , "(/2 $2! !
#.
! .
*88* !#$ 7*/!
1$
//. ,1#69<+ 3!1#6 ,!-.1, 5! 1$
* !2! !3<,1"51""!,
2.$./.8< . ,!
89*/!, !/. ,
/.##!/$!,
1"2*9
!""#$%&!'()*
&!'"
-4-