M/S The Warrier Mining Minerals & Infra Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana & ORS




  
       !"#$ %"&' ($#

#$ )*'+%) ,) %'% -
"%  .-

  '/' 0%"%1% %% -+' 

'2 '
 



 
 
 


 



' (   3 %% 0-+/40 -&%5+ ) 0 0+%3%4-&%4"+2  ) %+/0 ,+42/1-&% %4%1% %4 "'2 '

 ) 3% +%/-+%14-&%4"'2  )

%40 -&%5+ )'

/8 %93% 4-&%4"'2 '

!

:::: 
 
 
+ 2  +%' &+% ,- + %&&2% & " + 8- " '

!% -  +,/ -+%+15'/83-81 -+ 3'2/%- +;%/& & +2 '/83'+%+8-' '/83-81'2 '

!% - %+/,++,++% +2 <' 8-81
 7&'% -
= $&''2&1/,+ +%8 %&&2-%'+153%-3+%  $3 /'%"+2 <'8- +%>&-+2

# 1 % & -%- ## #$  + %1% %  3  "3- + , % 2/8& +% 3 , %'' 5/- 8 ,% - " + ?%& "3 3 %'

 ,%''58%/& -"% 2- "   1%' %&+  + 8-' 5  8 '/83- " %3/ ' 2


%

/3  + % & ' @/ % & '/&  " + "5 , & - '"+;%/& &(;
     

              

                             

        



         !     

        "  "    

  

# $  

                    %&'%%'() '*#'' +  %,'%%'() (%#'' - ." !           

/ " ('     0           "   ((#1' +  (%#'' 2              0        ('  !        "         

    3 0            "  0 ('       !   

    4    

          0   ('('  !  

          ',#''        0    "     (%           "            "                  4"     2             4"   

'53 -%4+8-'58"%3/ '2 %

/38/+-/% "+%''5%' $1%'

+2 '/83-


8-' " 2 '

# % - 4 '2   ! 8- " 2 '

# % -  % - 

8-"2

'2  !--'/838-'3+%  $3 /'%"+ 2 <'8- '2&"+'%33  +"'3+'+%22 -5%' 5+  + 2  8- '

!4$ 4!$$$$*; % #( (7# =$ % - '2   !8-
 !4$A4!$4$$$*;% #(#A( #

+8-"'2  !5%'4 +"4 3 +%  $ 3 /' %" + 2 <' 8-  + 2 4 +54&  /-8-- ,+ -%'--++8--'

3%1 +8-"'2  !"
 4!$4$$$*;5%'++,+' !

+' 5%' '     + 8-- , 85  + 2  % - ' !% - "2

+"'3+ $3 /'35%' &''- 85  + 2  % - '2  '

! % -  5%' 5+  + 2 8-
 4 74!$4$$$*;% #(#(7

# B% -'2  !8-
 !4!$4$$$*; % #(7 ($ ==!

  + 8--'   '2& " 2  &/- ,+2 4+54&  /-8-- , 3%1+8-" 

"
 !47!4!$4$$$*;% !(!B(!

7=$5%'++,+' 

 0-+/4+% -' &/ '%22% , 8+%""+ 2  '/83- +% + 33  3 +%  $ 3 /' +%- %2'- 85 +2 <'8-% -+'"+'2 '4+'%/,+ +%8 & "3- +2 <'"%/5+/23 ,% 1"/+ 8-'

  & -- +% / - &%/' C D " + ;%/& &4  & $ 3 /' %2'- %" % 8-4  "/+ 8-' &%  8 23-   "/+ '/83-+%+ $3 /2-3/'8&32/- '2&"+8-' "%&+"+ ''2%%1 +'2 '& --+5'


&&- ,+3"%8-''/83- '2&"% 1"+ '4 + 2- " $ 3 /' &33 &' "3 +% 3 " % + 3 '


+ 5-'4 %&&- ,  + '2 '4 31 8&%/' % 2- " $ 3 /'%2''"3%8- '2&"%2%&/%3 45/-3%E  -"" &"-/ ,+' $3 /2-%8-''/83- '2&"% 1 +3 
'32%  +%+%/& 5%'+- '2&"% + ''3/% /'1 +8-- ,E2%&'3/% /'1"% +  3 '

 %&+ " + 8--' 5%' ,  % ' , /'
  5+&+  -+3'/83+8-' ;  8--5%' -8-"% 1

/38"3 '

&/-8-">/' %+ '

+' "%&'%''' + 2% "&%/''C D% -CD = +"'' & &%/'C D2-'+%F    

        

 

!

 "    

   #       $

  #    GGGG

+" &'F

      

 

!

 EH  + 5-' F

        

 

H -&%%" &%8- '2&"% 1"+ '% - % 1 2%&/% 3   + 5-' +% "5' FGGGGGG +  + 3 " &'/"+%/& GGGGH"+%/&  , % '2&" %+ '% - +3  '2&"5+&++%8-' &- 
"+ 5%'3+" &+8-' '2&"  1 % 2%&/% 3 4 + &%/' 5/- +% 8  5-- -"" 1 
 5/-+%8 '2&"&%12--+% &%'% 18- '2&"% 2%&/%3 '&- $3 /'2&'/"+8-'85 +3'2/%-4+ +3"&'/"+%/&  '2&"+%


2%&/%3 5/-8? -- +%4+545/-@/+&%/' 85 5+&+' 23''8 + '& - ' &   &%/' C D %' '/22' +' & '/&


2-'+%+? ' " $3 /'5/-&  / +8-'%&-5+ + ? $3 /'"+%'8-F"% 1"+ 3 H +5-'F 

  

H3%E&%+%+" &+ 8-''  '2&"%2%&/%3 8/ '2&"% 1"+  3 '

+' ,/%I3 <%22%'8%12,%2+&% + 5%'8/'1/'+2/%I3 '< +''&%"3+5-'F

   

+/'+? ' " $3 /'5/-&33 &"3%8- '2&"% 1"+3 '% -8%22&%8% 1"+3 '


+ 5-'4 " % 8- ' &-   '2& " % 2%&/% 3 4 + 5/- %/3%&%18% ? ' " $3 /''/83%8- '2&% 1" ++3 '%'5

 "3%2%&&%2 "54+'& '/& &33 -' '"/'

'53 -%4%8--3%18-"% 1 /38" 3 ' ; + 3%1 8- " % +  3 '

 +   5%'  , + 8--'%' %8332+8-'

8--3%18 "/ &-81 +8-'&- 31 '2&" "+3 '+%++%'8-" 8/  '2&"++3 '+%++%'8-" 8--5++%' 8-"3+%  5/- %/%1%E33 '2 - '2&"%&+"+3+% %8--5+8-'" 1  
5/- 8-""&/"'/&+%8--E2%&E"+3 '2&"'% 8-''2%%1


#
 ' %' %8  2'/3 +% + 2%1   ,  -' --  3%E  &    " 8--'  32 + 8-'

  2%1  , -'&%

82'/3-&%/'8'%&'*-""&/' 2%' 32 ,+8-'

+%5/-8'"-"% ,

 0-+/'/83-+%+&%/'' &% '/83- +%+ 2% 2%&-81+3'%'2%/'8 . /' 2'/3 +%  8 ' 
" % &%/'   % &33&% -&/3  '2&%1   +% '2/%' + 3' % - & - ' " % %/& '&%2%8"5 2% '455/-/ +'% ,1"%/+  +%%-% &'+2/2'"% %/& %318% +8'2&   %/&  ' '' %1 & -/&-   %8 + '  8%  + 8' 2& +%% %/& & -/&-81+0%' '/3 %''%' ,%+2%''3%1'/%-% 22/ 1"2%&2% , +  /' " + 0% ' % -""  3% %,+    2  %/&  '

+''8% +8'2&"3%+,88--' !

"+2 <'& '%&&2-4+""&%'2 ' 5/-'%8/
 7&' '2&"2 #% -%8/
= $&' '2&"2

+15/-%''%,%3/ ' %&&/ " '/&+%  2%   '2&"++' 2'

+%4+54 ' +8%''" 2 ,+%,3  
"+2% % ,/%,"+ 3'5%'&%4+/5/- 8>/'"-  2 ,+3' +5'31 %&&/ "+" % &%,% +%%&&/' "%/" +""&%'2 '

54 "+2 <'&%''%&&2-4+""&% '5/- 88/ -  %& %&5+ +''&%


"3&%/' #5+&+2-'+%+8-'""-5/-82' %1 %&&2- % - + & 5/- 8%  + -' " +  3  +

% 3"-/84&%/' #2-'+% 8-'+%8 ,%--%''/&&''"// ''%&&2-81+ 3  %-5+- "%/ " + 2 4  5/- ' +% 8  2   + ""&% '+%&&2>&+8- 
" %&&/ "+ 3/' -"" & +8-'+""&%'2 '-&--+-%"'+%/& 4 +1&/- +%8 "%/- +&&/3'% &'4+2 '-'3''- C0  9J
 D 

  0
 $#

#$   C

 ..
D I% -<   





 

√