Kamlesh Rani v. State Of Punjab & ORS
!"#$#%&'&() *!+,#'- !(& #"&"&(#. '
/#.'0'
1"!"#0(2!3!($"-#.'
#'4($#(" '
) 56 1 * 61 .#'#(")7 .*0,3-0'-!( !-#2!8$9%!"#8."-#4#"&"&(#. .('-0, 04"!8''&'"!(" 0(2!3 .+!(1-!.+!8$9%!"#8.8 .11-!,&:!,8$9%!"#8..#'4($#("'!($; -#"-#."-# #4."#.',%!,(#:'4!4#.+!<3#!,,:#$" '##"-#20$=+#("> 3#.##..#$""-# #4."#..(" ; -#"-#."-#20$=+#("'-0,$3#.#4."#$&("-#$&=#'"> 77 77 * 61
6 -#4#"&"&(#.8:-:!':.?&(=!'!1#(&.''&'"!(":&"- .#'4($#("70(2!3 !"#. #'0.%#' !(!=#+#(" !($ #9#,4+#("
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
77 !$-%'#.9&%#!($'#(&.&"<8A0!:-&%-%.'':.&"':#.#&,#$:.&" 4#"&"&(&# 7B78"&",#$!'!.'-!(!1-!.+!!($"-#.'/#.'0' 0(2!31"!"#03#:#,, .4.!"&( !($"-#.'8:!'$&'4'#$ 3<!
.$&(!"##(%-"-&' 0."8:&"-!$&.#%"&(".#'4($#("'".+0,!"# "-#'#(&.&"<,&'"!.#'-!($%($0%""-##C#.%&'#:&"-&('&C+("-'.+"-# $!"#.#%#&4"%#."&&#$%4<"-#.$#.89&$#.$#.$!"#$B;
((#C0.#7 7 "&'0."-#.$&.#%"#$"-!"&&"&'0($"-!""-#4#"&"&(#.' !.#"3#4!&$"-#%('#A0#("&!,3#(#&"'8"-#'!+#3#4!&$:&"-&(": +("-'"-#.#!"#.-#!#%"#$#+4,<##'8.&9!"#.#'4($#("';" @&( 7B784.##..#$!(!44#!,ʥ@8"&",#$!' +!.2&"*!0.!($!("-#./#.'0'0(2!31"!"#03#:#,, .4.!"&(!($ "-#.'8:-&%-:!'$&'+&''#$3<!&9&'&(#(%-"-&' 0."(;@
((#C0.#7 7; -#4#"&"&(#.&''"!"#$"-!9#=&9#(!(!&$!9&"&( #3.0!.<8 ((#C0.#7 7 :-#.#3<'-#-!$.#A0#'"#$"-!"'-#+!<3# !,,:#$"-#4!<+#("-&=-#.'%!,#(!%%0("-&=-#..#'4('&3&,&"&#'!' 0(&.''&'"!(" 1-#-!$0."-#.!=.##$"-!"'-#:&,,-!9#(32#%"&( :&"-.#=!.$"4,!%#+#("!($&C!"&(-#.4!<'%!,#'&("#.+'20$=+#(" 4!''#$3<"-#&=- 0."":!'0."-#.0($#."!?#("-!"&&"&'0($3<"-#
.4.!"&("-!"4,!%#+#("(:3#&(==.!("#$""-#4#"&"&(#.&'("&( %('(!(%# :&"- "-# 20$=+#(" "-# &=- 0."8 "-# .4.!"&( &'
!0"-.&'#$ " +!?# .#%9#.< .+ "-# '!,!.< .#"&.!, 3#(#&"' !,(=:&"- !%%.0&(=&(!(%&!,3#(#&"'!($"-#4#"&"&(#.:&,,-!9#(32#%"&(.+ "-# '!&$.#%9#.< "&''"!"#$"-!""-#!.#'!&$:.&"4#"&"&(&# 7 B7:!'&(!,,<$#%&$#$(B; ((#C0.#7 7 8&(:-&%-&"
:!'-#,$"-!""-#!$-%'#.9&%#&'(""3#%0("#$":!.$''#(&.&"<!($ "-#'#(&.&"<,&'":!'.$#.#$"3#.#7%!'"#$!''0%--#!44#!, 67
7;7 7@ 4.##..#$3<"-#!#%"#$#+4,<##'!=!&('""-#'!&$:.&"4#"&"&(
7B7 :!'&(!,,<$&'+&''#$3<!&9&'&(#(%-"-&' 0."
( ;@ ((#C0.#7 7; " &' 0."-#. '"!"#$ "-!" "-# =.!"0&"< !+0("&(=" 'B8D@8@ 7:!'4!&$(@!($"-#.#9&'#$=.!"0&"< ' ;B8@B 7 :!' 4!&$ ( ;; -# ,#!9# #(%!'-+#(" :!' :&"--#,$!'"-#,!'"4!<$.!:("-#4#"&"&(#.%0,$(,<-!9#!..&9#$!" !"#."-#$#%&'&("-#:.&"4#"&"&(-#,#!9##(%!'-+#("!+0("&(="
'8@8BBB 7!($ '8 7:#.#4!&$(B@!($D@ .#'4#%"&9#,< -!9#-#!.$"-#,#!.(#$%0('#,'."-#4!."&#'!($-!9#!,' %!.#0,,<=(#"-.0=-"-#&,# $+&""#$,<8 "-#.# :!' ! $&'40"# .#=!.$&(= '#(&.&"< !($ %('#A0#("&!, .#7&C!"&( "-# '!,!.< 3#":##( ": '#%"&(' "-# #+4,<##'-#!&$!9&""-#4#"&"&(#. ((#C0.#7 7 4.$0%#$(&,# '-:'"-!"'-#-!$0($#."!?#(!($!0"-.&'#$"-# .4.!"&("+!?#!(< .#%9#.<.+-#.'!,!.< .#"&.!,3#(#&"'8&"-#'!+#&'0($$0#-#'!&$ !&$!9&":!'0.(&'-#$&(#3.0!.<8!($"-#4#"&"&(#..#"&.#$.+ '#.9&%#(; ("-&'%!'#8"-#=.!"0&"<:!'.#,#!'#$(@ !($ "-#.#9&'#$ =.!"0&"<:!' .#,#!'#$ (;; -#'!+#:#.# .#A0&.#$"3#.#,#!'#$ :&"-&("-.##+("-'.+"-#$!"#.#"&.#+#(" -#.#.#8."-#$#,!<#$4!<+#("=.!"0&"<!($"-#.#9&'#$=.!"0&"<8"-# 4#"&"&(#.&'#("&",#$"&("#.#'"!""-#.!"#E4#.!((0+
#=!.$&(="-#,#!9##(%!'-+#("8"-#(,<4,#!.#'4($#("' &'"-!""-#6.#=!.$&(='#(&.&"<:!'&(!,,<$#%&$#$3<!&9&'&(#(%- "-&' 0."(;@!($&(.$#."+!?#"-#.#%9#.<8"-##("&.# ,#!9##(%!'-+#(":!':&"--#,$
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
##<#!.'!($"-#4#"&"&(#.&' !%%.$&(=,<#("&",#$"&("#.#'""-#.#-#.#.#8"-#.#'4($#("''-!,,4!< &("#.#'"!""-#.!"#E4#.!((0+("-#$#,!<#$4!<+#("',#!9# #(%!'-+#("!($"-#.#9&'#$,#!9##(%!'-+#("8'"!."&(="-.##+("-'.+ "-#$!"#.#"&.#+#(""&,,"-#$!"#4!<+#(" -#4.#'#(":.&"4#"&"&(&'!
* 61 '2?' -#"-#.'4#!?&(= .#!'(#$ ) #' -#"-#. #4."!3,# )