← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9389/2013dismissed

Surinder Kumari And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia14 pages

  !"!#!$% &$'()(*!(%+((( !(*#(%!

  * 

, - 

.



          

    %(,!/)0"%'$1 "#11(*!((0( 

 

  !

"



  # $  % !

"



 &  & # !

"

    

  '

 $  % $    #11(*!((0(2'3 (  )#   %%    * +   

, -  ../0  1220 12*3  1223 **40 /21 1515 1*052 122 1*43 /52. .043 1*43  121 5*/5  5020  12*  , -  2/05  120 " "

 6    "  % +  !

%! 

%%  +   7 "  8# 

 

  

  ( " %%# 

%       142.121  9 : +8  8   

  # "     ;

 " ; +  + +  "     +  8    % % +     "    8  #  "% 114  

  < 6 #      +



   8  # "#     "

  #  8    "

% #+ "

6 % 8

(   "%   8    )#    !!

"#$

  "  13122  9 :*   

% 

&'( 

  "  152.12  9 :0  % %     8

          8 9

    8 %  #+      "

!

      "

!  

 "  +  

     <   8 %       +     =   >"

    # # 

    ( "  "

%%# 

" ""  "     !   8 #   8   22554?221224      "

  2.255/?*21122/    

!% !"  

  #  % 55/? 

!% !"  

  #  % 122/    55/ %?122/ % "!% %%%# %%  "

   % " + "    )#  7%% &"  

  &)



 

* +, +  "%  "

!   !

       8 % 8 

   9 +  +            ! +

    % + "

   + % 8%  8 "

+  #  " " %%# 8    %  55/  122/  "%   8

    8"  "

 %    8 

 +"     8     55/ %   :

- ./0123.,0,4.5.,23/ /4.67

*  





 

   

 

        

                                 

             

  

         

 

 

 % % % 0   122/ % +" "

  " + 221224   :

%  $    '    /  

867  





 



 

 

        

                           

     

   

  

 

(     "   

  %  "       #  

          ( "  '

  122/   "

      1  % + % "

   % "  % "    =!  &" )#  

  9'( 

 

* +,:   )9  

  

*+,%%  8    86 )#    %  !

%   %     "     +  ) % " + "   =!  &" )#   ;4

  *+ ,!:+ "   #      "

% + 8)"

  "

    

    8 %   !

         + #  

   + 6 + %   % %#8%    8  #   "

%

%       ! ! % #    )#   !"# $% &+     %% +   ::!



 ' ( 

 

"  1*2512 (   )#  +   % 8 + =!  &"  4/:



 

"9  "  2121121   4/%%

 

'    @ % 8    8# @ -  13.35:13.4. +   52124 % "  "   =!  &" )#  

 !

:

/

   "  2/122/  )#   !

'

   !   +  %  !+   8 

 <  8     @ % 8 -

  @ -  3*4  1225 +     4211225     !+      -  *01  122 +    1*21122 

 !   -  */2  12* +    2421120 % %  

  !

  9

   # 8 "

    )#  %   8      #  8 #          #% #    !

% %  +  "  8   '  ( $% &+

  

 " %%#  %    +8   "

% + 8# + + +   "

    +!  % 8 +"

+  #      +     9    "

!   9"   +     8 "

! 8 9   " +  % ( =!  &" "

   "

"%   ""

  % "



 ! !

% 8%  

 !   "  #          

  "   "% *25

 

  <  < + ""

#% %   +

# !  !

    ""  

    + !    "

  % 8      $ ! !

 "

     #     $ ! !" +"     8 "

  8

?

 % "

%     "

% #% + +  "  "       "

% ( %!

   '  ( "

   :

)*   

        

  

  

 +   

  

   , $     #        8'    8 8   0 ') 8 1&* +%: !

   

 



      

     

   

-  #

  

  

     

   

 

 .         , $  #    ,<  )*

%+:!3< 0  ( & '*

+!



 

            

 # ,   

   */0    

 ')001   ' 2  

  

          

-   )/ 3/     



 ,  '))

    

  

 



     

  

  

       ' ))  

 

      4+ ))  5 4+  





 



     

       

              

             

         



  

 

      ')) ')001

 



     

 

  

  

             

     

                    

    

  

 

 

  .         "  

   - +   

                   6   



    

.



 

       

 #

    

  



  -



  -

  .  

     #

                                           "  

              6 

 ')) 

        

   

    7 -3     

 

 '))   '    7    





 '))  

 8     

   7 -3 .  

      7 -3 9          7                  7 -:  '))  

.  

  7 -:  <       

 +  

   9

 

!%  % -  04.

 124 8 



  9



#  !+   "      +    "

   % 122/   "

  "        

!"     123 "    "     +" +   + 8 #      +  # #   "

" +  "

"%   + 8  #

  # #  !

%  %   52124 ( %!

      :

           

 7 



      '))                     

/    

  

  3/)2       

     

        

 

 30  ;

 3//1 .  

     



         ,      

 '))              

 30  ;

 3//1     6 

        

    #  

         . 7   

 

      

    



9          ')) 



:

.     

 

<    "    

    9



    8"  "

 % 8     

 <( +" +   #  @ -  005  121  @ -  42  4  121 +" + # 

 )#   ( < $"

 +"  % " % "   !"# $% &

( 9

 %     % )#   8 ($ % &        % % 8     )# =!  &"  8 ($ % &+ % #

   +    +  8     % =! &" )#    

 #=  

*!+4):

 #      )   +" 

   ""   +  8)"

  "

   ( =!  &"   #   8   #     % =!  &"  :

%  ,<

 #="  242355/   %    +  

    ""%       +   !

%  

 !  %%  8 %   8   ""   <   8  "   

    )#   #  $% & +   8  

 =!  &"  2/122/ < ( < $% &  #% '#   %   #% &" )#   !"# $% &      

 + % #

   +    #% '#    %% +  !+   =!  &"  8 ($% & # 

    

   8 % 8  9

   % % % "  8 % "   #  ( $% &+" 

%  8 " !  #  $% &+  +   + %% + A  %  +    8 #    "

    #% &"    =!  &"         

%  "  "

 !  232/1225  %  !

% %  ""

%%       "

  %      )#   " B"  =!  &"   ""

%%  "   % +  !

%    +        "  "

    9    +   8  "  " %%#     %  8 #  ( "

   %% 8     )#  +"

  %"

8%    "  ""  "   "

   "

! ( #       + =!  &" )# 

2

 8      

  %  %% +  !+ +"  !

 8%       % 8%  8 "" #  !+  )#   7%% &"  0;

,4"

> ? /0)*#=+   ( 7%% &"     "

   %       "     86 )#     8 %% + 8   +"      +  % +

 % %

 "" % ( %!

      :

           "       

     , .            =   " 

   =    , $  >                .        

       

           6                 6



+$     

    #     

 +6=         

 ,        $

3* 8      "  +

=             +  

                9  "       #

           +6 =   

  

                      

         

                     "    #

    6

 7 

    

                    

                        ?     ,      "    

  



  .        "  + 6=   #

    

          

 

( %#8%   $ !    + #   

   # #      "

%   + +

  8 +  "

 8  =!  &"  # @$ % &  :

  7 3   # ,     

 

     

    

    

     

$$$<$

 )/-3/         

  

  .     

 

) ) )00A

.     

  

                

          

     



A                  

 



         

6    

                  

               

   7 3 ;

 



    7 3   A       

    



    

1          

    7 3       

             5   

    



           6 

   

           7   3     

    

        7 3 .   57

 (  

$% &=# =$ % &                                6     

    7 3  

      

  $$    $<$  

          

 



         6     

        ?6 

     

                       7 *    

  .   7 *                          7 3

 % %  #  < $% &  + % +% "

# %   55/ 8  =!  &"    "   "

% + % 8  %  ( %!

      :

*    

'   

       

    

      

       

      

*                 

          

                     

>

B           9    

 

     

                            ' 22//+0///         >

B      ' 2///+C12/    

     '  ))         '             ' 22//+0///      ' 2///+C12/

              

   < 

       7       

( 

  "

  8  "

:

  &" 1425124  :!%

4

   +    

  "  )#   8 ($ #  ( $% &     % 8  9

   '  ( $% &   @       

  

 <(       +   8 "#     +    9"  )"   "% 01  

  < +8 8   8 #!      '  ( $  +!    +  "  9  "

!  !+   86 )#   9

   #=

) @5 * +  

!*+)A 

0 ""

#% #  !+  !  " 

      "  =!  &"  '  ( $% &  "

# "

%%  " "    %  +    =!  &"   "

  8 (#  % &  

 !+   8    )#   #     ) 8 # #   ""       )#  

% %%   6  

         )#   =!  &"  # @D#  <  '  ( $ % & +%% 8 %% %"

8%    "  ""  " 8 +" 

  8  % %   +       

 9#     %  +!  !+   )#   9

  '6B $% &    %%   8 % 

  "

!   8    9   " (  

 ""

#% % %   %  % % 232512.

$  -= , @<  !

? ! 'A=$> ,  ?

# C?- ,   8% C?-