High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5760/2012dismissed

Icici Lombard Insurance Company Ltd. And ANR v. Sanjeev Kohli And ORS

2023-07-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

!"# $ %&'()*# + , (((%% !!'

- "#"

(/0 12,!3', "

(((4 "% '"

!"# $ %&'()*# + , (((%% !!'

- "#"

(/0 12,!3', "

(((4 "% '"

(/0 12,!3', "

(((%% !!'"

- "#"

!"# $ %&'()*# + , "( (((4 "% '"

(/0 12,!3', "

(((%% !!'"

- "#"

!"# $ %&'()*# + , "( (((4 "% '"

"#$%&$'()(%*+,,

+ -.

, /,/, " '6

(40 /3+,)1$' 7 ', %% !!'

"% '8( 3 "*0 !! (

(5 %900)1$' 7 ', %% !!'"3 3 7 "% '"8( '3 ,

(.13 2# )1$' 7 "% '8(3

7 "% '8(3 "*0 !! , ::::

,/, 1,

( 9&',3" )",!!3"%" 77# "3( ( 73! ,!773"# $ $ %&

"*0 !! 73! ,!77', $!3 '") ;,3$,,1 3" #'7', " $$3 '( ( 3 7!& "'' ) 7$'" 7 ', $" ',' (

( / '(5#",%. 13!+;3',, ,#"

/,(5 <",,2,!3 "3 "

" ', % "";

1 !!3+31$ 3+ +3"'

'3 8(59

$ 3+7 4 %# 5,#!+3+'; "8 , 7'

'' 3+

3+ 7#$'3 ', $ ;" 3+ 31 /,(5 <",,2,!3;, ', &, $, 3', 713!!+ = '#<'; "9 !"3 )', '

#$< 3+ +3"'

'38(4= , 37'

' " ', 77 3+ '

#$< $ 7

%%"3' "3 3+ 31 & "% '8( 413 /3+,3 ", +!3+ ' 3'$!!3 ;3',1$ 3># "'3)"

"#!'/ '(5#",%. 13/,(5 <",,2,!3"#77 #!'3%!

30# 3 "3 '', "%');, "', $$#%'"'

1 !!3+3', 3!! 7' 1 $ !" "#77 30# 3 "( ?, & ;

'< ' ", *"%3'!);, 7', 30# !&/ '(/ ,0'2# ,!" @%3 (

!4;3', '', $$3 ';"+' ( ( ?, $!3 '"3( (.

(/0 12,!340312,!3A""

"; !!" 3<9, 3A#+,'

7/,(5 <",,2,!3 / '(5#",% . 13 ,

#+,' '; " % ' $!3 % '3'3" +3"'

"% '" 3( (413 /3+,A )* 0 '/3+,A;

! "# $ %& '() *# + ,

40"',A3"#

7', 77 3+'

#$<( ( ?, $!3 % '3'3 3+ ?8(

(( ,

73! &', $!3 '")$!3 3+$ % "'374"( !<," $$#'7 ',7', 3 ', / '(5#",%. 13)"#

3''3+','', $ " ;"+ #'& ") #3+ #'3># 3, ,#" #

', "'&! 7 B"5#",%9#'3># )8 !;" 3+ 4"( )B% ',( ( C, "$!3 % '3'3 3+ ?8( ?7

(( , 73! &'," 1 &$!3 '";3', ' ',7', 3 7',

/,(5 <",,2,!3$' 3+',' $ " ;" #3+'

"% '

%&! " ) 3+4"( )B% ',$$#'7,3"

% '# 3" )', $!3 '",1 "#77 !"";

'3'! '+ '', $ % "'374"( !<,"( ( + ''3+'3$ )!!', ', "% '",%% 73! ;

3'' "''

'" $' "'3+ ', $!3 % '3'3" '<3+ !

"3 3! "'3 ',', $!3 % '3'3"( 4 "% '" 8( , "#

3'' 03' ;

3'' "''

' 3"3+1 3#"! +! 0 $'3")';3'','$!3 % '3'3";

' 3'3 ! ', $!3 '",!$#""'3 $#" 7$'3' 73! ', $!3 % '3'3"', $!3 % '3'3";

7 03 7 ; 3"#

7', 1$ (

3'")"#$, "% '" 3 ',' "% '8( ,$#" &$$3 ' ', $' ',', ,

3 %!3$' 37!" $" " ''

77$')', $$3 ','< %!$ # ' ", +!3+ ' 313+7', 1$ &3'"

/,(5 <",,2,!3);,;"# ', 37!# $ 7!3># "3$ , ;" '# 3+7 ',

3+ , , 3"

,1 ;3', $, "'

+3 !"3',

3+ 7#$'3, ,! 7'',

3+ % '&3+ "'

#$<', $ +3"'', '

#$<7 "% '8( 3+ 31

"% '8( (?, ""

'3";3', '$$#%'33$ 7 ', $ " ;

!" 7#' ( ', " % ' ;

3'' "''

'" 73! ,!7 7

"% ' 8() ', $!3 % '3'3" ;

$' "' $' 3+ ','

"% '8( ;"',13+1!3 77 $'31 313+!3$ $ '

', '3 7', $$3 '', $$3 ',''< %!$ 3',

""'' 3', $!3 % '3'3"(';"7# ', "#

3'' ','37',

$$3 ';"% 1 3','$" 3','< %!$ # '7#!'7 7 ', 1$ $$#'7,3" ", +!3+ ' 313+( !!', ', "% '",% & 7 3"

3""!7', $!3 % '3'3"( ( ?, $!3 '",73! %!3$'3"'', ;

3'' "''

73! ,!77 "% '"8( #'''', ;

3'' "''

73! ,!77 "% '8($'

1 '3+', !! +'3"3', ;

3'' "''

'" ;, " 3'

'3+ ', "' '< 3 ', $!3

% '3'3"( ( ', %! 3+"7', % '3 ")7!!;3+3""# ";

7 3 ?8(

(( 6

( C, ', 5#",%. 13;37 7!' 5 <",,2,!33 $$#'730# 3 ""#"'3 3 ' 1 ,3$#! $$3 ');,3$, '< %!$ # 3+ ', 3'

1 3+ 3+,' 7 (

(

( 3', 713!!+ = '#<'; "9 !"3 )5(/( 4 %# 5,#!).3"'

3$'9',3# ' ", +!3+ ' 313+ 7'

#$< 3+ +3"'

'38(4= & "% '8( 55( ( C, ', ', $!3 '" '3'! '$ % "'3D7"';,'

@' '7 ;, D55( ( C, ', ', $!3 % '3'33"' 3'3 ! D54( ( C, ', ', $!3 '",1 !$#""'3'73! ', % " '

% '3'3D54( ( C, ', ', $!3 % '3'33" 7 03 7 $ ""

% '3 "D54( ( C, ', ',3"?

#!,"0# 3"3$'3''

&', % '3'3D54( ( C, ', "% '8( ;"',!3+1!3 77 $'31 313+!3$ $ )37"3'" 77 $'D54( ( 4 !3 7( ( C3', ' ? 8( ? 7

(( ) ', !& 377 $ 3', 3""# "3";3', '', 7 $ " 3+

'3 "/,(5 <",,2,!33%!$ 7/ '(5#",%. 133 3""# 8( (

( ?, % '3 " ;

77 >#' %% '#3'3 " ' ! 13 $ 3"#%% '7', 3 "% $'31 $!3 "(

( 7'

, 3+ +# '") ', ' $$3 ' !3 "

#!)5'3! , 37'

'"', ?

#!!!; ', $!3 % '3'3"13 " % ' ; "' (( $ % "'37 4"() )B;3',3'

"'EF% # 7 ', ' 7', $!3

% '3'3'3!! !3G'3;"; 3$!3 % '3'3 3+ ?

(( '$!3 '")%& ! &!!', "% '"03'!& " 1 !!&$ % "'374"())B;3',3'

"'EF%

# 7 ', ' 7', $!3 % '3'3'3!! !3G'3 "3 "$"'"7 ', % '3'3;"; 3$!3 % '3'3 3+ ?8( ?7

(( '$!3 '"B% '3'3 ")%& ! &!!', "% '"03'!& " 1 !!&(?, 3;,3$,', $ % "'33"' %% '3

'; ', $!3 '"3 ',', $!3 % '3'3"3"!"+31 3',

; "(

( ?, "% ' 8( 3"# $ $ %& 7# ', % "'3"; 3 ',', $!3 % '3'3"' ,3+, "3 ,"$,!! + ', " &;&773!3+';" % ' %% !"3( ( 8(7 ;3', '$ % "'3; 3 ?

(( 8( 7 ;3', '', % "'3; 3 ?8( ?7

(( (

( /3 3! !&)', $!3 '"733+', $ % "'3; '

"3 ,73! ';" % ' %% !"3( (8( 7 ;3', '', $ % "'3; 3 ?8(

(( 8( 7 ;3', '', $ % "'3; 3

?8( ?7

(( (

( 8'3$ " 7 ', %% !" ;

3""# ' ', "% $'31

"% '");,%#'3%% $ ', #+,$#" !(

( ,1 , ! $#" !7 ', % '3 " "3 "+3+ ', #+,', (

( ' & '3 , ','', ?

#!3 ?8(

(( '<3+3'13 ;', & ;3' ""$$#'7', $$3 ' % 13 &C 40312,!3C . ",2# $"3 3+ ', 4!+ 3+', $$3 '"H@($%&7%"'

% '7/,(5 <",,2,!3"H@(', 7$'',' "% '

8( ,'%% '

#'', 13 $ #$ &', $!3 '" '"#%% '', 1 "37"#$, "% '" '#%3', ;

3'' "''

') , '# 733+','$$3 '3;,3$,', $ " ,!"'', 3

!31 ",'< %!$ $$#'7 ", +!3+ ' 313+7', 77 3+'

#$< & "% '8( 413 /3+,(?,3"733+;"'

$,!! + &! $#" !7 ', %% !!'A3"# $ $ %& # 3+', $# " 7 +# '", ,"$73 ,3" +# '";3',

'>#'# 7$ % "'3; (

( ?,#+, ! $#" ! 7 ', %% !!' A 3"# $ %&,"'

3 ' #3!'#% +# '','', $ % "'3; ', ?

#!3 ',', $!3 % '3'3"3",3+, "3 #''73

&" !73+

'3',' (4', 73

3'3', +# '"

1$ & ! $#" ! 7 ', %% !!'"B$!3 '" ',' ', % "'3; 3"', !;

"3 (

( 3 "'!&'<3+#%', $ % "'3; &', ?

3 ?8(

(( $$#'7 ',7/ '(5#",%. 13(

( "% ', $" 7', $!3 '")", ;"+ & "

#3+ #'3># 3, ,#" # ', "'&! 7 B"5#",% 9#'3># ) 8 !) 3+ 4"( )B % ',( ?, ?

#! ,"

1 ',' ', ;" 733' % 7 3+ 3$ 7 ', $ " #'',

3+'1 3#"0#+ '";, 33';" "

1 ',' ', ,#" ;37 "3 " % 7

3+ , '

3! #'3 " !" % 7

#!'37 3#" "

13$ "3$!#3+ +3+', '3 7 3!& 773 "'<3+$ 7, ,#"

$,3! ;,3$,3$!#3+$<3+ 77);",3+7$!', ")', 7 )', '3!3$ 7', $ " 3',3"$" ;""" "" ' 4"() B% ',( ( *; 1 )73','', 3$ """ "" ' ',

"3 (8# '); "$'

#' '', 7 3!& &3+ ,#" ,!$, "3$!#3+$<3+)$! 3+#' "3!");",3+$!', " +3+', ,#" ,!773 "3'3"3773$#!''>#'37&"#$, "

13$ " & ,#" ,! !& ' ', 7 3!&) ,; 1 )

" ! #'3"' '< 3',' (

!)', % @ # ', 1!#' ', $'

#'37,#" ,!;37 '4"()B%

',(';"$$3 ');,3$,'<%!$ 3 (0#+ '

%"" & 3' 9 $, '3'!

" " # $

% '

(" )

*+*) ', '3!3$ 7 ,#" ;37 ;"'< ' 4"()B 3'3;" '; "7#'# % "% $'"(', 7 ,13+'3'! # ,

(( & 3' 9 $,7', # ')', '3!3$ 7 ,#" ;37 ;""" "" ' 4"() B% ',( 7 ,13+'3'! "

0&"

$3 ( ( & 3' 9 $,7', # ')', '3!

3$ 7,#" ;37 ;""" "" ' 4"()B% ',(

( 2 %3+313 ;', 7$'"$3 $# "'$ "7', $" )', + 7', $ " )73','3';#! % % %% % 3' 37', '3! 3$ 7 ', $ " / '(5#",% . 13 3" '< '

4"()B% ',( ( ?, ?

#! ," 3+,'!& #$' B 7 ', '3!

3$ '; "% "!!313+ @% " "7', $ " (',';&)

', $'

#'37', $ " / '(5#",%. 13'; "', $!3 '"

" #' ' 4"()B A ( ?, #!

#'3B % $&$ "#''4"()B @ ( ( ?, ?

#!,"'< ', + 7', $ " / '(5#",% . 13' & "" '

3, %"'

% '"H@( ('

73&7#!'3%% $,7', ?

#!33+"(?, #!'3%!3 7 ," $

$'!&%%!3 &', ?

#!(.3+','', $ % "'3 "#'' 4"() )B @( ( ?, ?

#! ," ' ; & #' '; "

$1 '3! , "( *; 1 ) " % ', !' "' 0#+ ' "

% '

1 1-)

.,, 2

34! 56 +5 7 2

83 47) ', $!3 '" ' + ' "# 74"()B3''!# ', , !""7$" '3# (?, $!3 '" 7# ', '3'! '+ '4"( )B " 7# ! @% " " 4"( )B 7 !"" 7 "'' ( ?, ''!

% "'3$ "#'' 4"() )B 4"( II I ( ( ?, ?

#!,"; $ % "'374"() )B( ( ',3" ;&) ', ,$ #' $ " #' '

4"( ))B (?, ', '

"$3'3"

+31 3', !3 7$!#" ",!!%%!&'', ,$ #'"; !!( ( 8;$ 3+'', $ % "'3; 3 ?8( ?

(( $$#'7 ',7/,(5 <",,2,!3( ( ',3" $" ' "' !3", ', 3$ 7 ', $ " "

4"( )B% ',)', $!3 '",1 @ 3 . ",2# ) $$#''7 B" !,?

"% ' %&) !,);,% #$ $# '"H@( '(?, ?

#!," 0 $' ,3"' "'3 &7 ',

"',', ,'

#+,'&#', 3'&! ''

' %" ,!77 ', $ %&;"'3%"" ""37&+

' 3+ ! "3+#'', $ %&371# 7', $ " ( ( &$"3 13 ;)"#$,%% $,7', ?

#!;"

'% % ('," $"3"' '$" 7', $!3 '" 3+,'7 ',

+33+"%! 3', $!3 % '3'33'" !7',' $ " ;" #3+ '

"% '$ %&! " 3+4"( )B% ',(?, &, @ 3 ;3' "";3', '% 1 ','7$'3( (. ",2#

; <3+"$$#'';3', B" !,?

"% ' %&) !,( ,3" 77313' H@(C B ) , , $' ',' , #" ' 3'3 $$#' <"77 B" !,?

"% ' %&) !,33!&

#'3 "#$,$ %&,'; #" "13 +3"'

'38(59

59 5 <",,2,!3 $ " ,'< ',"

#" "! " ;( (7( (( #" '%!&', " $'

!', 773 "7', $ %&(?, ;3' "",7# ', "'' ',', ,

#+,'

$$#' <"7', $ %&7 ', % 37 A % % 3+', !$ ", '")$%&7;,3$,;

H@( 'H@(( * "'' ',' ', $ %& #" ' %& 4"( )B % ', "

3""3'5 <",,2,!3(* ,% 1 $%&7$ '373$' "

"H@('H@((,3"$ "" @ 3'3), $#!' ",''

&%3'(?, $" 7', $!3 '"#!&% 1 7 ', !' "'3 &

7C . ",2# $# '% 1 &,3 (8 13 $ 3

#''!, #$ &', "% '"(?, ?

#!$! !&7 !!3

3"" ""3+', '3!3$ 7 $ " 5 <",,2,!3 "4"()B;, #+,$+ '$13$3+ 13 $ , #$ &', $!3 '"'% 1 ,3"1$'3$'#!3$ ( ( ?, 7 )'< ', 3$ 7', $ " /,(5 <", ,2,!3' 4"( )B(?, ?

#!," 3+,'!&'< ', + 7 $ " ' & "313 ;7,3""#$,+ '

3,3"%"'

% 'H@((?, 7 )3'3'; "7#'# % "% $'"3"'

(?, ?

#!," 3+,'!& #$'37 B '; "% "!

@% " "(?,#"', ',!& % $&7', $!3 '"$ "#'' 4"()B

A ( ?, #! % $& $ " #' ' 4"()B @ ( ( 2 %3+313 ;', + 7', $ " ' & ")', ?

#!," 3+,'!&#" #!'3%!3 7(.3+','', $ % "'3 "#'' 4"() )B @( ( J ', $1 '3!, "3( (!1 77 $'3 7# ! @% " ")', ?

#!,"; 4"()B# $,, ' ', $!3 '"( ( *; 1 ) " % ', !' "' 0#+ ' " $

% '

1 1-)

"#% )', $!3 '" ' + ' "# 74"()B3''!# ', , !""7$" '3# (?, $!3 '" 7# ', '3'! '+ '4"( )B " 7# ! @% " " 4"( )B 7 !"" 7 "'' ( ?, ''!

% "'3$ "#'' 4"())B 4"() )II

I ( ( ?, ?

#!,"; $ % "'374"())B( ( ',3";&)', ,$ #'$ "#''4"())B

))))(?, ', '

"$3'3"+31 3', !3 7 $!#" ",!!%%!&'', ,$ #'"; !!( ( C3',', " 373$'3") "*0 !! 73! ,!77', $!3 '""'!!; % '!&( ( " ># '!&) 73! ,!77', 3"# $ $ %&"'3"

3"" ( /3$ "*0 !! 73! ,!7 7', $!3 '""'!!; % '!& 73! ,!77', 3"# $ $ %&"'3"

3"" )',

3"$ !! #"%%!3$'3 ")37&"'3"%" 7$$ 3+!&( (( ,/, 23$#3$44$")%*$05)6$"7(*8 + $)5% 23$#3$44$6%4#"9:$ + $)5%