High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/941/2013dismissed

Shantanu Chatterji & ORS v. Union Of India & ORS

2017-05-09Mr. Justice Darshan Singh7 pages

!"#"$% &

'

(% )*(+, ! " #

$

%& ' %( ) ,-.*/ * $ ! + , " -!,.

/ 0 , " -,.

01

&232 4

$

0 , " 5

!

" $

$

/

50

$ + "$

" , !, " 5 6 /

/0 7)78'779- 4:3.

;"

+ 0 + + &( '779

" "+0 0

/ / $ $

",!, "

0

1 " 0 , " 6 $

",!,/ $

" , !, + /+ +0 + !

" "+0 "+0

"<

/ 0 "0 $+0 " = 5 + $

",!,

$

+ /+ +0 + !

" "+0 "+0 " 5 / +$" 5 +0" /0+ + + " +

+ ?

@A ++ % + B/@ 5 + 797)'7&&- 4:&8.#0

0 +

/0 0 / "

", !, "

% + 5 +5 5 -%555./ /

" "+0 5

$ " +

'7&& "+0 ++"$ $ 0!

"0 "

/0 !, " 5 ++"++$ / $

/0, " " "+0 ' +

" + ++ ?

! + ""

" ?

1

?

CC + 4"

"1 +

"" + ++05 ""

+ / " + 38 / $

/0 , " 0 ,

+ 4

0 * 4"

/ ""

$

" '3&&&23) +/

/0 " " ++0 "

" 5

"" ""

1+ $" $ + + +/ " " ++0 + /+ %555 +

1 $ "

/0 + !

"

# + / 4 /0 0 "+ "+0 %555 1

" , !, +0 $ , &232%

"

+/ " +0/ + + +!

"

+0 $ "

" , !, " 5 $" " " 5 $" ? + A $ /0 B )&7@'7&) + D"

E + $ "/ ')73'7&9

+ /+ , ? + A $ + <

/ $ ++ $ ? +

0

0 +5 + +

" 5 + "

" # + "

4:8-++

+0.

" / $

/0 , " 0/1 &2325

$

$1

$+ " + "+0 /+ 5

$ " +

/ 0

+

$ /

/

$ $ 0 5

1 1 $ " 4

$ / "1 < 4"+ 1 $$

+0 +

$ + / +

-

. / 6 -* * . '7&8 929 '7&8 -&. 5 &28

" $" A $ / A 0 F$ $ '7&9(8'('7&9-).5'39 5 " + / ""

"

1

0" " 0 /0 A $ $/

-

. ;

0

"+0 "+0

0

0=

0 ++/ " 5 " 4+ -

. + +0

1 $ +

0 + A / /0 1 $

+ / "

+ /+ F$ $ /0 A $ 0

0" / " 4 " +

0+ +/ 6

/ 5"0"

+

/ + /0+$0 /0 + + (779'772 $ / / $/+

$

, " " ++ D% " E-%.5 < " " (779'772 /

" " / + ;/ "

/ 0

, ?

/ " "+0 "# GGG +

" / /

0, 6 "

/ 0

, !,:":

" , "+0 / 7&7&'77) ' 5 "+0 "/

7&7&'77) / + 0

% 0 " -%. / "0+/ "

/ " % "+0 / 7&7&'77) 5 + " - . 5 4 $

/ 0

,-/ "+0 "+0 . + / "

5 , % " -

.

/ 0

, ?

/ "

" /0 + "1 " 4:

$ 0" &7H "+0 E

/ "+0 $

%

-

.

$"+0

/ /0 "+0 I &7H / 0 J ?

"

/ /0 " I&7H# 0J?

+/ 0/+ 5 "+0 E

/ + / " " " @ "+0

% +/ + "

&7H # 0J?

-

. 5 % + / + +0 + /+ "+0 7&7&'77) 4 C?

"0 / + + "+ " "

< %&@&(@'773 '3 % "/

'773 + $ % "+0 " / 7&7&'77) - . 5 "+0

7&7&'77) "0/ $

" $, " "

%= 5 $" $

!, " 5 " " % "

+ &97('772 4:&' &(8 :/1

&232 6

$/

'779 $ /

'772 4

0 "

$ '7&( 5

0 % " + " /

+ "+0 /

" / 6

+ &232 ++'772 ++'7&( + "+ $%

" A " " /

+ + /

+/ " +

"" "

+ ++ + $$ +0 4+ + >0+ "

0 4 "

$# 7)78'779- 4:

3. / "$ +/

4

% " /0 % % " / ++ $

5 " ++ , !, % " , $ "

"

&

' 0,1 "+